PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
March 1st, 2012 at 4:59 pm
I’m surprised you noticed being so high up on your horse. You must have a lot of problems considering you’re writing an I Saw You about a four year old.
March 1st, 2012 at 6:10 pm
Want a lump of sugar for your horse?
March 1st, 2012 at 6:12 pm
And I saw YOU, lurking on the internet, bullying children not yet old enough to be in school. Well done! :)
March 1st, 2012 at 8:05 pm
I’m sorry but every time I see a young obese child I can’t help but think that it’s a form of child abuse. The parents aren’t teaching the child any self control and are just sending them into a early grave. And i see it more today than ever. It’s disgusting and parents should be ashamed of themselves for doing such a thing to their children.
March 1st, 2012 at 8:12 pm
And you should be ashamed for assuming its always the parents fault.
March 1st, 2012 at 10:35 pm
it sure isn’t always genetics!
March 2nd, 2012 at 12:28 am
Exactly my point. You never know what it could be, so instead why look at a child and assume you know?
March 2nd, 2012 at 9:56 am
the kid is 4!!! who else is to blame!
March 2nd, 2012 at 10:09 am
Well, how would you know what this kids problems are? Besides, the kid IS 4! How many kids are “pudgy” when they’re young? A LOT! I was and I’m not as an adult. I also had times when I ate a lot of junk, that happens from time to time for everyone, especially when you’re a kid.
March 2nd, 2012 at 11:03 am
Doesn’t matter whose fault it is…fact remains that someone took time out of their day to write an I saw you directed towards a four year old kid…
Get a life.
March 2nd, 2012 at 11:23 am
it’s a comment directed at ‘society’, not the four year old.
your snide cynicism is boring.
it’s got nothing to do with high-horses – the poster is not saying s/he is better than others, s/he is saying it is poor parenting leading to greater issues that DO affect him/her.
it IS a sort of child abuse, just as smoking in front of them all the time, or naming your child Adolf Hitler is wrong (and the state will step in on you if you do that). the parent sets the tone of the kids life. the kid has no idea that stuffing two chocolate croissants in his gob is neither healthy in the short nor long run, nor that it is subconsciously unethical. and when he’s 8 and lying in front of the playstation and fat, it will still be their fault. and that it bothers a passer-by says that members of society don’t accept it.
obesity is rarely genetic, rarely.
poor food choices, overeating and under-exercising habits are the major cause, you can add whichever excuse/diagnosis to it that you like, but if it’s from formed habit as a child, it IS the parent’s fault. whose else fault could it be?
if you go to Cuba, where most folks are poor compared to us, you’ll see lots of fit people (not skinny and starved, but fit and trim) and very very few obese people (I saw only one in Havana in two weeks of being in the city, and not at the beach – where you’ll see tons of fat Canadians). If you actually don’t have the wealth of endless food supplies, you cannot abuse it. It’s Western entitlement to over-eat.
And while it does harm the individual child, it weighs very heavy on society.
it IS our business to point this out, as the healthcare system will have to pay for it.
I was visiting a friend in hospital two years ago, across the room in another bed was a well-overweight woman who wasn’t even 50, getting a hip replacement.
She was propped up in the bed with a ton of junk food around her (seriously, a bag of candy under each arm!), her fat 8 year old sitting at the foot of the bed with a gob full of candy.
Poor health and eating habits, too much weight, no exercise = weakened muscle/skeletal support = give me a new hip at the taxpayer’s expense. Feel my pain.
What a joke.
It’s an affront to the healthcare system and the nurse trying to look after her – you are OUT OF ORDER if you think it’s fair for the rest of us to pay for your weaknesses, with new hips and homecare to allow you to continue the bad habits that got you in this position.
We need a Fat Tax. Prove to your doctor with an every-6-month visit that you are making an effort, and your fat tax is reduced or eliminated (it’s a great motivator, money). Make an effort. Work towards and maintain a healthy lifestyle/weight, never pay a fat tax. Sit around and get fat, or bring your over-fed kid in, PAY the tax. and make it a hefty tax, so it actually is felt.
Fat tax revenue is held aside for Diabetes and hip replacement and other obesity issues. The idea of taxing a bag of chips or a pop is stupid. You’d have to tax it out of a realistic price for it to make any difference.
You can say I’m cruel but it’s basic logic. It’s abusive to the rest of us who are eating moderately and exercising moderately, and raise kids that way. Simply because we live in abundance doesn’t mean we need to be stuffing it into us with no penalty.
I sat down with a guy a few years ago, fairly overweight, and ready to tuck in to a huge steak. he said with a sort of ‘aw shucks’ attitude: “I just love to eat…” as though he were saying “I just have brown hair, and I’ll have to live with it…”
wtf?
