
Left: CBS 2012. Right: CBS 2022? (actually, 'The American Dream' by Roma Flowers, and the skyline of Denver.
Considering the rapid growth CBS has been experiencing over the past few years, it should come as no surprise that it is now Newfoundland’s second largest community. There are new roads all along the main highway, each with brand new developments of single family homes. All sorts of amenities are within close reach, and a new big box “Smart Centre” in the area provides even less reason to visit St. John’s.
Debate has raged over the idea of amalgamation for a while, with opponents fearing a bill for services they might not get, and proponents blaming the so-called bedroom communities for the poor conditions of St. John’s roads. But now with CBS population passing the mark for city status, the debate is shifting towards a new question: Is CBS ready to be a city?
CBS lacks most of the traditional elements that people associate with cities. At first glance, it doesn’t seem to have institutional and government edifices, monuments, economic centres, cultural districts, transit systems, notable architecture, entertainment districts with night clubs, theatres, restaurants and hotels.
But maybe CBS isn’t a traditional city. Maybe it’s on its way to becoming an ‘edge city’. In North America, a surprising thing occurred in urban areas in the late 20th century. Suburbs were originally intended to be serene places to live away from the busy urban core of a city, with residents expected to commute to the city centre for work, shopping and entertainment. What happened was that people started moving all those elements closer to the place they live—to the suburbs. Hence, the ‘edge city’ was born. It’s not just a suburb anymore, it has some mid-rise office buildings, maybe a small library, a few schools, a shopping centre or a big box centre. Much like what is happening in CBS—albeit on a larger scale.
Author and futurist Joel Garreau coined the term in his 1991 book titled Edge City. He defines it as having a large geographic area, on the edge of a traditional city, close to a highway or airport, built to the scale of the car. They have mid-rise office buildings, and low-density single family homes. In the long term, edge cities face problems that limit their growth, and these have to do with the fact that they are designed exclusively for car-user lifestyles. Land along primary arterial highways can’t be easily adapted to divide into more lots, and the hierarchical road networks are not amenable to public transit. Essentially, it’s a pedestrian nightmare. It may not sound like a place you would want to spend your time now, but it has been suggested that all cities are chaotic in their early formative years. Garreau is optimistic, and projects a future where abandoned big boxes are akin to the hip converted industrial loft spaces, and sprawling parking lots are community gardens.
For a long time, the ‘city’ has existed in conflict with its suburban counterpart, but now it seems like the suburb-city is starting to be recognized as a phenomenon of its own, without being forced into the mold of the traditional, historic city. I am not so optimistic as Garreau about everthing working itself out on its own. I think CBS has a lot of possible futures and some are better than others. The fact that we can learn from other cities’ experiences with edge cities means that we could have a little more agency in determining that future.
Mon, Feb 27, 2012

The St. John’s city council liveblog: your weekly flood of council tweets since 2009.
Andrew Harvey here to tweet you the comings and goings of your muncipal government from the bunker on New Gower.
Tom Hann is the first councillor out to chambers, chomping at the bit to solve the city’s problems.
There is some sort of schmoozing going on in the back with council and a bunch of people. They have yet to share the hors dervrs!
Council appears to be discussing strategy for the CBC pancake breakfast trivia challenge tommorrow.
@DebbieHanlon1 is hard at work on the iPad before the meeting begins. Good to see!
Here comes O’Keefe and the meeting has begun. Looks to be several delegations, now well fed from the back room.
It is the Kinsmen and Kinettes week. The service organization has been on the go since 1920.
Colbert has snuck in a few minutes late and that makes for a full deck of council.
Today is heritage day. The day is to celebrate, recognize, and protect our heritage.
They are presenting the winner of the heritage day poster contest, Katie Walsh (gr 6) from Harbour Grace!
O’Keefe is now presenting awards to commercial and residential property owners who have excelled at protecting heritage properties.
O’Keefe: “We have to ensure that the development happens in a way that preserves our heritage… As much as it can”.
The first award goes to 32 Lemarchant Rd which has recently been revamped and they have improved 75% energy efficiency.
The next winner is 78 Water st, who have done a real number on the building, keeping many original features, including mouldings, etc.
This building is home to @Raymonds_Ca and Killick capital.
Jeremy (chef at Raymonds) “It’s an honour to get to go to work there everyday… It’s beautiful”.
The next winner is 108 Water St. and Republic properties. This is their new office in what is becoming the “re-vamped” Water St East.
The next is 110 Water st (former turner’s tavern). Next door to the previous winners.
The winners are two former students of O’Keefe! He must have taught them something.
They are approving a proposal for 38 Cairo St, to construct 2 additional infill units to make 4 units total on the property.
They are deferring a proposal for 5 Carpasian Rd for Pony pilates. City staff wants more time to review traffic concerns brought up.
Duff is discussing a public meeting held on new drive-thru regulations. Citizens are mainly concerned about the buffer and # of spots.
People are concerned that a 5m buffer is not sufficient and a min of 12 ‘stacking spots’ is not enough.
These concerns raised by citizens will be brought back and looked at by city staff.
Tilley: “What’s good for a residential area is good for a commercial area” around drive-thru’s next to residential properties.
O’Keefe: “1935, that’s you councillor Tilley” on the NextUp program (for people 19-35).
Congrats to The Scope’s own Taryn Sheppard who is the first NextUp committee member for the Heritage Advisiory Committee!
Colbert says that he thinks it is wonderful when groups come in with not only problems, but solutions. Residents of Hazelwood Cr did this.
Hazelwood Cr residents brought concerns to the Police and Traffic committee and some proposed solutions.
As a part of traffic calming work is to be done on Old Topsail Rd The budget for this is $400k, $100k over the whole traffic calming budget
Breen says that if they had of know the work for Old Topsail Rd was going to cost $400k, they would have budgeted for it.
Breen: “Although it’s necessary, it’s expensive” on work happening under the traffic calming policy.
Traffic calming work includes speed bumps, signage, and the like. Galgay says area residents are “tickeled pink”.
Hann: “Call the cops, that’s a good idea” on enforcement issues around snowmobiles being used in the city.
Hickman: “It’s crazy” on changing the speed limit to 50km/hr (from 60 in one snall section) on Torbay rd beyond Stavanger dr.
Hickman: “I think it’s noteworthy that there was only one tender on these things” (3 tenders for metrobus) over $460k for the 3.
Duff is discussing a new initative to put a face to people who are homeless. The posters will be launched tomorrow concurrent with a video.
O’Leary was the photographer for this project and encourages people to check out the video on the city’s website.
Hanlon says she and O’Leary will be missing next week as they will be in Toronto for an economic summit.
Hann says that the city is going forward with buying cameras to catch illegal dumpers.
O’Leary: “I am a firm believer in the concept of round-abouts” she wants us to keep these in mind when planning traffic calming.
That’s all folks, tweet ya next week.
Tue, Feb 14, 2012

