
Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him on Monday afternoons at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal madness from the bunker on New Gower.
I am again joined in the gallery by striking Metrobus workers, who have been at council each week since they went on strike.
It’s budget day!
I just had to argue with someone from the city clerk’s office to get a copy of the budget.
She wouldn’t give me a copy of the budget until she asked the city’s communication officer who said, “yeah, he’s the Twitter guy”
That’s right, I’m the Twitter guy, and I am just as legitimate as any other media-type who sits on the floor of council chambers.
The mill rate is set to be increased by 0.5 mills. This will be discussed and voted on today.
This increase of 0.5 mills would be an increase in property tax of $100/yr for a $200k home.
The residential water tax will increase by $10 to $580/yr per home.
Council has started to assemble. As Frank Galgay entered, the Metrobus workers said, “you didn’t forget about us did you Frank?”
I am not sure what exactly the Metrobus workers are hoping to accomplish. Council has made it clear that try are not getting involved.
“His worship, the Mayor”… O’Keefe has arrived, and the meeting has begun.
Paul Mackey from the city is making a presentation regarding changes to garbage collection over the holidays.
All of council is in attendance for this budget meeting.
Changes to the garbage collection schedule start on Dec. 18th. For next week everyone is a day early.
Please check your calendar, or call 3-1-1 if you have questions.
Paul Mackey says that Christmas wrapping paper is not recyclable, and should be treated as garbage. Unless you wrap in old newspaper, that is
A business on 84 Gower Street is being converted to a residential property. Is this the old furniture store? Someone run down for me.
RT @NostalgicNerd Google Street View says yes, the one with the funky statue outside it.
The nomenclature committee is naming 6 new streets, and renaming one old one.
Duff is presenting the budget as the chair of the finance committee.
45% of the increase in city expenditures will go to wages and benefits.
Addressing concerns over the increases to city budgets, Duff says these are related to increasing service levels, and new regional services.
Duff says that our budgets carry the cost of some of these regional services are cost-shared with other municipalities.
She says these cost-shared services are deceptive, and make the increase in our budget look worse than it is, as we recoup some of this $.
Commercial tax rates and business occupancy tax will also increase by 0.5 mill.
Hanlon: “I know that no one here likes to see an increase in tax, but I will support the budget.”
Hanlon is also happy to see the relief for seniors, with the seniors tax discount increasing to 25% (from 20%).
Galgay: “This city is expanding in leaps and bounds”
RT dougjonesphoto the city is expanding in an irresponsible manner and spiraling out of control.
@dougjonesphoto Agreed, we are paying a fortune for servicing large areas of unsustainable urban sprawl.
Galgay also says that in-migration to the NE Avalon places much more demands on city infrastructure.
Galgay: “I don’t like increasing taxes either, but we have to be responsible.”
Breen says he will not support the budget. He does not agree with all of the city’s grants and subsidies.
Another place Breen disagrees with on a “philosophical level” are some programs which the city funds. He did not give an example of which.
Breen: “We need to start looking at three year budgets, which will bring some stability”
Breen says in the new year he will bring a motion forward to expand the mandate of the audit committee, which he chairs.
Breen says he does not think they did enough to ensure the budget was as efficient as it could have been.
O’Leary says that it is important to ensure we continue to fund cultural, recreational and community groups through grants.
O’Leary says that although it is not in this budget, she does not agree with increasing salaries for councillors.
Tilley says he cannot support the budget on a matter of principle. He is doing this to stand up for his constituents.
Tilley says that because of our zero-based budget, it leaves no room for reducing budgets for individual programs.
Tilley: “The Fortis project, we threw it out the window.” Not quite Bruce, council never voted on it.
Tilley wants a full review of city services. He cites that the city pays $100k for the Aquarena, and collects no tax from the university.
As Tom Hann stood, Metrobus workers all coughed in unison.
Hann: “We have done a lot on the cycling plan, which I question as a priority right now.”
Hann says that we have not done enough to bring the sides together on development.
Hann says she is shocked to see that the city gave money to a cellist to go to Toronto to renew their creative juices.
Hann: “We cannot continue to turn these things [proposals] down.”
Hann: “A complete review is long overdue of how we spend taxpayers dollars.”
Hickman says that at the beginning of the process he did not expect to have to increase taxes.
Hickman also agrees that we need a full operational review of the city to find efficiencies.
Hickman has a plea for the provincial government, that the city needs enhanced support from the province.
Hickman says that we should try and work out an arrangement for payment in lieu of services for what we do for provincial buildings.
Hickman “begrudgingly accepts” the budget.
This is Colbert’s 21st budget! He says he will support it.
Hickman says that the main thing we need to keep in our mind is our debt-equity ratio.
Colbert says that our city staff, councillors, and citizens have worked for the last 20 years to keep the city in excellent financial shape.
Colbert: “This city can stand above all others in the province, possibly across Canada” in relation to our debt-equity ratio.
