
Adam Clarke knows about your crooked wang
In the previous instalment of this review, I went over the flaws of Community‘s third season. Episodes that tried to tell too many stories in a single half-hour, storylines that didn’t go anywhere, recycling ideas from the past two seasons, Michael K. Williams’ stiff performance: all of these problems dominated the first three episodes of the season. Luckily, the rest of the season shaped up to be pretty amazing even if those initial episodes got things off to a terrible start. Dan Harmon earned a grace period with fans. If the fourth season opened with episodes that weak, I know I wouldn’t last all 13 episodes.
The remainder of this season consisted of…

Remedial Chaos Theory
Crib notes: When a game of Yahtzee is interrupted by a pizza delivery, the dice is rolled to determine which member of the study group will get it. This creates a series of alternate universes with each of the Greendale Seven getting up for pizza in separate timelines. Depending on who leaves to get the pizza in the prime timeline, the effects on the study group could be disastrous.
Choice dialogue: “To Pierce, may he rest…in Pierce. Ha!”
“Shirley, I think you’ve had enough”
“…of YOU”
- Britta (Gillian Jacobs) vs a drunken Shirley (Yvette Nicole Brown) in the darkest timeline
Grade: Easily a contender for Community‘s finest (half) hour, with all of the characters getting a moment to shine. This episode introduces the timelines, Evil Troy and Evil Abed, the Scandinavian troll from Troy’s nightmares (“Feel the terror, Troy!”) and has the first funny closing credits tag of the season (partially quoted above).
This episode did some much needed repair work for Shirley’s character. In season two, Shirley seemed to be around not because the writers had any real stories for her, but because Brown could turn every line they gave her into comedy gold. She had more to do in the end credits tag of “Remedial Chaos Theory” than most of the previous season. Her need to bake as a means of contributing something to the group offers a retroactive explanation for Shirley’s more cartoonish moments in earlier episodes. Also, I totally want her “He Is Risen” apron. A+.

Horror Fiction in Seven Spooky Steps
Crib notes: Britta receives the results of her anonymous psychological questionnaires and it turns out someone in the study group has homicidal tendencies. Britta then invites the gang to a Halloween pre-party and gets each member of the study group to tell a horror story in the hopes of weeding out Greendale’s most disturbed student.
Choice dialogue: “Then he chainsawed them to bits! Then he put them back together. Then he chainsawed them again…forever.”
- Shirley tells a spooky story.
Grade: I once heard that the reason Star Trek: The Next Generation had so many “Wesley saves the day” stories is because every staff writer was asked to write such a story and the producers were only going to film the best one. TV production being what it is, the producers got into a jam and had to film all of them. I don’t know if that’s true, but it feels like a lot of season two and three was comprised of stories dealing with in-fighting amongst the study group. I hope the new showrunners don’t lean as heavy on the “study group is fighting again” plots as Harmon and company did for the first half of the season. It’s also a bit disappointing that the episode reveals that Abed is the only one who tested as sane in Britta’s revised profile. Anyone who’d seen a handful of episodes of the show guessed that. However, it kinda contradicts the “Evil Abed” storyline that develops later this season. Still, this is a funny, stylish episode that retreads all-too-familiar ground and suffers from comparisons to previous episodes about group infighting (particularly “Remedial Chaos Theory”), as well as the last two Halloween specials. B

