These days, Dan Aykroyd must be living in a Peabody’s Improbable History segment from Rocky & Bullwinke, imagining himself as the wisened dog, Mr. Peabody, and the rest of the world as his boy, Sherman.
You remember Sherman, don’t you? That’s how he sees us, the filmgoers. Cheery, gullible, bespectecled ginger kids eagerly asking “where we gonna go today, Mr. Aykroyd?”
With that question, the pendulous drooping chin of the Aykroyd-dog waddles with delight. “The same place we always go, dear boy: 15 years ago,” he replies.
“Are we going to relive your days on such critically-acclaimed hits as that show where you acted like a PBS telethon host for the supernatural, begging viewers to call in with their real stories of alien abductions and spooky ghosts or that other show where you a rockin’ priest who sometimes crossed over with Home Improvement?” we ask.
“No, dear child. We’re going to go back in time and, ahem, scare up some money.”
Then the Canadian actor springs to life and asjusts the co-ordinates on his Wayback Machine. His beady eyes beam with the desperation seen only in washed-up comic actors who haven’t been funny in more than two decades. Fifteen of which, he’s been telling anyone who would listen about the prospect of Ghostbusters III. Apparently, Santa finally responded to Aykroyd’s Christmas wish because–whether it’s Bill Murray’s recent appearance in full costume at the Scream Awards last month or the news that the writers of Year One have turned in a draft so awful that Aykroyd has to rewrite it to appease Murray–people are talking about Ghostbusters III.

While Aykroyd will talk to anybody about the project and has done for years (seriously, he called me four times when he found out I was writing about this on The Scope, even though I didn’t tell anybody and my number’s unlisted), now he’s being taken seriously. While there’s a certain nostalgic allure in the prospect of seeing Aykroyd, Murray, Harold Ramis and Ernie Hudson don their gear again, nostalgia is for collectors and cover bands. This sequel is a terrible idea for a number of reasons.
Here are the reasons this sequel is a terrible idea:
1. We’ve already had an awful sequel to the 1984 comedy. It came out in 1989, remember? It had the boys in grey overcome all meanness in the world by convincing New Yorkers to smile more, which is exactly the sort of plot that makes you wish all involved had their faces immediately kicked in.
2. We’ve already had a Ghostbusters reunion in the form of the 2009 video game, in which our slumming actors reprised their roles in exhuastive cutscenes with professionalism (save Bill Murray who sounded like he was swimming in Vicodin) but absolutely no charm. And when the actors weren’t smugly reciting their wink-wink, “remember when we said this twenty years ago” dialogue, you were left in a game that was about as fun as watching a dog drown and deserved a trip to that fabled landfill with Atari’s E.T. game.
3. The plot of the film is a passing of the torch story, in which we’re introduced to a new group of Ghostbusters to replace the funny ones we like. You know, they’re replacing the iconic, memorable characters with newer, younger characters who’ll be fighting for screentime and give the audience an excuse to take a bathroom break whenever their onscreen.
4. If the above sounds familiar to you, it was already the basis of a cartoon series called Extreme Ghostbusters. After the first cartoon, The Real Ghostbusters came to an end in 1991, this new series began in 1997. In it, the character were aged and mostly written out in favour of exciting, ‘edgy’ twenty-somethings who could only be identified by their tokenism. This was the series where the Ghostbusters consisted of a girl in goth makeup, a black guy voiced by Carlton from Fresh Prince, a Hispanic guy and a Ghostbuster in a wheelchair. While I’m all for destroying stereotypes, there’s something inherently laughable about an action hero who says “I’ll get the wheelchair access!” each and every week. Extreme Ghostbusters was about as good as it sounds and ended the year it began.
5. While I’m on record as preferring unasked for sequels to unasked for remakes, I think Ghostbusters has more to offer if it was remade rather than sequelized. No not remade for cinema, but for television. Instead of slavishly rewriting/referencing the first film with a cast of A-list stars with no chemistry (which a big-budget remake would most assuredly do), the best chance of renewing interest in the show is casting a cast of working TV actors and unknowns to reprise the main roles. CGI effects required for proton guns and armies of ghosts can be easily achieved on a TV budget these days and the new actors and TV format would, if done well, allow the writers and actors a great deal of freedom to play with the characters and bring in audiences again. If they could develop a dynamic as strong as that of the original film with the kind of creativity fueling the plots of The Real Ghostbusters at its best, you’d have something worth watching.
Come on, Dan Aykroyd. If you need the money that badly, why not just endorse a drink or create another garish tribute chain store to the music claim to love. Leave Ghostbusters, please?




November 5th, 2010 at 11:37 am
I ain’t afraid of another ghost busters sequel.
November 5th, 2010 at 12:13 pm
Aykroyd doesn’t need the money, he genuinely loved the film and the characters and knows the fans (yourself excepted) want to see more. From what I’ve read the new script was actually pretty good but Venkman – excuse me, Bill Murray – would only go for it if he wasn’t in the whole thing. Yes he’s been a bit of an a** about it, but please don’t smear good ‘ole Danny boy (he’s the heart of the Ghostbusters!)
The sequel was actually really good. Yes the idea of mood slime is kind of weird (keep in mind it’s a COMEDY) but the film gave us a ton of classic Ghostbuster moments.
The Ghostbusters video game did exactly what it was supposed to do. It was written for the fans of the films and all those nods and winks were on purpose. And as gamer it was actually a pretty good 3rd person shooter. Definitely doesn’t deserve being lumped in with the unholy grail that was E.T. I mean, you get to fire a proton pack!
By the time Extreme Ghostbusters rolled around I was waaay past watching Saturday morning cartoons.
I guess to be truly excited about the possibility of a third film you had to have seen the first one when it came out in 1984. Nostalgia isn’t a bad thing and a movie doesn’t have to be perfect to be fun to watch. My fingers are crossed. Aging Ghostbusters training in a new team, if done the right way, could actually be really good.
“Dogs and cat’s, living together, mass hysteria!”
November 5th, 2010 at 12:50 pm
hulk watch anything as long as it in 3d!!!!!!