Colbert says that because of the good financial state we are in, when federal funding becomes available, we are able to avail of it.
Collins: “The same three guys who aren’t voting for it this year didn’t vote for it last year.”
Collins: “That’s only BS as far as I’m concerned,” talking about the dissenters complaints, and inability to point to where to save $6.8 million.
O’Keefe: “We have been voted the #6 city in Canada… That vibrancy comes with a cost.” In reference to our ranking on the most livable cities in Canada list by the Conference Board of Canada.
Going back to what Collins said, he said the dissenters never came up with any solutions where to find the $6.8 million gap.
Collins says they only criticized grants of tens of thousands, not the millions they needed to make up.
O’Keefe is proud that they will keep service levels that people reasonably expect, and currently have. “That adds up to a reasonable budget”
O’Keefe: “You can’t talk about restraint then go and spend a quarter million on an operational review. I won’t support that.”
O’Keefe also says that we need to look at how municipalities are funded, provincially, and federally.
O’Keefe: “So ends the sermon” to his own rant on the budget.
O’Keefe says this is “not a budget of restraint,” but a reasonable one.
Duff: “We have a philosophical debate here about what kind of city we want.” In reference to going back to core values of the city only providing infrastructure and essential services.
Budget passed! With Tilley, Breen, and Hann voting against.
Duff wants to thank Ron Penney for the stability he has brought to the city, and the fine staff he leaves the city with.
O’Leary is asking where this council isn’t encouraging both parties in getting back to the table to negotiate an end to the Metrobus strike.
O’Leary comments got huge applause from the crowd.
Hann: “Despite what the busdrivers might think, there is a lot going on behind the scenes.”
Hann says they will continue to offer suggestions, and they want to see an end to this strike.
Colbert says that Ron Penney has not done a good job, but an outstanding job.
Collins: “[Ron Penney] can finally throw away his nerve pills.”
O’Keefe: “The man exudes [fiscal prudence]” in reference to Ron Penney.
O’Keefe would like to see both sides make “a valiant effort” to resolve the Metrobus strike before Christmas.
Ron Penney: “It has been a tremendous honour to be the city manager of St. John’s.”
That’s all folks, that was the last meeting of 2010. It has been a pleasure tweeting you, see ya in 2011. Andrew Harvey out.
Thu, Dec 2, 2010

By Andrew Harvey, Sarah Smellie & Elling Lien. Illustrations by Elling Lien.
Yes indeed, it’s time for the Scope’s Not-So-Annual (And Pretty Much Randomly Occurring) St. John’s City Council Report Card! Last time we did something like this was back in 2008.
We canvassed a bunch of business and arts organizations, city council watchdogs, and general city politics afficianados to ask them how the felt each councillor had performed over the past year. They gave each council member a letter grade and explained why.
Then we got council members to fill out questionnaires of their own, asking them how they thought they did, what they thought the biggest issues of the past year were, and where their priorities for the future lay.
Taking all that into account, we then poured over the results, searched deep within our own hearts and minds, and assigned the final grades.
The criteria for each grade was, roughly, based on a number of questions: Who tends to lead, and who tends to stay on the sidelines? Who has vision? Who sticks to their guns, and who is inconsistent? Who represents their ward well? Who attends and participates in meetings?
Here’s our opinion.
Click here to find out what ward you live in.

2010 grade: D+
2008 grade: C+
In the wake of Andy Wells, O’Keefe has brought much needed decorum and stability to council. His efforts to make council chambers a more civil, productive place have been well met, but as a chair of council meetings, he can be fairly divisive. A case and point is his conduct during the Fortis proposal and withdrawal. While it is one thing to be in favour of a certain project, it is another thing for a mayor to be all over the media begging Fortis to reconsider and expressing “frustration” over the “events leading up to its withdrawal.” (www.bit.ly/g9dct9) Dude, from our perspective, the events leading up to the proposal’s withdrawal consisted of citizens and councillors participating in a democracy. That’s the sort of thing a mayor should encourage.
We’re also disappointed in his continued stalling of the review of the city’s municipal plan, especially after he made such a fuss about of the importance of developing a vision for St. John’s during the election.

2010 grade: A
2008 grade: A-
Say what you will, but we find it hard to criticize Shannie Duff for much. She is one of the most active councillors, and speaks intelligently and knowledgeably on virtually every topic. For someone who is routinely lambasted by sections of the public for being “anti-development,” she was leading the charge in the rezoning of Water Street West, which allowed for bonus height and new development in the area. Her many years on council give her a keen sense of when information is being presented in a misleading, or incorrect manner, and she does not hesitate to call people out on it. She is probably the most likely one to get in a racket, but in doing so, she’s usually defending her right to speak, or defending a position she has clearly articulated. Although she did call Tom Hann a “drama queen” that one time…

2010 grade: B
2008 grade: n/a
One of the newcomers to council, Danny Breen is learning the ropes and fitting in well. Breen has taken a fresh approach to the tight budgets he’s been facing, looking for belts to tighten within programs, rather than scrapping said programs outright. He’s also in good contact with his constituents, and often brings their concerns to council. Breen is always respectful and sensible when he talks, and listens to others’ perspectives. This is an excellent characteristic for a productive council member.
