
Image via boingboing.net
$115 million in federal funding gone. 88 news jobs eliminated. 215 jobs in English Services to be axed by June. This is what is happening to the CBC.
But how many posts did you see on your Facebook feed about any of the above three facts?
Most people agree that the CBC cuts are bad, but the biggest worrying I saw on Facebook seemed to be over the potential cancellation of Dragon’s Den or Republic of Doyle. And people took their howls of rage to social media for a good ol’ stint of slacktivism.
Here a pleasant narrative is created: First, share a “Save Our Show” campaign for a successful series that wasn’t going to be canceled anyway. Second, a few days later, share the press release confirming that said series will indeed be returning to the airwaves. You get to show concern about the Harper government’s gutting of the CBC and put a band-aid on the problem in the same week. All’s good! What were we so mad about again? I’m not sure!
Why hasn’t the threat of CBC Radio 2 selling commercial time received half as much concern as the people worries about losing their favourite shows? Oh right. Because you saved Dragon’s Den. Remember that victory when you hear a car rental jingle in between Basia Bulat and Beethoven.
Here’s what I’m still really mad about: The cuts are a huge trespass on our relationship with the CBC. The CBC is like our little brother. We can tell it how much it sucks whenever we want. But here our government has thrown a hissy fit about what the CBC says about them, and decided to beat them up and take their lunch money.
Nobody picks on the CBC but us!
I love the CBC. But, yes, that love is put to the test whenever Stuart McLean croaks about Morley in whatever town is willing to applaud him that week. Yes, that love is put to the test when no expense is spared for Peter Mansbridge’s round-the-clock coverage of Kate Middleton’s princess wedding.
I feel like CBC Television has never reached its potential. Not with its dramas and comedies, anyway. The network wants so desperately to be successful without ever taking the chances necessary to be successful. I fear that’s a lost cause (at least until we get a gritty reboot of Seeing Things), but they will be less inclined to take risks without funding.
You know what’s really scary about this? It has all the signs that the Harper government is that one squirrelly guy in prison who acts crazy in the hopes that no one will mess with him. How else can you reconcile the fact that the Conservatives — tied to the prohibitively expensive G20 summit (which effectively brought martial law to the streets of Toronto) and potentially tied the election robocall scandal — are the ones crying foul about the CBC’s transparency and money hemorrhaging?
Don’t think about that too much or you’ll need to wear a helmet just to keep your brain from popping out and sticking to the ceiling like a Wacky WallWalker.



May 1st, 2012 at 11:03 pm
THANK YOU!
I’ve been pretty angry about this and it seems as though I am one of very few people who care about the CBC beyond episdoes of Doyle.
The role of our government mandated national broadcaster is too important to be compromised like this. The CBC needs to a) exist and b) be properly funded because Canadaians need to be informed about what is going on in our country, province, municipality, etc. Without the CBC we would be relying on privately owned media conglomerates (/cell phone companies-lol!) to inform us. And, as I can only hope we all know, these conglomerates aren’t always the most reliable sources for unbiased and unlazy (or copy/paste) reporting.
Being in Newfoundland, we should especially be fighting for the CBC because without them our local televised news would be limited to NTV (what a sad, sad nightmare). There is no CTV or Global affiliate for Newfoundland. I am not counting the “Atlantic” or “Maritime” stations because their Newfoundland coverage is simply not good enough. And their parent companies, Bell and Shaw, respectively, know that it is not financially viable (especially in this economy) to set up shop here.
I agree with the speculation that the Tories hold a grudge against CBC for being too “liberal”/critical of them. Although I do understand that cuts ran pretty deep in a lot of areas with this most recent budget but $115 million is EXCESSIVE. That is a statement. The media and the government are SUPPOSED to have a co-dependent relationship. The media is to exist as a watchdog for the government and rely on the government for material to report on; the government is to use the media to inform the public and publicize themselves. I cannot understand why Harper would jeopardize this (though, it is worth noting that the Tories just won this year’s Code of Silence Award from the Canadian Association of Journalists).
Ideally, the CBC would work the same as the BBC in the UK and be entirely funded by the governement. I’m afraid, though, that in light of these budget cuts and the fact that Radio 2 will soon be forced to air commercials, that it will eventially become more like PBS and NPR in the States, which rely entirely on public donations from pledge drives. And that shit is ANNOYING.
I should also probably get into how our culture is being threatened with these cuts but I’ll stop here as this has already become tl;dr.
May 2nd, 2012 at 12:34 am
Years of ratings have consistently shown that Canadians, when given a TV remote and access to channels other than the CBC, will usually pick private sector content imported from the U.S.
Where’s the justification for forcing every Canadian to subsidize shows that they do not wish to watch or listen to? Hell, there are Anarchist ‘zines that are more self-sustaining than Republic of Doyle.
