
Adam Clarke remembers an age when Star Trek actually felt like Star Trek
Within the first twenty minutes of the moronically-titled Star Trek Into Darkness, a Starfleet building is blown to pieces, characters are assassinated in hails of gunfire and, to top it all off, Captain Kirk (Chris Pine) suggests that the man responsible be tracked and murdered.
Shortly thereafter, Scotty (Simon Pegg) asks “didn’t we used to be explorers?”
That one line captures much of what’s wrong with the latest Trek. Here we have another Trek film that sacrifices the spirit of the series in favour of a generic action flick, which has been happening since at least ’96. More depressingly, Scotty’s line is stolen, having been uttered by Captain Picard in Star Trek: Insurrection.
Star Trek Into Darkness is a cynical exercise in talking down to the audience. By embracing a script with no inspiration, J.J. Abrams and his writers prove that they can make a very polished looking action movie that’s superficially pleasing but bereft of ideas. 2009′s Star Trek compensated for a limp villain with a fast pace, note perfect cast, terrific score and impressive special effects.
The successful elements return in Darkness, but the problems are magnified. Thought Nero was uninteresting? Well, this film has two villains whose goals and actions are often baffling. Where the last film sacrificed the idea that these characters are exploring the unknown, it’s completely forgotten about in a film that includes foot chases through crowded city streets, universal terrorism and women who exist solely to either whine or look good in their undies.
It all could’ve been so different. In the first ten minutes, there’s a dumb but fun action sequence that offers a glimpse of an entertaining Trek sequel. The Enterprise crew have to distract an alien civilization from a volcanic eruption. While the aliens (Cinema Natives from the Planet Stereotype) chase Kirk and Bones, Spock descends into a volcano to detonate a cold fusion bomb that’ll stop the eruption somehow(?)
Then the Enterprise rescues its three main characters from furthering tinkering with their Prime Directive of non-interference and they all whisk away. How was the Enterprise hiding from the natives, you ask? In space, perhaps? No, dingus! The Enterprise was under water.
Okay, that’s stupid, but it’s the only really fun part of this film. That scene also points the way to a successful sequel with its wide-eyed adventurous tone. This film deals with terrorism and enemies attacking a hero from the inside, which is old hat after the new Batman films, Skyfall and the like. It also rips off most moments from one of Star Trek‘s most iconic stories. But instead of mixing Trek‘s greatest hits with contemporary war on terror bullshit, the Darkness should’ve turned to Raiders Of The Lost Ark if they wanted to imitate a successful blockbuster.
If this Trek turned to Raiders or even Richard Chamberlain’s King Solomon’s Mines for inspiration, it’d be a damn sight better than what ended up on screen. An adventure movie within the Spielberg-Lucas tradition is certainly in line with Abrams’ interests and would make for a Trek that would appeal to just about everybody. Bigwigs in Hollywood assume people want big action sequences with loud noises, frantic editing and spinning cameras. Trekkies want a film about exploring the unknown. By aping something like Raiders you’d have your big action scenes, but you’d at least be forced to have the characters go out, y’know, adventuring.
Now, I don’t necessarily want a Star Trek film for everybody and would be happy for a film that took a few chances and had ambition, but the creative team behind this incarnation of Trek are not only uninterested in an ambitious script, but it seems they’re incapable of creating one.
I’ll refrain from spoilers, but if you’ve read any of the guides to this film or even glanced at its Wikipedia page, I can assure you that the dumb, obvious pandering is all there.
Star Trek Into Darkness isn’t the worst film I’ve seen all year. This is the year I was subjected to Identity Thief, Spring Breakers, Oz: The Great & Powerful and Stoner FM, so that’s more or less impossible. The special effects are amazing, as are the cast (I could watch an entire film where Karl Urban’s McCoy grumbles in space) and score (Abrams regular Michael Giacchino)…again. The problem is that the film is insultingly dumb.
Without spoiling anything, let me ask you this, is a Star Trek movie that hinges on a character having magic blood really worth seeing?



May 23rd, 2013 at 10:53 pm
It’s weird because on the one hand, they seemed to have no intetrest in making an actual Star Trek movie, but then on the other hand there’s all this pandering to… well I don’t want to give anything away either, but if you’ve seen it you know what I mean.
They don’t respect the philosophy of Star Trek and they totally don’t respect the science and…
And ok, SPOILERS ALERT
*
*
*
Ok…
So you can just rock up to an incredibly powerful alien race’s planet and launch a scout shit from your massive starship and not be detected… because you’re heading for an abandoned province? The area surrounding that homeworld should be busier than the Panama Canal. They should have been detected immediately.
Same goes for the battle near Earth. Where the heck are all the ships and stations and general space traffic? Why isn’t anyone scanning the area at all times and sending forces to investigate giant starship battles happening between Earth and the Moon? Why is Starfleet so defenceless against falling debris the size of the largest starship ever built heading not just right for the planet but right for them? Which seemed to yield no real consequences in the story. Are we supposed to just care? So many faceless people have died at this point, it’s kind of hard to feel anything more in that department. Just a big crash for a big crash’s sake, I guess.
It’s all too convenient and weird.
Still, oddly, I enjoyed the movie. About 20 minutes in I was super grumpy for many of the reasons you’ve listed above. And then I just said eff it and decided to go along for the ride. And it was fun while it lasted.
May 24th, 2013 at 7:05 pm
You guys forgot to get drunk first!