4:28:05 PM: The St. John’s city council liveblog: municipal democracy, Twitter-style
4:32:53 PM: Andrew Harvey here to bring you all the happenings on New Gower street.
4:41:02 PM: Exciting meeting coming up, proposed text ammendments for building regulations for properties on Water St. The Arcade and woolworth building
4:42:35 PM: Possible ammendments will be discussed for the Municipal Plan and Development regulations. We will see if they actually vote on them.
4:46:20 PM: The meeting called to order by Shannie Duff, O’Keefe is not here.
4:47:00 PM: Delegation for Occupational Health and Safety week.
4:49:52 PM: There is a full week of activities this week, all encouraging safety, from equipment safety to the effects of sodium on your health.
4:51:16 PM: In 2009, there were 46 fatalities related to workplace accidents. Be safe people.
4:53:27 PM: Bruce Tilley says that when he has been at the depot, safety seems to be key.
4:55:00 PM: Decleration for MS month.
4:55:39 PM: 1 in 500 Canadians have MS, and there is no known cure.
4:57:24 PM: There have been exciting new developments in treating MS, and will hopefully lead to a cure.
4:59:00 PM: Delegation for the Seniors Resource Centre. Mothers Day Rose campaign
5:00:53 PM: Look for Roses for sale to support the Seniors Resource Centre. With our aging population more and more of us will be seniors soon.
5:03:22 PM: Tom Hann just gave 2 roses to 2 reporters in the media gallery. What a sweetheart.
5:05:27 PM: There was to be a public meeting regarding the rezoning of some land for Corpus Christi Parish, but the meeting was cancelled.
5:06:15 PM: It was cancelled because there were no wrItten objections.
5:07:55 PM: O’Leary is discussing the Councillors pension scheme. Supposedly it is cheaper for the councillors to not pay into a pension scheme.!?
5:09:21 PM: I have no idea how that works (currently they pay nothing for their pension). O’Leary says she is satisfied now that she has investigated it
5:12:26 PM: There is a proposal for a lounge in the basement of Compu College. Dept of Planning reccommended to approve, but they are voting to deny it.
5:13:27 PM: The issue is that this is a discretionary use, and council does not have to approve it. They say there are enough clubs in the area.
5:14:57 PM: Discussion about Pipers wanting to come in on Elizabeth Ave. On the site of the old Subaru.
5:16:46 PM: Galgay says that they have listened to the concerns of citizens, and will make sure they will work with Pipers to address their concerns.
5:18:12 PM: Breen is noting concerns over trying to get a left turn lane near there on New Cove Rd.
5:19:31 PM: Tom Hann says that Debbie Hanlon, the ward councillor for the area, asked him to state she supports this proposal, and hopes it goes ahead.
5:20:32 PM: Shannie Duff wants to know if any considerations will be made with the colour scheme of the store to make sure it fits in to the area.
5:21:45 PM: Duff: “So we’ll leave the colour scheme in her [Hanlon's] capable hands.”
5:24:58 PM: Parks and Recreation comittee report by Wally Collins. The city will sponsor a flower patch in Bowring park.
5:26:25 PM: St. John’s minor baseball association is looking for more field space. Collins says Bannerman park is fully used, but they will work to help
5:27:35 PM: They will help by using other fields for big tournaments and try to see about building a new field somewhere.
5:28:17 PM: Planning and Housing Committee Report by Bruce Tilley.
5:29:37 PM: Compusult Ltd. spoke to the committee about their property on Water street, the Arcade property.
5:31:12 PM: Duff says the proposal still does not meet new parking regulations, and that will need to be addressed before the proposal will be looked at
5:32:22 PM: Hann says that there is no need for discussion on the matter. The new regulations are very clear on the new amount of parking required.
5:33:58 PM: Hickman says that the motion they are discussing is realy about height. What he saw was 4 stories, but the issue was 15m was not enough.
5:35:00 PM: Breen says the issue was only over 1.5m, and that it is too hard to build 4 stories of class A office space in 15m.
5:36:14 PM: To clarify, there is no formal proposal here, the company was looking for an indication if they were heading in the right direction.
5:38:01 PM: A proposal for a subdivision off Pennywell rd was rejected. This type of development will not be approved until services can be provided.
5:40:12 PM: Council has moved to have a public meeting for a subdivision on Teakwood Dr. Duff says she has some concerns about technical considerations.
5:41:29 PM: Collins says they have found some property for a community centre for the Southlands. They need 5,000 people to qualify for one.
