
Adam Clarke is a friend to boils and ghouls everywhere.
With The Cabin In The Woods currently providing some throwback scares in theatres with its references to 80s horror films, I couldn’t help but be reminded of nostalgia-soaked horror for previous generations: EC comic tributes.
EC Comics, as you know, published short, violent, irony-laden stories in The Vault Of Horror, The Haunt Of Fear, Two-Fisted Tales and, most famously, Tales From The Crypt. When censors thought such comics were corrupting our youth, these blackly-comic, er, comics disappeared from all but memory. Before EC and its stories returned to television in the form of HBO’s sleek Tales From The Crypt, these grisly tales were given some very fond tributes on the big screen. The best of these are Freddie Francis’ Tales From The Crypt (1972) & George A. Romero’s Creepshow (1982).
Despite the obvious debt to the source material, these are very different films in terms of style and tone. Freddie Francis’ Crypt is the official EC adaptation, but it’s Romero’s film that better recaptures the feel of the comics, perhaps inspiring the goofy-grisly tone of the later HBO series. Both are above-average horror anthologies; Creepshow is the best such example from the 80′s (sorry, Deadtime Stories) and Crypt is probably the best of the Amicus anthologies next to Torture Garden.
The cultural differences make a side-by-side viewing of these two anthologies irresistible. Crypt feels very “British” and Creepshow feels very “American”, for lack of better signifiers. Crypt is restrained and, curious for those familiar with the EC formula (ie. horrible people receive a horrible supernatural comeuppance), it sports some surprisingly warm characters. Not warm in the sense that they’re cuddly human beings, but the characters are often kinder and seem to possess greater moral scruples than the EC comics or HBO series featured. Admittedly, that’s not saying much. Notable examples would be the surprisingly loving husband in the film’s take on “And All Through The House” (a remarkable contrast to the asshole in the HBO version of that story), an adulterer who expresses regret for running away from his wife and children (even bidding the latter a tender goodbye) and a character in a Monkey’s Paw-like story who is never shown to commit any wrong-doing (a reference to his harsh business practices seems shoe-horned in to fit the theme, last minute). Even the Crypt Keeper has been recast as a moral crusader (and guardian of Hell) instead of the punning ghoul so loved by his audience of “kiddies”.
If I were to dock points, it’d be the film’s few stale moments. This “moral” take on the Crypt Keeper, and its focus in the film’s wrap-around story, does nothing to disguise the fact that those segments rip-off the superior Torture Garden. Another unflattering comparison comes from the aforementioned Richard Donner directed “And All Through The House” for the HBO Crypt. Not only is the TV version faster, funnier and more suspenseful… it sports a memorably creepy villain. Larry Drake’s snaggletoothed killer is a remarkable improvement on the film’s barely noticeable baddie in a Santa suit. It’s like the director hired his dad to walk around in a Santa suit looking dirty and sad.
Nonetheless, all of the stories have their moments of inspiration. The use of Xmas carols dominating the film’s soundtrack in the first segment (much more effective than a traditional score) is one such highlight. The best story is just a Monkey’s Paw rip-off, but a rip-off enlivened by some wonderfully surreal touches. The appearances by a grim reaper on a motorcycle and whimsical pallbearers in tophats feel like outtakes from a Halloween episode of ITV’s The Avengers and things get surprisingly shocking/gory at the end. Francis’ Crypt generally benefits from a “less is more” approach, which also puts it at odds with the style of its source material. It’s great fun.

Ten years later, Romero and Stephen King’s five story EC tribute is a little more authentic and a little more American. I found this movie boring as a kid, but that’s likely because the seriocomic approach is never too intense or too funny. It’s like a subtler version of the Crypt TV series, which is to say it’s about as subtle as a “very special episode” of Family Matters…although it is a little distracting when you realize that half the score was re-used in Eli Roth’s Grindhouse trailer, Thanksgiving. Still, all of the stories have their merits, beginning with “Father’s Day”. This story also bends the EC rules a little bit, as the asshole character comes back and kills the ones he’s wronged, as well as a complete innocent. A complete innocent played by Ed Harris. A dancing Ed Harris, no less.
Next is Stephen King’s one man show as Jody Verill, the man who became a plant. King’s dialogue is very funny (“meteor shit!”) and his hammy, cartoon-like performance is highly entertaining. Despite the comedic tone, I was impressed that the ending gave poor Jody a moment of pathos before dying horribly. I kept expecting him to have survived his suicide attempt in one last bit of “Verill luck”, but the low-key ending bucked my expectations nicely.
“Something To Tide You Over” is the most fun story of the five. Richard (Leslie Nielsen), arrives at Harry’s (Ted Danson) apartment and pulls a gun on TV’s Sam Malone. Richard knows that Harry’s been having an affair with his wife, Becky. His revenge? Richard buries both Harry and Becky up to their necks on the beach…and there’s a very high tide coming in.
This one is exciting, funny and perfectly cast. Danson is surprisingly sympathetic as Harry, but Nielsen steals the show with a brilliant b-movie performance. His deadpan, hard-boiled delivery is perfect for Richard and, when the character cracks up in the climax, his manic insanity provides one of the film’s best moments (“I can hold my breath for a looooooong time! Haha!”). Credit must also be given to the sound designers who gave zombie Becky and Harry a creepy, digital bubbling under their dialogue for their brief re-appearances as waterlogged zombies.
Wrapping the film up, we have “The Crate”. It is still a funny story, but is probably the closest Creepshow comes to being frightening (tellingly, it was the only segment I liked as a kid). The monster– a cross between Shakma, Alien and Harry (from Harry And The Hendersons fame)–is genuinely frightening and the few comic vignettes (like Holbrook’s fantasies of killing his wife, the best of which sees him getting applause at a posh dinner party) only enhance the suspense.
Finally, “They’re Creeping Up On You” and the wraparound story close out the picture. The former has a great, Darren McGavinish performance by E.G. Marshall and the latter is somewhat by-rote, but is saved by a nice turn by Tom Atkins as the kid’s abusive father and a funny cameo from Tom Savini. Whenever someone references the wraparound, I can’t help but think of it as a ten minute pre-cursor to Michael Jackson’s “Black or White” prologue with George Wendt in place of Atkins. It ends the film on an appropriately nasty note.
As with Grindhouse and The Cabin In The Woods, it’s nice to see such loving tributes to eras of horror gone by. Whether it’s in reference to the giddily nasty comics of the 50′s or a Vestron VHS with lurid cover art, there’s something kind of sweet about filmmakers growing up to pay homage to the scary stories of their youths. One can only hope that future throwbacks will be as fun as the ’72 Crypt or Creepshow.
Until next week, boils and ghouls, I’ll be in the cinematic trenches watching questionable films. In the interim, I leave you with the following rap video featuring the Crypt Keeper and the poor man’s equivalent of the Fly Girls. Boo!



Adam Clarke | Mon, Apr 16, 2012 | 744
On Screen