The St. John’s city council liveblog: mixing old-style politics with new-fangled technology since 2009.
Andrew Harvey, The Scope’s resident council hawk, here to keep you informed of all the goings on from the bunker on New Gower.
Galgay has won the race out to chambers as council begins to assemble.
Duff is in the chair as O’Keefe is away. Collins is also absent and the rest of council is here.
Paul Mackey is givin an update on the storm yesterday. The official mark was 65mm of rain! Nearly a record for rain in Feb.
Paul Mackey says there were particular problems in the Goulds/Kilbride. Speaking of which Wally Collins has arrived.
The city recieved 240 complaints related to flooding over the weekend! Holy snikies!!
Hann wants to know if the flooding was related to aging infastructure. “I guess it comes to light when we have an incident like this.”
Paul Mackey says that this is something they will look into. He does say that have had less problems where they have done upgrades recently.
If anyone has had trouble with flooding and needs a clean-up kit from the red cross, call @311StJohns
Collins: “I had 6 inches of water in me own basement” on flooding problems in Ward 5.
Hanlon says that residents of Dublin Rd have had ongoing issues. They have approved a capital works project for this area apparently.
Walt Mills (Engineering) says that they hope to go to tender for the sewer upgrades on Dublin Rd by mid-March.
Council is moving to approve a discretionary use for 83 Thorburn Rd to build a medical clinic, pharmacy and a RNC office. Approved.
The development committee is approving the demolishnent and replacement of a house at 24-26 King’s Hill Rd, in the watershed area.
The Heritage Advisory Committee is reccommending preliminary approval for the development at 61 Hamilton Ave. This will be the lettuce farm
The Heritage Advisory Committee “agrees in principle” with the preliminary design for the redevelopment of 345 Duckworth St -NLtel building
Hickman: “It’s not just glass and concrete… I think developers are starting to get it”
Hann and O’Leary agree that there is a change in the type of proposals which are coming in these days.
O’Leary notes that the Memorial Garden for the bannerman park redevelopment has been approved and will go ahead.
There is a tender approved for $4 million for “bulk carbon dioxide.” To be used for water treatment. Who knew this was so expensive?
Tilley is discussing the award of contract for a demand and needs analysis and business plan for a multi-purpose arts facility.
Sheppard Case has been awarded this contract for $100k. The city is cost-sharing this and is paying 1/3.
Duff says that the need for production space for the arts has been the #1 need identified in the last 3 symposiums on the arts.
O’Leary says that there is now a group formed to petition for a grocery store in Churchill Sq. “I think that’s really positive”.
Yesterday the Outer battery neghibourhood association met with a steering committee for Ft. Amherst to plan for the narrows.
Hann: “Sometimes we do something right” on the praise the city got from The Muse for the NextUp program.
Hanlon says they recieved over 80 applications for the NextUp program! This is for youth 19-35 to have a spot on an advisiory committee.
Hanlon: “It’s good to see the power of the people” about the Churchill Sq Save Easy issue.
Collins is also going to meet with Ryan @ClearyNDP about the narrows planning issue and Ft. Amherst.
That’s all folks. Tweet ya next week. Andrew Harvey out.
Wed, Feb 1, 2012

Planetary ONE's proposed Super Dock for Brooklyn, New York (image: Planetary ONE)
Taryn Shppard looks into how a proposed mixed townhouse, commercial, and lettuce farm building downtown fits into a growing global trend of grown architecture.
Another new development has been proposed for downtown near Hamilton Ave. The old Swift Meats industrial building on Brine Street will be converted into ten townhouses and commercial space. The Lettuce Farm, which has been growing hydroponic lettuce and herbs in this building for the past 12 years will continue to operate there, with the living spaces on the upper levels. The development group have described the building’s style as ‘industrial contemporary’.
There will also be a new laundromat in the building which will exist in a symbiotic relationship with the Lettuce Farm, which will use excess heat and CO2 from the laundromat to help grow their produce.
The combination of living space, agricultural/industrial, and commercial activity in one building is new for downtown. It takes ‘mixed use’ to a whole other level: the multiple uses do not simply co-exist, they are dependent on one another.
This project reminds me of the work of Terreform ONE (the ONE stands for Open Network Ecology), who work in a similar theme but much larger and much more radical. This architecture studio is led by Mitchell Joachim, and their work combines biological systems into structures that people can live in. Known for their ‘bio-design’, Terreform ONE is all about developing cyclical resource networks, where waste products of one function support another, much like the laundry-lettuce system. The research-based eco-architecture group often shock people with their organic, fleshy design aesthetic, particularly the Fab Tree Hab, a house grown out of vegetation, and the‘meat house’, made of living tissue grown in a lab.
Joachim is also a partner in the urban design group Planetary ONE. Their Super Dock proposal for an industrial waterfront in Brooklyn dramatically re-imagines ‘mixed use’ architecture. The project re-envisions an under-used area as a self-sustaining working waterfront where green industries use experimental technologies in service to the environment and the economy; a place where nature and industry co-exist and thrive together.
The dock is intentionally landscaped to mitigate climatic issues, and prioritizes pedestrian movement. It has five distinct docks. One is for ship building with massive scale 3-D rapid prototyping, another is for research in restorative ecology, another is for manufacturing solar panels, and another houses phytoremediation (plants that clean polluted water) barges for sewer overflow. The structural forms of the dock are like rising and falling waves over the site.
The Super Dock proposal responds to a growing sense of urgency for architects and planners to merge industry, ecology, and human activity in mutually beneficial ways. This growing movement is backed by emerging contemporary architecture theory focused on design that is about what a building can contribute to the needs of a community, industry, or ecology, beyond just being a pleasing form.
The new design of the Lettuce Farm building is informed by the existing building’s industrial history, while, at the same time, adhering to the new architectural movement towards buildings serving multiple, inter-dependant functions. It might not be quite as radical as growing houses out of the lettuce, but Compared to a lot of other new developments in the city, the Lettuce Farm building is much more progressive in its architecture.

Terreform ONE's Fab Tree Hab (left)--a house grown of grafted trees--would take 7-8 years to grow according to Joachim. The Meat House (right) is made of meat grown in a lab and comes complete with sphincters for windows and doors. (Images: Terreform ONE)
Tue, Jan 24, 2012

