PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
December 19th, 2012 at 4:17 pm
Is that why they don’t clear the sidewalks though?
December 20th, 2012 at 8:55 am
Partly, they’ve said in the past that they don’t have the money in the budget to pay crews to work on getting the snow off sidewalks, which in the light of the money going to a fence, smells like bullshit, they just cant be bothered because no-one on city council likely walks anywhere, other than from their car to home, work, etc. so they have no idea what its like trying to get around in the winter. If there was money to be made in snow clearing, they would find a way I bet.
Granted, the layout of the streets is an issue, some of the streets in the downtown core were designed long before cars so getting plows around them is a nightmare, but thats only a small section of the city and there’s absolutely no reason why they cant do a much better job on main drags like Columbus Drive or Kenmount Road, those roads are death traps for pedestrians in the winter, but the city doesn’t care. If someone does go under a bus or gets killed by a driver while being forced to walk in the streets, the city will come up with a way to make sure it gets done, which will mean it could have been done all along. I fully recognize that I’m speculating on things that haven’t happened, but its a likely scenario.
Another alternative would be enforcing a bylaw that makes property owners shovel the sidewalks in front of their home or business, it works in cities like Halifax, it could be done here too, but the city is to chicken shit to actually try and make people do that as there would be a huge public outcry, and half the people just wouldn’t do it, so its a moot point, look at Merrymeeting Road for example, there’s a few good folks who shovel in front of their property (thank you), but the majority cant be bothered, so its rather pointless.
The only people who don’t see anything wrong with how the city does its snow clearing, are people who drive, because they don’t have to deal with it. Theres no need, and it makes St. Johns look bad, to its citizens at least, and its been proven that the city just doesnt care about them. If you want to be treated with an ounce of respect, you have to visit on a cruise ship.
December 20th, 2012 at 9:38 am
I suspect they don’t clear the sidewalks because the old boys running the show can’t imagine there’s a life outside their cars.
December 20th, 2012 at 5:52 pm
I’m surprised the city hasn’t passed a bylaw to enforce snow clearing. Hasn’t some greedy soul figured out that on top of outrageous property tax, they could also be sucking more money out of people by way of fines?
It isn’t just walkers who find downtown awful in the winter. I don’t live in town but I do frequent it and trying to navigate over piles of ice and snow to get from my car to the (relatively) clean bits of sidewalk without breaking my neck is a real challenge. I can’t imagine how seniors or anyone with a disability that impedes walking manages to get around at all!
December 20th, 2012 at 5:59 pm
How about all the pedestrians who complain about sidewalks not being cleared bring a shovel with them on their travels to shovel the sidewalks they want to walk on…?
December 20th, 2012 at 6:12 pm
John is exactly right. If you want to talk about bylaws lets talk about the cities that force people to clear the sidewalks in front of their homes. Winter is a big inconvenience for everyone, and I would hate to be one of the municipal bureaucrats charged with budgeting and planning snowclearing, especially in a city like St. John’s which has very unpredictable winters. I’ve noticed that the city seems to be doing a reasonable job of prioritizing snowclearing so far, even on the sidewalks, I’ve seen those guys out in force lately and certainly the sidewalks on major roads are clear. People should quit whining and pick up a shovel. Winter is a pain for everyone, deal with it.
December 20th, 2012 at 6:56 pm
I’m not shoveling the sidewalk in front of my home so people can slip and sue me because I shoveled it and didn’t salt it. Go ahead, ticket me, fine me, I don’t care, I’m not having any part of that. Next thing people will be asking home owners to do is shovel and salt the portions of road in front of their homes. While we’re at it why don’t we outlaw vehicles so pedestrians won’t be in danger and get rid of our electrical services and water and sewer…
Exactly…it’s not realistic. We should be moving forward not backwards. Isn’t that why we pay taxes? The City should own up to these problems and fix what is their problem.
December 20th, 2012 at 7:49 pm
What you are saying sounds a lot like something I would normally say, and you make very good points. I would like to read more about how this policy has worked out in the other cities which have implemented it.
December 21st, 2012 at 8:50 am
“I’m not shoveling the sidewalk in front of my home so people can slip and sue me because I shoveled it and didn’t salt it. Go ahead, ticket me, fine me, I don’t care, I’m not having any part of that.”
So, you’re saying you can shovel a sidewalk but not salt it? That’s just going too far? You would think the possibility of getting sued would be motivation to make sure its done. That works in other cities. That’s my point. Its sad that St. Johns doesn’t care enough about the safety of its citizens to do it, so maybe we have to do it ourselves.
Unfortunately that reaction is the reason something like a by-law making people clear their own sidewalks will never work here, for years people haven’t had to do it, and despite all the chest beating about how resourceful we like to think we are, no one actually wants to do the work. People would just not do it out of spite.