I love to eat too, and I cook a mean curry. The difference with me is that I stop when I’ve had enough, and I don’t eat as a habit/crutch, and I select healthy food over chips (i do eat them sometimes), and I go for a walk now and then, and I RESPECT the wealth the universe has afforded us. Over-eaters neither respect the universe nor themselves, and they ALWAYS have an excuse. Fat Tax them into living responsibly if they won’t do it themselves. They’ll actually thank you for it once they realize their mistake (ask anyone who has transformed themselves from former-obesity). To me they are just as offensive to society as thieving drug-addicts. We pay for prisons, we pay for hip-replacements. Neither get rehabilitated, both continue on with their offenses, many get worse. It all effects the rest of us.
I don’t care if you don’t like my attitude, I’m sick of looking at you excuse-making abusers all the time.
Stuff that in your fat kid’s gob.
March 2nd, 2012 at 12:07 pm
I agree with anon. Obesity is an issue that we are still very taboo about within our society. I bet 100 people will tell a person to stop beating a dog before they will tell a parent to stop overfeeding their already obese child.
Abuse is abuse.
March 2nd, 2012 at 3:29 pm
anon3: Thank you. Oh my god thank you.
March 2nd, 2012 at 4:43 pm
Anon3 – Well said!
March 2nd, 2012 at 9:18 pm
First of all: the original post is not about society or parenting. Go read it again. The criticism is being levied at the child, not at the parent. Even if the parenting point was valid, and I’m not convinced that it is, the original post is an attack on a four year old child which seems to take for granted that the child is sufficiently developed to be aware of the standards which the OP takes for granted, and which so many have reiterated here. Maybe the parent should have stepped in, or maybe not. I take no stand on that, but I take a strong stand against any comment so foolish as this. If you know that the child is four, then you know it has an awful lot of psychological and physical development to go, and cannot accept responsibility for its actions in the way the OP suggests it should. The post is so phenomenally stupid and hawkish that it smacks of bait, and I wasn’t going to say anything initially because of that.
Thing is, I had to say something when I read Anon3′s post, which is occasionally well thought out – key word ‘occasionally’ – but often not. Let me ask you this: what about the non-lifestyle answers for ‘obesity’ (a loaded term) which are not genetic? What about thyroid disorders? What about an eating disorder? What about a medical side effect? I grant you these probably do not relate to the OP’s ‘pudgy four year old’ (and thank you to Steve for pointing out that ‘pudginess’ is not necessarily life long, or even bad) but much of Anon3′s post didn’t, either, so I think we can disregard that. This hypothetical ‘fat tax’ that you postulate – would it apply to people with binge eating disorders? Could you get a psychologist’s note to get out of paying it, or are you screwed along with the obviously lazy and stupid people who can’t be bothered to listen to the fine, knowledgeable individuals here? If you gain a great deal of weight as a result of a new prescription, do you have to stop taking the drug or face the fat tax? If the diabetes you’d have it set aside for has a link to weight, would you not receive any of the funds set aside? I mean, after all, it’s just because you weren’t Putting In An Effort (to do what I am not certain) in the way everyone apparently knows you should.
Further, given that the tax is really about sedentary lifestyle, what about people who have a naturally fast metabolism but still eat a lot and never exercise? Should they have to declare their metabolism and pay the tax, and would that be at a reduced rate? Could you be found guilty of tax evasion if you have such a metabolism and you get caught eating a plate of chips? Further, who decides the definition of ‘moderate’? Given that the BMI measure is the most widely used, we’d probably use that, but does that mean we ignore all the criticism of it?
And for what it’s worth: Anon3 makes a nebulous, but valid, argument that allowing overeating is ‘child abuse’, but no valid argument at all that it is abusive to anyone else. Do you have proof that the ONLY reason that woman needed a hip replacement was excess weight? In what exact way is it ‘abusive’ to you that some people have health problems who happen to be obese? I have known enough people to know that a great many people who are ‘overweight’, or who lead sedentary lifestyles, or who have substantial appetites do not always run into issues of health, and if they do, there is not always a link to their weight. I have also known at least one person who’s had a hip replacement and she’s not ‘obese’ or ‘sedentary’ by any definition of those words.
If you’re going to put a ‘hefty tax’ on ‘overeating’ because the idea bothers you and you feel personally offended, then I suggest we’ll need to give in to an awful lot of demands. A hefty tax on smoking, obviously, in favour of all those who feel offended when their taxes go to pay for chemo being performed on a lung cancer victim. A hefty tax on drinking to please those who get peeved when someone with cirrhosis needs antibiotics. You can come up with more; I’m too annoyed to continue. You can also imagine exactly how these things would be enforced.
