
Illustration by Ricky King
Facility:QUEEN’S RD
Facility Category:STREETS
City:St. John’s
State/Province:Newfoundland
Country:CANADA
Request Category:Streets-Parking-Traffic
Request Type:Driveway or Sidewalk
Request Title:CLEAR SIDEWALK OF SNOW
Request Description:I WENT FOR A WALK LAST NIGHT WITH MY DAUGHTER IN HER STROLLER IN OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD AND HAD TO WALK IN THE STREET ON MILITARY ROAD, LONGS HILL, BALSAM STREET AND QUEENS RD. VERY DANGEROUS AND QUITE UPSETTING THAT I CANT EVEN TAKE MY DAUGHTER OUT FOR A WALK AND ENJOY SOME FRESH AIR AND EXERCISE WITHOUT WORRYING ABOUT BEING HIT BY A CAR OR THE STROLLER TIPPING OVER ON SEVERAL SPOTS ALONG THAT WALK. ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS THAT THESE ARE NOT CLEARED AND PEOPLE CANNOT GET OUT TO ENJOY OUR CITY WITHOUT IT BEING A COMPLETE HASSLE AND HAZARD TO THE SAFETY OF OUR LIVES. THESE STREETS ARE ALL ON THE LIST FOR SIDEWALK CLEARING AND IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT DONE.
Submission Date:2012/Dec/20 10:38 AM
Expected End Date:2012/Dec/28 10:38 AM
Request Priority:Normal
Request Status:Notified
Rant by Citizen and Mother of St. John’s, NL






December 20th, 2012 at 8:10 pm
Here come the mainlanders
December 20th, 2012 at 8:19 pm
I totally agree. I recently moved from the downtown area after living there for several years and I’ve recently realized it seems like people don’t realize that when it snows here in st. johns downtown seems to get a LOT more then the rest of the city. Now I totally understand that there is no where to put all the snow and it does cause quite an inconvenience removing the snow but come on St. John’s city this isn’t like a problem that you’ve recently discovered n the past years. Cant you clear one side of the sidewalk for people to be able to walk safely instead of having to worry about the douchbag coming up around the blind corner on Military road in front of the basilica a little too fast for winter driving and a little too close to the curb while he’s texting on his phone?
To the drivers of this city I ask that you take it a little slow this winter when driving. Yes you have snow tires and yes “your a good driver” but please think of us who are walking the streets. We have enough to worry about then slipping on some black ice and sliding under your car cause you were driving close enough to us. Enough people have been in accidents this year we don’t need to hear about anymore in the city.
December 20th, 2012 at 8:43 pm
That’s really funny. I had a cabbie tell me one night that the reason that the snow clearing is so shitty is because they hire mainland plow operators who can’t adapt to the city’s streets.
The next big move into St.John’s will be from Europe. There are already hundreds of Norwegians here. You’ll have to adjust your xenophobia accordingly.
December 20th, 2012 at 10:30 pm
I agree and given that the city apparently has enough money for a multi-million dollar fence, I don’t know why they can’t invest more in sidewalk clearing. And before anyone says it, yes citizens should be clearing sidewalks in front of their homes but I’ve seen a lot of sidewalks away from homes that haven’t been cleared either and should be looked after by the city.
December 24th, 2012 at 2:53 pm
“you’re a good driver”
December 24th, 2012 at 3:18 pm
No, residents should not be shoveling sidewalks in front of their homes. There’s more to the city than the Downtown area. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again:
1. I’m not shoveling the sidewalk in front of my home so people can slip and sue me because I shoveled it and didn’t salt it. If you do things to try to help people, and it injures them somehow, they will most likely try to sue. People quickly forget about “goodwill” and think “money”. Who wants to take on that needless liability?
2. Who buys the salt for home owners to shake on the sidewalks?
3. How often does it need to be cleared?
4. If there is a snowfall while a home owner is at work do they have a liability to rush home (without pay) and clear it?
5. If a plow goes down the street at 3am and pushes a pile of snow on the sidewalks, do home owners have a liability to get out of bed and clean it up?
