
Photo illustration by Elling Lien
No buses yet? Seriously?
Seriously. We continue our story after December 9th, five and a half weeks after Metrobus workers represented by the Amalgamated Transit Union (ATU) walked off the job.
More than a month later, they’re still off the job. Two and a half months.
The sticking point was, and continues to be, the workers’ benefits package. When the strike began, Metrobus had asked that any new hires pay for half of their benefits package, as opposed to the 12 per cent everyone was already paying. Negotiations in November failed. Further negotiations in late December failed, with Metrobus claiming that the union was now accepting the condition that new hires pay for half their benefits, as long as present employees no longer had to pay for any of theirs. With a conciliator in tow, they all trudged back to the bargaining table on January 5th. On January 7th, Metrobus announced that the ATU had rejected all of their offers and walked away from the talks. According to mayor Dennis O’Keefe, the new Metrobus offers didn’t even make it to a vote by the workers.
Since then? Nothing new.
Both city officials and Metrobus are saying that the union hasn’t actually met with management face to face. The two parties have been making their offers through a conciliator.
Are government officials involved yet?
Not really, no. City council continues to firmly back Metrobus (they supply much of Metrobus’ operational funds, after all) and are openly encouraging the two parties to resume talks. But they’re not pushing the province for any back-to-work legislation.
“Council hasn’t discussed it to any great degree at this time,” says O’Keefe. “We would prefer that the union allowed the bus drivers to vote on the offer that was made to them ten days ago. We’re confident that if the drivers were allowed to vote then the strike would be over tomorrow. So why is it that they can’t vote on it? This is the question that the people should be asking.”
“But,” he continues, “we would be extremely reluctant to go down the road of binding arbitration or essential service or legislating the drivers back to work.”
The province has the power to legislate the Metrobus employees back to work, but they haven’t made any move yet. Steve Kelly and others from the St. John’s, NL, Metrobus Strike Facebook group collected a petition of 1,000 signatures asking the provincial government to step in and introduce back-to-work legislation, declare the bus service an essential service, and to have both parties enter into binding arbitration.
“I got a phone call from the premier’s office saying that the request for a representative to accept the petition had been passed Darin King, Minister of Human Resources, Labour and Employment,” says Kelly. “Then I got in touch with his office and received nothing but a three-line email from his executive assistant, Derick Reid. Their response was, without even having seen what we were asking, that it was imperative that the minister stay neutral.”
Kelly says he and group of twenty or so demonstrators went down to the Confederation Building on Friday, January 14th, and nobody was there to take the petition. They wound up handing it over to a security guard.
So, yeah, the province doesn’t seem too keen to step in.
Is the city going to cancel the transit service?
On January 10th, the CBC reported that Mayor Dennis O’Keefe was bracing the public for a reduced transit system once the strike ends.
O’Keefe doesn’t quite agree with that summary.
“When the strike is over,” he says, “and if we have — and we’re going to have it — reduced ridership and revenues as a result of the strike, and if Metrobus is coming back to the city in the 2012 budget looking for an extra one or two million dollars because of the strike and lost revenue, then that kind of money will not be there.”
He says that denying Metrobus any additional subsidies to cover that lost cash won’t necessarily have to result in reduced service.
“The service is run and managed by the Metrobus St. John’s Transportation Commission, and they’re the ones responsible for deciding the system. Given an extreme increase in their subsidy demand, and if that wasn’t there, they would have to look at how they would deal with that situation, and it may not be reduced service.”
Thanks to our friends at Perfect Day Design for the shout-out in their video below!
How to deal with the Metrobus strike
Keep prodding the powers that be
A lot of the members of the St. John’s, NL, Metrobus Strike Facebook group have sent letters to city and provincial officials to ask that they intervene. They post the responses they get on the Facebook site. One of their letters to Lorraine Michael prompted her to send a note to the St. John’s city council to ask them “to work towards the successful resolution of this strike before this already unacceptable situation gets worse.” It’s not much, but it’s better than nothing.
Only the province has the power to legislate workers back behind the wheel, and if you’d like to encourage your MHA to do so, you’ll find their email address here.
You can reach your city councillors here and ask them to encourage talks or provincial intervention.
Find an alternative
Many of the resources we listed in our last post about the strike are still worthwhile.
Metrobus just announced that they’ll be selling taxi vouchers at a reduced rate, beginning on January 19th. You can buy them in $25 books, and that one book is good for $50 worth of rides. Here’s the news release from Metrobus about it.
Share your story
How has the strike affected you and/or your family? Steve Kelly, the petition organizer interviewed above, wants to know. Though he’s not sure exactly what he’ll do with all the stories he collects, he’s hoping that he’ll get them out into the open and that they’ll help persuade all parties to put an end to this bus strike already. You can email him your tale at stephenckelly74@gmail.com.
Additional Resources
Here’s our past list.
