The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
The Scope's Log (Blog)
The Scope's Bloggy Log Blog | Log Archives | RSS feed | Contact Us

Dec 7, 2012



Well then, I guess shit just got real.

Link: Allan Hawco galvanizes campaign against harbour fence – Nfld. & Labrador – CBC News

Permalink | Leave a comment

 

3 Responses

  1. avatar
    Terrance Hounsell Says:

    We have heard Mayor O’Keefe’s arguments in support of the harbor fence, and we understand its necessity in support of the Port Authorities activities and the jobs it creates. However, he is missing the bigger picture and what amounts to a critical juncture in the history and development of St. John’s. Remember when the City of Boston became concerned that their city was being overrun by giant highways? what did they do? they accepted the necessity of motor vehicle transportation but they had the good sense to put the highways underground and then they built parks on top of them. A long term project that was technically challenging and cost big bucks but they had the long term vision and commitment to see it through for the greater good. Here is my long-term vision for the harbour front in St. John’s: Have the city or province give the Port Authority the land they need in Fresh Water Bay in exchange for the land that they currently occupy. Have them build a modern International Ship and Port Facility Security (ISPS) code compliant port there. Build a breakwater if extra wharfage and or protection from the elements is required. It is close enough to St. John’s that it can still be part of the city and thus remain part of the revenue stream. The hiking trails will have to be respected. At the same time change the existing industrialized water front into a park for the enjoyment of the people and tourists alike. Look at the Halifax water front where they have museums and celebrate their historic past while we bus our cruise ship tourists out. We should be inspired by the fine examples set by Boston and Halifax! Question is do we have the will political or otherwise? Major O’Keefe is signaling that the harbour’s future is one where industry will trump livability. The major was angry that Alan Hawco didn’t come to him before speaking out so accordingly I ask Mayor O’Keefe to ask the people by way of referendum, YES it’s that important!

    By the way, I understand that according to NL law, there is a mandatory shoreline reservation consisting of a 15-metre strip of public land around all bodies of water, whether marine, inland or riparian. All water – salt water, fresh water, lakes, ponds, rivers, brooks and the sea. The Lands Act clearly states that such waters will remain accessible to the public. A waterfront lot has open access to the water along part of its boundary but is separated from it by the public shoreline reservation. That is, the owner can use it but has no right to prevent others from using it. Why doesn’t this apply to our harbour? This sacred right needs to prevail.

  2. avatar
    anon3 Says:

    why has no one brought forward the mayor’s interview with CBC only a couple of years ago where he said we were going to make the harbour more ‘social’?

  3. avatar
    Sean Says:

    The Port Authority says it is following requirements from Transport Canada. If Transport Canada claims to be interpreting international agreements and thus setting a requirement for the Port Authority, why can’t we see the actual order from Transport Canada? My suspicion is that there isn’t a specific requirement for a permanent fence to cover a specific area. I understand there was a risk assessment indicating that perimeter security needed to be improved, but I am willing to bet that there are several options as to how that security could be improved. The fence is a significant one time layout of cash, but I’m thinking that the Port Authority sees it as cheaper in the long run than hiring extra security guards, extra people to monitor surveillance cameras, or whatever other options there might be. On top of that, they’re getting the City to chip in. I think this is win-win for the Port, becuase they’re making Transport Canada happy and they’re getting a bargain on a fence from City Hall. I think a permanent fence is a choice that they have made out of an array of potential options to increase security. I also question the amount of real estate around the harbour which needs to be at this lockdown level of security. Yes, permanently fence certain areas, but the area along the harbour apron should continue to be fenced temporarily only when ships with heightened security needs dock there. This is St. John’s, not Beirut or New York City.


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.