
Track: John Vanderslice — “White Dove”
From Emerald City (2007)
California
www.johnvanderslice.com
Sarah Smellie: You know how Sonic Youth can somehow make their guitars sound like a furious cluster of bees swarming your head? “White Dove” pulls that off a few times. Unfortunately, that’s the only thing to distinguish this song from the rest of the generic, Matthew-Good-esque type of vaguely rockin’ yet ultimately forgettable music out there.
Rachel Jean Harding: I think I have gotten to the point where I have listened to so much indie rock that I can’t hear one band without hearing another. So here I go and commit the cardinal sin of music reviewing and namedrop: it reminds me of Neutral Milk Hotel. Though my feeling is I’d rather listen to Neutral Milk Hotel, I’m curious about what else the album might have going on.
Anshuman Iddamsetty: Unlike most crits, I’ve no issue with Vanderslice continuing his descent into post-9/11 tensions since 2005’s Pixel Revolt. “White Dove” is a taut-to-the-point-of-snapping indie rock argument over the loss of children at ground zero. It’s propulsive, accusatory, and on par for a dude who fought Bill Gates.



The Scope | Wed, Aug 1, 2007 | 192
Podcast