Advanced Gay
Crib notes: Hawthorne Wipes moist towelettes become an unexpected hit with gay consumers, making Pierce something of a gay icon. Jeff defends Pierce against Pierce’s ancient, bigoted father, Cornelius (Larry Cedar). Troy is kidnapped by Vice Dean Laybourne (John Goodman) and pressured to enter the Air Conditioner Repair Annex.
Choice dialogue: “Gentlemen, you are here tonight because you have been selected as potential candidates for the Greendale Air Conditioning Repair School. But why kidnap you? Why put a sack over your head and drag you here in the middle of the night? Why is there an astronaut in the corner making paninis? Simple. We don’t want you telling anyone about this. If you do, we don’t want them believing you. Isn’t that right, Black Hitler?”
- Vice Dean Laybourne
Grade: Another contender for the series’ best episode. Unlike the season premiere, this episode anchors the Laybourne story arc to a strong main story. Pierce as a reluctant gay icon, Pierce and Jeff taking on Cornelius, Britta psychoanalyzing (and annoying) the hell out of Jeff…all make for an exceptionally strong, banter-heavy episode of Community. Pierce’s storyline goes for the sweet, Troy’s storyline goes for the surreal, and the two unrelated plots make for a very satisfying whole. Abed’s Troy impression (“I like football, but also I don’t”), Annie’s disappointment over the cancelled pride party (“I just bought a cone bra”) and the opening scene with an increasingly flustered Pierce (“Stop putting gay things in my mouth!”) feature all members of the cast at their finest. A+

Studies in Modern Movement
Crib notes: The gang help Annie move in to Troy and Abed’s place, save Jeff who’s faking a sick day in order to hang out at the mall…with Dean Pelton.
Choice dialogue: “Men — can’t live with ‘em, can’t leave ‘em alone with your tape”
“Britta, don’t tell jokes. You’re bad at it”
- Britta and Annie
Grade: An interesting question about Annie’s place in the group is raised and dropped. Still, it’s not really a great episode for Annie, as “Studies” works because of its Shirley/Britta and Jeff/Dean subplots. This episode is extremely important for establishing the Dreamatorium, a closet rigged to look like the holodeck where Troy and Abed have pretend adventures. The Dreamatorium will, of course, be tied to Abed’s neuroses, as well as his brief slip into madness in the finale. Even if the episode feels a little rushed (I could’ve watched a whole episode of Shirley and Britta clashing in the car) and lacks a strong conclusion, it’s still a very funny episode. B

Documentary Filmmaking Redux
Crib notes: Dean Pelton’s perfectionist and tyrannical sides come out while filming a commercial for Greendale.
Choice dialogue: “I’m thinking about breaking into the TV game since it’s apparently sticking around. I don’t want to wake up 30 years and wonder, ‘what if?’”
- Leonard Rodriguez (Richard Erdman), Greendale’s oldest mature student.
Grade: A long overdue episode to showcase the series’ quirkiest character and beloved Dean, Craig Pelton. While ostensibly acting as a spoof of behind-the-scenes epic, Hearts of Darkness: A Filmmaker’s Apocalypse (name-checked by Abed as being way better than Apocalypse Now), “Redux” does what Community does best: a story that parodies a pop culture artifact on the surface as a vehicle for character growth. In this case, the Dean’s meltdown when he finally takes charge of something important. From the brilliant dialogue (“The word he’s looking for is ‘sassy’. Better pray he don’t find it”) to the rare funny moment for Chang (as a self-appointed understudy for Jeff) to its sweet conclusion, “Redux” is easily in the top 5 episodes of the series. A+

Foosball and Nocturnal Vigilantism
Crib notes: Jeff and Shirley join forces to defeat smug foosball enthusiasts. When his copy of The Dark Knight is destroyed, Abed dresses as Batman to find the culprit.
Choice dialogue: “Shut up, Leonard! I found your YouTube page. What’s the point of reviewing frozen pizzas?”
“You’re talking about it.”
- Shirley and Leonard sum up internet culture in a single exchange.
Grade: Continuing her recovery from a walking stereotype in season two, Shirley gets a strong story alongside Jeff, fighting against Nick Kroll (hilarious in his role as a foosball enthusiast). While the ending’s a little schmaltzy, that story is funny and sweet. It’s great to see Jeff bond with Shirley (it’s easily the best pairing of characters outside of Troy and Abed). Abed’s Batman storyline is less successful, as it just milks Danny Pudi’s Christian Bale impression, which was put to greater effect in season one’s “Introduction to Statistics”. A-