The St. John’s city council liveblog: your voyeuristic eye on council since 2009.
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the down and dirty details of city council, LIVE from the gallery of council chambers.
Here they come, Frank Galgay is the eager beaver again this week and is the first councillor out.
Here comes O’Keefe and the meeting has begun. All are here but Duff.
The Parks & Rec committee are requesting $200k for the design and concept plan for the redevelopment of Wedgewood park.
Breen is discussing a public meeting on the rezoning of 61 Hamilton Ave to allow a hydroponic operation and a laundromat.
Galgay says there was no objection and great support at the meeting for the public hearing.
Duff is here now, a bit late, tisk, tisk.
Breen is discussing a public hearing held for the proposed rezoning of 25 Rhodora St.
This would allow a 4-story, 28 unit condo and a 2-story office building.
Breen says there was some concern over traffic, a lack of green space and the height of the building.
Hanlon says that there was a rumour that land would be expropriated, but that is not true, it is only a rezoning.
This is close to the airport and the airport authority would have to approve the height of the building. Don’t want no planes hitting it.
Hanlon says that St. John’s has many neghibourhoods and Airport heights is a good one.
The development committee is reccommending approval of an extension for a home in the watershed area but rejecting a proposal for a farm.
The farm being rejected because Agricultural use is not allowed in the watershed area. The proposal was for a sod farm/greenhouse/hobby farm
There is also a proposal to sub-divide the property at 219 Logy Bay rd. Some of the neghibours are against it and are concerned over traffic
Hanlon has declared a conflict of interest on one matter in the Planning & housing committee. “Oh, I could tell you things.”
A land use assessment is being completed for 83&90 Duckworth st, the final step before a public hearing.
There is an application for Sugarloaf Rd to put in a 65-unit residential subdivision. Committed reccommends rejection. Too close to the dump
Breen wants to see the city sit down with the proponents for Sugarloaf rd and see if there is another use they can find for the land.
The committee is also rejecting a industrial park which is mostly in CBS but a bit is in St. John’s. It is contrary to the municipal plan.
They are discussing the rezoning/building of a new west end high school.
The city wants to try and work with eastern school district to “incorporate other needs of the community” says Colbert.
They are discussing the mayor’s symposium which will be the kick-off for the review of the municipal plan.
This symposium is scheduled for Feb. 25th from 9am-12:30pm. It will be facilitated by the rural secritariat.
Only 100 people can attend this event and it will be on a first-come, first-serve basis. Register soon people!
Duff: “This is an exciting time for our city” on the mayor’s symposium and the municipal plan review.
There is some confusion over when registration for this will begin. Email early and email often I’d say.
Hann says that they are leaving the door open for another symposium if the demand is as great as they hope/expect.
Tilley: “This [the municipal plan review] will be the most significant thing this council does”.
The Public Works committee is investigating a zero net increase run-off policy for new developments.
They will be undertaking an industry consultation process and see what they say. O’leary also wants to see NEACAPP included in this process.
Hickman is making a notice of motion that he will move to enact a whistleblower protection by-law.
The city is approving $522k for approval to build a new West End Fire Station at 215 Blackmarsh rd.
Hanlon has been discussing integrating students into the mayor’s advisiory committee on youth.
Hanlon is encouraging people to apply to the NextUp program, to have a youth (19-35) rep on 4 advisiory committies.
Tilley is delighted to see the Lubya Orlov go. O’Keefe says the port authority took a hit on it and lost more then $100k on it.
There are 3 public hearings this week, the big hotel on Springdale st, big condo on Job st and the Star of the Sea redevelopment.
O’Leary is again talking about the snow removal on Belvedere laneway, at the end of Margret’s place. The city has been plowing it in.
The concern is that Belvedere laneway is emergency access for Margret’s place and fire trucks need to get down there.
That’s all folks, tweet ya next week, Andrew Harvey out.
Thu, Jan 19, 2012

The St. John’s city council liveblog: council served fresh to your smartphone every Monday since 2009.
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the play-by-play of council from the bunker on New Gower.
Council is beginning to assemble Galgay is the first one out.
“His worship, the mayor” is here and the meeting has begun… Except it appears we are waiting while CBC does a live spot.
It seems like they are talking about Rob Ford losing weight and O’Keefe walking…
It seems a bit rediculous that we are all sitting here waiting for them to talk about this when the meeting is supposed to be taking place.
They just announced O’Keefe again and the meeting seems to actually be starting now.
There is a delegation here for city staff, Brian and Lesely, reminding people to be safe on the ice this winter.
They are also both national award winners with the lifesaving society. NL sees more people die per capita then any other by drowning.
They are moving to ammend the zoning regulations to allow “heritage use” as a discretionary use in the Commercial/Office zone.
This ammendment will allow St. Michael’s convent at 53 Margret’s Place to be converted into 6 condominiums.
Duff says the building has been falling apart for years and she is happy to see something going in there to “save the building”.
They are deferring a proposal for 110 Howlett’s Line to rezone to allow for the subdivision of the property to build another house.
Hann says that they are moving forward with drivethru regulations. There will be a public meeting to get feedback on what they have drafted
The heritage advisiory committee is recommending approval for the initial design concept for the proposal for the end of Duckworth (83&90).
This is the former Crazy Horse and east end fire station. The committee “appreciates the care taken by the developer” in the concept design.
The developer says they are not putting in a pedway. This proposal is for a hotel/condo on one side and retail/parking on the other.
The city will be cost-sharing upgrades to the Goulds Arena. The cost to the city will be $200k and the Lions Club is also chipping in $.
Colbert says that it is important for the city to maintain both sites as public land to figure out what the best way to use the land is.
Hanlon has made a notice of motion to review the terms of reference for council. “Going down that road again” says O’Keefe.
There is an addiion to the agenda that they are discussing. It is about development above the 170m contour line.
They made several ammendments back in May to start the ball rolling. Some of this land is in or bordering the Southlands development.
These ammendments still require an ammendment to the regional plan (provincial) and a public hearing.
“This information was just laid on our desk” O’Leary says they have not had time to read it. She wants to defer but she can’t get a seconder
Kinda scary that council will make votes regarding huge swaths of land without having read material they are voting on.
In their defense, Cliff Johnson (dir. of planning) explained it and it seems to be a formality about a previous motion.
Tilley wants to see a public awareness campaign to encourage people, particuarly students, to face traffic when they are walking on the road
Galgay is discussing an issue from a constituient who has had 3 floods in the last couple years at 70 Merrymeeting Rd.
This is in the same area as the recent water main break at Mayor Ave/Merrymeeting rd. She is worried that she will lose her insurance.
Paul Mackey says there is 30-40 ft of old pipe left at Merrymeeting rd they are going to replace before they repave.
Hann thinks the city should become more proactive about trying to catch people who are illegally dumping trash.
Hann says CBS has cameras they rotate in common dumping areas. He wants to buy a few of our own.
Collins has also been vocal about these illegal dumping sites.
Collins: “I’m after getting thirty or forty [cars] out of the Goulds.”
It seems like there is an opportunity for the HRG Mews Ctr to move to the site of the Metrobus depot when they move out.
O’Keefe: “We can no longer provide the level of service people expect… If we have to rely on property tax”.
O’Keefe has been meeting with other mayors and the province to encourage a change in municipal/provincial financial relationship.
O’Keefe brings up the point that the province is charging the city HST on the 26 affordable housing units they are currently building.
O’Keefe says that he has a meeting with Kathy Dunderdale on Feb. 20th. He’s going to try and get this sorted for the next provincial budget.
That’s all folks. Andrew Harvey out, tweet ya next week.
Wed, Jan 11, 2012

