
Photo illustration by Elling Lien
It has been 12 long weeks, but Metrobus and its workers have finally reached a tentative agreement. Buses are expected back on the streets on Monday.
The Metrobus strike has polarized the city, and people coming at the issue from all different angles have been thinking out loud about public transportation. Now, at the end, it might be a good time to step back from the emotion-charged specifics of the strike and look at the bigger picture.
What do we expect from Metrobus? What do we expect from the city with regards to public transportation? What is reasonable to expect given the reality of life on the North-East Avalon?
In the 2011 budget, Merobus projected a total operating cost of about $16.5 million. At the time, they planned to make about $6 million from fares and advertising. The longer this strike goes on, the lower this number will be. For its part, Mount Pearl contributes $750,000 to have two routes through their city (who says Dennis and Randy can’t play nice?) The other $9.7 million has been allocated as a subsidy from the City of St. John’s.
So, the big questions are… Why is this so expensive? Who really rides the bus anyways? And what can be done about it?
Costs are massive for many reasons, including stuff like high gas prices, low ridership, and the massive area Metrobus is forced to cover. Over the last several decades, the trend of large-scale development on the North-East Avalon has been pretty much unmitigated urban sprawl. The simple formula for a successful bus system is high population density combined with disincentives to have a car. We have neither here.
Who rides the bus? Fewer and fewer people. Many of those who were once riders have migrated to communities surrounding St. John’s. They still commute into town, and were probably replaced by someone who could afford skyrocketing property values, and thus, probably have a car. The only people left riding the bus are the proportion of people who can still manage to find a somewhat affordable place to live, but have no other transportation option.
What can be done? We can encourage or require — yes, the city can do this — higher densities for new developments and redevelopments. Metrobus also needs to be improved if it is to lure drivers back onto the bus. Or maybe by the time gas hits $2/l. Either way, Metrobus needs to be a viable alternative to a car, and right now, most people don’t think it is.
While the cost of a public transportation system is high, it remains the most environmentally-friendly method of commuting short of walking or cycling. If we could convince people to ride the bus rather then drive themselves, we would see a wide array of benefits, including lower public works costs to maintain roads, smaller expense to the city for parking, less congested streets, and greater levels of public interaction. When the buses get back on the roads this Monday, if people really value having a public transportation service, we need to advocate for it, and above all use it. Otherwise, we may lose it. And not just for 12 weeks.



January 27th, 2011 at 3:15 pm
According to CBC’s Nadia Stewart, Metrobus riders will ride for free from February 1-15. http://goo.gl/2l8SO
January 27th, 2011 at 9:02 pm
so this strike cost the service 1.5 million in lost revenue? wow. the managers of mile one must be feeling quite smug right now.
January 28th, 2011 at 12:51 am
I appreciate the call for public dialogue on the serious need to reform public transit in this city, but I’m not so into the complaints about “sprawl” and any suggestions that we need social engineering from city hall to stop that supposed problem.
For one, it isn’t realistic. These developments wouldn’t be going up if people didn’t want to live in them, and the people who are buying (and building) these homes are taxpayers and voters, and there are likely even a few of them on council. I’m not sure what your plan is, but I can guarantee you that city hall wouldn’t dare try to force people to live in townhouses and apartment buildings when they obviously don’t want to. Council would all lose their jobs, except for maybe Shannie Duff and Frank Galgay.
Second, St. John’s doesn’t even really have a sprawl “problem”. Go to Toronto and take a look around, and I’m not talking about the old city of Toronto, I mean the entire GTA area. Then you can come back and tell me whether or not St. John’s has a real sprawl problem. That city, the entire city not just downtown, has an excellent transit system that puts ours to shame. And they manage to do it while dealing with sprawling suburbs and big box parks that are simply in a completely different league than what we have here.
It should also be mentioned that many of the people in this city who complain about our supposed sprawl problem are the first to go out and protest when a high-density condo tower is proposed to go up in downtown St. John’s. Make up your minds, folks. The city is growing whether you like it or not. In fact, Andrew, if I remember correctly from one of your city council blogs Shannie Duff even complained recently about an apartment building being built in the Torbay Road/McDonald drive area. That was absolute foolishness. The area is pretty much a model of what you’re proposing in this article (and what has been proposed in other articles in this paper); A mixed income, relatively high-density neighborhood with a mix of private homes, apartment buildings, condos, parks, schools, and businesses such as grocery stores and restaurants, all within walking distance. For Shannie Duff to even consider opposing it shows great hypocrisy and foolishness on her part.
Anyway, I’m sort of getting off topic here but my point is that while our transit system does need to be reformed it isn’t going to happen because of heavy-handed social engineering from city hall. It isn’t necessary, it isn’t realistic, and council wouldn’t dare try it. When it comes to fixing public transit we’re simply going to have to work with the city the way it is.
