PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
April 15th, 2012 at 1:35 pm
while I can’t find the ad you’re quoting, I can say you shouldn’t be so harsh and critical of the new tourism ads, especially if you’re going to challenge Newfoundlanders to be more hospitable.
Personally I think the new tourism ads are something to be proud of. They’re visually astounding, every time I catch them on TV I start to wonder where this beautiful place is and I’m always amazed when I learn that it’s NL. Look at what we have to work with– rocks and fog and cold. But we have such a unique culture in terms of our architecture and our traditions and the heritage we’ve come from.
I don’t care what kind of editing was done post production on those ads, because to me that just showcases another talent that the people from our province have. And after seeing the ad showcasing St. John’s I have a huge sense of pride when I walk through town because I had never noticed how beautiful this city was until then.
April 16th, 2012 at 9:14 am
zzzzzzzzzzzz – knee-jerk nationalism.
“I start to wonder where this beautiful place is” – that should set your bullshit detector off right there. you don’t even recognize a place you lived your whole life?!
also, it’s 50-50 that the ‘talent’ that produced these ads is Newfoundland talent. the AOR is concerned with making money, NOT hiring NL talent.
there are at least 20 male announcer voice talents here that could/should narrate these, but the guy was hired out of the mainland or the states. I think NLgov should force the AOR to spend EVERY DOLLAR of their budget here in NL.
What’s the point of having Creative Director, Director, editor, narrator, etc. (all from somewhere else) take pictures of NL and then photo-shop them to look other than they are, take buildings out of pictures to make the place look more quaint, put icebergs where they certainly are not, to have whales and foxes (not to scale) appear in the scenics, and to saturate the colours of the houses, lichen, treees etc, to mislead viewers into thinking that the people of NL created them about the place they see in the ads?! it’s false. it’s lame. I couldn’t care less if you are “proud” of that, you obviously are part of the un-knowing. go to Tim’s and get a ‘coffee’
April 16th, 2012 at 1:25 pm
I thought M5 was the PC advertising arm? Aren’t they local?
April 16th, 2012 at 2:10 pm
seems to me like you’re making a lot of assumptions without doing much research. i cannot understand why you’re so hostile, unless you’re just one of those self-hating newfoundlanders.
and for all you know, emma is from BRAZIL and she had just never noticed the beauty in the town/province/country where she now lives.
absolutely, the jobs should stay here but regardless of whomever was responsible, they truly are “visually astounding”. And is it not the point of tourism ads to appeal to potential tourists?
my question for you, “agreed” (more like op lol), is: how would you like to see newfoundland represented in its tourism ads? would you cut out all production value? what slogan would you prefer to use?
if you’ve ever paid attention to tourism ads from other places you should notice that there is a certain level of stereotyping involved. that is because the name of a place usually has distinct connotations. this is called “front-stage” tourism, which is intended to appeal to tourists by showcasing the stereotypical side of a place. this is not a new concept, nor is it specific to newfoundland.
i just don’t understand why some people have to shit on everything. haters gonna hate, i suppose. and your tim’s comment was just ignorant.