PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
October 23rd, 2011 at 6:49 pm
Care to elaborate?
Are we all being tarred with the same brush?
Can a place be misogynistic?
October 23rd, 2011 at 9:07 pm
Don’t worry about it, CFA. There are semi regular comments here about all guys in St. John’s being arseholes, cheaters, whatever. It’s best to ignore them – you’re only taking their bait.
October 24th, 2011 at 6:47 am
What about the man bashing? That’s perfectly acceptable it seems. I have lost count of all the derogatory comments I have heard women here make about men.
October 24th, 2011 at 9:11 am
I’m guessing the OP is talking about the taxi cab debate and the relative support that has been voiced on this forum.
October 24th, 2011 at 9:16 am
You just called about 100000 people misogynists. What does that make you?
October 24th, 2011 at 11:07 am
That makes her someone who feels frustrated and disempowered. It may be a generalisation, but, it’s obviously a response to something or a lot of things in this city that have made her feel that way. Why do people have to tear each other apart here instead of recognizing that someone might have some sort of legitimate concern or at least feels alienated. What’s the point of trying to make her feel worse?
October 24th, 2011 at 11:17 am
This is a public forum Nannerpoo, and if you choose to make a broad sweeping generalization about an entire population you should expect someone to call you on it. If someone said the entire city of St. John’s was notable for racism and left it there, I’d expect the many non-racist residents of the city to pipe up and call that person on it. I don’t see people tearing each other apart, I see someone who made a very broad, unfair, insulting statement, and others are simply saying “what? – how do you justify that?” If she has a legitimate concern or grievance, by all means share it if you wish, but such a broad sweeping insult which originated from the initial comment serves no purpose.
October 24th, 2011 at 11:27 am
The OP isn’t alone in this assessment, and I doubt it’s just about taxis. This is a common complaint in St. John’s, and rather than blustering about man-bashing, or brushing these complaints aside with indignation, I’d encourage my fellow men in this city to CALL OTHER MEN OUT on their BS. Is your friend dismissing his wife/girlfriend/MHA/Deputy Mayor as a bitch, because she’s voicing/defending a position? Is someone bragging about his affairs? How about condescending to women with cringe-worthy, infantilizing terms like ‘duckie’? Or refusing service on the basis of gender? Point out this is bad behaviour, gentlemen – when women do it, they too often are ignored as ‘hysterical man-bashing bitches’…
October 24th, 2011 at 12:02 pm
Hey DIY, What are you talking about? Someone bashes the entire City (presumably aiming at men) and saying we’re all misogynistic, and now who else is making generalizations? You got a problem with “duckie”? Then tell all the female retail workers and waitresses in NL to stop calling me duckie too, (except this is just too foolish to talk about). Your comment is the equivalent of someone telling women not to get their knickers in a knot. I don’t fit the stereotype of all men that you and the original comment seems to share, and how do you know I don’t already call others on bad behaviour – I’m calling you on it right now (except the duckie business)? Furthermore, most men I know don’t do the things you’re suggesting. You’re taking the bad apples and making generalizations, so you’re just as much in the wrong here as the initial comment. Making generalizations about an entire group of people is the root of discrimination. You don’t fight discrimination by simply insulting another group of people through gross generalizations. If the original comment was meant to accomplish any of what you suggest, why didn’t she just say those things, rather than just aimless bashing of men? The men who you are aiming at, who are actually the source of some of these problems, don’t give a shit, while the rest of us who were raised in homes where none of that behaviour would have been tolerated for a second are somehow called out because presumably we’re not “man-police” enough for you? Give me a break!
October 24th, 2011 at 12:23 pm
I didn’t make the comment so I don’t know what her situation is. I didn’t have any problem with people asking her to justify herself. I took issue with the “what does that make you” comment. Calling something misogynistic isn’t an “insult”. She could simply have been commenting on her observation of a culture of systemic misogyny here, not making a claim that each and every individual in St. John’s is a misogynist. All I was saying was that maybe instead of calling the op names, we might want to recognize that a lot of women in this city have experienced frequent misogyny and there might be something in this city that could be addressed to change that. But, instead people just seem to get personally insulted and insult her back.
October 24th, 2011 at 12:32 pm
Yes a place can be misogynistic, in that it is socially consructed in a way that disempowers women or enables or doesn’t recognize discrimination as something that is negative. It does not mean every single individual in that city is a misogynist. Religions can be considered misogynistic but it doesn’t mean that every single individual who practices that religion is a misogynist.