5:43:29 PM: Here it is, discussion on potential ammendments which would remove the land between Bishops Cove and Steer’s cove from the Heritage areas.
5:44:16 PM: Hickman says this piece of DT is obvious what needs to happen.
5:44:16 PM: Hickman says this piece of DT is obvious what needs to happen.
5:45:37 PM: Hann: “I don’t this this is a proper motion to be included here”. He says because council voted to defer the review of the Municipal plan.
5:46:20 PM: Hann says he doesn’t want these changes to happen piecemeal.
5:47:11 PM: Hann has risen on a point of order, asking for a ruling if they are reflecting on a previous motion.
5:48:55 PM: City Manager advises this discussion is not in conflict with the precious motion. There is now some speaking over one another over this ohhh
5:50:22 PM: Galgay says that these are important developments should not have to wait for the Provinces Regional plan.
5:51:43 PM: Duff has said that if we were going to look at development in this area, the one with the Woolworth building, it should happen as a block.
5:53:05 PM: Some lively discussion in an important matter. Council passed the motion which will send this proposed ammendment to the heritage committee.
5:54:13 PM: There will also be a public meeting before the changes to the Municipal Plan and Regulations.
5:57:00 PM: There is a proposal for Carew street from Stella Burry for 10 additional affordable housing units on their Carew Lodge.
5:58:42 PM: Apparently some of their funding for this proposal is time sensitive, Breen urges the city to move quickly on this matter.
6:00:37 PM: Tree Committe Report from O’Leary. 4 community groups are getting trees planted for Arbour day. West Heights Tenants association gets 2!
6:02:02 PM: Hickman is asking about a previous reccommendation to require one tree per lot in new developments.
6:03:13 PM: Duff will check on this and get back to him.
6:04:52 PM: A whole bunch of tenders approved. Two new street sweepers. Imagine if there were no litter, we wouldn’t need these!
6:04:52 PM: A whole bunch of tenders approved. Two new street sweepers. Imagine if there were no litter, we wouldn’t need these!
6:08:30 PM: Tilley is impressed with the recent economic development and advancement here in St. John’s.
6:14:36 PM: Tilley thinks it is unfair to have no notice for work on Water st/ Prescott st. City staff explained this is the contractors job.
6:15:47 PM: Breen says there is a public meeting this Thursday at 7pm re. a development for the bellavista.
6:17:10 PM: Breen says some residents of Ward 1 are complaining about a smell coming from the dump. He says they are looking into this.
6:18:50 PM: Breen says that in response to an article on CBC, libraries are a provincial responsibility, and we have to focus on our own jurisdiction
6:22:08 PM: Hann says that in relation to issues of off-leash dogs, the issue is a lack of staffing in parks, and animal control.
6:24:34 PM: There is a youth art show on here at City Council, come on down.
6:25:42 PM: Hickman reminds people that the covered garbage bylaw is now in effect. Cover your garbage or use containers, those damn gulls will be at it
6:27:08 PM: O’Leary says that if people see offenders of bylaws such as dogs or litter, to call 311, and take an active role in helping our city.
6:30:27 PM: O’Leary says there will be a study being done on lead levels in children’s blood living in pre-1970′s housing projects.
6:30:52 PM: Holy long meeting batman! Longest meeting in a while. That’s it for this one. Tweet you next week.



May 4th, 2010 at 1:18 am
Would you be able to start telling us which councillors didn’t attend the meetings? I know for tonights meeting Doc and Hanlon were in Houston but was Colbert anywhere to be seen?
May 4th, 2010 at 9:54 am
Hey Jordan,
That is probably a good idea, people should know who is, and is not at the council meetings.
Gerry Colbert was missing, along with O’Keefe and Hanlon.
I will start doing this in the future, thanks for the input, and keep reading and giving feedback.
May 4th, 2010 at 8:43 pm
Are we going to get any follow-up on the counciller’s pension scheme/O’leary dialogue?
May 5th, 2010 at 10:57 am
Hey Anon,
I hadn’t had anything planned for it, and don’t know that much about it. I was aware of the pension scheme, and how great of a cost it is to the city (I believe over $1 Million/year is paid out to former members of council). It did not sit well with me at the time I found out to know that councillors do not pay into their pension scheme, like every other city employee has to.
I don’t know the specifics of this, but Sheilagh O’Leary had brought this up herself in council weeks ago, and said she was going to look into it. Apparently after a conversation she had with city staff she was informed, and convinced, that it was cheaper for the city to not have councillors pay into a pension scheme.