6. Who shovels and salts the sidewalks which aren’t adjacent to any particular home?
7. What about home owners who have disabilities and disabling diseases and aren’t able to shovel their own driveways?
8. What happens if a home owner goes on a vacation during our winter season and no one is home to shovel the sidewalk?
9. What about seniors who are on fixed incomes and not in good health? They physically can’t do all that shoveling and can’t afford to pay someone to do it.
10. Who’s responsible for shoveling the sidewalks in rental properties where the landlord/home owner doesn’t live on site?
11. I know several people who live on the corner of two streets, where the sidewalks extend from the front of the house, all the way around the corner and down the other street. Why should one resident have to clear more sidewalk than his/her neighbor just because they bought a corner lot before all these rules came into being? Who would ever buy a corner lot from then on? (from Tim in an “I Saw You” post)
Everybody shoots their mouth off about how residents should be clearing sidewalks in front of their homes just because they’ve had a bad experience while out walking. Think realistic, because it’s not a realistic expectation. If they ever did impose a by-law which made it mandatory for residents to shovel sidewalks in front of their homes, half, or more than half of the people who complain about this issue wouldn’t even do it themselves, or don’t live in a situation where they would have to clear sidewalks.
I feel the OP’s frustration, but this is the City’s problem and they shouldn’t ask residents to pick up the slack because they don’t allocate their budget more efficiently toward serious issues like these.
December 24th, 2012 at 3:51 pm
If the City ever came in with a by-law requiring residents to clear City owned sidewalks, I have a feeling they would need to put more money into the 311 Service Line because there would be so many complaints on every aspect of this issue it wouldn’t be fit. Like anon said, most of the people who are complaining about this probably wouldn’t even clear the sidewalks themselves, or don’t have sidewalks to clear. They are blinded by their own needs and think that everyone else has to serve them.
December 24th, 2012 at 4:07 pm
How about making all the perfectly healthy people who are collecting welfare go out and shovel the sidewalks to earn their pay checks like the rest of us have to do for 30+ years.
December 25th, 2012 at 12:21 am
or we could import slaves from overseas.
December 25th, 2012 at 8:13 am
yes people should be shovelling the sidewalk in front of their property. A lot of people do already, or pay someone to do it for them.
I. the sidewalk is city property as far as liability issues and will remain so. this comment most likely reflects the posters litigious nature.
2.who buys the other consumables required to keep up residence in a city? Keeping ones property in good repair and condition is a civic and legal responsibility. Use sand anyways, it is just as effective, less costly and not a contaminant like salt.
3.Like most regulation this can be worded to require “a reasonable effort is made” i.e. once a day. If we do it as soon as possible after it falls the job is so much easier and with a broom to finish and a bit of sand a far better job then any city operated “sidewalk plow” which leaves enough residue to form a treacherous icy surface under the guise of a “cleared” sidewalk.
4.and5. see above
6.obviously the city should do the job in areas not adjacent to a homeowner or business property. This includes street corners and the lane ways that are not plowed. The city already does this eventually but can do a much better job
7.people who are not able to shovel can, if they have the resource to, pay others to.In lots of cases neighbours spontaneously will shovel the sidewalks and access of people unable to.
8. this is tiresome but obvious, if one can afford a vacation away from it all the cost of paying someone to clear your sidewalk is part of “getting away from it all”
9.Being a senior or any one else on a “fixed” income is disingenuous. A lot of “fixed” incomes are more generous then working peoples earned income. If a senior, or anyone else is unable to shovel their sidewalk, and unable to afford paying someone to do it for them, again the city should do these areas.
10.tenants assume the same responsibility as the owner in the areas of garbage and snow removal unless the owner takes that responsibility under the rental agreement.
11.corner lots are a desirable real estate in most cases. This is reflected in the increased valuation when they are for sale.
Also properties which have comparatively longer frontages have a greater real estate value and if one can afford that property clearing the sidewalk is part of their civic and legal responsibility.
the poster “anon” writes about “everybody shoots their mouth off” That would be an apt description of their own posting.