January 28th, 2011 at 8:44 am
HULK WANT HIGH DENSITY DEVELOPMENT
BUT HULK ALSO WANT TO LIKE BUILDINGS AROUND HULK
ALSO! HULK NOT ALWAYS AGREE SHANNIE DUFF
THIS ALL CONFUSE ANONYMOUS
January 28th, 2011 at 4:48 pm
It’s called civil engineering. Social engineering is the more the reason the sheeple all want their lawns and decks they will never ever use. also, you should try not thinking in absolutes all the time.
January 28th, 2011 at 5:27 pm
It’s probably more complex than this, but I like to keep it simple, and if you do the math, I think LOWERING the bus prices will see a larger ridership, thus generating more revenue overall. I take public transit when I travel. I don’t very often in St. John’s, where I live.
Many cities offer differing types of services when it comes to transit, but by far my favorite that I’ve seen is in the city of Austin, TX. They charge 0.50c for a ride. it will take you just about anywhere up into the wee hours of the morning. For an extra 0.50c (that’s a total of one dollar) you can ride the bus indefinitely for the next 24 hours. You get a little slip that you show to the bus driver with the time of purchase on it. So, for example, if you buy a bus ride at 5:23pm on January 29th, you will get to ride anywhere anytime until 5:23pm on January 30th.
That alone was incentive enough for me to ride the bus to my heart’s content.
We just need some creative ideas like that here.
To the sprawl guy who commented earlier, I’m sorry but although Toronto’s sprawl problem is far worse than our’s, St. John’s does indeed have a sprawl problem. Toronto’s transit is just that much more varied, bigger, and far reaching than St. John’s. It can take about an hour to get to Donovan’s by bus from downtown St. John’s. St. John’s is a geographically much smaller city than Toronto (and many other cities for that matter), but gone are the days when I can walk to Mark’s Work Warehouse (which used to be on Freshwater Road). Just because people live on the outskirts of town where all the box stores now go, doesn’t mean that the other few tens of thousands of people in the city who don’t live in those areas can walk to a large commercial area like that. Thus, we now have sprawl.
PS, if the bus system reduces it’s cost to 50c I will probably sell my car. Just sayin’
January 28th, 2011 at 6:07 pm
Honestly, I don’t really care what the buildings around me look like, or what they are preventing me from seeing. As long as they aren’t built sloppy (i’m looking at YOU Education Building), i’m all for ‘em.
January 28th, 2011 at 6:42 pm
PS, just did some more math:
If, for example, unlimited rides on the bus cost $1.00 for a 24 hour pass, that’s just $365 a year for unlimited rides across St. John’s and Mount Pearl – compare that to the $2500 I paid for my 9-year old used Toyota plus gas is a pain in the you know what (and that new gas tank I had to put on, the new stabilizer link, the new tailpipe, the new wiper blades, all the oil it consumes, the air filter, and other such expenses I’m missing… oh winter tires!) or compare it to the cost of a new car (plus interest), $365 to get you anywhere whenever you want for a year is good.
And say, for example, 25,000 people are enticed to take in an offer from transit of this type (and ridership could potentially be more than this), at $365 a person, that’s $9,125,000 in gross revenue.
Expand service to the airport and charge a modest $3.00 for arrivals to downtown (compared to the $22.50 flat rate from the cab company for a ten minute drive) and there’s even more revenue from tourism dollars right into Metrobus.
I think this is something that should be seriously considered
January 29th, 2011 at 9:19 pm
You’re wrong. What the writer of this article is suggesting is that council should bring in regulations that would essentially force people to live in the types of neighborhoods that he thinks they should be living in, and not the ones that they actually want to be living in. Like I said, if people wanted to be living in high-density neighborhoods that is exactly what the developers would be building. And when I wrote that response I was also thinking about another article I read in the Scope a little while back that was about a similar topic. It was basically arguing that council should legislate developers to build up high-density neighborhoods designed in such a way that would, according to the writer, influence people to live communally rather than live the supposed individualistic lifestyle that people supposedly have in the suburbs. This is definitely social engineering and it’s something that I disagree with on many levels.
The biggest problem with our transit system is that Metrobus is incompetent and city council doesn’t care, which was more evident than ever during this strike. The second biggest problem is that our roads simply aren’t properly designed for a mass transit system. We don’t need less suburban development to have a good transit system, we need better planning put into the roads that connect those suburbs so that the buses can run more smoothly. The reason why a huge sprawling city like Toronto can have such good public transit is because they have an excellent network of big east-west-north-south thoroughfares, which is obviously something that we don’t have.
January 30th, 2011 at 11:44 am
Hey everyone,
Thanks for the comments, and your perspectives.
