
It has been five months since the explosion on board the Deepwater Horizon deep water oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico. Since then, 776 million litres of crude has spewed from the undersea well. Today BP published its 193-page WTFHappen report.
So what will be the disaster’s lasting legacy? Jeff Rubin was the Chief Economist at CIBC World Markets for almost twenty years, and he was one of the first economists to accurately predict triple-digit oil prices back in 2000. He is now one of the world’s most sought after energy experts. According to him, the spill might create the same stigma as Three Mile Island did for nuclear power.
I got a chance to chat with him when he launched his book Why Your World Is About To Get a Whole Lot Smaller: Oil and the End of Globalization back in May…
What advice would you give the Premier of Newfoundland or the government of Newfoundland and Labrador in terms of energy policy?
Well, Newfoundland’s energy policy is of course going to be determined by what happens to the fate of deep water. As you probably know, Chevron is drilling a well that’s almost twice the depth of the ruptured well in the Gulf of Mexico [Update: They finished drilling]. I think your province produces somewhere around 300,000 barrels a day. Most of it is not deep water. Most of it is still continental shelf, but I think the future certainly involves deep water.

Let me say this about that issue: I don’t think the future of deep water drilling, in either the Gulf of Mexico or the Sea of Labrador, is going to be determined by government. In other words by President Obama declaring a moratorium, or lifting a moratorium, or by Danny Williams saying it’s okay or not okay to drill there. I think it’s going to be determined by the market. BP has already lost over 50% of its value on the stock market. That is a number that is 30 or 40 times anything that it has spent on the clean up. If the fate of BP is ultimately Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, then the question will be how eager will its competitors be to want to follow in its deep water footsteps? The impact of Three Mile Island in 1979 wasn’t just regulatory changes. It made it virtually impossible for new nuclear power plants to be financed or insured in the market.
And you see a similar legacy for the Gulf spill?
The same could well be for the Gulf spill. The key to what happens in the Gulf is what happens to BP. If one of the largest oil companies in the world has to go into bankruptcy protection or has to sell itself or sell huge chunks of its company to competitors to stay alive, chances are its competitors are going to take note. So that’s what I’d say about the future of deep water. At the end of the day it’s not going to be about Danny Williams, it’s not going to be about President Obama. It’s going to be about what happens to BP.
You argue in your book that as the cost of extracting oil rises, the oil our economy relies on will be so expensive we’ll have to change the way we live. Why do you think people are so resistant to that idea?
People get angry when people tell you you can’t live the way you used to live. I think our obsession with finding new forms of supply at increasing economic environmental cost, whether we’re talking about a well a mile below the ocean floor in the Gulf of Mexico, or we’re talking about the Canadian Tar Sands, or we’re talking about foreign-based flow. It’s all about finding new supply, because we really don’t want to have to address what has to be addressed.
So to put it this way, instead of trying to find a way to turn cow shit into high octane fuel we just got to learn to get off the roads. I mean, but we’re very resistant to that. However, prices are going to take us off the roads.
[laugh] Well, there’s a lot of shit in the world.
Everybody’s so focused on finding a solution for future sources of energy. I’m sure in time we will, but the point of my book is that we don’t have time. We have to adjust now. The way we adjust now is to find ways of using a whole lot less energy. The way that peak oil doesn’t become peak GDP is we go from a global economy to a regional economy, because in the process of doing that we’re going to be able to use a lot less oil per unit of GDP.
Why Your World Is About To Get a Whole Lot Smaller: Oil and the End of Globalization is published by Random House.



September 8th, 2010 at 8:29 pm
The world needs oil, yet the risk/reward dictates we shouldn’t drill these wells. However try and tell that to someone who now haw to pay triple the ticket prices. We can’t have all the modern conveniences we enjoy and keep them affordable without “lower” oil prices.