October 24th, 2011 at 1:24 pm
Good point, I would not be surprised if the derogatory comments on here directed towards men by women far outweight the opposite.
October 24th, 2011 at 1:38 pm
“Calling something misogynistic isn’t an “insult”.” Where do you come off making a statement like this? This completely rejects Steve’s comment about calling people out on things. Obviously if someone said St. John’s was “racist,” people would pipe. Calling a town misogynistic is equal to calling people misogynistic, and in most cases those “people” are males. It certainly is an insult; how would you like to be the resident of a town that someone has called “racist?”
It seems to me like a lot of women are abusing the feminist devices developed to protect them against men. When you start calling a city misogynistic that’s a bit far, and an obvious sweeping generalization. The OP probably just brought it out because it’s a new word she learned at MUN and figured she’d sound smart applying it somewhere, anyway, lol.
For equality among men and women, we’re better off avoiding the word misogynist unless it obviously applies. This is not a case where it obviously applies, and the OP has given no indication that would support such an absurd statement, because honestly, it’s absurd to think that she or the majority of people on here would know this town well enough to be able to say with a multitude of evidence that St. John’s is a misogynist town.
If you have a problem with men being abusive, by all means, pursue the issue, but posting sweeping generalizations on the Scope website is not going to solve anything and if anything will promote resentment in men who see it as an unwarranted/unjustified attack. The OP’s post speaks on a real issue but it causes more problems than solutions.
October 24th, 2011 at 1:39 pm
“Calling something misogynistic isn’t an “insult”.” Where do you come off making a statement like this? This completely rejects Steve’s comment about calling people out on things. Obviously if someone said St. John’s was “racist,” people would pipe. Calling a town misogynistic is equal to calling people misogynistic, and in most cases those “people” are males. It certainly is an insult; how would you like to be the resident of a town that someone has called “racist?”
It seems to me like a lot of women are abusing the feminist devices developed to protect them against men. When you start calling a city misogynistic that’s a bit far, and an obvious sweeping generalization. The OP probably just brought it out because it’s a new word she learned at MUN and figured she’d sound smart applying it somewhere, anyway, lol.
For equality among men and women, we’re better off avoiding the word misogynist unless it obviously applies. This is not a case where it obviously applies, and the OP has given no indication that would support such an absurd statement, because honestly, it’s absurd to think that she or the majority of people on here would know this town well enough to be able to say with a multitude of evidence that St. John’s is a misogynist town.
If you have a problem with men being abusive, by all means, pursue the issue, but posting sweeping generalizations on the Scope website is not going to solve anything and if anything will promote resentment in men who see it as an unwarranted/unjustified attack. The OP’s post speaks on a real issue but it causes more problems than solutions…
October 24th, 2011 at 2:20 pm
Yes this girl must be so wrong, look at all of the super accepting fellas here on this forum demanding her accountability. Of course she couldn’t be using that word properly. Unfortunatly Jim, Steve and Frank have your number, little lady. Feminism is done. Accept that everything is equal and just move on.
October 24th, 2011 at 3:15 pm
Anon, so do you think I should just say, yes, I agree with this woman even if I don’t? If she says I and the majority of my fellow citizens are misogynists, I must be one I guess. I find Scope readers are pretty sharp, and any comments in this forum are open to analysis and discussion. To say that we should be hands off and “kid gloves” with someone for some reason is a bit hard to fathom. We’re all grown ups here. To respond to your assertions, neither Jim, Frank or me said that there are no misogynists in St. John’s. No one said feminism is done. No one said to accept everything is equal and move on. Why can’t you accept that we’re essentially calling on this poster to indicate why she believes that “St. John’s is a deeply misogynistic place.” We’re basically saying that we, as citizens, do not believe we are misogynists, and think it is unfair to generalize about an entire population. I don’t think that’s out of line in any way. Women have faught for many years against unfair generalizations which lead to discrimination. Why are you defending the initial comment, which in itself is also a generalization?
October 24th, 2011 at 3:56 pm
Seriously, the point was lost on most of you. Yes, it was a generalization – but the point was that this place has a lot of growing up to do.
October 24th, 2011 at 4:17 pm
Really? Because there’s a big difference between misogyny and immaturity, and one is on a much different scale than the other. Is it “this place” which has a lot of growing up to do, or is it certain individuals who are in the original poster’s social circle? Is it really “deeply” misogynistic as the poster alleged? If St. John’s is “deeply” misogynistic, what is Afghanistan? Or Saudi Arabia? Or dozens of other countries and hundreds of other cities in the world? I would like to think we’re a little more enlightened here than in Kandahar.