You know what doesn’t annoy me, though? The idea of moderation. It’s a sensible thought, and one which I try to follow, but it doesn’t always work. The same holds true for many people. Saying that people who don’t follow such guidelines are irresponsible and victims of their own idiocy and of course FAT FAT FAT FAT FAT gets us nowhere. Neither does saying that you feel personally offended because some infinitessimal percentage of your tax money might have gone to support rehabilitation or recuperative procedures for someone whose health problems might have had some nebulous link to weight.
I have a great friend who is anorexic, and she often refers to our society as “an eating disorder factory”. With comments like these, I can’t help but agree.
March 2nd, 2012 at 10:57 pm
OHFORGAWDSAKE! Maybe it was the kid’s bloody birthday. If I was four, you best believe I’d be at rocket eatin me two chocolate croissants. Maybe three! OOOOOOOOOOOH! You hear that? THREE!
And then I’d go run around and jump up and down on the bed and MIND MY OWN BUSINESS, like kids do.
March 3rd, 2012 at 8:36 am
i can’t believe how seriously y’all are taking this post.
March 3rd, 2012 at 3:30 pm
We’re even more slim and trim than those fat slobs in cuba.
March 3rd, 2012 at 3:45 pm
Thank you. As a recovering anorexic, the kind of rhetoric above deeply disturbs me. I think a great number of the “fat slobs” that these people are referring to also have eating disorders. Studies have shown that certain foods cause a similar synaptic reaction in the brain as some drugs, therefore, this could be more of an addiction issue than one of moderation. The idea of simply deterring “fat” people with a tax is far too simplistic. Over-eating is often a psychological disorder and can be worsened by feelings of shame and isolation — often caused by a society who views them as “fat slobs” who are simply too lazy to stop eating.
I know my disorder is different, but, it’s still a psychological disorder based on food. I’ve gone through YEARS of treatment and I still wrestle with this daily. I doubt simply taxing and shaming people with an overeating disorder would do anything but make them feel worse.
March 3rd, 2012 at 7:15 pm
Tell me about it! People really have way too much time on their hands. Leave the kid alone…& his/her parents….you don’t know what the circumstances are…..maybe it really was their freakin’ birthday! Who cares! They may only get one treat day a week, or a month for all you know! Worry about yourselves & your own kids!
March 3rd, 2012 at 7:50 pm
Anon3….you are one egotistical POS. The kid is 4 years old for christ sakes. When I was 4 I weighed 35 pounds over my normal weight, all through out my younger years I was a pudgy fat pig slob as some have referred to the kid as here. When I hit puberty it all changed, so before you go on your holier than thou condescending blurb, stop and think that fat kid may outlive some aneroxic girl who’s trying to look like some pencil thin model BECAUSE THATS WHAT SOCIETY THINK SHE HAS TO LOOK LIKE!
March 3rd, 2012 at 11:19 pm
I think Cuba would be a good match for anon3. I’ve seen a few of this person’s posts on this site, and they believe that the government should tell us what/how much to eat, where to live, and how much money we can make. That’s called communism, and history has shown that it doesn’t work. I like living in a free country, thank you very much anon3.
March 5th, 2012 at 1:16 pm
You are the reason people complain about I Saw Yous being negative.
Grow up.
March 7th, 2012 at 10:51 am
Wow, Anon3, that might have been the most sanctimonious, narcissistic crap I’ve ever read. Yes, everyone knows we are a much more sedentary society these days than ever before, but THIS is the issue you choose to get all enraged about?! What are you, the fat police? Why does other people’s weight make you so angry, you have even come up with a “fat tax” theory to “solve” it? Do you think people who are obese choose to be that way? Contrary to what you believe, compulsive overeating is a legitimate psychological disorder, an eating disorder like anorexia and bulimia, and it’s even more common. Even without that diagnosis, people who are overweight usually have emotional issues leading them to use food to self-medicate. Are you saying you are better than them? What about an emergency room doctor, who, between 24-hour shifts of saving lives, grabs a bag of chips and a Coke because it’s what’s convenient- are you better than her? Is she an affront to society, as you say, because of what she might or might not weigh?
Shaming people into losing weight— yeah, that’ll work. No foreseeable problems there.
Can we impose a douchebag tax? Because I’d support that.
March 8th, 2012 at 8:33 pm
Wow ANON3! You are so perfect! Maybe we should consider taxing people who run to maintain their health because they sometimes need hip replacements too……or create a tax for people who have genetic history of heart disease and choose to have children that end up with heart disease that our taxes end up having to pay for! Imagine the money that could be earned/saved by taxing everyone who makes a poor choice!!! And, fortunately us perfect people won’t have to pay a thing!!
March 14th, 2012 at 2:13 am
flatbread adn 2 chocolate croisants at 4 years old? I think we can safely assume it’s the food!