He does seem more likely to react to a motion than to make one, but hopefully that will change once he’s had a bit more experience.

2010 grade: C
2008 grade: B
If there’s one councillor who really lays out—perhaps ad nauseum—why he’s voting a certain way, it’s Frank Galgay. With 13 years on council, Galgay brings a calm, reasonable perspective to the table. Though he does stick to playing nicey-nice and smiling pretty for the cameras, his recent vote for the development on Signal Hill had many of his constituents pretty miffed. And although his perspective is balanced, it may be too much so for what is probably the city’s most radical and creative ward (which includes most of downtown).

2010 grade: C
2008 grade: n/a
On his second go at council, Bruce Tilley represents Ward 3 with quiet dignity and clearly does a good job of staying in touch with his ward. He is generally reserved at council meetings, keeping his speeches short and getting right to the point with little explanation. He’s occasionally confused with what point the meeting is at, for which he takes a good ribbing from the other councillors, but he gets bonus points for bringing up safety concerns about the ducks on the road by Bowring Park with a straight face.

2010 grade: B
2008 grade: n/a
Debbie Hanlon is a councillor who always speaks her mind, and is smart enough to say when she doesn’t know something. This refreshing honesty makes her many contributions to discussion and debate welcome. She stays well in touch with her constituents through her website, www.ward4report.com, and brings their concerns to council. And she gets bonus points for her idea for a city-funded position to help artists promote their work locally and abroad to new markets. Outside-the-box ideas like this are crucial for surviving whatever grim financial times could lay ahead, and we’d love to see more initiative from her to turn these good ideas into motions.

2010 grade: C+
2008 grade: D+
Wally Collins is like the quiet kid at the back of the class who occasionally cracks the hilarious joke. You don’t hear much from Wally Collins in council (for example, he was the only council member not to return our questionnaire, which loses him a few points) though when he does speak, it’s clear that he has his finger on the pulse of Ward 5, and that he’s responsive to constituent concerns. As far as issues outside of his ward, he seems to be a go-with-your-gut kind of guy. And speaking of guts, he ran the Cape to Cabot race this year in just over two hours. We’d like to see more of that moving and shaking from Collins in council chambers, too.

2010 grade: B
2008 grade: n/a
Having been elected with more votes than any other candidate, O’Leary came in with all the expectations of Obama. She has been extremely active in her time on council so far, raising a wide variety of issues, from funding for the arts to advocating for a ban on cosmetic pesticide use. She does do an excellent job of reaching out to the public and makes sure their voices are heard in council chambers.
Gotta say, though, we couldn’t help but be disappointed when she took up litter as one of her key issues. Litter? Really? That’s a pretty tame issue for a councillor who really seemed she was going to be a fist-pumping radical who fought for the little guys. We know keeping our city litter free is useful to remind people about environmental stewardship, but jeez.

2010 grade: C-
2008 grade: C+
Sad to say, but if there was a councillor you might forget about, it’s Sandy Hickman. When he speaks, he’s sensible, respectful, and concise, but he just doesn’t speak enough. For a councillor-at-large, it would be nice to see Hickman pick up a torch—almost any torch, and really carry it.

2010 grade: D-
2008 grade: F
With over 20 years on council, the often sensible voice of Gerry Colbert is one we wish we heard more. He’s civil, he speaks to the point and his experience lends a valuable perspective. And he’s got a great moustache.
So what’s with the D-? Councillor Colbert is, like, never there. Back in April 2010, just months after his re-election, The Telegram reported that Colbert had already missed 30 per cent of council’s regular meetings on account of his trips to Florida (www.bit.ly/g1g2nv.)
We gave him an F for his lousy attendance last time around. It’s improved a bit since then, so we are bumping his grade to a D-.

2010 grade: C+
2008 grade: C+
Another active councillor, Tom Hann is not shy to voice his opinion, and he’s quick to point out inconsistencies in the actions of council. As a result of his questioning, we have seen a review of the city’s policy on sponsoring charity events, leading to a fairer process for dispensing city funds.
On the downside, Hann recently made a comment insinuating that video cameras should not be allowed in the gallery, which has us worried about his commitment to transparency and openness of council.
He also listed a review of the municipal plan as one of his top three priorities to us in the questionnaire we sent him this year, despite voting and speaking against a motion to begin the review several months ago.
Click here to read the councillors’ responses to our 2010 questionnaire.
