
Watchmen (In Theatres)
Director Zach Snyder has taken Watchmen—a highly progressive and experimental graphic novel—and turned it into a forgettable, by-the-numbers action movie. Those who have read the graphic novel will see Watchmen as a stripped-down version of the comic’s story. Those who haven’t read the graphic novel will find it schizophrenic and confounding. You’ll have to read the comics to understand why the public turned against superheroes, or why Ozymandias has a purple tiger, or why the whole thing is worth a damn.
Many of the key events happen in the same way, with the same dialogue, but the comic’s atmosphere and tone are not simply absent but consciously exorcised from this soulless adaptation. Zach Snyder, the film’s director, carefully left all the sex, violence, and violent sex unchanged, but removed any character growth that was not conveniently framed with a fistfight.
Even at two and a half hours long, the movie still only tells a third of the story that it should, owing largely to its superfluous use of slow motion. Everything happens in slow motion, every gunshot, every kick, every pelvic thrust. The film is a visual mess, abandoning the bright, surrealist colouring of the comics for grimy greys and blacks. The visuals lack charm. They’re more concerned with being believable than being consistent with the comic-book fantasy world they exist in.
My favourite aspect of the Watchmen comics was the depths to which they explored the main characters. Each came across as a heavily flawed but lovable individual—human beings in costume rather than simply superheroes. The film pays lip service to these characterisations, but has discarded the nuance. Take, for example, Silk Spectre, in the comics a haughty, emotional wreck who chain smokes and complains incessantly about her life of privilege; in the film a stoic badass who never loses her cool and always remains upbeat.
Then again, maybe it’s for the best that these details are lost, considering the stiff acting. Jeffrey Dean Morgan the actor portraying The Comedian is particularly talentless. In one heated exchange between he and Dr. Manhattan, he is completely incapable of emoting and reading his lines at once. Honourable mentions in the category of Worst Actor go to Matthew Goode for his stunningly inept portrayal of Ozymandias—taking a highly complex character and reducing him to a one note egotist—as well as the movie’s screen-writer David Hayter for acting as though his script was worth shooting.
Matthew Esteves



April 9th, 2009 at 8:24 pm
For a far more faithful, small-screen adaptation, I highly recommend the motion comic.