October 24th, 2011 at 5:50 pm
@DIY – Far from “blustering” about man-bashing I was simply trying to make a point. While misogyny here may certainly be a problem it is unfair not to look at the other side of the coin.
I am a woman, and I work with women. The way I hear most – not all but by FAR the majority – speak of their husbands, boyfriends, and men in general disgusts me. Men are looked down on as infantile, immature, and stupid. Comments regarding men (as a whole) and their inability to look after their own children/clean the house properly/cook a meal/grocery shop/be trusted with money are far too common.
It’s a two-way street – if you want respect, give it.
October 24th, 2011 at 6:53 pm
Honey you should just stay in the kitchen where you belong. That way you wont need to worry about those big bad misogynists.
October 25th, 2011 at 12:05 am
I’m wondering something: why are you all assuming the original post was made by a woman?
October 25th, 2011 at 12:31 pm
I like this Steve guy. He makes sense and defends himself in a very smart and intelligent manner. Way to go!
I don’t want to assume that the OP may need to get a new set of man friends, but…well, I have a lot of guy friends, probably more guy friends than gal friends. I have never, ever considered any of them to be misogynistic, sexist or any of those terrible things. They’re lovely, kind and considerate people who i’ve had the pleasure of knowing for most of my life. They love their lady friends and treat us with respect. I love these guys and it pains me that such a generalization was made, since it would probably include these wonderful people that I know.
I also just married the most wonderful man who his kind, respectful, considerate, loving and has a stong distaste for men with sexist attitudes. Again, having him thrown into such a generalization is very wrong.
Since OP never really came out and stated specifics, it’s hard to comment on what the exact problem may be. And I don’t want to come off as sounding glib, but, maybe OP needs to just loosen up a little. Grow a sense of humor even. We Newfoundlanders are a different breed of people. And I don’t mean a sexist, misogynistic people. We’re a kind of people who make jokes and like a laugh and spout off terms of endearment, such as duckie and lovey,used by both men and women, without even a moments thought that it might offend. It’s how many were raised and it’s just a part of being a Newfoundlander. That doesn’t mean we’re hateful people who are man/woman bashers.
OP, think about what you’ve said. Can that REALLY be applied to every single one of us?
October 25th, 2011 at 4:32 pm
Steve: My earlier comment wasn’t aimed at you specifically. It was a call for men (myself included) to respond differently to complaints about men – and more importantly, a suggestion that we stop tacitly condoning bad behaviour from our friends and family. Maybe you do already call people out on this stuff – Great! You’re already part of a solution. Feel free to ignore the post, or pass on the idea to others. But responding to comments about misogyny with some variation of ‘no, the problem is with YOU, sister’ is, to me, missing the point and distracts from the original issue. This type of response is often misogynistic in itself – consider Rush Limbaugh’s reference to feminists as ‘feminazis’.
As for making blanket generalizations: no, clearly we are not all misogynists, nor do we all allow misogynistic behaviour in others to pass without comment. But do we really need to preface every post with disclaimers, stating exactly who the post does or does not apply to? We’re talking about patterns, not attacking individuals.
October 25th, 2011 at 7:13 pm
Exactly, anon! Guys like Jim post stuff here like “The OP probably just brought it out because it’s a new word she learned at MUN and figured she’d sound smart applying it somewhere, anyway, lol.”
In what world is that *not* misogynistic?!
You talked down to the O.P., question her age, maturity level, and intelligence. That’s the very definition of a misogynist. The hypocrisy of Jim, Steve, and Frank is just other worldly.
October 25th, 2011 at 7:25 pm
Downvoted for asking relevant questions… that says a lot.
October 25th, 2011 at 11:31 pm
The definition of misogynist is “a person who hates women”. Is everyone in this thread aware of this??
It certainly appears to me that a number of people in this thread are misusing the word and adding values to it that don’t apply. How about before using the word again you take a look at this site (or consult a dictionary if you own one):
http://tinyurl.com/4qjym48
and actually … maybe look up the word hate as well. Familiarize yourself with that word also.
October 26th, 2011 at 8:14 pm
Better question for you: How IS it misogynistic? There is actually nothing misogynistic about treating an individual critically, unless one evokes gender-specific stereotypes, which I have not. I certainly do not believe that only women “learn new words at MUN and then try them out.” Any gender can do that! The OP could be male for all I know!
