PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
October 7th, 2011 at 5:50 pm
What? Because it hasn’t been your experience, than it can’t be true for anyone?!
Plenty of people were in agreement in the thread you’re taking a huge dump on. We spoke of how we tried being warm, open, and welcoming and the townies we’ve often come across just weren’t having it. It seems to have become a common theme on these message boards, a lot of people are unhappy with how they get treated here.
It doesn’t sound like you live in St. John’s currently (I think that’s what I gathered from your douche speech). Consider yourself lucky.
October 7th, 2011 at 6:04 pm
Right, this basically reads as “Not to talk down to you, or devalue your experience, but you’re wrong because I myself never experienced anything like that, and I’m the King of Town. I employ a Poop Smith and everything! Now I’m going to start talkin’ like Sarah Palin and droppin’ my g’s, and say that you must be a generatin’ negativity. Meaning, y’all must be the real jerks. Not putting you down though.”
October 7th, 2011 at 8:37 pm
I’ve been here over a decade – and have found Newfoundlanders to be superficially friendly, but unwelcoming on any deeper level. I have an active social life, volunteer regularly, and work in job that actively improves the community. I have a good circle of friends – but none from the island. Not for lack of trying on my part (I frequently invite NLers’s out, to dinner parties, to shows or films or galleries), but I can count the number of returned invitations on one hand.
Labradorians, on the other hand – easy to make friends with.
Just another anecdote, but ‘cliquey’ is a word I’d agree with.
October 7th, 2011 at 10:28 pm
As a former townie I wholeheartedly agree. The arts scene is particularly brutal and prickish.
October 8th, 2011 at 8:56 am
I also agree with 12 yr CFA veteran completely. This has been my experience the entire time I’ve been here.
October 8th, 2011 at 12:35 pm
Let’s not resort to stereotypes here, it’s not all Newfoundlanders.
That said, I can’t disagree with much of the sentiment here. When you’re a “CFA” (a term so pervasive many of us have adopted it) it seems to be the first thing many people here take into account, and their perception of you actively changes as a result. I have seen conversations turn cold when people found out I am Haligonian by birth, I have been distrusted about miniscule things as a result of that discovery, and I have seriously confused people because I enjoy the province’s culture but wasn’t born here. An American friend of mine has expressed similar concerns, and we’ve both noted that people seem taken aback when you mention that you weren’t born here, often a shock accompanied by some turn of phrase like “Oh, I just wouldn’t have guessed – you’re so nice!” The (slightly too common, if not universal) construction seems to be that “mainlanders” just hate this place and would all rather be off at Massey Hall listening to classical music, drinking anything but Black Horse and speaking the Queen’s English. If you want proof of that last bit, go ask the literally dozens of people who have queried me on my birthplace because “you speak so well, you’re, like, grammatically correct and everything!”
The recent turn in this city, at least, seems to be towards creating massive constructions and defining them in opposition to each other, and I think that’s at the heart of the cliquishness we’re discussing. It starts with this issue of birthplace (‘Newfoundlander’ and ‘other’) and then continues downwards until everyone is pigeonholed, and it extends everywhere from what you do in your spare time to where you buy your coffee, or (even more commonly) your beer. I’ve never had a problem with much older Newfoundlanders, who very often are the warm, inviting individuals the OP described, but I’m a university student and I think we might have the worst of it.
October 8th, 2011 at 6:28 pm
A…poop smith?
October 8th, 2011 at 8:47 pm
UGH… this post makes me want to barf. The condescending superficially “positive” attitude of the OP is EXACTLY what drives me bonkers about this town.
October 9th, 2011 at 9:31 am
It’s a Homestar Runner reference.
October 9th, 2011 at 9:55 am
Nathan Downey, let me Google that for you.
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Poop+Smith
October 9th, 2011 at 1:00 pm
Smoot, I think this I Saw You author is simply expressing an opinion different than the author of the one that said they think St. John’s is snotty and cliquey. Maybe it would make your life a littler easier if you stopped taking personal offence when people express publicly that they /don’t/ hate St. John’s? Just a suggestion, I’m not, you know, trying to tell you what to do or anything.
October 9th, 2011 at 4:06 pm
I consistently get asked: “where are you from? no, I know you SAY nl, but, where are you REALLY from?”, “you don’t look/talk like a newfoundlander though”, and a variety of other subversively xenophobic remarks daily, even though I was born and raised here (one of my parents is visibly “foreign” though). I’ve long tried to feel like I’m from this place, but, I’m treated like an outsider so frequently I’ve given up. I SO agree with the posters who’ve said that people are superficially friendly to outsiders, but, are ultimately suspicious and never truly accept outsiders. I’ve found this EVEN among segments of townie society that profess their inclusiveness, if you’re visibly an outsider you may be accepted as a ‘friend’, but, you’re still treated like a novelty and not a ‘member’ of the townie club.
November 3rd, 2011 at 5:12 pm
If ‘out, dinner parties, shows or films or galleries’ don’t work, then try a kitchen party?
February 17th, 2012 at 2:06 pm
I moved here 6 months ago. My parents are Newfoundlanders, however I was born and raised on the mainland. My family has a very long long history in Newfoundland and settled here in the 1700′s. I get all kinds of comments from NLers and questions asking me where I’m from and what am I doing here. One guy even went as far as saying “who did I think I was coming to Newfoundland for a job and taking a job from a Newfoundlander”. I don’t understand the double standard, because Nlers have/are going all over Canada for work. I’m sure the population of Alberta has a substantial NL population. I agree that many people are superfically friendly and have encountered people backstabbing others. I’m a very positive person and have been nothing but friendly to people. I have met several genuine people here as well, but I think some NLers should recognize that the superficial niceties exist. To act like that in my opinon is cowardly. I would rather have someone be upfront and say they don’t like me than have some nice to my face and then talk shit as soon as you turn you back. That behaviour seems to be epidemic here. Other than that…I love this place!