People will say, “what about seniors who cant physically do it?” Seniors live in cities like Halifax and Winnipeg, it gets figured out, ie: being resourceful, neighbours helping neighbours.
To be fair, I have also noticed an improvement in the last few years in terms of sidewalk clearing, still pretty piss poor, but an attempt is being made. Its just the constant brushes with death that make a person testy. And I honestly anyone who doesn’t feel that way, never walks anywhere.
Here is an interesting, albeit short, article that explores both sides of the argument in other cities, with examples of places that have the by law, and ones that dont.
http://www2.macleans.ca/2011/03/17/down-shovels-the-city-should-clear-the-sidewalks/
Im too lazy (ha!) to go back and edit this rant, but I feel I should apologize for being so snarky (to anon), it just boils my blood to see what in my mind comes down to laziness and lack of empathy by the city, endanger peoples lives on a daily basis.
December 21st, 2012 at 8:52 am
Edit – I was totally wrong with the Winnipeg example. Main sentiment remains however
December 21st, 2012 at 5:57 pm
“So, you’re saying you can shovel a sidewalk but not salt it? That’s just going too far? You would think the possibility of getting sued would be motivation to make sure its done.”
No, it’s not motivation at all. It’s depressing to know how true what I’m saying actually is. If you do things to try to help people, and it injures them somehow, they will most likely try to sue. People quickly forget about “goodwill” and think “money”.
Who wants to take on needless liability?
Who buys the salt for home owners to shake on the sidewalks?
How often does it need to be cleared?
If there is a severe snowfall while a home owner is at work do they have a liability to rush home (without pay) and clear it?
If a plow goes down the street at 3am and pushes a pile of snow on the sidewalks, do home owners have a liability to get out of bed and clean it up?
Who shovels and salts the sidewalks which aren’t adjacent to any particular home?
December 21st, 2012 at 6:09 pm
What about home owners who have disabilities and disabling diseases and aren’t able to shovel their own driveways?
What happens if a home owner goes on a vacation during our winter season and no one is home to shovel the sidewalk. They end up getting a ticket for being on a vacation.
December 21st, 2012 at 6:20 pm
What about seniors who are on fixed incomes and not in good health? They physically can’t do all that shoveling and can’t afford to pay someone to do it.
December 21st, 2012 at 6:32 pm
I clear and salt my bit of sidewalk.. I figure if I’m already out doing it for my front walkway (so visitors, postal workers etc don’t slip, fall and sue) I might as well spend the extra few minutes to do the sidewalk..
BUT! I strongly believe the City should take responsibility for sidewalks, even if just the more frequently used ones. Making St. John’s easier to get around for people who don’t drive is a worthwhile investment.. and it isn’t just about students, seniors, the poor, etc.. I’ve known a number of people who moved here for work only to leave a year or two later, partly because they got fed up with how difficult it was to get around without a car. Some young professionals would rather pay off their student loans faster or save for a down payment, rather than blow their money on gas and insurance..
December 21st, 2012 at 6:55 pm
“Some young professionals would rather pay off their student loans faster or save for a down payment, rather than blow their money on gas and insurance..”
That’s ones choice. Other people shouldn’t have to make life easier for people who are too cheap to go get a car. You can’t have it all.
December 23rd, 2012 at 1:42 am
“Some young professionals would rather pay off their student loans faster or save for a down payment, rather than blow their money on gas and insurance..”
These are people who make choices on what they want first in life. It’s no one else’s problem that Joe Blow decides he’d rather pay off his student loan(s) and save for a down payment on a house. Others shouldn’t be held accountable to make life easier for Joe.
I have student loans, I have a car, and I’m saving for a down payment to buy a home. I don’t cry for help from the general public just because it’s hard at times. My situation is no one else’s problem.
To add to anon’s list of “issues without answers”, I know several people who live on the corner of two streets, where the sidewalks extend from the front of the house, all the way around the corner and down the other street. Why should one resident have to clear more sidewalk than his/her neighbor just because they bought a corner lot before all these rules came into being? Who would ever buy a corner lot from then on?
I think people are failing to realize that there is life outside of Downtown St. John’s where a lot of the houses only have 5 or 10 feet of sidewalk adjacent to them. It’s not all about the granolas who want to walk around Downtown all day, busking, bumming, and drinking coffee. Wake up, take on some actual responsibilities, and stop living in that fantasy world because it’s no fantasy. If you can’t handle the snow, move somewhere warm. If you don’t want to move, pick up a shovel and clear your own way, because I’m not doing it for you!!!
December 26th, 2012 at 11:28 am
Yeah, that’s what I’ll do. Bring my shovel to school with me. Stop your trollin’