For God’s sake people, stop being so sensitive and seeing everything in terms of gender. We’re all human and we’re all prone to making generalizations. Regardless of the gender of the OP, that’s a fucking generalization. Excuse my french.
I think you’re going to have to be a little sharper than that if you want to call me something I’m not.
October 26th, 2011 at 8:28 pm
That’s a great point Andrew. Often in comment sections we have people using words in an extreme fashion.
I don’t see a great loathing of women in St. John’s, nore do I see a fear of them attacking. This comes back to a point I made; just because an understanding of “misogyny” MAY HAVE been discovered in a Memorial classroom (not necessarily of course), doesn’t mean that it should be used in a casual sweeping generalization about this city.
I’ll even go as far as to say I have known people to display misogynistic behavior (one or two), and even in their ignorant ways, I hardly see them as a threat or a representation of the whole of this town.
If the begged question is “Is St. John’s? a mysogenistic cityÉ” I think it’s clear from these comments that it is NOT.
October 28th, 2011 at 8:34 am
That’s not a better question, that’s just you continuing to be willfully obtuse. You did NOT just treat an “individual” critically, what you did was 1.) Assume that the post was made by a WOMAN 2.)Not a woman, really, probably just some young girl, who 3.) is most likely some know-it-all student trying to show off and 4.) doesn’t know what the word means anyway, so what she says doesn’t count or matter.
How were you NOT making gender specific generalizations?! YOU came up with a scenario where YOU generalized that it was okay to not take the O.P. seriously, because you said you thought the post in question was written by a young, FEMALE, student! You can try to backtrack all you want, but it’s pretty obvious that you’re completely full of it.
I can’t say that you outright hate women, Jim, but you’re definitely sexist and disrespectful. Also, telling people to “stop being so sensitive” is typically the calling card of clueless a-holes.
October 28th, 2011 at 10:05 pm
“That’s not a better question, that’s just you continuing to be willfully obtuse.” – I think you missed my intention in saying this which was to emphasize that I am not a misogynist, and what I said is not misogynistic in any way.
Let’s take a look at your “analysis” of me.
“1.) Assume that the post was made by a WOMAN” – I did actually do this, however I corrected myself in the second comment, so there is no need to hyperventilate. It’s old news now. Regardless of what gender has said it, it’s a sweeping generalization we could do without.
“2.)Not a woman, really, probably just some young girl,” – Um, exactly WHERE did I call her probably just some girl?” I didn’t, so don’t suggest it. There is nothing in my comment that would suggest age, and even if there were, age is DIFFERENT than gender.
“3.) is most likely some know-it-all student trying to show off” – Dude, you are showing examples of ways I have attacked him/her. That doesn’t make me misogynistic. I think you need to recheck the definition, because nowhere do I say that all women are know-it-all students trying to show off, and I’ve admitted that this could equally apply to a male – I know males who it DOES apply to. Stop trying to build me up to fit into your profile and consult a dictionary.
“4.) doesn’t know what the word means anyway, so what she says doesn’t count or matter.” – Where exactly did I suggest that the OP “doesn’t know what the word means anyway?” You have to work on your quoting skills because what you have to offer lacks evidence and seems to be more a reading of what you WANT me to be.
My thinking that the post was written by a woman has absolutely nothing to do with my general feelings towards women. I see women as equal and what I’ve said could equally apply to a male. The ONLY mistake I made was assuming the OP was female, and this is simply because in my lifetime I have found women to be the only ones breaking out the “mysognist” word. Admittedly that was an oversight, but your reading of me as generalizing that all women fit the exact criticism I delivered is so off the mark, to be honest, it’s embarassing. This is exactly the kind of ridiculous self-fulfilling thinking that-yes-extreme feminists engage in, and just so you don’t think I’m mysognisitc all over again, it’s equally the type of thinking right-wing bigots engage in-and a number MALES come to mind.
“I can’t say that you outright hate women, Jim, but you’re definitely sexist and disrespectful.” You can call me disrespectful but you can’t call me sexist. If you want to be treated as equal get used to being told to shut-up when you get on with the utter nonsense you have dished out in your response above.
If you want to promote a society of equality, stop trying so hard to label men as “mysognists.” There are many great men out there, and I am one of them, but I don’t tolerate BS like sweeping generalizations such as the one the OP has made. I don’t tolerate that from ANY gender. And I can tell you what I CERTAINLY would not do; I would not give a woman special treatment on the intellectual battlefield just because they are women. Why not? Because – surprise surprise – I see them as equal.