May 2nd, 2012 at 10:35 am
Republic of Doyle got a million viewers every episode this past Season. It also gets millions of dollars from NL Tourism due to the fact that they track visitors who are inspired to come to the province specifically because of what they see on the show.
Priorities of the CBC are basically 1. News 2. Radio 3. Sports 4. Light Entertainment. If you don’t see the value in 1 or 2, maybe you should move to the states where you can watch HBO and Hulu.
May 2nd, 2012 at 3:07 pm
Agreed anon.
The 10% funding cut means I’m about 10% satisfied. Pull the plug on it altogether.
Adam Clarke seems to deliberately leave out the fact that 110 million dollars, which sounds like a lot, only makes up for 10% of the taxpayer subsidies that the CBC receives. The amount of public money pumped into this wasteful organization is absolutely shocking.
May 2nd, 2012 at 3:15 pm
You can watch HBO here in Canada, I am a Republic fan however I don’t watch it on TV, I download it off the internet the next morning and watch it. Every time I pass a CBC station on the program dial I cringe.
May 2nd, 2012 at 3:48 pm
Gordon and anon, for an alternate viewpoint consider the BBC – arguably one of the most successful broadcasters in the world – and how it is funded.
Everyone in the UK who owns a TV must pay an annual license fee of £145.50 (£49 if it’s black and white), and this money goes directly towards funding the BBC’s many TV, Radio and online services.
For a breakdown of how this money is spent, check this link: http://www.bbc.co.uk/aboutthebbc/insidethebbc/whoweare/licencefee/
You pay the fee regardless of whether you watch the BBC on you TV or or not. And in the UK there are some really great free, privately operated channels like Channel 4 and ITV that compete with the BBC. Yet the BBC is insanely popular.
People in the UK invest in the BBC and they get a great return on that investment.
Funny how that works.
May 2nd, 2012 at 6:59 pm
there is a lot wrong with that you’re saying and i wrote a comment almost a full day ago that is still awaiting moderation which explains why. i hope i wasn’t forgotten about!
May 2nd, 2012 at 7:51 pm
I’d merely be content with a reversal of the CBC’s guiding principles (as outlined in the 1991 Broadcasting Act) into its traditional role of news collector and broadcaster – the only job it has done well since the CBC was created decades ago.
Everything else is unsustainable luggage that should fend for itself in the private sector.
May 2nd, 2012 at 9:15 pm
I know this is a serious issue but it has to be said… That picture is amazing. That is how I am going to fry my ham and/or bologna from now on.
May 3rd, 2012 at 12:21 pm
Whether or not it is a good investment for most Brits is irrelevant. It is still morally unjust and ethically wrong to force people to make investments in goods that have no concrete benefit to society as a whole.
I’m all for paying taxes in order to fund programs that build a better society – roads, police, basic education, and comprehensive healthcare. Everyone benefits when crime, preventable illnesses, and illiteracy aren’t running rampant.
Does Arctic Air or Republic of Doyle meet these requirements? Absolutely not. They are, when you get down to it, luxury goods. Pulling them would not have the effect that cuts to healthcare, OAS, or education are having right now.
When you get down to it, that’s where most of the CBC hate comes from. We see millions of dollars being taken from valuable and needed programs, and diverted towards the production of TV shows we don’t watch and art we would never buy.
I am not denying these people the opportunity to live their lives the way they want. I simply don’t want them to live on my dime, especially when I see no concrete benefit coming from what they produce.
May 3rd, 2012 at 12:25 pm
There’s great value in 1 and 2, which are public goods that should be divorced from the influences of the free market in order to keep journalism in this country in the hands of Canadians (and Canadians alone).
I fail to see any real value in 3 or 4, though.
May 5th, 2012 at 6:22 pm
Don’t think for one second that the CBC isn’t motivated (and biased) by money. That’s one of the main reasons why people hate them. They behave like any other corporation while enjoying their taxpayer subsidies which give them an unfair advantage over their competition. Conservatives tend to think that the CBC is too “liberal”, and that may be true by default, but the hatchet job they have done on the Conservative party has nothing to do with ideology, they’re just terrified of having their funding cut.
May 6th, 2012 at 5:52 pm
I listen to CBC radio a lot, mainly for news and current affairs shows. I no longer watch CBC TV or any TV really, except for the 10 o’clock news occasionally via the internet. The innovative shows I liked, like JPod got cancelled. Torchwood and DR, Who were on too late at night.
The BBC in UK does a great job and gets a lot of money.
This government is insane….
May 6th, 2012 at 5:55 pm
Anyone who dislikes frying bologna or ham in the shape of the cbc logo can pack a lunch.
