
Performing stand-up in Japan, Adam Clarke is often billed as “Captain Supermarket”.
Fede Alvarez’s 2013 remake of Sam Raimi’s Evil Dead can proudly boast that it’s the single best remake of all the remakes of classic 70′s and 80′s horror that’ve haunted cinemas in recent years. Given that the only competition in that category comes from the likes of Rob Zombie’s Halloween films (and their director’s cuts), 2006′s The Hills Have Eyes, 2009′s Friday The 13th, 2010′s A Nightmare On Elm Street and the 3-D Piranhas, besting this glut of derivatives is the textbook definition of an easy feat. I may as well give myself a prize for “Best Jogger In My House” because I can outrun the jar of mayonnaise gently resting in my fridge.
The new Evil Dead begins with something completely fresh. A young woman (Phoenix Connolly) is tied down in the basement of a familiar cabin. Under the supervision of the friendly neighborhood Log Lady (Sian Davis) and some onlooking mutant-people, the girl’s father (Jim McLarty) struggles to set her on fire. Between the girl’s begging and the father’s calm explanation of why he has to torch her alive, Evil Dead is in uncertain and decidedly creepy territory. It seems like we’ll finally have a recent remake that actually understands why John Carpenter’s The Thing and David Cronenberg’s The Fly succeeded: if you want a remake to work, you have to give the audience something they haven’t seen before.
Immediately after the credits, we’ve got a new group of college students at the cabin. This time, they’re a largely estranged group of friends, lover and family uniting to help Mia (Jane Levy) overcome her smack habit. In the cabin, Mia’s brother David (Shiloh Fernandez) and childhood friend Eric (Lou Taylor Pucci) find the Book of the Dead. Despite several written warnings on the pages of the cursed book, Eric reads part of it aloud for some reason. Cue Mia getting raped in the woods by the woods and becoming possessed by an ancient demon. Soon, all Hell is unleashed and no one escapes unmutilated. Credits.
Did they really have to redo the tree rape scene from the original? The scene Sam Raimi apologized for in subsequent interviews after The Evil Dead?
This plague of horror remakes wouldn’t be so awful if every one of them didn’t clumsily reference their source material. Freddy Krueger in 2010 has to say “I’m your boyfriend now, Nancy” even if it makes no sense in its new context and loses all of its power. Same with Dr Loomis going on about Michael Myers’ evil in the Rob Zombie Halloweens despite all evidence to the contrary. Fede Alvarez struggles under the weight of expectations for an Evil Dead remake. The film stops for clever referential touches (I particularly liked the subtle inclusion of Bob Dorian’s tape recorder voice from the original film), but goes overboard with them.
That brings us back to the infamous tree rape sequence. In the original film, this misguided scene at least fit with the overall tone of Sam Raimi’s The Evil Dead. Raimi’s film was going to shock you with fantastical violence and horror in a way that you never thought possible. Given that the demons in the woods want to humiliate, torture and mutilate their host-victims, the sequence makes sense in that context. That brutal scene happens to the only developed character in that film, Cheryl (Ellen Sandweiss), and is still powerful and revolting to see the film’s one real character struggle to not have their dignity stolen away.
By contrast, Mia is raped in the woods because it’s a remake and the original had a tree rape scene, so there ya go. I’m not sure whose genius idea it was to include it in the new Evil Dead, but director Fede Alvarez seems exceptionally uncomfortable with it and tries to get it over with as quickly as possible. The original film’s version was a bizarre scene whose inclusion made sense in an already bizarre, gruesome, gratuitous and over-the-top film. Alvarez is chained to audience expectations, which makes the scene so offensively unnecessary.
Of course, the real problem with remaking Evil Dead faithfully is that we’ve already experienced endless variations on its basic plot. Whether it’s Raimi’s own quasi-remake in Evil Dead II, the moronic Cabin Fever or the clever Cabin In The Woods, we don’t need a remake of The Evil Dead to be a valentine to its source material. Other people have done that. You’re better off watching Alvarez’s short films on his youtube channel instead of shilling out ten bucks for his Evil Dead.
This Evil Dead is rife with problems. The film stupidly abandons the intriguing idea that the demons are manifestations of Mia’s drug withdrawal, intensifying her family history of mental illness. I wish the film had maybe explored the idea that people are compelled to read from the book of the dead because it possesses some unnatural will of its own. I wish the Deadites’ dialogue hadn’t been rewritten by Captain Howdy (the demon that possessed Regan in The Exorcist) without realizing that those scenes were disturbing coming from an innocent child. This is the film’s worst sin, as demons talking about fucking and incest is laughable and obvious nearly forty years after The Exorcist
Praise must be given, however, for Fede Alvarez overall. He’s got a knack for creating atmosphere, he makes the violence suitably over-the-top and painful, and he gives the film a few neat visuals. Alvarez does a fine job with the material, but I feel like he was on assignment to reference the original films. I wish that his film wasn’t so obligated to have tree rapes, a woman in the cellar (like the first two Evil Deads!) or characters losing their hands (because that happened once in Evil Dead II!). It’s so antithetical to the spirit of the original films to do something so predictable.



April 8th, 2013 at 9:15 am
Good review! I didnt saw that movie till now but can follow your point as a fan of the original Evil Dead. Fed Alvarez of course do not have the class of Sam Raimi but it seems he did a classic watchable horromovie…im gonna see it for sure too but dont expect much more than a try. See forward of the originally “Army of Darkness 2″ and possibly “Evil Dead 3″ by Sam Raimi.