PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
August 20th, 2011 at 11:05 am
Eh?
August 20th, 2011 at 9:10 pm
he speaks the truth, anything from what the scope considers the incorrect end of the abortion debate does not get posted. playing dumb about it is silly.
August 21st, 2011 at 5:15 am
And now, a word from our resident web grinder monkey:
“Bullshit.”
August 21st, 2011 at 1:15 pm
I don’t know if the Scope is censoring anti-abortion comments or not, it’s certainly possible. You guys should loosen up when it comes to moderating comments, assume that your readers are civilized and mature people and let the comments appear automatically when they are posted. Truly inappropriate comments can be deleted later, and at least your readers will be able to see just what it is you guys are censoring.
August 21st, 2011 at 5:00 pm
In light of two recent incidents, one involving a nasty attack on Mopey Mumble Mouse, and the other being some rumor being started on here that got blew way the fuck out of proportion, i’m beginning to think that the “I Saw You” section is devolving into a cesspool of negative bullshit and petty jealousies. I think, if anything, it should be filtered better to avoid future needless dramas.
August 21st, 2011 at 10:29 pm
And bring back Dan Savage. The naked american apparel chicks just ain’t doing it for me.
August 21st, 2011 at 11:28 pm
That wasn’t really a nasty attack. They just said the band sucked the life out of the place. I’ve heard their music and can understand where that person was coming from. That’s not me being nasty, it’s just my opinion. Unfortunatly, things like music, politics and religion often cause people to jump down other peoples throats.
August 22nd, 2011 at 4:15 pm
Just wanted to expand on my “eh?” and “bullshit” comments here. I didn’t mean to be glib, but the accusation that we were putting up unnecessary barriers to conversation really irritated me. We are happy when people are talking to each other.
About censoring anti-abortion comments:
As far as I can tell, the original poster was referring to comments which were posted on Friday afternoon which were not approved until the next morning. It was nice outside on Friday, and we had the day off. All of the comments that went through moderation that day were approved on Saturday morning.
About the comment moderation process:
There aren’t many sites like ours that still allow anonymous comments without registration, but we believe the possibilities for frank, open discussion still outweigh most of the problems we have with trolls. Comments are automatically accepted if they don’t contain any flag words we’ve entered. If one of those words is present, it gets passed through the moderation queue.
When a comment appears in the moderation queue, I ask myself a few questions:
- Is the comment sexist, racist, homophobic, or similar (religion)?
- Has a person or business been accused of doing something illegal?
- Could a particular, identifiable person be negatively affected by the comment in an unfair way?
- Is the negative comment an opinion, or is it being passed off as fact?
This isn’t a flowchart or anything, these are just questions I consider. The core thing for us is to avoid libelous or abusive comments. In the eyes of the law, anything we post on the website has been “published” by us, so we have to be sensitive to that to protect ourselves.
In the case of StitchUp, where a specific, identifiable, innocent person on the street is featured, we’re usually a little more sensitive to negative or hurtful comments. If you write a comment you can easily imagine being shouted out the window of a passing car, you are probably being an asshole and hurtful to someone unnecessarily. In the case of I Saw You, when someone isn’t named or otherwise identified, there’s ambiguity, so we’re a little more lenient. In the restaurant section, we occasionally get reports of food poisoning or unsanitary conditions and because we can’t verify those claims, we can’t publish them without opening ourselves up to legal action. (By the way, if this happens to you at a restaurant, please take it up with the NL Department of Government Services at http://www.gs.gov.nl.ca/department/inspections_contact.html)
About Savage Love not being printed:
I’m glad you brought this up, Lesbian Seagul. I was at a friend’s birthday party recently when someone I respect said they were upset Savage Love wasn’t printed but American Apparel ads were — inferring that we were selling out. Because I was at a friend’s house and I’d had a beer or two, my guard was down. I was hurt. I got angry.
Here’s why:
I miss Dan Savage too, and I’d love to have his column back. Also, while I would prefer to have our back cover sold to a local advertiser, I’m happy that American Apparel have chosen us as a way of promoting themselves.