Thu, Dec 2, 2010

As part of the process to decide our grades for the city council report card, we got council members to fill out questionnaires asking them how they thought they did this year, what they thought the biggest issues were, and where their priorities for the future lay.
Illustrations by Elling Lien.
Questionnaire by Andrew Harvey, Sarah Smellie and Elling Lien.What you see below is unedited.
Mayor
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
I would leave that to the judgement of the residents of St. John’s.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
Top three in no particular order:
- Fiscal and budgetary responsibility/development
- Affordable housing and housing affordability
- Infrastructure maintenance and renewal
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
To re-tender the Recycling Facility operation. It saved taxpayers about $ 750,000 annually for the life of the contract.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
Reviewing the Municipal Plan is very important. It is our opportunity to realistically plan for and meet development pressures the city will face in the next five or more years. It is equally important that this plan be in line with the provincial Regional Plan.
City funding for the arts
The City has always been and should continue to be a great supporter of arts and culture. Such support is an investment in the in the city and its future as a vibrant Canadian capital city.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
We should continue to cooperate with each other and share services. That will lead us to the inevitable……….. unification of the metro area taking in St. John’s, Mt.Pearl and the urban part of Paradise.
Decorum in council
Council after all is a political chamber and sparks will fly from time to time in heated debate. However, all should be within the rules of procedure and decorum.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
Different magazines from time to time from municipal issues to religion to family magazines.
Deputy Mayor
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
This has been a very busy and exciting year. It has been challenging at times but think I have performed well.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
The three top priorities for the city are .
1. To ensure that we have the fiscal capacity going into the future to address the infrastructure needs as well as our core programs and services.
2. To manage the changes that are inevitable in the immediate future so that our rush to
prosperity does not overshadow the social needs of our citizens and destroy the special qualities that make St. John’s a unique, beautiful and liveable place to live and work.
3.To operate a transparent and accountable government and to promote good communications
and initiatives that will give our citizens the information they need to make informed decisions and support meaningful citizen engagement.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
A review of the City’s Municipal Plan is overdue and urgent. I do not agree that waiting for the completion of the North East Avalon Plan was necessary. Our present plan is a good document but very few people are familiar with the underlying policies in this plan. Our biggest problem is the process of constant amendments has made it somewhat meaningless. We need to review it, and either affirm the present planning policy directions, or change them and adopt a new vision for the city. We need, more than ever before to have clear planning direction for the future and to bring some consistency and stability to the process.
And speaking of process, it is as important as the product. I hope a Municipal Review will include really meaningful citizen engagement in developing our collective vision for the future of our City. Hopefully we will get a start on this in 2011
City funding for the arts
I have always supported Municipal Finding for the Arts. The arts are a very important component of our quality of life and contribute greatly to our ability to attract and retain new businesses and workers. We focus our support on local community benefits and consider our participation as an investment in an important local industry.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
This region is so interdependent form both an economic and a servicing point of view that
cooperation is essential. Most of the essential services already have a regional component and regional committees so regional cooperation is well underway.
Decorum in council
It certainly has improved but it may never be perfect because common sense and common
courtesy can ‘t be legislated.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
Lot’s of them. I like cities that are liveable, beautiful and interesting. I likethem to have a human scale and good amenities, When cities are good custodians of their natural and heritage assets it is an added plus for me. I spent some time this summer in the Scandinavian Capitals and all these cities fit the bill for me but there are many others I like as well.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
The Newfoundland Quarterly,
This Week,
The Economist,
The Atlantic Magazine.
Heritage Canada Magazine.
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
If I were Mayor, I would probably support much the same issues that I do as Deputy Mayor. I
would on building consensus within Council on key issues as a Mayor does not have any executive ability to act independent of Council.
Ward One
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
I feel my first year on Council has been a very good one. My goal coming in was to represent my constituents to the best of my ability, be responsive and to learn about the inner workings of the City. I feel I have been responsive to the needs of my constituents and I have consulted with them in issues that directly impacted them. I have attended practically all Standing Committee Meetings and sit on several regional boards as well as the board of St. John’s Sports and Entertainment. The only true rating of my performance will occur in the next election so I will leave that to the residents of Ward 1 to decide.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
The City’s three main priorities for me are taxation, infrastructure and regionalization of services. Residents are concerned over taxation levels, particularly seniors. The city has a major infrastructure deficit that needs to be addressed. I believe there are many advantages to regionalizing services with neighboring municipalities that need to be explored.
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
I pay a great detail of attention to all Council votes. Although not all directly impact the residents of Ward 1 or may not be high profile issues, each vote affects someone and it’s my responsibility that I understand the issues around each vote so that it is given the attention it deserves. As for one vote that was most important, I would say my vote against the 2010 budget, as it affected everyone in the city.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
We will begin the process of reviewing our Municipal Plan this year. For me, communications is the most important part of this process. We need to ensure that we have a communication plan in place that encourages input from the public. This has to go beyond the usual public meeting and letter writing approach. We have to use mediums that people want to express their opinion, whether it be social networking tools, storefront or kiosks, etc. I will be planning several initiatives in Ward 1 to encourage and facilitate input.
