
Adam Clarke is a clown who’s crying on the inside. Also, the outside.
In 50/50, Seth Rogen gets to flex his dramatic chops a little more than usual, which reminds us of just how good comedians and comic actors can be when stepping outside their range. While some actors alternate between comedy and drama (Kevin Kline, Robin Williams, John C. Reilly, Bill Murray), I’ve listed 5 of the most surprising dramatic performances from performers best known for comedy.
1) John Candy, JFK
The insanely talented, versatile and very funny SCTV cast were seldom served well by motion pictures. Rick Moranis, for instance, created many characters and displayed remarkable gifts as a mimic. In his film career, he was forever typecast as a “nerdy pipsqueak” (Little Shop Of Horrors, Ghostbusters and its sequel, Honey We/I Shrunk/Blew Up Ourselves/The Kid/Kids).
The same is true of fellow SCTV cast-mate, John Candy. As such, it’s easy to forget how popular or just how good Candy really was. Judging by the quality of the films he chose to be involved in, Candy didn’t seem to know how good he was, either.
In Oliver Stone’s JFK, Candy was cast as Dean Andrews Jr., a slang-talking, jittery lawyer hired to represent Lee Harvey Oswald. Candy’s brief appearance is the highlight of the film, elevating a potentially silly role with a frenzied, somewhat menacing performance. It remains one of the few, frustrating glimpses of the unrealized dramatic chops John Candy possessed.

2) John Cleese, Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein
Kenneth Branagh’s 1994 film Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein had much in common with its predecessor, Francis Ford Coppola’s Bram Stoker’s Dracula. Both films were lavishly-budgeted and feature A-list actors delivering some of the worst performances of their careers. Both films were touted as returning to the roots of their respective novels after previous adaptations had long abandoned any semblance to their source material.
Such claims proved to be false and both films were career nadirs for their directors. Getting through either film was a bit like winning a cat pee drinking contest. Yes, it was a challenge to make it to the end, but at what cost?
Despite burdening the film with a sea of bad ideas, director-star Branagh scored a striking performance out of John Cleese as a mentor to the titular Victor Frankenstein. In the film, Cleese is a subdued and melancholy scientist whose genius brain ultimately serves to power the creature. Like Candy, one can’t help but wish he’d had the sense to pull a Bill Murray and jump ship to drama instead of wasting his talents doing pratfalls in Brosnan-era Bond movies.

3) Dave Foley, From The Earth To The Moon
A life getting by on alimony payment vehicles like Postal and Vampires Suck means that Dave Foley’s talent for drama has also gone largely untouched. His role as Alan Bean in Tom Hanks’ acclaimed mini-series puts Foley’s earnestness and likability to the forefront and is one of the highlights of the series.
4) Andy Kaufman, God Told Me To
Everything about Larry Cohen’s little-seen horror/sci-fi flick amounts to a bizarre experience. As such, the surprise appearance of Andy Kaufman is one of the least jarring things about it.
Like many Cohen scripts, God has a perfect hook. There’s a sudden wave of killings occur in New York, each one committed by someone with no history of violence. When asked why, each killer has the same answer: “God told me to”. As is often the case with Cohen films, the concept would make a brilliant short story, but instead fuels a flawed, if memorable film.
Kaufman cameos as a policeman who flips out and guns down several fellow officers during a parade. Since there was always something a little otherworldly about the comedian’s boyish face and intense stare, Kaufman’s appearance adds to the film’s unpredictability.
5) Patton Oswalt, Big Fan
Patton Oswalt’s performance in Big Fan is surprising given his relative inexperience as a dramatic actor. A celebrated stand-up comedian and writer who grew in popularity for his voice work in Ratatouille and his supporting role on King Of Queens, Oswalt delivers an honest, uncomfortable performance. His obsessive, unstable title character is elevated by Oswalt’s natural nerdiness. His dramatic turn covers ground that Adam Sandler hoped to, but failed to reach in the overrated Punch-Drunk Love.



Adam Clarke | Mon, Oct 3, 2011 | 1162
On Screen