
Track review: Basia Bulat — “I was a daughter” [listen at her MySpace page]
From Oh, My Darling (2007)
Ontario
www.basiabulat.com
Darcy Fitzpatrick: Daughter attacks its own melancholy with a plucky upbeat rhythm which builds, disappears, then reappears. When it’s gone, Bulat’s vocals become haunting and there’s a time for a solemn moment of self-reflection. When the rhythm returns, it feels deserved, like a genuine hope has been revealed.
Dan Murray: This could have been a nice average folky indie pop tune, but Bulat decided to go a bit quirky, and it doesn’t help her at all. The repetitive hand claps and drums are irritating, and the viola seems unnecessary. If it were only a piano, guitar and ukulele I could have put up with the song—please remember that less can be more.
Thea Morash: Running barefoot through the woods, heady with nostalgia, moss underfoot… Bulat’s voice is wistful and unaffected, at once light and full, and the strong flow of this song carries you back to a time when the idea of love was new, and not scary. Beautiful.



The Scope | Thu, Nov 22, 2007 | 142
Podcast