City funding for the arts
The City has contributed significantly to the Arts over the years. We have to ensure that taxes are kept as low as possible while addressing our infrastructure needs, municipal services and support for Community groups, such as the Arts. Our challenge will be finding a way to find the necessary balance amongst these needs.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
I think further regionalization of services on the Northeast Avalon is in the tax payers best interest. I am a supporter of amalgamation.
Decorum in council
I don’t have any issues with the decorum, or lack thereof, in Council meetings.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
My other favourite city is Fredericton, New Brunswick. It’s a smaller city, very beautiful and pays a lot of attention to family centered activities.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
Unfortunately, outside of professional journals, I don’t get much chance now to read magazines. I used to read Sports Illustrated and Newsweek but not so much in the past year. I usually do have a book to read. I recently finished Bill Rowe’s book about Danny Williams War with Ottawa, and now I am reading Rick Hilliers book, A Soldier First.
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
If I was Mayor I would ensure the lowest possible taxation levels through effective fiscal management coupled with responsible growth and development.
Ward Two
This is my 4th term having been elected in 1997, 2001, 2005, 2009. It has always been the most contested ward in the city.
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
I would rate my performance as VERY GOOD.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
1.Provide public services such as: water, recycling-garbage collection, fire protection services, sidewalk and street construction and repairs, street and sidewalk snow clearing, and a clean city.
2. Provide parks and recreation and cultural activities.
3. Provide parking and traffic control in general in the city but more specifically in the downtown which is a challenge.
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
My most important vote was for the passing of the City of St. John’s Budget.
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
The biggest issue will be balancing the pressures coming from increased development because of the spin offs from offshore oil and gas revenues and the need to retain our distinctive heritage character. There has to be a balance somewhere between these two forces.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
I believe the Municipal Plan should be reviewed. I voted to do so. Council has agreed to place a budgetary amount for consideration and discussion in the present budget discussions for 2011.
City funding for the arts
There is a need to support the arts. The city does fund individuals and groups. In the past it has given capital support to the Resource Center For The Arts and the Anna Templeton Building but to name a few.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
There is ongoing cooperation between towns and cities with regular meetings. We presently have regional cooperation on water, fire services, sewage treatment plant, transportation and Robin Hood Bay.
Decorum in council
I am pleased with the decorum demonstrated with the present council.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
Yes, Quebec City
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
Yes
Canada’s History
Newfoundland Quarterly
Newfoundland and Labrador Studies
The Downhome
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
I would bring my own style and personality on the office.
Ward Three
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
I have worked extremely hard for my constituents, however, my constituents are the judges.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
To bring development to St. John’s that will enhance the tax base and will provide no tax increases to constituents and the general public at large; to initiate programs that will provide citizens less fortunate with affordable housing; to have an effective Municipal and Regional plan completed that will provide the vision and the structure for the future of St. John’s.
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
No tax increase.
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
2011 Budget
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
This should be done in accordance with the Regional plan.
City funding for the arts
should be based on needs through the grants program with a complete financial statement.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
Everyone work together for the common good.
Decorum in council
Decorum should always maintain decorum and we should always have the opportunity to express individual opinions. I thought the past year we worked well together.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
There is no other.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
Canadian Business, MacLeans.
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
enhance opportunities for job creation through development and reducing taxes for seniors.
Ward Four
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
Well, my mother thinks I’m doing an absolutely amazing job, and me, I’m one of those people who tries to do their best at everything they do
What are/should be the city’s top 3 priorities?
#1: the Strategic Economic Roadmap which will be guiding our economy for the next 10 years. Without this in place our city simply will not be ready for the success that’s coming. Let’s face it, if you don’t have a map it’s hard to tell where you’re going and, just as importantly, remember where you came from.
#2: fostering culture, tourism and the arts. This goes hand in hand with the Strategic Economic Roadmap. As our city experiences an influx of companies and people, we have to stay grounded. We can’t forget what makes this place so special and that’s its people and their unique talents. After all, it’s no good to be financially rich and culturally and artistically poor.
#3: controlled, conscientious development. This applies to the downtown area where we can’t sell our past to buy our future, but it also applies just as importantly to affordable housing. Through controlled development we can raise revenues and use part of those revenues to tackle the growing problem of affordable housing for people who need it.
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
My vote against the proposed Fortis development which, for me, was a vote for preserving the historical qualities of our downtown core.
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
The biggest issue will be, without doubt, increased pressure for development to provide class A space downtown. Right now our city has no class A space available and that’s what companies coming here expect and demand. How we handle that pressure and control the development so it doesn’t completely change the face of our city is a challenge all of council has to work on together.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
Before moving ahead with the Municipal Plan, we first need to finalize the Regional Plan. That’s just the order things have to proceed in, you don’t buy a couch until you know what colour the walls are going to be. So the first step is regional and that will certainly help shape parts of the Municipal Plan.