The St. John’s city council liveblog: Council in easy-to-swallow 140 character bites.
Andrew Harvey here with the call of all the municipal shennanigans from the bunker on New Gower.
Bruce Tilley is the first councillor out for what looks like will be a quick meeting, thin agenda.
Here is O’Keefe and the meeting has begun.
There is a delegtion here from St. John’s clean and beautiful. The Newfoundland Chocolate Company has won the golden broom award!
The golden broom award is to recognize a business for excellence in keeping their store clean… and beautiful I suppose.
Owner Brent Smith brought chocolates for council “to sweeten up your meeting”.
O’Keefe says the rest of council can have the chocolates “if the’re good”.
Bell Mobility has asked to out up a 30m tower at 266 Torbay Rd. This would be at the back of the property by the Grand Concourse Trail.
The city currently owns the land and can decide to lease the property to Bell.
Cliff Johnson says that ultimately this type of tower is regulated by Industry Canada. There was one letter of concern over health.
Breen has moved to reject this application and doesn’t think this sort of thing should be in residential/commercial areas.
Hann agrees with Breen and is worried about what might be in the “fall zone” of a 30m/100ft tower.
Hickman wants to know why they need a tower now and wants to see where the companies have towers to help work with them to plan coverage.
O’Leary also has health concerns and says we should err on the side of caution when the impact of such things is unknown.
Application unamiously rejected, sorry Bell users in the area.
The Nomenclature Committee (yes, such a thing exists) is naming a cul-de-sac off Kenmount Road Titania Place.
There are 5 public meetings for rezonings in Jan. “It looks like we’re really going to be earning our salary this month” says Galgay.
Duff is talking about the “great pity” of the loss of the Save Easy in Churchill Square. “It’s not good for the neghibourhood”.
Duff: “They were quite willing to come talk to us when they wanted something from us, they should come talk to us when we want something”.
Duff is referring to Loblaws when they wanted to put their store down in the Memorial Stadium.
O’Leary is congratulating city poet-laureat Tom Dawe on a recent award he won for a book of poetry.
Good for Tom Dawe but I do wonder what he is doing in his capacity as poet-laureate.
O’Leary is bringing up some issues with the fire access to Margret’s Place. Staff assures her that the developer must keep this clear.
Tilley wants O’Keefe to write a letter to the coach of the Ice Caps to congratulate them on their success and what they bring to the city.
Hanlon is encouraging people to apply to become a citizen member of one of the city’s committees. Apply at stjohns.ca
Hanlon also encourages people to contact Loblaws to encourage then to keep te Save Easy in Churchill Sq.
That’s all folks, have a wonderful night and I’ll tweet ya next week. Andrew Harvey out.
Tue, Jan 10, 2012

The St. John’s City Council liveblog: Your council gossip on Twitter since 2009.
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call for the first liveblog of 2012! Merry new year to you all!
Here’s O’Keefe and the meeting has begun. He welcomes everyone back after the holiday break.
They are moving to approve a discretionary use application for 75 Della Dr to allow a home business making “lunch box items”.
Hann is movIng to change the Taxi By-law to increase rates by 15%. These rates have not been increased since 1997.
As a former cab driver let me tell you that this increase is needed. The price of gas’ll kill ya.
O’Leary wants to know if there is some form of ongoing regulation which could ensure price increases don’t become expodential.
Hann: “I suggest that… It is not our place do do so [further regulate]“. Hann doesn’t want to iterfere with the free market.
The development committee is reccommending a 6m building line for a proposed subdivision at Topsail rd/Shaw st. This is to keep more trees
They are discussing the revised sidewalk clearing program. They are going from 2 routes of 50km to 4 routes of 33km.
There will be a public information session on sidewalk clearing next week (no time or date given).
Breen is discussing the 3-1-1 service and how they will be improving services in the next year.
They are also moving a media policy which controls how and who talks to media from the city.
They also reviewed requests for conference sponsorships for the year. The city will contribute $2,500 for the 2012 Festival of Architecture.
Hann is discussing the Planning committee report on new drive-thru standards. These regulations have been coming for a while.
Hann also says that the Municipal Plan review will kick off for the public will be Feb 25th with a Mayor’s symposium.
Hann encourages all members of the public to become involved in this process and is excited about the use of technology in the process.
The city has tendered $45k for a study on the impacts of major developments on the city if St. John’s. Really major, think Hebron, Long Hbr.
Wally Collins wants them to hold off on issuing a tender to rent offices for the Recreation Dept.
This tender would be for 7 years of rental and Collins says the Metrobus Depot will be available in 3 months.
Colbert wants them to see if they can change the tender to be for 1 year at a time, not 7 years at a time.
They have deferred this tender for now to get staff to see what their options are.
They are ‘confirming’ something which apparently has already been voted on in a special meeting, an extension for an option for sale.
The option for sale is for the East End Fire Station. O’Leary says she was opposed to the first option and that it is an issue of equity.
O’Keefe points out that there is no legal obligation for the city to publicly sell this land. “We sell land in this city all the time”.
Galgay says he was also against the sale of this public land because he thinks it will “come back to bite us” with other developers.
Tilley thinks that O’Leary is confusing the issue and points out that this is simply an option and is not a sale of the land.
Collins says that he doesn’t often change his mind, but he has now “I’m comfortable voting for this now”. He says referring to the benefits
Hann: “Here we have an opportunity” referring to the fact that this sale is tied to a development across the way at the old Crazy Horse.
This option for sale is contingent on successful rezoning of the land for the purpose of parking for a condo going on the Crazy Horse site.
Hickman says this is simply for extending an option which was already given and is just a curtosey.
Breen: “It’s a way to get an area developed which is difficult to develop” talking about how the building is needed for parking.
Galgay is asking for clarification on how this was handled and what exactly they voting on. They are re-affirming a previous vote.
Vote passed 6-3 (Hanlon is the only one not there and O’Keefe only votes as a tie-breaker).
O’Keefe has stepped out “to talk to the CBC” this must be live. Duff is now in the chair.
Hanlon and O’Leary will be going to a conference called “Cultivating and Sustaining Your Creative Economy Summit” in Toronto.
Tilley says the # of people on EI went down by 640 from 2011 to 2012. He says this is a good sign of our strong economy.
Tilley also encourages people to go down to the business resource centre in the cities Tourism office on Water street.
The city is waiving the permit fees for renovations for St. Teresa’s Parish Hall. This is often done for non-profits.
O’Leary is discussing an idea to send around some information to help educate pedestrians on winter safety.
They are also moving a media policy which controls how and who talks to media from the city.
They also reviewed requests for conference sponsorships for the year. The city will contribute $2,500 for the 2012 Festival of Architecture.
There will be a public information session on sidewalk clearing next week (no time or date given).
They are discussing the revised sidewalk clearing program. They are going from 2 routes of 50km to 4 routes of 33km.
Breen is discussing the 3-1-1 service and how they will be improving services in the next year.
Sorry, a couple tweets there from previous in the meeting which got held up in the Twitter-verse for a bit there.
Hickman is asking a few questions about clearing some bus stops out which was mentioned earlier.
Colbert is asking questions about when will council be moving to tablet computers. Duff says they are on order.
Breen wants to see if they can improve communication around changes to garbage pick up over the holidays.
O’Keefe is back in the seat for the end of the meeting. Tilley is thanking staff for the great job on New Years with the fireworks.
O’Keefe wants to congratulate NTV and to jeer ET Canada for their coverage of New Years.
O’Keefe says that the Canada Post community drop-off boxes is not about snow clearing but about trying to remove door-to-door service.
Mon, Jan 9, 2012

