In a town as small as St. John’s, does your reputation affect your chances at getting an application through council? If your name is Jeffrey Heale, you may be starting to think so. Heale has now had three applications rejected for his property at 271 Duckworth Street. The first two were for a martini bar, and the third was for a video sales and rental shop, with video arcade.
Heale has had his troubles with the law, which we will not go into here, but the question is whether or not his personal past is affecting council’s view on his applications, and ultimately their outcome.
On January 11th, the day after rejecting Mr. Heale’s second application, Ward 2 councillor Frank Galgay stated on the St. John’s Morning Show on CBC Radio One (mp3 link) that council’s decision had nothing to do with the applicant, and was based on “the principle of the application, regardless of who applies.” Galgay went on to state that back in November of 2009 development regulations were changed to make bars a discretionary use for the Downtown Business Improvement Area. This would allow council to look at each application on a case-by-case basis before approval would be given.
Council’s stated reasons for rejecting Mr. Heale’s applications ranged from worry about noise coming from the proposed martini bars to concern over the suitability of the location for an arcade. When moving to reject the arcade application, Ward 4 councillor Debbie Hanlon stated in chambers, “I’ve raised teenagers, and that’s the last place I would want them.”
What has raised an eyebrow for some was a recent decision by council to approve a bar for 331 Duckworth Street. Just 250 meters away from where Mr. Heale was twice rejected, Quattro Holdings Ltd. was approved for an application to operate a bar to accommodate the relocation of Magnum & Steins. This application prompted a letter to council from a citizen who said “favouritism is obviously alive and well at city hall,” noting the seeming inconsistency in council’s decisions.
The broader issue that these applications raise is the level of discretion we are comfortable with council exercising. To fairly apply rules, there has to be some level of objectivity. How possible that is, or even how desirable that is would be questionable. On January 10th, Debbie Hanlon went as far as to say “we do have a moral responsibility, that’s why we were elected.” Hanlon’s comments point to the inescapable fact that we have humans, not totally objective computers, running our council. For better, or for worse, when given discretion, humans tend to go with their gut on decisions, whether or not it’s fair.
What do you think? Leave a comment below.



March 7th, 2011 at 4:55 pm
I can’t comment as it will affect my ability to exist in this small town – to note, this town is far worse than other small towns: it’s protectionist, nepotistic St. John’s after all. it stinks here.
March 7th, 2011 at 5:08 pm
To Debbie Hanlon: The LAST place you’d want your teenagers in is an arcade downtown? REALLY?? The LAST??
Get real.
March 7th, 2011 at 6:02 pm
uggggggghhhhhh…
Do we really need another “St John’s is a smelly poo” troll thread here? please let’s not start this bullshit again.
March 7th, 2011 at 7:40 pm
It’s impossible to do anything in this city if you don’t have friends on council. It’s the main reason why this city is run in such an incompetent manner, qualifications just don’t matter to these clowns.
I also think that Debbie Hanlon will be voted out come election time. I don’t want to be making personal attacks, but when someone can’t properly handle their own finances why should they be trusted to spend the taxpayer’s money? And then she asks for a pay raise? Give me a break.
March 10th, 2011 at 4:16 pm
Shame how this town always oscillates between a desire for economic diversification and the same old soft headed Nehru-esq paternalistic bullshit. Insularity’s a bitch.