City funding for the arts
I have always been a strong advocate for city funding for the arts.I would like to see the funding continued and even increased but in more defined atmosphere. I’ve personally given to the LSPU Hall for years now and from owning and running Jesperson Publishing I’m very aware of the need for that funding. In fact I think that along with city funding we should start exploring other avenues such as the companies that have set up shop here. Why not lobby them to put money into an arts pool? I’m sure they’d be agreeable seeing how it fits their good corporate citizen mandate. One last point is the use of the money, I believe a portion needs to be allocated for management of the artistic community. We have people who can produce amazing works but seem to be lacking in the
next level of that which is marketing it and getting it out there.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
The North-East Avalon is going to continue to grow, it’s in migration to the city, not oil, that is the main driving economic force . So basically there’s going to be a lot more of us sharing the same space so cooperation is a must. That begins with talking and our council needs to meet regularly with the other councils and discuss issues, both mutual and different and start working together for the good of the entire area.
Decorum in council
didn’t think there was any. Just kidding. Any time you get a diverse group of people in the same room and add cameras and
microphones it’s going to turn into a bit of a reality TV show. That means at times, grand standing, soap box singing and talking to simply be heard talking. It’s a tough problem to fix because there are so many personalities involved and I feel the best thing all of us can do is be aware of our job as a council, not as individual councillors needing votes and all that.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favorite city?
Oui! Next to St. John’s, my favorite city in Canada is Montreal, it’s got a similar street vibe to here. In the world I’d have to say Paris and New York are pretty even but every city has got things in it that make it unique and worth seeing.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
The only magazine I subscribe to at the moment is The New Yorker. It’s an amazing collection of writings on a really wide range of topics. Where else could you find a piece on the history of knife making next to an insider’s view of the political situation in Afghanistan? One thing I read in it really helped shape my political philosophy; one writer observed that there are two types of politicians: those who want to be something and those who want to do something. I’ve always tried to be the second type,
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
..go down in history as the Mayor with the best shoe collection. Seriously though, I would do what I’m doing now as Ward 4 councillor and that is do the best I can every day. It would be a different title but with the same work ethic, preparation and
professionalism I bring to my role as councillor

Ward Five
Councillor Collins did not respond to our questionnaire.
At Large
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
Excellent! I have worked extremely hard and tackled many of the issues I said I would including working towards a pesticide ban, supporting recycling in the City, tackling the garbage situation in the City, advocating responsible development (no to Fortis’ proposal and Murphy’s Lane sub-division on Signal Hill) yes to MANY other appropriate developments, and basically being one on one responsive to constituents.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
Review of Municipal Plan (overdue by 3 years)
Recycling/waste management
Affordable Housing
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
It’s a tie….
To vote to instate a curbside recycling program for the City of St. John’s and to vote against the Fortis Tower development proposal.
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
Development all over the City, especially in the downtown, heritage core.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
Absolutely necessary and long overdue. There is a pressing need to review the City’s plan in lieu of the economic boom that St. John’s economy is experiencing and the increase in development issues all over the City.
City funding for the arts
With the support of the Arts Advisory Committee, VANL and ACI, I have requested an increase in grants to artists from $1 to $2 per capita in the 2011 budget. I AM an artist and I strongly support an increased investment in our vibrant and economically beneficial cultural community.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
Communities working together is a must, as we share water and waste disposal services, roads and other resource. The City’s infrastructure benefits many communities outside the City limits and all must work together to create an equal opportunity to benefit as well as a responsibility to share in its cost.
Decorum in council
Despite differing opinions, respect is an absolute essential. Council has to work together in an optimal fashion in order to make real improvements in our City.
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
In Canada…. it’s Montreal.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
Aperture, National Geographic
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
My 3 priorities: Review of municipal plan, recycling/waste management, affordable housing.
Hire more city enforcement for litter and property upkeep violations.
Lobby the provincial government for the necessary legislation to ban the use of cosmetic pesticides in the City.
Ongoing replacement of aging infrastructure.
Strengthen the legislation around heritage guidelines.
At Large
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
Consistent with past performance – less flash, more dash! i’m not one to enunciate the obvious; I give credit to the public for their interest and understanding of issues and will speak out when it is important that I make my position clear and when i feel i need to push for a certain resolution to an issue. i prefer to do my work at committee level and one-on-onel.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
- financial control – curtail spending where possible but continue to fund the important services the city provides as well as those provided by third parties.
- the environment – the city (and region) has moved light years recently in this area and will continue to do so as curbside recycling gets underway.
- infrastructure – it has become more and more obvious that the City is unable to sustain it’s own growth in infrastructure needs. we have the oldest infrastructure in the province and need to be developing more as the City grows. we need increased support from the provincial and federal governments to have any chance of catching up.