Nice job, St. John’s! The 2012 budget proves that if you are vocal enough and persistent enough, you might just get what you want. After years of protests, lobbying, and wet feet, the city of St. John’s doubled the sidewalk clearing budget for 2012. On December 12th a large group of people from the Essential Transit Association were in the gallery of council chambers to see the vote on the budget which added $250,000 for crews and $450,000 for three new sidewalk plows.
Although the budget for sidewalk clearing has been doubled, this does not necessarily mean that there will be twice as many sidewalks cleared. Last year around 200 kilometres of sidewalk were cleared (not 100 as I said last month) but city staff tell me that although we will see an increase in the amount of sidewalks cleared, and we’ll also see an improvement in the speed and frequency of clearing for the sidewalks which are done. What makes it hard to peg down is that no one knows when and how much snow is going to fall this year.
Apart from this huge victory for pedestrians, the budget was largely stay-the-course. Property taxes stayed the same and no programs or service levels were cut. Overall expenditures for the city were up 4.3 per cent over last year, but this is almost half the rate of growth from last year (8.9 per cent), which shows a good deal of budget restraint. They seem to be doing a good job reining in spending increases, and they even managed to find small ‘efficiencies’ across the board in different departments and programs… All without cutting services. Weird.
Another change announced which came from public input is that the city is moving to a three-year budget cycle. This will make the city’s budget coincide with assessment cycles and eliminate some of the year-to-year uncertainty when it comes to tax rates.
The topic of the city’s fiscal relationship with the province came up many times. It was noted that the province is charging the city HST on the costs associated with building 23 new affordable housing units in Pleasantville and that Metrobus pays a ridiculous $385,000 in road taxes to the province every year for the privilege of driving the city’s own vehicles on the city’s own roads. 2012 is sure to see continued calls for a review of the municipal-provincial relationship.
Also, it seems there have been steps toward improving the amount of public input in the budgeting process. This budget goes a long way to portray that the city is listening and that they value input. Not bad at all.
So in 2012 make sure to participate in the review of the Municipal Plan which will take place. You never know, the way things are headed, you might just get what you want.
Mon, Jan 9, 2012

Bennett House will be a colourful new building in Pleasantville full of—get this—rental units. Image: Killam Properties
This year’s Best New Building category went to The Rooms. It’s not surprising, given that The Rooms is probably one of the most interesting and creatively designed new buildings in our city, and it really stands out as having architectural merit. Problem is though, The Rooms isn’t all that new. It’s been open to the public for nearly seven years now. But, to be fair, there aren’t a lot of new architecturally designed buildings to choose from when it comes to picking a favourite.
If you want to get a good, overall view of new developments in St. John’s, you could check out skyscraperpage.com. They have a pretty good database of facts and statistics for St. John’s buildings on their “St. John’s project thread” page, and a nice collection of elevations of local buildings. The site’s contributors are generally neutral when it comes to opinions about architecture, and there isn’t a lot of editorial commenting on the buildings listed here, but I couldn’t help but notice the caption of one particular new proposal described as “design wise… one of the best current residential proposals in St. John’s so far.” This caught my attention.
According to them, the best new building going up in St. John’s is Bennett House, a new rental apartment building intended for development near Rutledge Manor in Pleasantville. It’s owned by Killam Properties out of Halifax and the apartment is being designed by Studio Works International (who have an office in Halifax).
The first glimpse we get of it reveals an ‘L’ shape plan, extruded up four storeys. It has a concrete and steel structure, with large square windows, and its facade is embellished with coloured blocks and small balconies with what looks like glass balusters. The average one-bedroom unit will be 750 square feet, and include six appliances. The building will have amenities for the residents, like a multi-purpose lounge, a movie theatre, and underground parking. It’ll be 107,500 square feet, and will house 71 units. It’s the first phase of an expected three-phase development to create 210 units in the area.
Whether or not this is the best new proposal in terms of style, and design is definitely up for debate, but what is welcome about this new proposal is the fact that these are rental units.
Finally, someone has paid attention to the fact that we have had a record low in rental unit vacancy rates for the past three years, and that trend is only expected to continue. We haven’t seen construction of any new rental units in more than 15 years. In the CMHC Housing stats recently released for 2011, we’re shown that most rental units are in buildings built before 1940, and the vacancy rate for St. John’s core city area is even lower than the larger metropolitan area average.
It remains to be seen what it will be to rent these units, but, regardless, the existence of this many new spaces will benefit the renting community by relieving the extremely high demand in the market. The design itself is probably attractive to some because of its freedom from the usual trappings of traditional architecture, but either way, it’s high time for some variety in style and types of residential developments we build here. And this one seems like a step in the right direction.
Thu, Dec 22, 2011

Image via www.nlparkingwars.tumblr.com
In the great universe of parking lot parking, Newfoundland and Labrador — and St. John’s in particular — might just be one of the most lawless. At least that’s what teacher and student Jaime Brazil believes. Fed up with people parking like pigs without repercussion, she created a blog, NL Parking Wars, where people can post photos of the worst of the worst. Her site follows in the footsteps of other parking blogs like www.youparklikeanasshole.com, www.parking-fail.com and www.iparklikeanidiot.com, but, bear in mind, those are for the whole planet.
You can visit the site at www.nlparkingwars.tumblr.com
Why create a Tumblr like this?
Many people in the last few weeks and months have been using Twitter to post photos of people parking in an inconsiderate or just downright idiotic manner, and it was suggested on a few occasions that someone start a blog to reinforce what was happening on Twitter. When no one else bit, I decided to take the plunge.
Any clue as to why the parking is so bad these days?
I think a lot of people have entitlement issues. They’re too special to have to walk more than 10 feet to the door. Some people are in a rush and it’s just too much trouble to ensure they’ve parked their car in a considerate manner. Others take up more than one spot because they’re afraid someone might ding their precious vehicle.
What’s with coffee shops and terrible parkers? Can the uncaffeinated be deemed temporarily insane or is that being too generous?
I refuse to defend anyone who is too lazy, tired, or uncaffeinated to properly park their car and walk to the door. If they don’t want to walk, they should use the drive-thru.
What’s the worst example you’ve seen so far?
I think the photo of the person parked diagonally through 3 spaces on the Avalon Mall parking lot during the Christmas season last year is probably the worst. I can’t imagine anything more inconsiderate (although I’m sure I’ll see something worse sooner rather than later), especially considering how busy the mall is at Christmas. I actually received that particular photo from two different individuals, and I imagine there were more than a few who took a photo.

Image via www.nlparkingwars.tumblr.com
Tue, Dec 13, 2011
The St. John’s city council liveblog: council, fresh to your smartphone since 2009.