Regional Holiday Music
Crib notes: The study group is forced to compete in glee club regionals at the behest of sweatervest-clad, aggressively asexual Mr Rad (Taran Killam).
Choice dialogue: “Glee is the answer when questions are wrong”
-Cory “Mr Rad” Radison, head of the glee club.
Grade: Like Abed’s return as Batman in the previous episode, “Regional” takes a joke Community‘s done before (filling in for the glee club as per “Paradigms of Human Memory”) and expands on it. This time, the results are a lot more successful, as the story’s pretty inspired. Instead of the group being pressured to join the glee club, glee is portrayed in a Invasion of the Body Snatchers light with each Greendale student acting very differently when possessed by glee. Yes, it’s a bit late to be doing a Glee spoof after two seasons of jokes at Glee‘s expense, but songs like “Baby Boomer Santa” and “Jehovah’s Most Secret Witness” justify the project. The only aspects that leave a bad taste in my mouth are the lazy resolution (shifty character confesses to the murder of the glee club at the last minute; the exact same thing would be repeated in the season finale) and the lame closing credits tag. A-

Urban Matrimony and the Sandwich Arts
Crib notes: Shirley’s torn between re-marrying Andre (Malcolm Jamaal-Warner) and starting her own business with Pierce.
Choice dialogue: ‘Webster’s dictionary defines’? That’s the Jim Belushi of speech openings! It accomplishes nothing, everyone keeps using it and nobody even knows why!
- Annie destroys Jeff’s wedding speech
Grade: Between Shirley’s wedding, Britta’s unexpected talent as a floral arranger, Annie’s all-too-intense enthusiasm for wedding ideas, the Pierce-Shirley sandwich shop, Jeff’s speech dilemma and ongoing daddy issues, this episode is as overstuffed as the season premiere, but manages to be a lot more satisfying. Troy and Abed becoming normal made for some funny moments, but that easily could’ve been its own story. It’s telling that, despite the wedding being the central plot here, Pierce and Shirley trying to convince the Dean about the feasibility of a sandwich shop (“That’s me! Where did I get all that money I’m holding?”) makes for better television than Andre-Shirley sniping. B

Contemporary Impressionists
Crib notes: When Abed gets in debt with a celebrity lookalike business, Troy must go out of his way to protect his friend. Meanwhile, Jeff takes anti-anxiety medication with sexy results.
Choice dialogue: “I don’t know who told you pouting was an option for you, but all you’re making me feel is hatred toward Renee Zellwegger”
- Dean Pelton
Grade: A potentially funny idea plays a little flat onscreen with a few too many broad, easy jokes (Jeff being hit on by stereotypical divorcees, Chang’s thought balloons) to be truly great. Still, the subplot with Jeff on anti-anxiety meds gives the character a few interesting places to go before transforming into “Seacrest Hulk” and beating up an army of children. This is where the Evil Abed storyline begins to take hold, but that sort of arc-building is not Community‘s strength. Better is the last conversation with Troy and Abed, where Troy tries to reason with his best friend, who’s been oblivious to the trouble he’d gotten into with the shady celebrity lookalike service. Scenes like that remind me of season two’s great, melancholy “Mixology Certification” (Troy’s birthday), showcasing just how well the show can blend drama with comedy. Still, Chang and his child army are annoying and their scenes wouldn’t go anywhere until “The First Chang Dynasty”. B

Digital Exploration of Interior Design
Crib notes: Vice Dean Laybourne drives a wedge between Troy and Abed, as they fight over whether to build a pillow fort or a blanket fort. Britta falls for Subway, a new student representing the new franchise that’s opened in the Greendale cafeteria.
Choice dialogue: “Is that you, Subway? My eyesight’s not what it used to be.”
“Eat these tater tots, Harry. For what it’s worth, I think you see more than all of us.”
- Subway (Travis Schuldt) helps a blind man (Wil Garret).
Grade: Building on the rift between Troy and Abed in the previous episode, Laybourne successfully pushes Troy and Abed against each other. But the episode seems to know that the much funnier story involves Britta falling in love with a “corpo-humanoid” (a man who gives up all his rights, freedoms and identity to represent a corporation) named Subway. The Subway love story—and Subway’s subsequent expulsion due to a sex act “well out of the mainstream”–as well as Pierce’s increasingly insane feats of corporate espionage, provide the real laughs in the episode. John Goodman, whose character is “going through some stuff right now” (hence his new look), does some of his best work here. B+