I am not responding [rather then shooting my mouth off] due to having a “bad experience” while out walking, though I have. I am responding because I observe the many people who have no choice but to navigate the the streets on foot and am concerned. I also feel the city’s bias towards vehicle traffic deplorable. What world do we live in when it is an “offence” to put snow on the street but perfectly acceptable to pile it on the sidewalks to the point of making them impassable?
Anon’s and other posters which dismiss the idea of residents clearing the sidewalk in front of their domicile or business make me wonder if they are safely and warmly travelling in their cars and not concerned about the people who have no choice but to walk?
December 25th, 2012 at 12:27 pm
You seem to have covered the problems with a thin blanket of empty answers. I don’t buy it. You’re talking as if residents around here would do a fantastic job with clearing the sidewalks. Get real! I know plenty of people who can’t even shovel their own driveway decently (or at all). It’s a terrible idea and the idea should be outlawed.
December 25th, 2012 at 2:29 pm
anon, you have spoke to the problem with bombastic rhetoric.
Yes people can shovel the sidewalk in front of their home or business. If they lack the know how there are lots of people who will be glad to help them learn, myself included.
The problem is large amounts of snow in short periods of time and peoples need to be able to get around this city.
This is not just a problem in the high density areas downtown. The suburban residential areas are only cleared of snow in peoples driveways and the street. This leaves the street as the only option for walking traffic, not a safe solution.
If the city clears the streets and residents and business’s clear the sidewalks adjacent to them, what we need in the cramped areas is timely removal of the snow by the city.
Until that is possible the snow can be windrowed to the street side of the sidewalk and the sidewalk side of the street.Also clearing the storm drain openings allows the melting runoff to drain away quickly and avert large dangerous areas of ice and slushy snow.
I suggest this from real experience in this city shovelling snow, not “empty answers”. I suggest this because I feel a better and safer job can be done by people of this city and we do not need additional city moneys [and taxes] to make it safe for walking.
We also do not need the ridiculous fence being proposed for the harbour. The moneys from this could be better used towards providing and encouraging more affordable housing, daycare and other sorely needed services.
December 25th, 2012 at 2:34 pm
Anyone who ends their comment with the retort that an idea should be “outlawed” doesn’t seem to want to engage in any real discussion of ideas, just their own “shooting off of the mouth”
December 25th, 2012 at 6:17 pm
Pissy because someone doesn’t agree with you? Attacking words I use to express my point(s)? That hardly qualifies as real discussion of ideas either.
Residents WILL NOT be able to shovel sidewalks to any sort of consistent acceptable standard.
The City of St. John’s can’t even run a service line efficiently, so I can’t imagine how slack (or completely absent) an inspection service for sidewalk clearing would be. Where would the money come from to provide such a service? Tax Payers? So, when you said “…and we do not need additional city moneys [and taxes] to make it safe for walking”, we would just end up forking more tax money out for sidewalk inspections teams to go around and enforce the specifics of such a by-law. I’m willing to bet that some people wouldn’t even shovel the sidewalks and the City would do f’k all about it, just like they do about everything else, so what’s the point?
You speak as if this would be a straight forward task, but it’s not. There would be so many complaints on every aspect of this, from “It’s not done good enough” to “It’s too slippery” to “They didn’t have it done when I wanted to walk there”. City council would be causing more trouble for themselves by imposing such a thing, and causing higher taxes to make sure it runs as smoothly as people think it should. Nothing comes free.
December 26th, 2012 at 11:15 am
Outlawed you say……bahahahahaha perchance the self entitled attitude of those who feel the government MUST do everything for them should be outlawed.
December 26th, 2012 at 2:47 pm
What is the government for if they’re not there to provide efficient services for tax payers? Get over yourself.
December 26th, 2012 at 2:49 pm
You weren’t doing to bad until you added this childish sounding tidbit.
December 26th, 2012 at 7:19 pm
Imposing a by-law to clear sidewalks might not be all bad. It would create more work/jobs for people in the snow clearing business.