And here’s a great summary of what back-to-work legislation entails.



January 18th, 2011 at 5:32 pm
this graphic is amazing and describes my feeling exactly. muhaha…. } : >
January 18th, 2011 at 5:55 pm
“We’re confident that if the drivers were allowed to vote then the strike would be over tomorrow. So why is it that they can’t vote on it? This is the question that the people should be asking.”
—
This is one of the only sensible things I have ever seen O’Keefe say.
I’m predicting that the Metrobus union boss will be fired once this is all said and done.
January 18th, 2011 at 6:47 pm
He may be fired. That is always a possibility in such a position. He may step down. I suspect he was elected to the post.
I suspect the union membership voted to allows the negotiation team to make the yes or no decision on any offers. A strike vote is never an easy to vote make. If affects you and your family. It just happens, that this strike, has affected so many of us. That is unfortunate. I used Metrobus daily to travel to school. I want them back to work too.
Is binding arbitration the answer? Maybe. An essential service? Definitely.
Imagine someone taking away something of yours. Something that you’ve worked for, and they attempt to give a similar thing, but not as good as the original thing. Then patted you on the hand and said it is alright. How the hell would you feel?
January 19th, 2011 at 9:06 am
“Imagine someone taking away something of yours. Something that you’ve worked for, and they attempt to give a similar thing, but not as good as the original thing.”
I don”t need to imagine, my city tax bill is going up this year. The union wants to use the money that I worked for to give workers that are not even hired yet and don’t have any benefits package to start with. Metrobus workers are not being asked to give up anything, but I am. Sorry, no sympathy here. Buses are NOT essential, they are a convenience. The city has been operating just fine without them.
January 19th, 2011 at 10:21 am
Fuck you and your position of privilege too.
They’re not essential to you, but they are to thousands of people in this city including low-income families, the elderly, students, the working poor, and people who live with mental health issues. You’re lucky if you feel “the city has been operating just fine without them” but let me assure you there are many people who do not share your point of view.
January 19th, 2011 at 11:39 am
Well fuck you and your attitude of entitlement too Emma. I work for every dime that I make and pay my share of Provincial and Federal taxes to provide services for the citizens that you mentioned – they are not a municipal responsibility. The vast majority of Newfoundlanders (and all Labradorians) have NO acees to public transit. Living in st. John’s does not entitle one to perks – if they are there be thankful for them. Nobody is subsidizing my ride, why should I be forced by legislation to subsidize someone else’s?
January 19th, 2011 at 1:26 pm
There could be a real entrepreneurial opportunity here. Why doesn’t someone rent some 12 passenger vans and start running bus routes with a sign in the front….”Village Mall”, “Cowan Heights”, “Wherever the Fuck You Wanna Go”…and charge a flat rate cheaper than cabs. Illegal? yes…but recently on a visit to St. Maarten in the Caribbean I took one of these and it was a great cheap way to see the island.
January 19th, 2011 at 5:32 pm
I’m kinda surprised my comment passed moderation, I was in a terrible mood and I probably stated it more strongly than I could have.
But I don’t think “entitlement” means what you think it means. Nowhere in my post did I say that I fall into any of those categories myself. I’m in a position of privilege too – lucky enough to have a job and a car and a conscience that helps me empathize with those less fortunate than myself. ;)
…but you know what they say about arguing on the internet, Hands.
Peace!
January 21st, 2011 at 11:50 am
Metrobus seems to care more about the students and such than the union right now. We should be giving more support to Metrobus. The union is just being greedy, they want benefits are are only going to benefit a small majority. The harm they are causing is going to outweigh any small gain they receive.
January 22nd, 2011 at 8:06 am
I have some feedback about the taxi coupon program.
It seems that customers are sold chits from a random pre-purchased company, not one of their choosing. This is not good from either the taxi drivers’ or customers’ perspective.
A taxi company has an established customer base. Metrobus providing to customers of one company coupons to another company will only direct the customer away from the original company and this move may become permanent. As well, if there are equal number of coupons per company this is not fair as there are not an equal number of drivers per company. This, of course, hurts the drivers of the larger companies more than those of the smaller ones.
Customers may have had bad experiences with certain companies such as poor quality service or drivers (long wait times, unpleasant drivers, taken the long way around, etc). I know some young ladies will not drive with some companies as they do not feel safe with certain drivers. Metrobus providing not allowing customers to choose which company to use the coupons with removes their right to choose for their own comfort.
Yes, Metrobus is doing a good thing with the coupons but the logistics are not great. Instead of Metrobus selling coupons printed by the taxi companies, Metrobus should be selling generic coupons allowing customers to choose which taxi company to use. Much like any commercial coupon, each company should be able to collect all the coupons and submit their bills to Metrobus.
My proposal may even save Metrobus a few dollars if not all coupons are used as the current system as it looks like Metrobus paying the taxi companies for them regardless. The program needs to be changed.
