
Adam Clarke‘s nickname in high school was “Monster X”
Pacific Rim is the film the entire internet has ejaculated over. I won’t recap the plot here (in short: robot suits vs. monsters), but I am a bit puzzled by all the hype. Truth is, the first time I went to see the film, I fell asleep 20 minutes in. Second time was more successful, as I only fell asleep an hour into the movie. And this is the movie fanboys and fangirls are losing their robo-shit over?
After a third viewing where I stayed awake FOR THE WHOLE THING (cue applause here), I skimmed the internet commentary for the film. It’s telling that Pacific Rim‘s fandom is based entirely on reactions to other films. On the one hand, you’ve got movie aficionados eager to praise a new film as a cult classic, resulting in a baffling “it’s the new Star Wars” comments springing on message boards and the like. Next, you’ve got people comparing it to Avatar stating Pacific Rim will be remembered because, unlike Avatar, people are still talking about it and its fandom is growing. As much as Avatar left me cold, that sort of reasoning forgets that Avatar rode a wave of popularity for months after its release. Saying Pacific Rim will outlast it is roughly on par with an eager Geffen record executive predicting that all dances will be dropped in favor of The Bartman.

Pacific Rim wasn’t terrible, but it’s a film driven solely by nostalgia, not story or inspiration. Watching the film I was reminded of Sky Captain Of The World Of Tomorrow. Both films ooze with a passion for their source material, but had the same effect. I remember being bored in the theatre and thinking “I should be liking this”. Rim has Idris Elba and monster fights, Sky Captain has a cameo from Godzilla. These should be my favourite movies based on my movie rental choices for the last 20 years.
Except they’re both boring. Really boring.
With Sky Captain it seems that the sleek, green screen based production lead to a stiff, overtly-polished yet sterile film. It’s as boring as The Phantom Menace though it is far more inspired. Pacific Rim‘s not as bad as Captain, but I think part of the problem lies with the uninspiring designs. Look at that monster at the top of the page again. Now compare with…

…Godzilla Vs. Gigan. Look at those monsters! Specifically, pay attention to the monster with knives for hands. He has knives for hands. How did he steal Scott Summers’ visor if he has knives for hands?
That monster’s name is Gigan. He has a buzzsaw for a belly and is his design is incredibly silly. However, like King Ghidorah (the three-headed dragon in the above pic) and the other monsters in that picture, there’s one thing his design isn’t: bland. The monsters and robots in Pacific Rim have about as much personality as a bowlful of mayonnaise. I find it impossible to find anything exciting about this film unless nostalgia and nostalgia alone gives you one helluva charge. And if you spend all your time thinking about anime-inspired mech warriors and giant monsters, you’re probably too busy updating TV Tropes to watch a movie.
Like Sky Captain, the makers of Pacific Rim clearly like most of the same things I like. They also made love letters to their inspirations. Neat-o. It’d be nice if there was something other than nostalgia at work in either film. Unlike Star Wars, films like Sky Captain and Pacific Rim never seem like more than shopping lists of pop references.



Adam Clarke | Thu, Aug 8, 2013 |
On Screen