Pillows and Blankets
Crib notes: In this parody of Ken Burns documentaries, we see the results of the all-out pillow fight that resulted from the previous episode.
Choice dialogue: “Leonard likes this”
- Leonard’s award-winning re-enactment of his reaction to Troy’s facebook post.
Grade: A better idea in concept than execution, this episode is very funny when providing dramatic readings of Facebook statuses and texts. Community is at its best when it weds its pop culture stories to strong character development. While I don’t think the Troy-Abed feud/Burns spoof was the best of these, it did hit the right comedic and dramatic beats. It’s perfectly in character that Troy and Abed would keep fighting just to keep their friendship alive and it was a sweet touch that helping them gets Jeff out of his season three funk. Not the show’s finest hour, but worth it for the narration of Keith David (They Live, The Thing, Requiem For A Dream, Gargoyles) and Pierce in a full-body pillow suit of armor. B

Origins of Vampire Mythology
Crib notes: Britta’s ex, a carny named Blade, is her kryptonite, so Annie takes it upon herself to keep the two apart. After a visit from Vice Dean Laybourne, the Dean tries to lure Troy into the air conditioner repair school. Jeff and Shirley visit Blade at the carnival. Chang and Pierce are (briefly) best pals.
Choice dialogue: “Sorry, Britta. Some things are funny because they make no sense and that’s not one of them”
- Annie re: Britta having dated a carny named Blade.
Grade: Community is a show that needs to wear its heart on its sleeve, as its characters are just as important as the craziness of Greendale. Amid the standard TV fare of old flames and friends keeping each other under lock and key are some nice moments of bonding between Annie and Britta, as well as the romantic Troy-Britta tension. It’s great seeing Jeff and Shirley hanging out again (“That don’t change the way mustard taste, Jeffrey”), but the Pierce-Chang plot never gets off the ground. That story could’ve given some fresh material to Community‘s most sidelined, inconsistent characters, but it abruptly ends without doing much of anything. Minor complaints for an episode that brings the Dean into Troy/Abed/Annie’s apartment (I love how hurt he is when they ask him why he showed up) and the best end credit tag of the season: Abed’s stand-up comedy. A

Virtual Systems Analysis
Crib notes: When Troy and Britta go out to lunch, Annie keeps Abed company in the Dreamatorium. What starts off as an afternoon of playing pretend becomes a therapy session between Annie and Abed.
Choice dialogue: “I had to go to the bank today”
- Dean Pelton finally realizes the pointlessness of his many costumes.
Grade: Imaginative, interesting, but not hilarious. It’s an interesting script and brilliantly acted, but I didn’t laugh much, which pretty much sums up the Abed’s story arc in a nutshell. There’s a lot of funny moments (“the duali-Dean of man” in particular), but precious few of them occur inside the Dreamatorium. Outside of Troy’s Inception breakdown (“there’s so many layers”) and the cameos by Leonard (“I don’t have cable”) and “Emmy contender, Pierce Hawthorne”, the episode works more as a drama than a comedy. Sadly, the end credits tag continues the Abed screaming gag from the season premiere, which was never funny and simply reduces his character to “funny Asperger’s man”. This is really clever writing and I appreciate a show that’s ambitious enough to do stories like this one, but I don’t like the depiction of Abed as empathy-free and kind of petulant. B