January 22nd, 2011 at 12:56 pm
“Buses are NOT essential, they’re a convenience.” Try telling that to someone who, because of a medical condition or disability (such as limited vision or severe epilepsy), simply cannot operate a vehicle and needs public transit to get to school, work, medical appointments, etc. If you think you’re certain that you will never have to hang up your car keys due to a medical condition or disability and rely on public transit then you are incredibly naive. I would like to add that maybe the teacher who taught you how to read, the doctor who helped to make sure your birth was as safe as possible, or the construction worker who helped maintain the roads you drive on, now, for one reason or another, has to rely on public buses to get around. Buses ARE essential, and if you care about the environment, maybe you will use them instead of your car when and where possible, once this crisis (yes, this is a CRISIS) is over.
January 23rd, 2011 at 4:12 pm
I think Metrobus should offer better than a 50/50 deal on our taxi fares.
From the 15th communications bulletin on metrobus.com:
“We are purchasing the vouchers from local taxi-firms at full price ($50 per book of 10 vouchers) and reselling them to customers at a 50% discount ($25 per book of 10 vouchers) so for every dollar you spend on our taxi vouchers, we spend two dollars. We are providing $50 worth of taxi fares for $25.”
It costs you $2 when I buy your $2 for $1? I’m not sure if that’s how it works…
January 24th, 2011 at 3:30 pm
RE: FQC
That is a straw man argument. I wasn’t arguing whether or not taxi vouchers were good or not. I was arguing that Metrobus has done more for students during the strike than the unions. The union is simply doing like most unions and being greedy. Thy benefits will really only infinitesimally benefit the new recruits and have almost zero benefits to the people that have been there longer. What have the unions done to support those affected by the strike? Not even a voice of support I don’t believe. Also, at least Metrobus is doing something. I mean they are not making profit from this voucher program. The money to pay for half could come from a refund from a bus pass.
RE: Walksalot
If they made a better deal than 50/50 Metrobus would be losing profits. They probably have already lost a lot to the strike itself and possible reduction in ridership after the strike is over now because it has gone on for so long. You can’t just cave in to any persons demands just to avoid conflicts. The union can end the strike just well as Metrobus too.
P.S.; I cannot drive, and do not own a vehicle. Nor am I in walking distance. My support for Metrobus is based on reason not emotion.
January 24th, 2011 at 3:33 pm
“…but you know what they say about arguing on the internet, Hands. ”
If it doesn’t matter who wins an argument over the internet why take part in one? Or is this just a clever way to avoid admitting you lost?
January 27th, 2011 at 7:22 am
Metrobus’ website says they are not selling any more taxi coupons because of the tentative strike end, this is wrong. The agremment is tentative there is no promise to an end. Until there is the coupon program should proceed as usual. As well, people will still need taxis until the actual strike end which may or may not be next week. People are still out hundreds or thousands of dollars because of the strike, a few taxi coupons even after the strike would help compensate people as not everyday can someone get the bus and will has to use the odd taxi. Metrobus has already bought the coupons from the taxi companies. The money for them is sitting in the pockets of the taxi companies and now the coupons will just sit dormant in the Metrobus office. That is not right! Come on Metrobus, be moved, sell off the last few coupons!
January 27th, 2011 at 3:19 pm
A tentative agreement has been reached and the buses should be back by Monday: http://goo.gl/c6pIT
…Plus, according to CBC’s Nadia Stewart, Metrobus riders will ride for free from February 1-15. http://goo.gl/2l8SO
March 3rd, 2011 at 2:36 pm
Well, more than a month has passed since the Metrobus returned to the streets, and it makes me wonder how ridership has been in the weeks since? Has anyone taken a Metrobus since the strike ended, and if they have, has ridership gone down, even during peak periods?
And I expect there will be a fare hike come July, but not due to the strike, thankfully. I think the higher gas prices in recent months is probably to blame for a possible fare hike sooner or later. If it happens, then we can blame it on Northern Africa.
To be quite honest, I’ve only taken the bus twice since the strike ended, but that was only because the rides were free. But I am not one to retaliate against the drivers for what they did. Sure, it sucked what they did, but I believe that retaliation gets me nowhere. I only haven’t taken the bus since mid-February mainly due to the colder temperatures, but when the weather warms up again in the spring, I may take the bus more often again. And btw, my friend drives me to and from work on the weekdays. Buses are more a Saturday thing for me nowadays.
February 21st, 2012 at 10:14 am
“Try telling that to someone who, because of a medical condition or disability (such as limited vision or severe epilepsy), simply cannot operate a vehicle and needs public transit to get to school, work, medical appointments, etc.”
If Metrobus was to declare bankruptcy someday, the City would probably look into developing a specialized service for the group of people you just mentioned. Ever hear of Wheelway?
If the City and Metrobus want to avoid another strike, they should probably downsize sometime midway through the final year of the contract.