
Adam Clarke probably should’ve watched “Flirting With Disaster” again.
Ah, the romantic comedy. The only genre of film that can be roughly as pleasant as a brick in the gonads. Every year, countless vehicles come out in the hopes of telling stories with the standard formula of meet cutes, misunderstandings, and endless climaxes of people running towards each other in mild drizzle.
These films are usually as romantic as Jesse Ventura’s Predator dialogue, and they consistently fail to reach the heights that Woody Allen did when he perfected the modern rom-com in Annie Hall.
But they keep on coming. In the meantime, us drooling plebs at the multiplex suffer the sight of the grimacing, sour milk faces of Katherine Heigl and Kate Hudson hovering over us like the gargoyles they are. Seeing the noxious poster for Heigl’s The Ugly Truth and its near-identical twin Killers remain the only times “Coming Soon!” felt less like a promise and more like the grim warnings of Crazy Ralph (that Friday The 13th hobo who kept telling people they were doomed if they went to Camp Crystal Lake.)
Which brings us to Silver Linings Playbook, easily one of the better entries in this genre. Althought that accomplishment is roughly on par with being the dictator with the lowest genocide rate.
The film stars Bradley Cooper in a rare non-obnoxious role. He’s Pat, a bi-polar teacher who is institutionalized after finding his wife in the shower with another man and beating the bejesus out of him. After his short stint in the dark ward, Pat is placed in the care of his long-suffering parents (Jackie Weaver and Robert De Niro).
Despite the restraining order his ex-wife placed on him, Pat is keeping a PMA (Positive Mental Attitude) and is insistent he can piece his old life back together. Given his desire to hunt down his ex and compulsively watch their wedding video, his PMA (Positive Mental Attitude) seems more like a PMA (Permanent Mental Ailment).
It isn’t long before Tiffany (Jennifer Lawrence) literally comes running into his life while on his morning jog. She’s roughly as damaged as Pat, as the loss of her husband has made her a compulsive liar who numbs herself with impulsiveness. Tiffany likes Pat, but decides the best way to get his attention is to lie to him by promising to deliver a letter to his ex-wife. In return, she wants to enter a dance competition with him.
As someone with a long history of depression, I get a little testy about films depicting mental illness. An area that’s so painful for me is often portrayed as a series of comical quirks and twitches when the reality is a permanent bad dream. That Pat’s group therapy meeting — seen in the first two minutes of the film — included a nebbish with a sock puppet didn’t bode well for the rest of the picture.
To Playbook‘s credit, it was directed and written by David O. Russell (adapted from the novel by Matthew Quick). Russell’s made some great films in the past, like Flirting With Disaster and I Heart Huckabees, as well as the popular Three Kings and The Fighter. One goes into his rom-com hoping he can dodge the annoying tropes and awkward sentiment like so many action heroes outrunning fireballs in slow motion.
And, for the most part, he does. Sure, Pat’s therapist (Anupam Kher) wouldn’t be out of place in a Julia Roberts vehicle… and the film ends with a scene where (spoiler!) Pat has to run to Tiffany (gasp)… and the character of Tiffany only works because she’s got Jennifer Lawrence’s charm. Still, the film has its moments, even a few great ones, and Pat is depicted pretty honestly. For there to be a bi-polar character who isn’t played for cringe laughs and whose condition isn’t dumbed down is a mainstream movie miracle.
Kudos to Bradley Cooper, not only for his portrayal of Pat, but for playing something other than a charmless, facile prick for once. Following the unfunny The Hangover, Cooper became the go-to guy for producers needing a smarmy actor who doesn’t exude the same level of paralyzing douche-mist as Ryan Reynolds. In Playbook, Cooper’s muted, believable and, for the first time, likable. I never knew he had it in him.
On that note, another actor in the film casting off his usual antics is Chris Tucker as one of Pat’s group therapy buddies. Either Tucker can act or he finally discovered his Eddie Murphy impression wasn’t even funny in his pre-Jackie Chan days. Tucker’s and Cooper’s performances aren’t the revelation here, oh no. Perhaps even more impossibly, we have the first film in which De Niro bothered to act since, I dunno, Analyze This? De Niro’s character doesn’t have much depth, but it’s so nice to see him actually caring that I’ll give it a pass.
So, we have David O. Russell and company mostly getting it right in a fairly woeful genre. Russell deserves praise because he didn’t surrender to the cliches of portraying mental illness on screen. I’m inclined to give Silver Linings Playbook a recommendation, if only a minor one. Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m due back in the cinema, hoping to avoid any poster featuring rom-com ladies and their rotting pumpkin faces.
…They say if you stare into Katherine Heigl’s poster eyes, she’ll steal your soul, you know. If a film of hers is playing in the cinemas, don’t go! Her films have a Death Curse.



February 13th, 2013 at 11:04 am
While I mostly agree with your observations on the performances of Cooper, Tucker and De Niro (I thought Cooper was OK), I’m surprised you didn’t make any mention of Jennifer Lawrence other than to say her character benefited from Lawrence’s charm.
Lawrence stole the show, in my opinion. After seeing her in The Hunger Games, I thought that maybe she was made of wood, but her performance in SLP begs to differ.
I kinda loved this movie. Particularly the message. And there were some great setup/payoff moments that managed to take my by surprise.
And to a certain extent, I liked the fact that it recognized that we’re all a little bit off our rockers. Not in a mocking, exploitative way, as you acknowledged, but in an honest, not white-washing the characters way.