Well, you said you were going to get flack for getting rid of the Savage Love column, so here is one email to add to the pile of ‘disappointed liberal scope reader’ letters.
I’m not so much upset about the abolishment of Savage Love, although I admit that I would always turn to the last page in the Scope first to get my dose of Savage love. I’m more disappointed in your shift in content, to appeal to a more ‘conservative’ audience – to get into more locations and to increase profit, also known as, ‘selling out’.
Do you really think that the ‘conservative audience’ you’re trying to capture at Dominion is going to be interested in reading articles on the Fortis development project, St. John’s recycling program or bike route? Do you think they’re going to be looking at the Scope to see what’s on the go this weekend at the Ship or who MightyPop are bringing in? They’re exactly the ones who don’t give two s*its about those topics, and who definitely won’t be attracted to advertising from Posie Row or Planned Parenthood’s homophobic seminars.
I always found the Scope to be refreshing… to know that there were other people in this conservative town who were progressive thinkers, and who weren’t afraid to stand up against the conservative majority and publish content that they might deem inappropriate or uninteresting. Now that the Scope is trying to ‘broaden’ it’s audience, I believe you will be losing your loyal liberal readers. You know, sometimes growth and money isn’t always worth it, so I would really like to know what the purpose of this shift is.
Ranter: Boycotting for Dan Savage Material (BDSM)






May 24th, 2010 at 7:16 pm
While I agree with you that The Scope doesn’t need to go the conservative route to broaden it’s market, I think it’s the right choice to drop Dan Savage. Not because of the content mind you, I really enjoy Dan’s column, but because he’s already syndicated in a hundred other papers and blogs all over the continent. Dropping his column means there’s a whole new page that can be devoted to local content, maybe even a local sex column, who knows? People gotta realize that even though they give away this magazine for free it is a business that is supposed to make money and occasionally being a business means making a compromise in order to, y’know, stay in business. Getting the paper read in grocery stores or hospitals or whatever can mean a huge boost in readership and if dropping a single (admittedly sometimes controversial) nationally syndicated column in favor of more (possibly tamer) local content is what you gotta do to do it, then I say go for it.
May 26th, 2010 at 1:05 am
A quick question for BDSM, and all of his/her supporters:
How exactly do you intend on boycotting The Scope? It is a free publication, and (to my knowledge) all of its revenue comes from advertising – the vast majority of which is purchased by local businesses.
Do you intend on boycotting Posie Row, the Hava Java, Living Planet and every other business that advertises in The Scope? If not, then your “boycott” is little more than hot air.
May 26th, 2010 at 10:13 am
Has “selling out” always been so easily confused with “making a living”? It has? Oh, nevermind.
May 26th, 2010 at 12:02 pm
No need to get snarky or defensive here guys. I’m sure there are lots of people who are worried we’ll be changing our content to satisfy a conservative audience, so I’m glad BDSM brought it up.
But I want to make it clear: Aside from removing Savage Love, we don’t plan on changing our content at all. Really, why would we? It’s working really well for us. For a new, independent publication, we’ve been growing way quicker than the average, and expanding is important. Growing has allowed us to do more and more elaborate projects, pay more people to cover important issues, and generally be a louder alternative.
Unfortunately, store managers often have a knee-jerk reaction to words like “cock,” so, while it’s definitely a compromise, removing Savage Love from the print edition seemed like a logical step to greater ends. Dan Savage is taking one for the team.
I could go on, but I think the paper will speak for itself.
Don’t Panic.
May 27th, 2010 at 4:12 pm
I thing I love most about the scope is the fact that they are so different from other newspapers around town..and they arn’t afarid to say what they want, to whoever the hell they wanna say it too. So I do agree with you very much on this!
May 28th, 2010 at 12:09 pm
Maybe that leaves room for more comics???
:)
May 29th, 2010 at 6:07 pm
I was impressed to see that the Scope team is making a good business decision at the risk of offending certain ultra-liberal readers, the type who are constantly itching for something like this to complain about. I know that this is a left-wing publication and always will be, but there is such a thing as being irrationally rigid. Savage Love is not that great of a column. Yes, it’s entertaining, sometimes even informative, but it’s not worth it for a small local paper to lose out on business over a few small blurbs in which a know-it-all American lectures people on the etiquette of anilingus, especially when the vast majority of us can access more of this kinda stuff than we can handle with the click of a mouse, if we’re so inclined. I think that the folks who write and publish the Scope could have quietly replaced Savage Love with some other local and liberal feature, and not egg on the ultra-left whiners with terrible statements like “St John’s is a conservative city”, and there would have been less complaints. Instead they were open and honest about what they were doing and why, and I can respect that.