You however, whatever your gender may be, have displayed that you are not equal when it comes to a battle of wits, from reading your last comment. Again: You’ll have to be much more diligent if you’re so bent on making me out to look like a mysoginistic generalizer. Because the errors in your logic stick out like a sore thumb to anyone with a strong reasoning mind.
I will not be returning to this thread because I have better things to do.
October 29th, 2011 at 8:07 am
To Jim, who left that flippin’ book in the middle of the thread:
“There are many great men out there, and I am one of them.” Honey, no, you do not get to call yourself great. That’s something that people are supposed to say *about* you, to say it about yourself makes you sound like a megalomaniac. I heard Louis C.K. say something recently about how he doesn’t consider himself a great person, because he doesn’t do anything to help people, and that most of us are really just average. So, who do you volunteer with, Jim? What truly selfless acts have you committed recently that you get to call yourself “great”? All I’ve seen so far is you all over these message boards talking down to (and about) women, and then trying to back peddle when someone points out your nonsense.
“I will not be returning to this thread because I have better things to do.” You wasted time writing an essay for someone you don’t like, so no, clearly you don’t. I don’t either (in the mornings, anyway). Be honest with yourself.
October 29th, 2011 at 9:34 am
“Honey”. Hilarious. No irony there, right?
October 29th, 2011 at 12:24 pm
I know! Pretty stuffy, right? I thought I suffocated the thread there for a second. Still, I’m pretty sure 12 people realized that they misuse misogynist, whether on this thread or in real life, got embarrassed and disliked my comment out of sheer spite.
So, for those 12 people and others, here is a book recommendation and a website that may help in the future. And remember, I have only everyone’s best mental interest in mind.
http://tinyurl.com/5s8tr8m
http://www.merriam-webster.com
October 30th, 2011 at 11:25 am
Andrew: Dictionaries are great for strict, literal definitions of a word, but words have broader meaning, subtext, and implications beyond the scope of this helpful tool. Feminist theory uses the word misogyny to encompass beliefs, behaviour, and actions that reflect negative attitudes towards women. At this point, the general public does too. There isn’t a better word to use in this context: sexism is lacking (it’s not an adherence to archaic gender roles that’s the problem), as is chauvinism (although the belief in the superiority of men over women certainly contributes to some misogynists’ behaviour). A dictionary is a useful tool, yes – but when a depth of information is required, you may want to consult an encyclopedia instead. The ‘dislikes’ probably reflect this, perhaps along with frustration at the introduction of another distracting, tangential argument that deflects from the original issue.
November 1st, 2011 at 1:26 pm
Of all the posts in this thread, mine is the one accused of running on a tangent. That’s hilarious!
I would argue that my first post is completely relevant. The point of the post was to basically entice someone to have this very conversation which helps point out what I was noticing in the thread. Obviously people were using different definitions, criteria, etc for the word misogyny and several were using a loose definition of misogynist which so happens to conincide with feminist theory like you mentioned. “Negative attitudes towards women”? That could mean anything!
I do sympathize with you that a word may not currently exist for what you are trying to descibe, but the fact is, the definition of misogyinist is listed as “hatred” of women, not “negative attitudes” unless of course you subscribe to feminist theory, but a person shouldn’t have to study feminist theory to use the word. To imply as much is simply arrogant and pretentious.
You suggest that I consult an encyclopedia – you probably mean an encyclopedia of feminist theory, correct? The entry for misogyny in a regular old encyclopedia of social sciences just gives me examples of how different cultures and institutions have manifested their hate for women.
I’m not here to just rant. I’m partially here to maintain the integrity of my initial post, but I’m also interested in helping to bring about solutions and change where necessary so I would suggest three things and these are for whoever cares to read them: 1) be more transparent about how you are using the word, 2) if you are faced with an actual misogynist problem, you need to address it and help to dismantle it, but be more specific – don’t call an entire city misogynist, 3) properly identify people who actually hate women – don’t go on a witch hunt for misogynists i.e. (using just one example from this thread) calling men who address women as “duckie” misogynist.
Feel free to ignore or use those three suggestions as you see fit.
November 1st, 2011 at 5:16 pm
Andrew: Digging through this post, I find evidence that you know misogyny is not as simple as ‘hatred of women’. An encyclopedia gives you examples of cultures and institutions that manifest misogyny – so now a culture or an institution can be misogynistic (i.e, capable of manifesting misogyny), but a place can’t? Isn’t a place a collection of institutions? Don’t we all talk about the ‘culture’ of St. John’s? Can a culture hate something? Can an institution? The implication is that a dictionary definition of misogyny doesn’t cover it’s full use.