The St. John’s city council live blog: Council a la 21st century
Andrew Harvey here just out of the budget lock-up! They will vote on the budget today for 2012.
Big news from the 2012 budget, sidewalk-clearing budget doubled!
There is a big crowd here from the essential transit association here advocating increased sidewalk clearing, which they got!
There is a lady here who completed an art book about scenes of St. John’s. She received $50k from the city under tourism and promotion money.
O’Keefe: “It is something we are very proud of” on the book.
They are discussing a proposal for a deck at 6 Top Battery Rd. Hann says it is only 3-4 inches…
Hann says that it is not the deck, which is blocking the view, but a 4ft extension previously built which is the issue.
This was brought up last week and deferred so that members of council could go take a look at it themselves.
Colbert: “There was no way I could see any obstruction [from the deck]“.
Motion passed, the deck is allowed to stay.
Two crown land grants are being recommended to be approved, 58 Battery Rd and 6 Ordinance St.
A resident on Beach St is looking for a piece of city land to put a Foyer on his house. He needs 4m and it will still be 8m from the road.
Breen is “pleased to present the 2012 budget”. As he highlights the growth and prosperity of the city.
Total projected expenditures for 2012 is $235,677,577, up 4.3%. The rate of growth is down from 8.9% in 2011.
Breen: “No reduction in existing programs and services is anticipated in Budget 2012″.
Tax rates are staying the same as last year. 10.6 mils for residential properties if you care, or know what a mil is.
Breen: “sidewalk snow clearing was the dominant issue at the public budget consultation session held in November” on it’s doubling for 2012.
On a whole, at first glance the budget seems to be relatively stay-the-course. They also managed to find ‘efficiencies’ across the budget
Another theme across the budget is dissatisfaction with the current fiscal relationship with the province.
The city is not happy that they have to pay HST to the province to build 23 new affordable housing units in Pleasantville.
Water tax will go up from $580 to $615/yr for residential properties. Commercial water tax up 6%. Commercial properties are metered.
The city gets a “somewhat arbitrary” operating grant of $3.4 million. The city wants to renegotiate this arrangement with the province.
Moving forward, in 2013 the city is going to move towards 3-year budget cycles, coinciding with property assessment cycles.
The city also wants to “blend” their business realty tax and business occupancy tax. This will be revenue neutral but much easier.
The extension to Tean Gushue Hwy will be open in 2014 and the city will have to pay to maintain this road.
They are still trying to find a way to get Mount Pearl to pay for this.
Hanlon wants to wish everyone a merry Christmas. They take the next 2 weeks off for the holidays.
Hanlon: “It is very good to see this large commitment” on the doubling of the sidewalk clearing budget.
Hanlon: “Shame on Eastern School District” for not funding the crossing guard program. They city stepped up and is funding it for 2012.
Hanlon: “An informed citizen is the most important asset to the city”.
Hanlon is happy with the extra steps the city has been taking to engage people in the budgetary process. Me too!
Tilley is happy to be able to stand up and vote for this budget as there is no tax increase. He voted against the budget the last 2 years.
Tilley: “I’m committed to finding a better way to work with the province”.
RT @shawnkavanagh86 @thescopeNL how about Randy Simms isn’t allowed to host @VOCMOpenLine until da Pearl ponies up the $$$$$$$
Galgay: “I hope the budget next year is good too… because then we are into an election”. Frank is starting his politicking early.
Galgay: “There is a particular group within the city which finds it hard to find affordable housing”.
Galgay also wishes everyone a Merry Christmas and a happy new year. No happy Kwannza’s from anyone yet.
Breen is mentioning that one of the issues that came up was that the public wants more input in the budget process.
Colbert says that in his 6 consecutive terms on council this is the easiest, most straightforward budget yet.
Colbert says that an important factor in good financial prudence is the city keeping a good credit rating which saves money on interest rates
Colbert: “It is absolutely scandalous that the province is charging us HST on this [affordable housing]“.
Hann: “It’s the first budget that I’m happy with” he says this will be the first budget he will have voted for in 6 years on council.
Hann: “They [the province] charge us $385 million to drive our buses on our streets” on the road tax Metrobus has to pay each year.
Hann wishes everyone in the city a very happy holidays. (Nice job Tom, much more inclusive language.)
Jennifer Mills, the communication director, is getting a shout out from Hickman for the good job she has done at marketing this budget.
There is a slick package which came along with the budget this year and Jennifer assures me she will get the full document online tonight!
O’Leary: “We need to diversify our economy” on the importance of arts and culture as one of the many areas of the economy to grow.
Hanlon and O’Leary have both mentioned the importance of involving youth in the city. Agreed!
Duff says that it is important that the budget shows the city was listening during budgetary consultations.
The title of the budget is “Managing Growth for the Future”, which Duff says she has been talking about for a long time.
Duff: “The rising tide of economic growth has not and will not raise all boats” on the importance of keeping growth of the budget in check.
O’Keefe: “It will be a city that is not afraid of modernity” on the type of city we will build in the future.
O’Keefe: “Without parks you have nothing… All of these are important to the livability of the city”.
The budget has been passed! Along with a few incidental tax by-laws.
That’s all folks. I had a wonderful year tweeting to you and can’t wait to tweet ya in the New Year. Andrew Harvey out for 2011!
Wed, Dec 7, 2011

Gander Airport International Departure Lounge from Newfoundland Modern by Robert Mellin.
Newfoundland Modern: Architecture in the Smallwood Years 1949-1972 by Robert Mellin (McGill-Queens University Press, 2011), $59.95.
When you think of Newfoundland architecture, what comes to mind? Chances are you are thinking of colored rowhouses and saltboxes. Well, this new book by Robert Mellin questions the popular notions of architecture in Newfoundland, and demonstrates that the Modernist era plays an important historical role in our province.
Mellin looks at architecture in Newfoundland between the years 1949 and 1972. He ties the architecture of that era to the political climate, and places emphasis on the role former premier Joey Smallwood had in shaping development in the province. Smallwood saw new architecture as a propaganda tool, useful for convincing the public that his vision of Newfoundland-as-a-Modernist-utopia was working.
There are some fascinating bits of history throughout the book that demonstrate how vibrant this period in architectural history was. Mellin writes about the bridge in Bowring Park by Ove Arup—one of the world’s most brilliant structural engineers, who also made possible the construction of the Sydney Opera House. Then there’s the story about Walter Gropius, Modernist architect and founder of the Bauhaus movement, who expressed interest to the provincial government in designing some of the first buildings for MUN. He was ignored though; at that point Smallwood had come to be skeptical of architects, seeing them as a group who challenged his own views on design.
The book includes some brilliant old photos. It’s fascinating to see how great some of our old buildings looked when they were brand new and finished with their designers’ originally-intended details. Flipping through the book, you really get the sense of how absurd it is that this intense period of growth and creativity is largely uncharted historical territory. A great shot of The Gander airport (see above) shows its original fittings, true to the style, from the floor finish to the furniture and art.
Of course, recognising the value of Modernist architecture is not a new idea. Around the world and in all of the major Canadian cities, academics have rethought the historic value of buildings in that style. But it seems like it’s taken extra long for a scholarly recognition of Newfoundland’s architecture in that style. Is there more-than-normal resistance to appreciating these buildings when they happen to be in Newfoundland? Could it have something to do with their political origins? It could be that they’re bundled up in our minds with painful memories surrounding the politics of the day.
One telling page shows a photo of Smallwood next to one of Le Corbusier, a French architect, designer and urbanist known for his grand Modernist schemes and their insensitivity to local cultures. Aside from their similar taste in fashion (thick round glasses and bowtie), Smallwood and Le Corbusier had some ideologies in common. Smallwood saw resettlement, Modern architecture, and new industry as key elements in his plans for rapid modernisation.
Mellin’s idea that examples of Newfoundland Modernism are historically valuable throws into question some of the popular ideas of heritage architecture in the province. He shows that it’s is a part of who we are today, alongside the more recognised vernacular forms, and reveals the political undercurrents for many buildings from this era which still affect the way we perceive them as part of our cultural landscape.
This is by no means a simple coffee table book on architecture, but it’s relatively accessible, and promises to be of great interest to history buffs and architecture enthusiasts.
Fri, Dec 2, 2011
Did you know that you have 11 employees? You’re paying the wages of 11 elected city officials whose job it is to do your bidding. (Well, kinda.)
Each year, we like to give these 11 people a report card so you can check in on them and decide if you’re happy with their performance. This year, we broke the overall grade into categories:
Attendance: Do they show up for the public meetings?
Plays Well With Others: Since city politics is a team sport, how kind, cooperative, receptive and accommodating are they with other councillors?
Participation: How often do we hear their voice, and on how many issues?
Communication: How far and wide does their voice reach? Do they have a website or a Facebook group or a newsletter? Are they accessible to the media and their constituents? Do they seem approachable?
Creativity: Do they come up with, find, or promote new ideas and innovative solutions to problems? Do they have a vision for the city? Is all of this grounded in reality?
We didn’t do all this alone. As usual, aside from asking our online readers (see page 5) we rounded up local business people, municipal watchdogs, ex-councillors and organization leaders to weigh in and help us with the grades.
By Andrew Harvey, Sarah Smellie, Morgan Murray & Elling Lien.
Photo illustrations by Elling Lien.
Click here to find out what ward you live in.

