The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
The Scope's Log (Blog)
The Scope's Bloggy Log Blog | Log Archives | RSS feed | Contact Us

Sep 10, 2012



If you’re digging a storm shelter for Hurricane Leslie right now, you should watch this movie! Except don’t watch the ending. It’s terrible. (Link: Netflix : Take Shelter)

Permalink | Leave a comment

 

11 Responses

  1. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    I thought the ending was beautiful. Haunting and cathartic. The rest of the movie would have been weightless without it.

  2. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    [SPOILER ALERT BEYOND THIS POINT]

    The ending was cheap storyline deus ex machina. Meanwhile, in real life, people lose their minds and their lives fall apart and their delusions are not vindicated as reality. But they don’t get movies? Why can’t hallucinations be hallucinations?

    Ambiguity would have been an honorable way to satisfy everybody, but whatever.

    ANYWAY. Good movie. Thumb up.

  3. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    One last word: ZOMBIES.

    …Huh?

  4. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    Doubtless those people do get movies. They just didn’t get this movie.

    Movies don’t have to be a strict analogue to so-called real life. The fantastic, if earned, should be allowed. I think Take Shelter earned that ending.

  5. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    People dealing with mental illness don’t get enough good movies, and this one was stolen from them in the last five minutes.

    Of course movies don’t have to be analogues of real life, but I think the strongest stories are stories about human beings dealing with what it means to be actually human. Shit happens, and it’s not all magic.

    (And storylines, like hamburgers, should only be flipped a few times.)

    I would have ended it at the door-opening. The convincing him to unlock the shelter by himself? That was a cathartic moment. Real realness.

  6. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    Some of the strongest stories I’ve ever seen on the screen have been hyper-real. Still others have been hyper-fantastic. And plenty more have fallen somewhere in between.

    I think the strongest stories exist across a broad spectrum of representations of reality, but I agree they all come down to tackling in some shape or form what it means to be human.

    If you limit your test of the human spirit to situations you can only fathom happening in your own reality, then you limit the extent to which the human spirit can be tested.

    I don’t think this gives filmmakers license to concoct whatever scenarios suit their immediate dramatic whims. A show like Breaking Bad, which is supposedly grounded in reality, is, in my mind, far too often guilty of bending reality to suit its personal desire to build tension.

    But that’s not what I saw happening in the ending of Take Shelter. Like, I didn’t get the impression that the writer/director, Jeff Nichols, started off telling this story about a man hallucinating and dreaming apocalyptic images, building a wall between him and his family and community while building a storm shelter in the backyard and then when he got to page 100 said, “now what?”

    I think Nichols knew all along that Shannon’s character knew all along that this thing was coming. And it’s his journey towards being forced to accept that everything he knows to be true is false, of embracing an impossible truth in the face of incredible pressure from his family and his community, and how he breaks and succumbs under that pressure: that is what this movie is about.

    If it turned out he had a mental illness, then Take Shelter would have been about a man falling victim to his own mind. And not that that doesn’t happen, but it’s not quite as interesting as a man falling victim to the pressures of everyone around him being against his mind. That’s huge. It’s practically impossible. Which makes me all the more grateful that this filmmaker decided to tackle it and show us what that might look like.

  7. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    Sure, the ending is kind of interesting, but movies need to be more than just interesting for me to like them! And movies should make me want to like them because of reasons!

    With this rock solid argument in mind, I think Nichols did a disservice to the movie by ending it like he did. Like I mentioned before with my burger flipping analogy, I don’t think too many layers of illusion make a story more amazing. More often than not adding layers seems like the filmmakers discovered a fun way to blow the audience’s mind and decided to toss a bunch in there to try to get a good grade in film production class.

    WOAH DUDE
    http://i.imgur.com/Tb2mZ.jpg

    Seriously though, the ending came across as an easy way of avoiding the movie-viewing public’s inability to cope with the idea that the mind can sometimes fail the person using it. That idea is terrifying! Even more terrifying and interesting, at this point in movie trend-land, than a person with psychic powers predicting a zombie apocalypse and not being able to convince anyone. In this way I’d say the movie took the easy way out.

    Whether or not it was actually tacked on or if the director planned it isn’t important, but it seemed tacked on, and that seriously messes with the movie. And that is bad because of reasons!

    http://cdn.memegenerator.net/instances/400x/26499627.jpg

  8. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    “Without spoiling it for readers, the ending of the film is somewhat ambiguous. Do you have a preferred way that you want viewers to read it?”

    An interview where Nichols is asked about the ending: http://www.ifc.com/fix/2011/09/jeff-nichols-take-shelter-interview

  9. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    I’m not saying the ending is interesting. I’m saying the ending makes the entire rest of the movie more interesting.

    Maybe because of that ending it wasn’t the movie you wanted or expected or felt the mentally ill deserved. But that doesn’t make it a bad ending.

    I’m not really sure why you’re referring to complexity here, though. The only flip that happens in the movie is that everyone thought he was nuts and then it turned out he was right. There’s no cinematic energy expended in trying to explain how he knew. We’re not asked to ponder the question. We’re just left with the impact of the fact. Like Nichols cites in the interview you linked to, he and his wife finally have that moment where they’re both seeing the same thing. That’s powerful.

    Or not. I liked it, though.

  10. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    Yeah, the multiple flip complexity thing just came out of the burger analogy and I got carried away by what might have been my desire to eat a tasty burger. What I meant was any amount of flip might be too much for a good story. Why mess with a good thing? Stop flipping the burger! It’s cooked! You might as well squish it with the spatula and squeeze all the juice out and ruin the whole thing for god’s sake! DON’T SQUEEZE THE BURGER SO MUCH! !!

    I AM SO HUNGRY RIGHT NOW.

  11. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    If I’m reading you right, what you’re saying is you think Nichols flipped on the ending for the sake of flipping. That the story didn’t warrant it, but rather he did it to add a layer of superfluous, gratuitous complexity to the film.

    I don’t think that’s the case at all. I think the entire film builds towards that moment. That it’s more than just earned, it’s necessary. That moment completes the film, makes it whole and gives it resonance.

    Could a film have been made about a person who has apocalyptic dreams and visions that come between him and his family, community, that threaten to tear his life apart but for that he eventually learns to trust the people he loves and seeks the help he needs to overcome his paranoid delusions, and could this film have been whole and wonderful and resonant in its own right?

    Yes. Definitely. But it wouldn’t have been This Film – This Film’s Ending = That Film. It would have been a totally different film.


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.