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
- to initiate the curb-side recycling program. This will bring us up to par with most of the world but with the advantage of modern technology and best practices learned from other cities.
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
- finances and infrastructure – these will always be the two biggest issues, in my opinion; but,at the same time, we must continue to enhance all public services somehow.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
Should have been done 5 years after the previous review. we also should have undertaken a seperate study,in the interim, of the downtown because of it’s transitional state and the pressure on development.
City funding for the arts
City funding for the arts – must be enhanced. I am leading study into the infrstructure needs of the arts in the city and this has to be addressed very soon.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon – a given. thisa must. but I firmly believe that Paradise and mt. pearl should be subsumed by St. John’s, mostly, but smaller portions by CBS and portugal cove-St. phillips
Decorum in council
Decorum in council – feel it is important that all councillors have respect for the people of the city and the office they hold
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
Outside of NL – Montreal, although I dearly miss the Expos!
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
Macleans
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
If I were Mayor, I would encourage council to co-operate as a team and work towards solutions for our pressing financial problems. We have been elected to make tough decisions and we have such in front of us right now.
At Large
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
Difficult to rate your own performance. I guess the only rating that counts is the one from the voter.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
Provision of core services- water, sewer, garbage, snowclearing etc
Prudent financial management – watch the nickels and dimes… the dollars will look out for themselves.
Safe, family oriented city …. recreation, arts, open spaces etc
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
Reducing the mill rate after the civic assessments were done … perhaps could have been a little lower but services would have been affected
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
MONEY, MONEY, MONEY!!!! We are going to continually face tough years ahead in light of water and infrastructure requirements.
PLEASE STATE YOUR OPINIONS/MUSINGS ON THE FOLLOWING MUNICIPAL ISSUES:
Reviewing the Municipal Plan
We should have started our own municipal plan regardless of the larger Regional Plan. Some municipalities have already started theirs. When you think about a Regional Plan aren’t we REALLY talking about St. John’s? We are the Regional Plan! It’s becoming the Regional PAIN.
City funding for the arts
We presently fund the arts at a reasonable level considering our other pressing needs. Yes, we may be able to do a little more but someting else will have to be sacrificed or taxes go up.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
I believe we have reasonable cooperation, but notwithstanding that, there really should be one super city, one council.
Decorum in council
We have very good council deorum. One might even say its “Sleepy Hallow”! YAWN!
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
Montreal, and Tofino.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
No
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
If I were Mayor I’d take all the councillors to dinner every three months…. on my nickel.
At Large
How would you rate your performance during the past year on council?
I have performed to the best of my ability and fel I have been effective.
What are/should be the city’s top three priorities?
three top priorities, control spending and invest more in the core services required by taxpayers. Review of the Municiple Plan with input from ALL interest groups and citizens. A move toward more regional services and more regional co operation.
What was the most important vote you made this past year?
All my votes are important and I think them through before making my decision, given the information provided.
What do you think will be the biggest issue the city will face in the coming year?
The biggest issue is the budget. We are facing a deficit with increased demands for services, increased costs. How to avoid a tax increase while maintaining services.
City funding for the arts
My position is that the Arts are imposrtant to the life of the city as it defines who we are, and it is also an important economic generator so it’s important that the city, along with the province, and the federal government invest in the arts. The question always is at what level can the city afford with all the other pressures placed upon it. The city needs to take a closer look at how we spend out budget to ensure that the funding is spent to the best advantage of the arts community.
Cooperation between towns and cities in the North-East Avalon
As stated, regional co operation is of the utmost importance, especially in the North East Avalon where there is strong growth. We should investigate where there can be more regional co operation, just as we agree on the regional fire dept, regional water supply etc. there are many more regional issues we can be discussing which would ultimately ensure additonal financial efficiencies. Amalgamation in some form is inevitable eventually.
Decorum in council
It has become quieter in the chamber but the old games continue. The protocol has been reviewed and that Mayor is enforcing the rules
Other than St. John’s, do you have a favourite city?
Other than St. JOhn’s I have two favourite cities, Venice and old Montreal.
Do you subscribe to any magazines? If so, which ones?
My reading habits are wide and varied, especially in news and public affairs, while Macleans and Time are important, newspapers and electronic media are my main sources of information.
If I were Mayor, I would _________.
At this point in time I am not looking at becoming Mayor, but things can change.
Click here to read our city council report card for 2010.
Tue, Nov 30, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call from the bunker on New Gower St.
Council has begun to arrive, and I am again joined by several striking Metrobus workers in the gallery.
Breen and Galgay have been out here for about 5 min, but no one else is. They are joking that there is another meeting they weren’t invited to.
Breen: “We’re on the B-list”
Here comes O’Keefe, and the meeting will begin (10 min late).