Basic Lupine Urology
Crib notes: When their biology project is sabotaged, the study group splits into two seperate, but equally important groups in their quest for justice. CHUNG CHUNG.
Choice dialogue: “With a few adjustments, I can make the entire image…Old West-coloured!”
- Britta Perry, master of photoshop
Grade: The discovery of the corpse (of a yam) by two janitors, the opening credits, the nailing of both the law (Troy, Shirley and Abed) and order (Jeff and Annie) cliches…all the elements work as a Law & Order parody.
Every now and again, I hear how fans became disenfranchised with Community following the weirder ‘theme’ episodes of season two. Community‘s second season is easily its best, in my view, because it created the template for episodes like “Basic Lupine Urology”. A bad parody would take over the show, forcing characters to enact pre-set roles regardless of characterization. Here, the parody feeds into the stories and characters, resulting in an episode so great, not even Michael K. Williams’ somnambulant performance can louse it up. This episode makes terrific use of both the regulars and the larger ensemble of Magnitude, Todd, Fat Neil, Vicki and, in one of his final appearances, Star-Burns. Plus: any show that hires Michael Ironside (here as Todd’s uncle) and Eddie Pepitone (reprising his role as a janitor from “Competitive Ecology”) is already in my good books. A

Course Listing Unavailable
Crib notes: After failing their biology class, the study group is expelled from campus. Chang replaces the Dean with a lookalike and begins his rule of Greendale.
Choice dialogue: “You seemed smarter than me when I met you”
- Jeff, summing up Britta’s character development perfectly.
Grade: When people complain about Community being too weird, is this the kind of normal episode they want? Here, a boring story about the group eventually getting expelled doesn’t really gel or offer the kind of special humour I’ve come to expect from the series. I know fans have complained about the show’s obsession with “Inspector Spacetime” (a Dr Who-like show Abed’s obsessed with) and the evolution of Britta’s character, but what were you people expecting? Britta started off as a high school dropout who wanted to impress Radiohead and became one of the most original, charming goofballs on TV. A show that had a Dead Poets Society spoof in its third episode isn’t going off the deep end by incorporating parodies of Dr Who.
I don’t really have much to say about this episode because it highlights Community‘s big flaw this season: story arcs. The expulsion of the “Greendale 7” is so contrived and unsatisfying that the episodes building up to are retroactively tainted by how bland this one is. It’s nowhere near as Community-lite as the trio of episodes that opened the season, but if this is Community being normal, I’ll be in the corner waiting for more fried chicken space simulators and all-out musical numbers. B-

Curriculum Unavailable
Crib notes: When the study group visits a psychiatrist (John Hodgman), he tells them that Greendale is a delusion and they’re all patients in a mental institution.
Choice dialogue: “Good news, guys. I spent all my money!”
- Troy
Grade: Community rehashed Bat-Abed, forts, infighting and glee club takeovers this season, so it stands to reason that there’d be another fake clip show. While this one is not as fresh as its predecessor, it brilliantly parodies the hoariest cliche in the book: the shock reveal that our heroes were insane all along. Rather than taking away points for recycling “Paradigms of Human Memory”, I’ve got to give “Curriculum Unavailable” credit for being as balls-out funny as it is. The sketches of Greendale life and, especially, the sight of the Greendale 7 in straight-jackets re-enacting previous adventures (including the previous fake clip show) are hilarious. John Hodgman makes for a great antagonist even if his role doesn’t make much sense (Chang hired him with what? Was the study group just going to give up so easily?) Again, the arc aspect of season three doesn’t really work, but with episodes this funny, who cares? A
Like NBC before me, I’m going to go through the final three episodes of season three in one night. Join me next week for the final instalment of my look back on Community‘s third season.



August 28th, 2012 at 1:45 pm
I’d have to say tha maybe the GLEE parody episode’s final murder confession could be a satire on GLEE’s tendency to have shitily written dialogue hastily and Unsatisfyingly resolve and conclude ‘important’ plots.
Ugh, GLEE
August 28th, 2012 at 3:13 pm
Adam Clarke is and continues to be the best thing to ever happen to journalism and writing.
August 28th, 2012 at 8:59 pm
Thanks Dad!
August 29th, 2012 at 10:50 am
He can’t be my dad, AC. He’s being supportive.
August 29th, 2012 at 10:52 am
And Mr Rad would’ve gotten away with it, too, if it weren’t for that lousy study group.