
To get a sense of who they were and where they stand on a range of issues, we sent a questionnaire to each of the candidates running in the 2009 St. John’s municipal election.
As the election proceeds, we’ll be posting the candidates’ responses here at www.thescope.ca/election
Here is part two, the responses from the candidates for deputy mayor, Keith Coombs and Shannie Duff.

Keith Coombs
www.keithcoombs.ca
Please describe yourself in a few words.
Very positive and hardworking. People friendly. Forward thinking and gets the job done.
What is your present occupation?
Principal MDJH
Why are you running in this election?
Because I want to help lead our city grow in the future and do it in such a manner that people and families can afford to live here.
What should be the city’s top three priorities?
Reducing the tax burden on citizens. Responsible growth. Improved quality of life.
What has been the present council’s biggest blunder?
Not implementing the curb side recycling program fully during this term
What has been the present council’s biggest achievement?
Being able to allow responsible growth so as to improve the city and expand its tax base.
What other candidates running in this election do you think you would work best with?
Doesn’t matter you have to work with any and all
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city? (And why is it your favourite?)
Gander – flat for walking
How would you rate your performance during your time on council?
Very good and always aimed at improving the city
OPINIONS/ISSUES?
(Please rate the importance of each subject on a scale of 0 to 10, then add your comments.
Sidewalk snow clearing
9
Revising heritage building regulations
7
Park and Ride bus services
7
Live audio/video streaming of city council meetings
2
City support for community gardens
7
City support for farmers’ markets
7
City support for the arts
8
Downtown parking solutions
9
Recommended changes to the para-transit system
8
Reducing urban sprawl/Encouraging urban density
8
Term limit for councillor positions
2
Amalgamation with communities in the North-East Avalon
8
Water meters
1
Each of these plays a role in the growth and creation of a great city. While right now they can be rated as above, the fact remains that as conditions and pressures change so do the priorities. There are other issues not mentioned here which I believe are even more important and one of them is the level of taxation to which we are subjecting our citizens. We cannot allow St. John’s to become a city where people have to decide whether or not they can afford to remain here or move to another community in order to pay the bills. This must be stopped.
—

