Dear Food Nerd:
What makes a better pie crust: butter or shortening?
- Flaky, St. John’s
Dear Flaky,
That’s a good question, and one that has torn families apart for generations. An all-butter crust is rich and tender, while a shortening-only crust is flaky, with a neutral flavor (butter pastry tastes, well, buttery).
Most recipes call for a combination of the two, although the ratio will depend on the baker. My old standby recipe calls for ¾ cups butter and just over ¼ cup shortening for a single pie crust. It’s a delicious pastry, and pretty easy to work with.
Of late, though, I have come to love that bad-boy of baking, the lard pastry. I know, I know, we’re supposed to think lard is gross, but the thing is, lard is a much less processed form if fat than vegetable shortening is. Just think about it: it’s a lot easier to get pure, solid, fat off a pig than it is from, say, canola plants. Pigs are fatty. Canola is not. So if you want fat, I figure the pig knows best. And the pastry: oh, it’s delicious. Lard is why your grandma’s pies always tasted so good (well, that or Lucky margarine).
If you’re averse to all of the above, you can make a quite decent pie crust using frozen olive oil. Olive oil freezes almost solid. If the rest of your ingredients are very cold and you work fast, you can put a crust together without it melting. You’ll probably have to press it in the pan rather than rolling it, but that’s no matter.
Whichever ingredients you’re using, keep t hem cold and use nimble fingers. Move with confidence and certainty, and your pie crust will turn out fine.



August 25th, 2010 at 1:46 pm
Personally, I use nothing but real butter in my pie crusts. The trick to getting a great flaky crust with real butter is to keep it as cold as possible (I freeze mine before use) and to mix it to the bare minimum.
August 26th, 2010 at 9:52 am
Is that all lard or a lard-butter hybrid? MmmMmm lard-butter hybrid….
September 8th, 2010 at 9:45 pm
Butter by a long shot. It’s animal fat, so it’s REAL food and plus, animal fat is possibly the best (most healthy) kind of fat available for human consumption. Anything else (shortening, lard, margarine) are synthetic and made in the lab, not to forget, less healthy for you than butter. If you want more info about butter, I suggest reading Michael Pollan’s The Omnivore’s Dilemma and Marion Nestle’s Food Politics.
September 10th, 2010 at 12:09 am
Shortening/lard does come from animals. Unless you’re talking about vegetable shortening.
November 30th, 2010 at 10:40 am
I definitely use butter. Shortening/lard contains trans fats. No amount of trans fats are safe.