May 6th, 2012 at 6:11 pm
I don’t care so much about CBC TV as I used to when there were shows like ‘Seeing Things’ and ‘Riverdale’ and ‘The Kids on DeGrassi Street’ and ‘The King of Kensington’. But what I feel very protective of is CBC Radio One. Radio One is the only ‘place’ where Canadians from all parts of this vast country can hear from each other on a daily basis.
May 6th, 2012 at 8:24 pm
I not only have been making lots of comments about this but I have written to the PM, Mulcair and Rae with my outrage and the prime ministers lies during the election campaign. Of course the government and the PMO have not responded but the opposition did. I am not alone in making comments on FB and urging people to write their members. However, this government wants to pretend that everything is fine and therefore does not acknowledge this.
May 6th, 2012 at 8:30 pm
You seem incapable of understanding how this promotes Canadian culture so let me help. We know very little about our native peoples and so a show that is set in the north with native Canadian actors helps to provide a window into the culture while at the same time entertaining us. The same goes for the Newfie show that has all that culture as a background. We are such a vast and diverse country that it is necessary to provide such a service in the name of national unity. We are unique in the world in that we live (and some would say are dominated by) the behemoth culture to the south. The only other place on earth remotely similar to this is New Zealand and Australia. Funnily enough the totally understand the issue.
May 7th, 2012 at 12:23 pm
That’s the whole point – subsidies are given to the CBC to ensure that they don’t have to compete in the private sector.
If Canadians actually hated the CBC for that reason, it wouldn’t exist, period. It would have already been privatized.
The whole point of the CBC (back when it was made) was to have a nationwide voice that is accountable ONLY to Canadians. Not to a small number of shareholders, who are usually foreign nationals.
I don’t know about you, Mr. Gekko, but it’s comforting to me to know that there’s at least one institution reporting the news in Canada that isn’t owned in part by Americans, Chinese, Saudis, or who else.
May 7th, 2012 at 12:31 pm
Here’s an idea. Instead of promoting national unity through token gestures like cop shows and b-movie dramas, why don’t we keep everyone in confederation through DRINKABLE WATER and FUNCTIONING HEALTH CARE?
I remember a friend of mine who lived most of his childhood in public housing. Every now and then well-meaning university students would trapize around the neighbourhood, getting all of the kids to do arts and crafts activities.
He always hated that. Why? Because he didn’t need to be taught how to make an ice-cream cone out of construction paper. He needed those students to fix the heating that never worked and clean the broken beer bottles out of the sand in the playground that he could otherwise never use.
Think about that the next time you champion the funneling of public money into another CBC TV show.
May 7th, 2012 at 3:44 pm
for anon, this is a typical ploy. It is called obfuscation. You imply that cutting funding for the CBC will improve health care and the lives of the poor. Of course one could say that if you didn’t spend $30 billion on fighter jets that cannot fly in the northern regions (we are a northern country) that we could spend it all on health care or poverty issues. Both arguments are specious at best. However, if we start at the beginning and say what are our priorities and name them as health care, abolishing poverty and education then the other priorities will fall into place. Surely our priority is not to give huge tax cuts to major corporations and oil companies so that we don’t have the revenue to pay for our number one priorities. When we make tradeoffs, as you are proposing, we should see where they fit in with those priorities. By the way those are all social and societal priorities. So in order to have the society that we want we need to fund it but how we fund it is as important as what we fund. It is all about choices and the choices should reflect the wishes of the majority (not talking fake gov’t majority) while respecting the wishes of the minority. What we no longer see coming out of Ottawa is respect.
May 8th, 2012 at 2:44 pm
I’m not implying it, I’m outright stating it.
The state has access to a limited amount of resources. Cutting spending in one sector, therefore, frees up resources to be used for any other government expenditure. Whether or not those funds are applied to program X, institution Y, or Z number of tax cuts depends on the priorities of the government.
Regarding the rest of you message, yes I do agree with you. The Harper government’s priorities are completely out of wack. But to me it is hypocritical to denounce a government program with dubious public benefit (F-35 fighter jets) while championing another government program with dubious public benefit (subsidies for CBC arts programs). Both are taking tax dollars which could have been used to help millions of Canadians and are spending them on projects that produce very little public benefits in return.
May 8th, 2012 at 8:07 pm
The CBC will never kill anyone. Fighter jets will. I know what I’d rather waste my tax dollars on…
May 9th, 2012 at 1:48 am
I will probably never convince you about the wonderful benefits of having the CBC with all its intellectual content that makes the Canadian people more thoughtful, considerate, tolerant of the differences in our country. It is what makes us so special and lucky to be Canadian. I for one am willing to spend my considerable contribution to the tax dollars spent on such a positive influence in my country. Having traveled and enjoyed listening to the CBC far from home and seeing what is NOT available in other countries I truly appreciate this wonderful institution. I will fight this government on their short sighted, small-minded, petty and vindictive pursuit of the destruction of the CBC.