Adam Clarke likes scary movies. This is probably why he didn’t care for Scre4m.
In the more innocent days of 1996, I was eager to see a barely-promoted horror film: Scream. The presence of Wes Craven behind the camera was enough to get me in the theatre in those days. I had freshly seen most of Craven’s movies up to that point, so he was still the talent who created A Nightmare On Elm Street, New Nightmare and The Serpent & The Rainbow rather than the chump behind Vampire In Brooklyn.* Even Shocker and The People Under The Stairs were minor masterpieces to this popcorn-munching kidlet, but I can only retroactively assume that Craven was aiming them at 12 year old kids. It’s better that way.
Scream had won me over. From its tense opening scene onward, viewers were set up for a smart slasher movie that playfully used horror trivia and in-jokes as a hook for its killings.
Scream was the logical end to the slasher film, as the entire subgenre was founded on killers who had a gimmick.* Now being the slasher was the gimmick. This new killer’s raison d’etre was that they knew their slasher flicks inside-out, which became the springboard for a film that stole bits and pieces from When A Stranger Calls, Black Christmas, John Carpenter’s Halloween and countless others. And it worked, too. Scream‘s original release was successful enough that the film was re-released in theatres to even greater box office.
With the film’s growing popularity, I’d felt like the Johnny-come-latelies in my class who’d been bowled over by Scream might finally appreciate the finer points of something like Phantasm. No dice. Scream was a parody, they’d insist.
Scream wasn’t a parody. It wasn’t a “self-aware” slasher flick, as it was often labeled. Scream was a loving tribute to a type of horror movie that had fallen out of fashion long before Jason took Manhattan. If it was a parody, nobody told Wes Craven, who displayed a kind of inspiration and energy behind the camera that had been absent for most of his post-Elm Street career. If Kevin Williamson’s script was intended to be a spoof, he’s a lousy writer. The script for Scream is clever rather than funny and clever. And clever, as comedy writer George Meyer once noted, is “the eunuch version of funny.”
Scream‘s artistic success wouldn’t last. When Jamie Kennedy met his admittedly surprising demise midway through Scream 2, the series had lost its voice and its most fun character. By the time that film’s villains were revealed to be Quinn Mallory from Sliders and Jackie from Roseanne, I felt like I was watching a big-budget version of Battle For The Network Stars. Scream 2 was a crushing disappointment. Scream 3, by all accounts, was worse, but I haven’t seen a frame of it. Having seen the annoyingly-titled Scre4m gives me no desire to catch its immediate predecessor.
The plot of this new film is simple. After years of having hack journalist, Gail Weathers (Courtney Cox) cash in on her tragic past, Sidney Prescott (Neve Campbell) pens her own memoir with a less lurid take on the events of the past three films. With the publication of the book and her subsequent return to her hometown to promote it, Prescott is soon facing off against another killer who drunk-dials young girls to test their knowledge of Prom Night like a psychopathic Joe Bob Briggs.
Jumping back a few years to talk about Scream 2, I must raise a point in its defense. Much though I disliked that film, it did open with a great scene and the only thing from either of the first two films that I’d consider an out-and-out spoof. Rather than trying to top the tense opening from the first film, Craven and Williamson created “Stab.” “Stab”, the movie-within-a-movie based on the events of the first Scream, was a hilariously dead-on parody of slasher films, which was made all the funnier by Craven’s direction. Whereas Scream was briskly edited and used clever camera angles to ramp up the tension, “Stab” was flatly-directed in such a deliberate, familiar way that it could’ve been mistaken for the worst of the slasher flicks of old. That was the only bit of parody in Scream 2, as I recall. In Scream 4 (or Scree-four-mmm as the title would have us say it), the movie uncomfortably shifts between trying to be the next Scream and trying to be the next Scary Movie. Except it does both incredibly poorly. The scare scenes are every bit as flat as those from Scream 2‘s “Stab” sequence and the film’s idea of funny is to have a character say “I hate Bruce Willis” after getting stabbed in the head (don’t ask).
I hate Bruce Willis too, but that’s not even clever. That’s not even a eunuch version of clever.
Impressively, the film’s one saving grace is its sole moment of actual parody. Any attempt at replicating the suspense of the original Scream is thrown out the window in favour of a surprisingly surreal set piece before the opening credits. We begin with two girls watching a “Stab” sequel only to get stabbed by a guy in familiar “Ghostface” garb. This turns out to be a scene from a different “Stab” sequel being watched by Kristen Wiig and Anna Paquin as they munch on a popcorn and talk about horror movies. When that scene ends in a murder, it’s revealed that that scene was part of a “Stab” sequel being watched by a different group of young girls. For a brief moment, I had hoped that the entire ad campaign was a hoax and that this new flick was not a Scream sequel at all, but a gory piece of conceptual art entitled Ninety Minutes Of False Starts. It would be like Jim Jarmusch’s Coffee & Cigarettes except with aggressive stabbings!
Alack, the film proper started before I could really get my hopes up and I settled in for a movie that had nothing interesting to say about horror movies old or new. Nor did it offer a single new cast member who you could remember within four seconds of their demise. It’s not often I say this, but the savvy horror geeks in this film made me pine for the subtle nuance of Scream‘s Matthew Lillard.
It is with a heavy heart that I must look away after having being taken advantage of by the Scream films again. It hurts to see Scream parading around with people so much younger than I, like it no longer has any dignity. When it comes time for Screams 5 and 6 to come out, I hope I’ll have the good sense to look away. I’ve done it with other slasher franchises. Though it was hard to miss out on the last two Leprechaun flicks, I knew in my heart that there was no more they could offer me after Leprechaun 4: In Space. Courage, Adam Clarke. Courage.
*Like Michael Myers, mute since age 6 and stabbing innocents every Halloween. Freddy Krueger, the burn victim who kills teenagers from beyond the grave with his patented glove of finger-knives. And, most famously of all, the two axe-wielding santas from Silent Night, Deadly Night parts 1, 2 and 3!



April 29th, 2011 at 12:21 pm
I agree with most of your points, that this film lost the clever and the loving tribute, and the effort and is just a flat cash grab. The one thing I don’t agree about is Scream 2…while they did make a huge misstep in killing off the best character of the first film and trying to turn everything into a sort of soap opera for the survivors of a slasher, I felt it did have some moments, especially in the suspense department-there were some very nice sequences that really got the audience going when I saw it in the theater, and I enjoyed the opening kill, which had the suspense that this one’s first actual kill lacked. Mostly Scream 4 felt like a whole lot of not carrying and treading water, with a side of “we don’t even remotely get the kids today” thrown in for good measure.
April 29th, 2011 at 12:40 pm
Two minor corrections (brought to me by Mortis): Stab sequences were directed by Robert Rodriguez and the dude from My Secret Identity was not one of the killers from Scream 2. I wish I had my pretty mind back.