
Dave Newman falls in love with Lars and the Real Girl.
So many things could have gone wrong with a movie like “Lars and the Real Girl”.
But they don’t.
And what we’re left with is a quirky but compassionate study of a man who learns a great many things about love a good deal later in life than most. Ryan Gosling, a young Canadian actor who has made a name for himself and backed it up with pure talent, plays Lars Lindstrom, who takes a town by surprise when he becomes infatuated with a life-sized doll he names Bianca.
Now I have to stop myself—the description already sounds like a ridiculously cheesy sitcom plot—but this movie bravely avoids opportunities to go wrong, due to a masterful control of tone by its director and by a cast of actors who appear to care deeply about the lead character and each other. It sometimes seems rare to see a movie this sincere about itself that doesn’t slide into melodrama, but I found Lars’ story to be handled with such care that the movie never once felt forced.
It’s quirky, yes, but also has an almost timeless elegance.
These are strange words to use when describing a movie billed and advertised as a comedy. But this movie is not laugh-out-loud funny, nor is it intended to be a comical story. It features a great many scenes that are amusing, which grow out of a deep attachment we feel for the characters on screen. So there you have it, if it is pure comedy that you want, look elsewhere, but this film is so charming and ultimately moving, I recommend it without hesitation.
The movie is set in a quiet little town. It shows us Lars, and the people who love him and care for him, his brother, played by Paul Schneider, and his sister-in-law, played by Emily Mortimer. They are all young actors—somewhat familiar and yet still untainted by pre-conceptions of celebrity—and all of them are portray believable characters.
We meet Lars’ psychiatrist, played by Patricia Clarkson, and so much is said about her relationship with her patient without words. We are introduced to other inhabitants of the town who know Lars and care for him enough as to carry on with an elaborate fantasy just so that he feels like he can fit in.
Again, as I describe elements of the movie I am reminded of how many things it had to juggle in order to get everything right—a lot. But not all of that is due to Ryan Gosling, who earned acclaim for his incredible role two years ago in “Half Nelson”—wherein he portrayed another character who had trouble adjusting to the world he lived in. Here, however, Ryan goes even deeper. Lars is as quiet, awkward, and confused a protagonist as you are liked to see, but Gosling plays every scene with a great sense of acting beyond mere dialogue delivery. He inhabits the role of Lars, making his every movement, stutter, and tick communicate a deep understanding of a character who is not necessarily as delusional or delayed as he might at first seem to be. Lars knows that he can’t keep fooling himself like this forever, and the film toys with scenes that indicate a great amount of toil and change within him which he never communicates to others.
This is a good enough performance to make him even more of a promising star, and, criminally, it seems as though this movie will soon fade into history largely unnoticed.
A great character study and a powerfully moving comedy. When we laugh, it’s not at anyone on screen—it’s with a sense of truth about the absurdity of the world. I came to this expecting to laugh, but ended up enjoying the learning a whole lot more.
Lars and the Real Girl is now available on DVD.



The Scope | Thu, Apr 24, 2008 | 170
On Screen