The point isn’t for everyone to grab a feminist theory textbook – as I stated earlier, the general public uses ‘misogyny’ in pretty much exactly the same way academics do these days. No one said ‘take a course’ – what I said was a dictionary is not a suitable reference to make your point. The ‘likes/dislikes’ for your original post suggest I’m not alone in this assessment.
November 2nd, 2011 at 12:15 am
@Late Entry – there wasn’t an option to reply to your last comment so I have to post it here at the bottom of the thread.
My second post was tongue-in-cheek. I don’t care about likes or dislikes, this isn’t a popularity contest for me. In fact, 22 people liked the OP’s comment so I’m wondering where the other 8 dislikes for my first post are!
I misquoted the encyclopedia and thought and subsequently wrote “institution” when I read, and this is verbatim “Many organized religions are highly misogynistic”, so that throws your questions about
institutions out of context, my apologies. But to your question “isn’t a place a collection of institutions” I would so no, a place – St. John’s – is not just a collection of institutions. How cold!
In regards to your references to culture, this particular encyclopedia of social sciences gives the following twisted examples of misogynism:
“In the highlands of New Guinea (Langness 1999), many tribesmen sleep apart from their wives, believing that women’s bodies are, especially when menstruating, contaminating and even poisonous to males. In the Amazon rain forest of South America, many Native American men regard women as the work of the devil—not only intellectually inferior to men, but also scheming, destructive, even demonic (Gregor 1985). In many areas of sub-Saharan Africa, women’s monthly flow is viewed with horror, and menstruating women are not allowed to appear in public. Many East African peoples practice clitoridectomy (surgical removal of the clitoris), a painful operation specifically designed to diminish a woman’s sexual pleasure, which is considered immoral (unlike a man’s).”
So, yeah a little different than what is being described here in this thread. If by chance this encyclopedia isn’t in your opinion correct, then what would you suggest that I reference instead?
You’ve said twice now in as many posts that the “general public” uses the word misogyny the same as feminist theorists and academics, but I’m curious how you would be certain of this? I would guess this is just conjecture as there probably hasn’t been a study or poll done with solid data to present although if there has, maybe you can produce the findings.
Are you honestly OK with a stigma of misogynist being placed on St. John’s? Is it possible that you are a part of the ironic Scope readership that hates St. John’s, but frequently visits a site dedicated to St. John’s culture?
November 2nd, 2011 at 1:41 am
@Andrew – that’s a lot for a comments section. Here are some attempts at succinct responses.
Use of misogyny by general public: well, there’s plenty of examples of the general public using misogyny to cover something less severe than female circumcision right here. When people in these comments use this word, I interpret the use to fit the context. Back to the original point re: dictionaries – words serve communication, and we’re allowed some leeway in their use. In this case, the posters aren’t grossly misusing a word – they’re applying it to communicate an idea.
Stigma of misogyny: No, this isn’t the New Guinea Highlands. But in terms of embracing the lessons of the feminist movement, St. John’s is behind every North American city I’ve lived in (but, frankly, ahead of the European cities I’ve lived in). Would I use the same phrasing as the OP? Only in a particularly frustrated moment, but none of us are at our most eloquent then – and we often say things we’d later like to rephrase. Still, I’d like to think people would try to understand my position regardless, rather than dismiss me as delusional (and/or man-bashing, naive, an intellectual dilettante with a brand new word, etc). Or worse, just point me to dictionary. Many of these responses reflect behaviours that inspire comments like the OP.
Is it possible I hate St. John’s?: I’ve chosen to live (emphasis on chosen – this isn’t the only place I’ve lived, but it’s the place I’ve decided to call home). So no, I don’t hate this place. But that doesn’t mean I can’t see problems, or room for improvement. Hopefully you intended this as tongue-in-cheek as well; it’s awfully close to the ‘you hate freedom/want the terrorists to win’ accusations republicans used to thrown at any critics during the Bush administration.
Collection of institutions: OK, I could have been more clear. Let’s try again: Is part of what makes a place not the collection of institutions it creates, or that contribute to it’s creation? (Cumbersome, and unnecessarily so, right?) I added culture as well, but of course that’s also just another part. Still, they’re big pieces – city hall, the school system, professional organizations, volunteer groups, religious bodies all contribute a large part to any city’s flavor. My original point remains: if a religion or culture can be misogynistic, then there’s more to the word than an individual’s hate.