Ward One
2011 grade: A- (3.7 GPA)
2010 grade: B
This Danny Breen guy isn’t too shabby! Sure, he might just be using council as a stepping stone to higher office, but he’s using it well.
Attendance: A
He’s there!
Plays Well With Others: A+
If Danny disagrees, he’s always super respectful and nice about it. “You know, I can’t think of a single thing he wasn’t nice about,” says Andrew Harvey.
Participation: B
He doesn’t take a lot of risks with what he speaks up about —if it’s a subject he knows really well, he’s all over it. Many on our panel feel that Breen has aspirations of higher office in the provincial government, and that he sticks to bigger-ticket issues accordingly.
Communication: A-
Breen brings up concerns from his constituents a lot, so they obviously feel good about contacting him. He reaches out, too—he once called The Scope of his own volition to discuss the bike lanes. He’s in the media a lot—most recently on CBC-TV’s On Point, discussing what he worries is St. John’s under-representation in Kathy Dunderdale’s cabinet.
Creativity: B+
His grasp on reality definitely outweighs his creativity, but in a good way. He’s an efficiencies-minded finance kind of guy—he always wants to go back and have a look at the numbers. He was chair of the audit committee, after all. He’s also responsible for the city’s whistle blower protection policy.

Ward Two
2011 grade: B (2.8 GPA)
2010 grade: C
Councillor Galgay is kind and helpful and dedicated, but we don’t think he’s really in tune with the bulk of his ward. We kind of think someone should take him to a Monsterbator show.
Attendance: A
We see him, we hear him.
Plays Well With Others: B+
He’s a cordial, accommodating guy who really doesn’t ruffle any feathers. He often winds up as the butt of jokes—he tends to go on—and he takes that pretty well.
Participation: B-
Okay, so yeah, he is very long-winded. And he uses very florid language with that wind. Though he does speak about most of the Ward 2-specific issues that come up, he could address some more of the bigger, city-wide issues. Briefly.
Communication: B
We’re pretty sure we believe Galgay when he says that he’s a city councillor full-time despite its being a part-time position. He talks to his constituents a lot and goes to check out buildings and spots of debate in the city. The technological side of his communications platform needs some work—he seems to think the Internet is something you have to throw over your garbage.
Creativity: D
Galgay would be great for the Waterford Bridge area maybe, but in our dealings with him, and from what he says in council, it’s clear that he’s not in touch with the downtown area, the heart of his ward. When we asked him about the rental crisis, for example, he jumped to talking about social assistance. Dude, people who don’t own houses aren’t necessarily on social assistance. That’s offensive.

Ward Three
2011 grade: C (2.04 GPA)
2010 grade: c
We wish we had more to go on with Tilley.
Attendance: B
Not stellar, but he’s no Gerry Colbert.
Plays Well With Others: C
Thing is, he doesn’t really play with others at all. If he says something, it’s usually a short summary of his opinion and he doesn’t often engage with the other councillors. He makes a big show of not voting for the budget every year.
Participation: C
Again, we don’t have much to go on here. He’s not all that active in public council meetings.
Communication: B-
Okay, so here’s something great about Bruce Tilley: He does a fabulous job chairing public meetings. He listens to everyone’s concerns, itemizes them and then tries to address each and every one. And then he brings that list of concerns to council. That’s a plus—it means that everyone gets heard and specific concerns get addressed. He’s also very brief and to-the-point when (if) he raises any points in council, and it’s clear that he is listening to the people in his ward. On the hand, have you ever seen him quoted in the media outside of election time? We haven’t either.
Creativity: D-
We’re not really sure what he would get points for here.

Ward Four
2011 grade: A- (3.7 GPA)
2010 grade: B
Hanlon is passionate and unafraid, and she’s full of good ideas. Her spot on council is well-deserved.
Attendance: B
Could be better.
Plays Well With Others: B+
She tends to be more emotional than someone like Danny Breen, say, but she outlines her arguments carefully when she has them. The only reason that she doesn’t get an A in this category is because she flares up.
Participation: A
Debbie sometimes gets a lot of flak for not being consistent, but that’s because she speaks up so much, and when she speaks up, she’s honest. Never afraid to admit that she doesn’t know something or when she’d like to change her mind about something, she’s true to the person she is. We think this is refreshing—it’s nice to have a real human being in politics.
Communication: A+
She has a website! And it’s updated sort of regularly! And she’s on Facebook, and she holds town meetings and reaches out to her constituents! She’s just plain excellent in this department. One could criticize her for not doing a great PR job explaining her position on the independent review of councillors’ time and salaries, but, in her defence, that turned into a media monster almost instantly and the real message was buried in all the hype.
Creativity: A-
Again, she’s not afraid to note little (or big) things that should change, and she voices her ideas all the time. Thankfully, a lot of the time those ideas are good. Podcasting council meetings (please do this!), working towards a paperless council, and an independent review of council with a look toward full-time city councillor positions are just some of the good ideas she’s floated.

Ward Five
2011 grade: B- (2.7 GPA)
2010 grade: C+
We appreciate his humour and the lightness it brings to council, but we wish he brought more.
Attendance: A
Plays Well With Others: A
Collins keeps pretty quiet, but when he does speak, he’s the class clown and the social lubricator. This is fantastic because he’s good at making light of tense situations.
Participation: C
We wish he spoke up more, because when he does, he’s concise yet thorough. If absolutely everyone is talking about something, he’ll chime in, but he otherwise remains silent.
Communication: B
He’s very active in his community and even though he brings up stuff like building dog parks in the West End (that’s a go-ahead, by the way), he’s representing his ward and he’s doing it well. He also talks about his community events a lot and does a good job promoting them at council meetings.
Creativity: D-
Um, extremely not very? He reacts to the public but rarely brings his own ideas forward. Let’s see… The dog park… and he brings up the idea of a community centre in the Southlands, so that will keep him above an F.

At Large
2011 grade: C- (1.6 GPA)
2010 grade: D-
The attendance thing is genuinely rude—we’re kind of embarrassed for everyone that voted for him (again).
Attendance: F
His absenteeism really stands out. Everyone we asked mentioned it. The Telegram even ran a story on it once. Is he on a city council in Fort Lauderdale or something?
Plays Well With Others: B
When he’s there, he’s all right: he’s blunt, but well-spoken, and whenever he speaks, it’s well thought-out. He doesn’t mix much with the other councillors, but he doesn’t un-mix, either—he’s the lone Floridian wolf.
Participation: D-
See Attendance. When he’s there, he talks, but most of the panel we spoke with think it’s for the camera; so it looks like he attends meetings.
Communication: C-
He seems like he returns emails from his constituents, but seeing as he’s so rarely in the country, email is probably the only way you can track him down. He doesn’t wind up in the media much, unless someone’s doing a story on how infrequently he sits in on meetings. Sigh.
Creativity: B
See, and here’s the thing: It would actually be great if Colbert showed up to the public meetings. Not just because then everyone who voted for him would look less foolish, but because he brings common sense to the conversation. He’s willing to dig into and revisit problems to see how they can be resolved. C’maaaan, Colbert.