I, for one, have no idea how this could be possible. Saying this, I have very limited knowledge of such things as benefit schemes.
I will send an email to Sheilagh O’Leary now asking for clarification on the matter, as she has investigated it, and I’m sure she will be able to provide the reasons she was given by city staff for public information.
I will ask her if she will respond here so that you, Anon, and everyone will get the answer to this question.
Thank you very much for reading the liveblog, and taking the extra step to ask questions to become informed about these municipal issues. They are often complicated issues, and usually the best person to ask are our elected officials. They are a competent bunch, and I’m sure would be more than happy to provide answers to your questions (or at least point you to where you could get the answer).
I would encourage anyone else who has questions about anything they read here to contact the appropriate member of council with any question they may have, and feel free to post the response here so that we may all also become informed.
May 8th, 2010 at 8:44 pm
Andrew:
I have followed the pension debate very closely.
Currently the city incurs costs of $116,945 per annum for former councillors’ pension. This pension is indexed so there is a potential increase each year.
From what I gather, St. John’s councillors are the only councillors in the country to receive a pension.
I have sent emails to councillors asking what ethical right do they have, to a non-contributing pension plan, but needless to say, no response.
There are three options as I see it.
a) No pension scheme
b) Join the staff’s pension scheme and contibute
c) In-lieu pension scheme.
The in-lieu scheme would see councillors paid an allowance in-lieu of pension. Currently the city contributes 7.5% to the staff’s pension scheme so using this figure based on the current councillors’ salary, the cost is approximately $23,000 per year.The other benefit of this scheme is there is no liability issue. Once a councillor leaves office, they receive no further pension payment! The current scheme has a liability of approximately $2.7 million.
So councillor O’Leary is not correct in saying the current scheme is the cheapest option. Yes, it will costs the city extra dollars to register a contributing plan for councillors but as I say, there are other options.
Councillors choose not to take one.
By the way, I’ve sent all this information to councillors and not had the figures disputed by any of them. Nor questioning the validity of my in-lieu proposal.
For further information check my blog…lionelwest.blogspot.com
May 10th, 2010 at 12:52 pm
Hey Lionel,
You are actually the one who first made me aware of this whole issue, when you brought it up in the pre-budget consultations back in December I believe. Apparently all of the submissions, such as yours were discussed during the process, but I would question to what degree they were really considered, especially one like yours.
I have yet to hear from Sheilagh O’Leary on this matter, but would be very interested as to how it could possibly be cheaper for someone not to pay into a pension.
It seems to me like you have made some very sensible recommendations to council Lionel, and I would like to see them be given much more serious consideration at the Finance Committee level. In a city which money is so tight, I would hate to think we could be saving money somewhere and not have that avenue explored.
May 11th, 2010 at 1:21 pm
Andrew,
Thanks for re-sending the link for this blog.
Yes, Lionel West has been a leader in this initiative, questioning the pension scheme for councillors for a long time. I applaud his questioning.
I asked in a public council meeting why councillors do not pay in, as opposed to the staff that do. This issue was raised previously before my time on council.
The present sentiment of some councillors, including Frank Galgay and myself, is that we would not object whatsoever to paying in to a pension plan. I would like to be clear, however…. I have no issue with Councillors receiving a pension for the work they provide, but I wanted to question why we cannot pay into it. I know the amount of time I clock on city business and that I feel the position of councillor in our city should be full time. But, it isn’t.
So, for me, it’s a part-time job whereby I am generally working full time hours. Also, a Councillor only receives pension benefits after two terms of service.
Mr. Robert Bishop, Director of Finance, has explained that in order to do so, we would have to register with a pension scheme and it would actually cost the city and its taxpayers more money that the present scheme as it exists. I also questioned RSP options as well but, this was not considered to be a cost efficient or viable measure either.
The Council did not want to pursue this any further as they felt they have been down this road several times before. I would like to suggest that if there are any further questions about this pension scheme or why Councillors cannot pay in, I would suggest you ask the Director himself.
I believe a really important question lies in accountability re: the councillors actual attendance at the myriad of attendance at committee meetings and council meetings itself. What you see on the Tele is just the tip of the iceberg… all week long there are ongoing committee meetings that require a huge amount of time and attention.
Day and night. We all know that some elected officials are absent for long stretches of time. This is something I feel needs to be questioned if we are discussing issues of inequality.
Thank you.
Sheilagh
Councillor O’Leary