
Extra! Extra! I’ve become my dad because I’ve spent the last few weeks going to bed after marathons of Columbo. Its reruns were the staple of the A&E network before they got in the game of every other TV network to transform television into the little rectangle angry viewers turn to watch little people fail. Columbo lasted from 1968 to 2003 and the cat-and-mouse detective stories were bound to be a hit with the right actor in the lead.
And Peter Falk was Columbo. No one else could do that. Hopefully, no one else will try. In honour of Peter Falk, who died June 23, 2011, I thought I’d look back on the five best episodes the long-running series had to offer.
Murder By The Book (1971)
The mystery novel writing team of Ken Franklin and Jim Ferris are splitting up… with murder!
Sorry, I couldn’t really resist that. In all seriousness, that is the basic plot, as Jack Cassidy’s Franklin murders his partner. Book is the very first episode of the Columbo series proper. The character, as played by Falk had originally appeared in two one-off TV movies: Prescription: Murder and Ransom For A Dead Man. Of the two, Dead Man is a decent episode of the series, but is more interesting to see Falk finding the character. Prescription: Murder‘s Columbo doesn’t even seem like the same guy and its one truly memorable aspect is a fantastic, funky score by Dave Grusin.
So, after those two films to establish the formula and character of Columbo, the regular series begins with this tight story written by Steven Bochco (Cop Rock) and directed by Steven Spielberg (1941). If you ever needed a reason as to why the Columbo telemovies had such longevity, Book is all the proof you need.

You are guilty...of looking fabulous.
Any Old Port In A Storm (1973)
Adrian Carsini (guest murderer Donald Pleasence) of the Carsini winery is perhaps the most respected man in the wine business. He has one of the most expensive wine collections in the world and produces a few expensive, but celebrated wines. When Carsini’s half-brother, Rick (Gary Conway) informs Adrian of his plans to sell the land to the makers of bargain basement wines, Adrian murders him and stages it to look like an accident. Of course, this doesn’t fool TV’s Columbo.
Port is the perfect showcase for the Columbo formula and why it works so well. Peter Falk cited this as one of the best episodes of the series and it’s easy to see why. Since the format of the series wasn’t “whodunnit” but “howcatchem”, strong actors were needed to pull off the episodes of the week. So, we have Pleasence against Falk in what would seem to be another snob-versus-slob battle that became the series’ most common dynamic. Unusually, we have a Columbo episode where the killer isn’t a total douche. Sure, Pleasence’s Carsini does come across like a lost relative of the Frasier Crane family, but there’s a child-like glee underneath all the manners. Where most Columbo guest murderers play up everything that’s dickish about their characters, Pleasence plays his scenes with Columbo with a legitimate vulnerability and, when discussing his passion for wine, a barely contained joy that seems to result in a friendship between the two. Pleasence’s giddiness seems to get the better of the detective, resulting in one of the more bittersweet endings to the series. Anything that pitted actors as powerful as Falk and Pleasence against each other was bound to be riveting and the script by Stanley Ralph Ross (a writer for the Adam West Batman) and Larry Cohen (Phone Booth, God Told Me To) is cracking stuff. Columbo was really a show to watch for the acting and Port gives Pleasence and Falk plenty of time to chew the scenery to bits.

Patrick McGoohan: the man with the laughing face.
By Dawn’s Early Light (1974) and Agenda For Murder (1990)
Dawn: When its board of trustees threatens to turn a military school from all-male to a co-ed operation, this ruffles the feathers of the perpetually agitated Col. Rumford (guest murderer Patrick McGoohan). Rumford then murders the president of the trustees by rigging a cannon to fire straight at the poor bastard during a ceremony. Columbo does what any good murder police would do and takes up room in the academy dorm.
Agenda: Lawyer Oscar Finch (McGoohan) has a promising future as an aid to a Vice Presidential candidate. When a former client threatens to expose a few skeletons in Finch’s closet, Finch silences his blackmailer with a bullet. Enter Columbo who gets his first clue from a newfangled device called a fax machine.
Earlier I mentioned that the Columbo formula played heavily on the slow-burn rage of its guest stars. Unsurprisingly, the hyper-intense creator-star of The Prisoner embodies this role perfectly. McGoohan, aged up somewhat unconvincingly to play Rumford, looks like he’s minutes away from stabbing everyone around him, so Falk’s continued picking at him is especially amusing. This is also true for McGoohan’s return in Agenda, which does give McGoohan a more sympathetic character but still allows for him to be as caustic and condescending as possible.
This later Columbo makes great use of McGoohan and his obvious discomfort around the shabby detective. Unlike the raging Rumford, there’s a lot more humour between Finch and Columbo’s encounters. The scene in which Columbo tells Finch a few recent jokes he heard while Finch reacts with delayed, forced laughter is one of the highlights of the series.
What this series does best, and why it only worked when it had the right actors for its murderers of the week, is to get talented, charismatic and theatrical actors to play off each other. For Columbo to work, you need an actor who threatens to steal the show from Falk. This was seldom a problem with the original 70’s Columbo series on NBC, but the ABC revival series from 1989-2003 is a different story. The trouble with the revival episodes is that too many of the killers are played by actors as charismatic as a bowlful of mayonnaise. McGoohan had already made a return appearance in 1975’s Identity Crisis (murdering Leslie Nielsen) and would return again in 1998’s Ashes To Ashes (murdering Rue McLanahan), which more or less makes him Columbo’s Moriarity. Either that or the same poor sap getting reincarnated to be jailed by an aging, schlubby cop.

William Shatner as Bane in the Adam West "Batman"
Fade In To Murder (1976)
Columbo vs. William Shatner. No words can do it justice, but I’ll try. In this sixth season episode, Ol’ Willy Shat is playing an egocentric TV actor who currently stars in a detective series, but was once a dangerous Toronto criminal (the worst kind of criminal!). He confounds our favourite TV detective by referring to himself in third person and offering Columbo advice “in character” as his TV detective. Needless to say, the bizarre, hammy character is perfect for Shatner.



June 28th, 2013 at 10:47 am
Nothing worse than a Toronto criminal….