This city-owned property at 90 Duckworth Street
It seems if you dangle a concept drawing of a big condo in front of council and ask for some public land on the sly, you can convince six of them to sell it to you. Without placing it up for public tender.
Proof of this came to light at the February 14th meeting of St. John’s city council. The issue at hand was the potential sale of the former East End Fire Department at 90 Duckworth Street, located across from the old Crazy Horse/Piccadilly Pub. These days 20 city employees use this building for office space.
By the time the council sat on Monday, a decision to sell it to a particular developer had already been made at a special meeting January 31st. The meeting was “special” meaning it was held behind closed doors, away from the prying eyes of the public and troublesome live bloggers. The decision was to give two potential developers an option to purchase the land for $556,000, providing they can satisfy several conditions, including successful re-zoning of the land.
At the public city council meeting, Deputy-Mayor Shannie Duff made a motion to rescind the decision to sell the property. Her motion failed in a tight 5-6 vote, with Hanlon, Tilley, Breen, Hann, Hickman, and O’Keefe opposed. Which means the offer stands.
Those who voted against the motion to rescind said the city had no legal obligation to have a public process to offload “surplus” land, and that this kind of thing has happened before. The former Animal Services building was sold by the city to Loblaws, and the Blackmarsh Dominion now rests on that spot.
Ward 4 Councillor Debbie Hanlon stressed that what the city agreed to is simply an option, not a sale, and that “nothing will go there without public input.”
I refer to the “potential” developers, because the two individuals who met with the city brought a concept drawing for the property, but didn’t ever formally submit a proposal. The concept involves upper-scale condominiums for 83 Duckworth. The land they want from the city would see two levels of retail and two levels of parking. Hanlon, who has 18 years experience in real estate says that she has done her own analysis of the property valuation of $556,000, and says the price is “spot on.”
But those opposed to the potential sale seem to be against how the whole thing is going down. Deputy-Mayor Duff says that the sale of public land occurring behind closed doors is “bad public policy” as it is neither fair nor transparent. She also argued that the land sold to Loblaws for the Dominion was not the same situation. In that case, the land had no frontage on a street, and could not have been developed by anyone else except Loblaws, who owned the property between it and Blackmarsh Road.
Councillor Gerry Colbert said the concept for the proposal is good, but “can’t see why council can’t wait.” He also thinks that the city needs “to see if it makes sense for the city, for the taxpayers, who, by the way,” he says, “own the building.”
Now, short of a scene like Tahrir Square, the re-zoning of the land will almost certainly go ahead, the sale will be made, and a precedent will have been set.



February 18th, 2011 at 3:07 pm
I have no problem with this. We really don’t need public input on every little thing that council does. Of course some people will be opposed to it, this sort of thing tends to bring out the NIMBY crowd as well as the folks in St. John’s who simply don’t want to see anything new get built ever. We’re talking about an old, ugly, useless fire hall. This should be a simple mundane matter, but with too much “public consultation” it could quickly turn into a drawn-out circus and nothing would get done. Sometimes we should just be happy to give our elected representatives the authority to make a decision.
February 19th, 2011 at 8:54 pm
I agree that sometimes we should just let our elected representatives make a decision, however the sale of major public assets is not one of those times. How do we know what other public assets are for sale? Should I contact City Hall and make an offer for St. Pat’s Ball Park? How about the Mews Centre? Mile One? When major public assets are sold (and yes, a property worth over half a million dollars is major), it should go through a process: 1)has the city looked at its long term strategic plan for parks and recreation; affordable housing; office space, etc to see if the property could fulfill one of those needs? 2)has the city made public that it plans to sell the property in the near future, with a few months of lead time for prospective buyer to put together proposals 3)if there is no other public use for the property as indicated in (1), then proceed with a sale by a public request for expressions of interest – not necessarily to the highest tender, but to the best use for the site, in consideration of the City’s Municipal Plan.
Folks, it may be that this particular proposal would go ahead. I haven’t seen the developer’s proposal – it might even be awesome. Frankly, this property is not a park or other publicly used facilty, but it is a very bad practice and a very bad precedent. There are lots of small public spaces around the city – little parkettes and playgrounds, which I’m sure wouldn’t be worth anywhere near half a million, but they are worth a lot to the children and families who use them. I’ve actually seen it happen, where a neighbourhood had to fight a rearguard action to protect against an individual buying their local park. Yes, this really almost happened, but thankfully people found out and kicked up a stink. Don’t we need to make sure that someone can’t just waltz in a make an offer, which is conditionally accepted by council, without any prior public input?
February 21st, 2011 at 9:35 am
The deal itself seems like a good one, but Shannie is right, you can’t pick and choose when it’s ok to do these ‘special’ meetings.