With Dan’s column printed in The Scope it wouldn’t possible for the print edition to be distributed as widely as we are now. When we decided to stop publishing Savage Love, about four years had passed since Bryhanna and I started The Scope with money she had inherited when her father passed away. We barely had two part-time employees, one handling ad sales and one helping with production. We were still bi-weekly, and working lots of 12-hour days, pulling all-nighters, working weekends, all while working out of a room in our own apartment. Things were definitely improving, but not as quickly as we had hoped. In the spring of last year we knew were at a point where we had to either grow to pay for help and keep things going or call it quits. That was last year.
Then, in April, my father passed away. I vividly remember thinking I was lucky he was dying in between issues of The Scope, otherwise I wouldn’t have been able to be in the home with him when he went, or to be with my mom and family during those handful of days.
You know what? That’s fucked up. We had spent four years building something everyone around us considered successful, but it was still keeping me from being human. I was beginning to hate The Scope. And I’m not one to throw that word around lightly.
The Scope is a small business. We rely on advertising to survive. Without good distribution, we won’t have advertising. Without advertising, we won’t have any money to pay for content. Without paid content, our content isn’t good content. Without good content, a publication is irrelevant and boring and no one reads it. By the time dad died, Bryh and I were almost ready to shut things down. We weren’t disillusioned by the work we were doing, we were just burning out.
So we decided to stop printing Savage Love. We moved from bi-weekly to monthly in print. We started focusing on the website, where things aren’t as time-sensitive and could start experimenting a little more to keep things interesting. We improved our distribution and started asking grocery stores if we could put stands inside their front door so more people could find us.
We got way more readers. We started getting more advertising. And we started being able to afford to hire people to do some more of the things we had been doing ourselves.
Bryh and I are not shooting to become wealthy from The Scope, and I don’t even know if that’s possible. But we do want to keep publishing. We want to keep engaging people. We want to encourage conversation about the city. The Scope is not a vanity project. It’s not just for our friends. It’s not because we have a single vision about how the city should grow. It’s because we love the city, we love the people here, and we want to see things get even more amazing and interesting than they already are, however that may be.
About American Apparel:
I’m not going to defend American Apparel much here, because I know people feel strongly about them and whatever I say here won’t change their minds, but I will say I have no problem with the particular images we’ve printed. And, yeah, the irony that we are able to publish a picture of a pretty girl in jean shorts in a sexy pose on our back cover without complaints, but unable to print a frank sex column because we get too many complaints, is not lost on us. But we’ve come to realize that is the way our city is these days, for some reason. We got tired of fighting to print Savage Love and struggling to grow because of it, especially because it was something people could easily read every week online for free. (http://www.thestranger.com/savage)
Anyway, I’ve gone on for too long here, but the accusation about censorship touched a nerve. I hope this helps people understand where we’re coming from.
Enjoy the sunshine!
August 22nd, 2011 at 7:39 pm
Well said Elling. As much as I love running my mouth on these comment boards, usually with comments that are contrary to those expressed in the Scope, I still think you guys are doing a great thing for the city by publishing this newspaper. Keep it up by’s.
August 22nd, 2011 at 8:35 pm
Exceptional post. I think too often in the anonymous internet world people forget that small businesses in town are run by real people, with real lives. It’s way too easy and lazy to just leave anonymous comments shitting on things as though they’re these amorphous entities with no flesh and blood attached.
August 22nd, 2011 at 8:48 pm
Thanks for that, Elling. I’ve often wondered what happened to the Dan Savage section too. But your post clarifies things quite a bit. I’m very glad you and Bryh decided to continue on with The Scope rather than calling it a wrap last year. It has a very important presence in our city. Thanks for doing all that you do.
May The Scope live long and prosper!
August 24th, 2011 at 12:35 am
OP here, sorry to have made such an unjust accusation… you are right, I thought this because of the delay in showing online.
August 24th, 2011 at 1:31 pm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_emotion
congrats.
August 25th, 2011 at 12:37 am
Lesbian Seagul, won’t you fly away to Hell?