At Large
2011 grade: A (3.8 GPA)
2010 grade: B
We hope O’Leary sticks around. She’s a great socially-minded voice on council.
Attendance: A
Plays Well With Others: B
She has occasional spats with other councillors, and sometimes she takes things personally. Otherwise, she’s quite pleasant.
Participation: A
O’Leary consistently speaks to a range of issues and brings up something every week in the go-around. The only reason Duff got the A+ in this category is because Duff has been around longer and knows the nuts and bolts of it all—she cuts to the chase.
Communication: A
O’Leary is very active on Facebook with her Jam Session newsletters. She’s also happy to bring concerns forth from constituents that contact her and does so regularly. She’s active in the community, and she’s frequently in the media. Thumbs up.
Creativity: A
The best thing about O’Leary is that she’s constantly mentioning what other cities are doing. She seems to always be thinking about new things, she just doesn’t quite have experience to implement them. We expect a bright future with her on council.

At Large
2011 grade: B- (2.7 GPA)
2010 grade: C+
Does he have to be so negative? Has he tried yoga?
Attendance: A
Plays Well With Others: D-
Hann tends to be pretty negative. He’s good at putting up obstacles and shooting down ideas, he picks fights, and he makes snide comments. Not cool.
Participation: A
He does, however, speak to a lot of issues. If only he’d just speak a little more constructively…
Communication: A-
Though his spelling could use some work, we can’t help but give him big points for sending out his own press releases through the city’s media list. That being said, he was also the spokesman for the Transit Committee during the Metrobus strike and he was bloody impossible to get a hold of.
Creativity: D
Like O’Keefe, he’s creative with excuses and complaints, but not solutions.

At Large
2011 grade: B- (2.48 GPA)
2010 grade: C-
Hello, hello? Councillor Hickman?
Attendance: B
Plays Well With Others: A
He’s nice, he has a heart, he explains himself with thought and care and he doesn’t argue.
Participation: C-
But maybe we haven’t noticed him bickering because, well, we haven’t noticed him. He talks about arts funding and tourism a lot, which makes sense given his job in the provincial government’s Tourism department. Maybe he’d say more if he didn’t have to have a second job. Perhaps Sandy Hickman is the case for full-time councillor positions.
Communication: C-
Hickman doesn’t undertake a whole lot of outreach, and he doesn’t wind up in the media very much. In short, we’re not really sure what he’s about.
Creativity: B-
When he does participate, Hickman is pretty good at coming up with solutions to problems. He seems to be fairly flexible and, equally as important, he encourages the other councillors to be flexible too.

Deputy Mayor
2011 grade: B+ (3.38 GPA)
2010 grade: A
Shannie’s been fighting the heritage and social equality fight for ages, and we’re really happy she’s been at it. Her arguments are always well thought-out and informed and she’s an effective member of council.
Attendance: A
She may have even been present at more council meetings than our city council watchdog, Andrew Harvey. ‘Nuff said.
Plays Well With Others: B-
Shannie’s no push-over, which is a good thing, but she does tend to bicker and talk over the people she’s bickering with (*cough*Tom Hann, *cough*O’Keefe). In her defense, though, people tend to assume she’s going on about heritage regulations and tune her out.
Participation: A+
She sets the bar for this one. Not afraid to stick her neck out, she speaks to every important issue and, with her experience, her input is usually excellent.
Communication: B
Though her website is inactive, she’s all over the websites of local media outlets, speaking to every issue under the sun. She also does a lot of speaking engagements with local organizations, which is great; people approach her because she’s approachable.
Creativity: B-
Shannie clearly pays attention to what other, more progressive, cities are doing, and she is open to new, innovative ideas. Usually, though, she sticks to thinking inside the box, but she sure knows her way around it.

Mayor
2011 grade: C+ (2.4 GPA)
2010 grade: D+
He plays it pretty safe and sticks to the books. We don’t expect the unexpected from O’Keefe.
Attendance: B
Okay, we know he had triple bypass surgery and all, but his attendance was less-than-A before the operation, we swear!
Plays Well With Others: C+
Though Doc attempts to be equitable, it doesn’t always come off that way. He cuts people off—and brevity is good—but he’s more prone to cut off those he disagrees with.
Participation: A
He definitely weighs in all the important issues—heck, he usually weighs in if it’s unimportant too.
Communication: B-
Remember, way back during the election, when he said he wanted to get everyone’s input on a cohesive vision for St. John’s? He hasn’t quite done that. Outside of protocol, he doesn’t really do much to solicit input from the public. He does, however, make himself readily available to the media.
Creativity: F
He’s not an Outside-The-Box kind of guy. Though he does tend to be pretty creative with his excuses for why the city can’t seem to do anything progressive. As one of our panelists said, “I’d encourage him to share his vision for the city, but I suspect the response would be both delayed and uninspiring.”
Thu, Dec 1, 2011

Some people say that the city won’t do anything about sidewalk clearing until someone gets killed. This past February we came way too close to this happening when two young women were walking beside snow-covered sidewalks on Topsail Road when they were struck by a drunk driver. The driver being drunk was clearly the main concern but one has to question whether or not walkable sidewalks could have prevented this from happening.
Currently the city clears around 100 kilometers of sidewalks as a part of the larger 15 million dollar snow clearing program (used for both roads and sidewalks). The 2012 budget is yet to be finalized but I’d bet my left sock we will not see an increase in the amount of sidewalks cleared this year. This year’s budget is shaping up to be a tight one—as they all seem to be—and it will be a tough sell to convince the majority of council to agree to expand on sidewalk clearing when it’s competing against the many other needs of the city.
You may remember that during last winter’s Metrobus strike, the city plowed additional sidewalks to help protect those forced to walk the treacherous streets. Don’t get your hopes up though, as Mayor O’Keefe was quick to point out at the time, these were exceptional circumstances and shouldn’t be considered the norm.
While one can understand a city under immense financial pressure not wanting to sign up for more costly snow-clearing, I have a harder time understanding why the city doesn’t look at cheap or free alternatives. Halifax has a bylaw requiring property owners to clear sidewalks in front of their property. If our city didn’t want to create a similar bylaw, there are still a lot of ways to encourage people to do what they already have the shovel for. How about sending the city truck down to pick up snow from any community that organizes its own sidewalk snow-clearing event? Maybe bring them down some hot chocolate or coffee to show them how much the city appreciates their hard work to make the city a more accessible place. A little inventiveness wouldn’t hurt.
Who knows? Maybe I’m being too cynical and the city will roll out an elaborately expanded and improved sidewalk clearing program with the 2012 budget at the end of December. Now that would be a Christmas present I’d like to see. In lieu of this let’s all try and think about each other this winter. Drive extra safe, walk extra careful, maybe even knock on your neighbour’s door next time it snows and have a go at the sidewalks on your street together.
Let’s just hope that we don’t have to see anyone else get hurt before seeing the change we all want.
Thu, Mar 1, 2012
Taryn Sheppard