As far as your Anonymous’ comments, I think that the distinction Hardy made between civil engineering and what you called social engineering is an important one. I would probably even simply call it city planning, which is something that happens all the time. It’s why you can’t build houses on institutional land, or put a business in the middle of a subdivision. Zoning laws, and building regulations are an important part of the development of any city.
As you mention, planning is how a city like Toronto has more accessible suburbs, which facilitates a good public transportation system. That and 5 million extra people to potentially use it.
I also do not agree with you when you stated:
“What the writer of this article is suggesting is that council should bring in regulations that would essentially force people to live in the types of neighborhoods that he thinks they should be living in, and not the ones that they actually want to be living in.”
I do not think that council could force people to live somewhere even if they wanted to, and would not try and impose my own will on anyone else, I was simply making a suggestion from a city-planning perspective as to how they could make public transportation more efficient.
I think that Dan Ficken’s example from Texas, and how to apply that here is St. John’s is an excellent one. There are probably many people in the middle right now who have been forced to buy a car because Metrobus was not able to meet their transportation needs, but if improved, could save them a lot of money, and convince them to sell their car, and get on the bus.
Keep all of the excellent comments coming.
January 30th, 2011 at 2:32 pm
I can’t wait to pay $2.50 for a 45 minutes tour of Mt. Pearl! What a deal!
January 30th, 2011 at 6:24 pm
Looking forward to being almost driven off the road tomorrow. Welcome back!
January 31st, 2011 at 1:57 pm
I really don’t have an easy solution to suggest for this problem, but I feel like a lot of the talk about what the problem is has been a little overly-optimistic, although I do think it largely relates to population. I really don’t think there are many people “in the middle”, i.e. people who have the option of driving a car but, given the right incentive, would take the bus instead. I honestly think that almost all of the people in St. John’s who would genuinely consider taking the bus probably already are.
Most people here outside of downtown simply won’t be willing to wait outside for the bus, let alone walk to the bus stop in the first place. Many of those who live outside of downtown probably only walk for exercise purposes rather than walking as a mode of transportation. I also think that the time spent on the bus is a turn-off. If you can get in your car and be somewhere in 10 mins, or walk to a bus stop, wait for the bus to come, and then spend much longer than 10 minutes taking the ride, the sad reality is that very people would actually leave the car and take the bus instead.
While it would seem to make sense considering that society is increasingly pushing health and environmental issues, I think that for most workaday types, the small amount of free time they have, and therefore the perceived need to rush around trumps the benefits of taking the bus.
Sorry to be a bummer, just my take.
February 3rd, 2011 at 6:48 am
I think something to be considered by both Metrobus and post-secondary institutes is a “UPass”. It’s simply a mandatory tuition fee of around $50-$60 dollars that gives students unlimited access to the transit system. It has plenty of benefits. It generates a whole lot of revenue for Metrobus, decreases the price for those folks that already purchase a semester pass, gives the incentive to city drivers to leave their vehicles at home and use their shiny new UPass, etc. It could even have benefits for those who live in areas without bus access by potentially decreasing traffic around the school and increasing parking.
If it hasn’t been considered before I think now is the time to look in to it and if it has, perhaps now is the time to review the decision.
February 3rd, 2011 at 9:40 pm
Heather this is something that I’m totally against. I go to MUN, I own a car, and I found a spot to live that is close enough to campus for me to walk to school within minutes. I don’t need or want a bus pass. I do not want to pay even more money to subsidize the transportation costs of others when I’m already paying plenty for my own transportation. I certainly don’t want to be paying extra tuition fees that will be going to a third-party company that has proven itself time and time again to be completely unreliable. If MUN ever proposed something like this I’m sure that there are others like me who would fight it tooth and nail.
February 4th, 2011 at 12:50 am
Heather, the UPass idea is an excellent one, and as you say, would be a huge source of revenue for Metrobus.
I know they do this in Halifax, and have heard it works extremely well (keeping in mind Halifax’s transit system puts Metrobus to shame).
Given the high number of students who already use the bus, and the deal the university (or students unions) could probably get if they were negotiating on behalf of 15,000 students, I think it would be something to look into.
JB, as far as your comments, you may be right. It is impossible to tell how many people are “in the middle” as I said, and I will give you that I am an eternal optimist. The main things I base my position on is the number of riders Metrobus has lost over the last 10 years. If you rode the bus a few years ago, there is probably a decent chance of luring you back, if it:
a)Made more sense financially
and/or b)Didn’t take so GD long to get around.
One of these things would have to change to get any of these people back on the bus.
Keep the excellent comments coming, and I suggest anyone who has ideas on public transit to contact their members of council (http://www.stjohns.ca/cityhall/council.jsp)