Shannie Duff
www.shannie.ca
Please describe yourself in a few words.
I am an experienced municipal politician. I am energetic, thoughtful, intelligent, hard working, outspoken and committed to working for the interests of the people of St. John’s. I am also a wife, mother,and grandmother with a lifetime track record of service as a community volunteer.
What is your present occupation?
City councillor. Community volunteer.
Why are you running in this election?
Because I am passionate about the future of this City. I recognize the opportunities that prosperity will bring but also the need to make thoughtful decisions that will protect the interests of those who may not benefit directly from the new prosperity. I also want to protect the natural environment, our neighbourhoods and our heritage and cultural assets. These are also important economic assets , which will encourage people to invest, work and live in our community.
What should be the city’s top three priorities?
Developing a long range plan for the city and the city’s role in the region so that we have a road map for the future.The planning process should be inclusive and engage citizens in a dialogue about the the kind of city they want St. John’s to become..
Careful management of the city’s finances to avoid unnecessary debt for future generations and reduce the tax burden on present residents..
Continued investment in infrastructure ( roads, sidewalks,water and sewer, parks, open spaces,public facilities,transit etc.)
The focus should be on enhancing the quality of life for all residents.
What has been the present council’s biggest blunder?
Lack of long range planning and lack of commitment to it’s own municipal plan and development regulations.
What has been the present council’s biggest achievement?
Undertaking the three major environmental projects which are now completed or close to completion.
- The Sewage Treatment Facility at Riverhead.
- The complete upgrade of the Robin Hood Bay Landfill.
- The major up grade of the water purification systems at Windsor Lake,and Bay Bulls Big Pond.
What other candidates running in this election do you think you would work best with?
I will work with any member of Council the voters decide to elect.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city? (And why is it your favourite?)
I have many favoutite cities. What they tend to have in common is human scale, a strong sense of their culture and heritage, life on the streets and beautiful spaces and places.
How would you rate your performance during your time on council?
I know I gave it my best shot. My husband thinks I did a geat job but he could be a bit biased. The only job evaluation that really counts is from the voters. It is a bit intimidating getting a report card from 70 plus thousand of your fellow citizens.
OPINIONS/ISSUES?
(Please rate the importance of each subject on a scale of 0 to 10, then add your comments.
Sidewalk snow clearing
10. High priority as an are for improvement. The limiting factors are cost, and climate.
Revising heritage building regulations
3
Regulations of any kind are only as good as the political will to enforce them. I have no problem with revisiting the Heritage Regulations in the context of a revision of the municipal plan and revising them if appropriate. It wasn’t so long ago that the City undertook two major studies of Economic Development and Heritage Conservation. Both were adopted by Council after extensive public consultation.. (2001 and 2003).
Park and Ride bus services
7
We have to find a way to get more people using public transit. However, I don’t think this is it is a sort term fix. It is part of a much larger issue of regional transportation services and at best will only be part of the solution.
Live audio/video streaming of city council meetings
0
This would be costly and a low priority for me. Meetins are already open to the public and coverend by the community Channel.and most major media outlets. Who would watch them at 4.30 in the afternoon?
City support for community gardens
10
I think we should encourage urban gardening in principal. Project would be elegible for mosdet financial support from the community grants program and I am not aware of any regulatory issues.
City support for farmers’ markets
10
I totally support a Farmer’s market for St. John’s. They are wonderful community spaces and support small enterprise of many types, not only agriculture. We should have had one long ago.
City support for the arts
10
I totally support municipal support for the arts. The arts community in St. John’s is a large part of the reason why this is a creative and livable city. They contribute so much to our quality of life and are an important economic as well as cultural asset.
Downtown parking solutions
10
This is an urgent issue. The City and the DDC have completed a study which will go to public hearings after the election.
Recommended changes to the para-transit system
10
Another issues needing urgen attention. I agree with many of the recommendations . The next step will be the budget process. I have reservations about some recommendations, including the full integration with Metrobus.
Term limit for councillor positions
0
I don’t agree with this. It is not the norm in municipal politics and I don’t really see the advantage. It is up top the voters to decide when municipal (or any other politicians should be terminated.
Reducing urban sprawl/Encouraging urban density
10
This is a very important issue in the North East Avalon, especially now that we are experiencing real development pressures. Our present Regional Plan is outdated and toothless. Fortunately it is currently in a review process. I am on the review committee. The Sprawl issue has to be dealt with regionnally and require a high degree of regional cooperation and sound planning. No communities, including St. John’s have a good track record on this because we have not taken a coordinated and long range approach to plamming.
Amalgamation with communities in the North-East Avalon
6
The study which was done a number of years ago recommended the amalgation of the urban core aeas of Mount Pearl and Paradise and St. John’s. I believe it will happen within the next decade because it makes good economic sense. However for the present I believe we should focus on developing our services regionally and fostering regional cooperation.
Amalgations have rarely taken place in any province without strong leadership by the provincial government. Regional cooperation will make it easier for the province to take the lead it has to take in this issue all over the province.
Water meters
In principal I agree with metering because it encouraeges conservation of water resources and is fairer to those who conserve. The city is doing a pilot project and conducting research on implementation of water metering. A big issue is the cost particularly to low income families so we are looking at the expereince and best practices from other jurisdictions Safe potable water is not free. It is becoming increasingly expensive to produce and distribute due to envirnmental and public health requirements and the cost of infrastructure.
There will be extensive public consultation before any action is taken.



September 13th, 2009 at 2:42 pm
I really hope Keith Coombs wins!!! Shanny has been around much too long and I hope this year, we see a bit of house cleaning when it comes to City Council. So many of them have been there so long, they’ve taken root. And are now rotting away the foundations of municipal politics in St. John’s.
September 13th, 2009 at 7:11 pm
I agree with you 100% Wallace it’s time for Shannie and many others on council to leave! There needs to be some new life in down at City Hall and we need people that can understand the youth of the city. It’s pretty bad that the soon to be mayor of St. John’s Ron Ellsworth is the youngest person on council.
September 14th, 2009 at 8:42 am
While I agree that we need fresh bodies in council, I have to say that I strongly believe Shannie has remained the most “in-tune” with the youth of St. John’s.
Ted Kennedy was in the US senate for almost 50 years and was well respected as one of the most effective members. To say that Shannie has been there for a long time is a very weak argument for her removal.
She’s proven herself time and again, and frankly I’m not sure the same can be said of Mr. Coombs.
September 16th, 2009 at 3:39 pm
I am mostly ambivalent about who wins the position of Deputy Mayor, but I am curious as to why you feel Keith Coombs should win? What exactly has Shannie Duff done to “rot the foundations of municipal politics” in St John’s? She may have been around a while, and maybe she supports the arts more than most people would like in an elected official, but it seems like she works her butt off at everything she does, and has gotten a lot done in her time in office. Mr Coombs may do a good job, but I don’t see why he should be elected just because he’s fresh meat. That is ridiculous. Vote on the issues, not because you want to see new faces. And as for younger voices on council… you could vote Mark Wilson for mayor and Andrew Harvey for Ward 2, but again, make sure you’re voting for them because of their stances on the important issues, not just because they are young.