December 27th, 2012 at 8:05 am
City council should stop treating this place as a small town and start treating it like a growing city. Things will be required and desired from tax payers. Making tax payers do your work for you is hardly a good way to run a growing city.
Residents should not be shoveling city sidewalks. It’s the city’s problem and they should deal with it without dragging the public in with them.
St. John’s is a terribly designed city and a bylaw like this would never work properly. There are some sidewalks in front of homes where city plows pile 10 or 15 feet of snow during peak snowfall. Who the f’k is actually going to keep that cleared? If we had some plow operators who actually knew what they were doing instead of piling 10 or 15 feet of snow in front of someones home then maybe it would be different.
December 27th, 2012 at 8:47 am
Not to mention the project areas of the City. Good luck getting them to shovel the sidewalks in front of their housing units. They just won’t pay the fines, the sidewalks there will never be cleared, and the city or NL housing will do nothing about it.
Oh wait, none of you cry babies want to walk in the projects anyway so it wouldn’t matter I guess.
December 27th, 2012 at 10:07 am
Not to mention that thing you mentioned.
December 27th, 2012 at 10:21 am
You mad?
December 27th, 2012 at 6:42 pm
don’t forget those who felch off the welfare system…..put the able bodied ones to work out of it.
December 27th, 2012 at 7:07 pm
Good point.
December 28th, 2012 at 3:18 pm
“you weren’t doing too bad…”(thought I would correct you seeing how you are the grammar Nazi of Rant Farm.
December 28th, 2012 at 5:42 pm
I was hoping twerp was going to bite at that one. Thanks for screwing it up.
December 28th, 2012 at 5:54 pm
Also, you forgot to close your explanation with a parenthesis.
December 28th, 2012 at 7:01 pm
BOB,Christopher Chafe,Outlaw,bringitup,gg…got anything to actually say? go for it
December 28th, 2012 at 7:59 pm
anonz said it all for me!
December 28th, 2012 at 8:00 pm
Go to bed out of it gonz.
December 28th, 2012 at 8:12 pm
BOB, so far nada
December 28th, 2012 at 10:01 pm
nope. twerp would have called you out for using bad (adjective) when you meant badly (adverb). but he didn’t want to get off the couch and venture out to your camp on the outskirts of literacy.
December 29th, 2012 at 10:54 am
Ahhh, that’s the twerp I know!! Thanks buddy!
December 29th, 2012 at 12:51 pm
Mostly it would just be nice if the city kept up on snow clearing in the places where there is a parking ban. My street has a winter parking ban, from December 1st to March 31st and the sign says specifically for snow removal, and not once has a plow come along to clear the side walks/sides of the road. I DO shovel the sidewalk in front of my home, but what is the point of me clearing the sidewalk in front of my own home if no one else on my street does it, and the city doesn’t come along to clear the sides of the road so people can at least safely walk there. It stinks when you live on a street where you do not have off street parking and you have to park 2 blocks away every day and walk home in 3 inches of hard snow and ice that have been sitting there since the first snow storm, I feel bad for the people who have no choice but to walk through it every day. It is very dangerous. I saw a girl get clipped by a car on Old Topsail road, because she had to walk in the road due to the icy sidewalk. It was close to one of the new bottle neck’s in the road and the car’s side view mirror caught her coat and tossed her. Thankfully she was not injured badly, and the person in the vehicle took her to the hospital.
December 29th, 2012 at 2:14 pm
It’s not that I don’t agree with sidewalk clearing, I just think the City should step up to the plate on this one instead of making residents do it. We live in a harsh unpredictable climate, so it should be no surprise to City council that more money needs to be invested in snow clearing machinery and additional workers to use it.
January 7th, 2013 at 7:42 pm
The City of St. John’s should start enforcing some of their other by-laws before they consider making new ones.
January 11th, 2013 at 10:26 pm
Now…everyone…go shovel the 20 foot snowbanks that the plows just piled up on the sidewalks in front of your homes…just like anon says it should be done.