Ten min late isn’t even that bad for them. If I was council’s boss they would get an earful …Not yet.
The author of the book “Occupied St. John’s 1939-1945″ is donating a copy to the City Archives. Apparently the archives were a great help in researching the book.
All of council is here except Gerry Colbert.
The Independent Living Resource Centre (ILRC) is holding an open house on Dec. 3rd for international day of disabled persons.
The ILRC also wants to thank the city for it’s work for those with disabilities, and note that they have been nominated for an award.
The award the city has been nominated for is for their work on the para-transit system.
Duff is giving a report of the Finance Committee.
There was some discussion at the committee that the guidelines for sponsorship of conferences and conventions should be reviewed.
The finance committee shows that there (may be) a nearly $1mil surplus in 2010. This is unsure as there are outstanding invoices which could change.
Tilley wants to note that that the city will waive $40k of fees and permits as their contribution to Ronald McDonald house (to be built).
There was also a meeting of the Condominium Services Committee. There was discussion as to whether or not this committee should exist.
Most of council thinks it should stay, and recognize that there are going to be more and more condos going up all the time in all parts of the city.
Breen wants to see a terms of reference drawn up and membership of the committee looked at.
The regional water rates have been set by the Regional Water Committee for 2011.
The Regional Water committee is a perfect example of how the NE Avalon can play nice. We just need to figure out how to do this more often.
The Animal Care Committee discussed the animal euthanasia program, and whether or not to charge a fee (it was free to have your animal put down).
In 2009, the city spent $112k to euthanize public and shelter pets. They are looking at an increase of $40k for 2011.
They are recommending charging a fee of $105 for cats and $145 for dogs. They also include a clause to allow for no fee if the owner cannot pay. Their research shows that most municipalities do not even offer this service, and the ones that do charge a fee.
O’Keefe wants to know how city staff will determine financial need for owners who say they can’t pay.
Collins wants to know why it is more to euthanize dogs then cats. Apparently it is based on size and weight.
Council has voted to charge a fee for the euthanasia program.
O’Keefe says he stopped down when Republic of Doyle was filming at City Hall yesterday.
Apparently Allan Hawco has offered to give the city some of the panoramic views the show has shot to the city for use in the Municipal Plan.
The tender for the Quidi Vidi Arts Visitors centre has been awarded for $2.5 mil (aprox.).
Galgay: “This [the centre] will be the jewel in the crown of Quidi Vidi Village”
They are discussing the membership of the Bannerman Park Committee. There will be four members of council on the committee.
Collins says they should take the Lt. Gov’s house and make Bannerman park twice as big. (I agree. Take that, Monarchy!)
Galgay wants to thank the DT Development Corp. (DDC) and all the businesses and organizations which made the Santa Claus parade.
O’Keefe: “I venture that there were 50,000 people down there”
Hann says that the DDC reports they collected 20,000 lbs of food and $10,000 in cash at the parade. Nice job everyone!
I don’t know if anyone else saw the city’s float, but I was decidedly underwhelmed. It was like they went to Kent and spend $400 on Christmas lawn ornaments, and put them on a trailer.
Tilley says that he went to an open house on the Team Gushue hwy extension, and he “wasn’t impressed”.
O’Keefe says that the province will construct the road, but the citizens of St. John’s will bear the cost of maintenance.
(Check out my first article for the scope, which covers this in more detail)
O’Keefe says he is going to instruct city staff to look further into the possibility of putting a toll on the road. He says they were already advised they would not be able to put a toll on the road.
O’Keefe has again said that “this points to the necessity of amalgamation” (in reference to Team Gushue Hwy.)
O’Leary wants to congratulate Robert Chafe (Governor General’s Literary Award) and The Once (Canadian Folk Awards) for winning their respective awards.
O’Keefe stopped O’Leary on this one (and Tilley earlier), and said they have a policy that says council is not to announce individual winners, deaths, or such, as they would be there all night if they got into that.
Duff says the deadline for non-profit community groups to apply for funding for 2011 is Dec.16th.
That’s all folks. I will be gone next week, so if you want the DL on council, you will have to come down yourself, dammit.
Tue, Nov 23, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the blow-by-blow of your city council at work.
The gallery is again guest to striking transport workers from Metrobus. They are looking for the city to intervene to end their strike.
They may be barking up the wrong tree coming here. Council seems to have no appetite to step into what they do not see as their fight.
O’Keefe has arrived, and the meeting has begun. All here but Colbert and Galgay.
Sheilagh O’Leary is moving to rescind the previous motion to amend development regulations in regards to the Signal Hill proposal.
The motion was rescinded quickly, without so much as speaking the words “signal hill”.
They are discussing a proposal for a 6-story Condominium on Tiffany Lane. This is beside Kenny’s pond.
They are looking for approval-in-principle for this. The proposal includes 52 indoor and 13 outdoor parking spaces.
Hanlon: “My concern is that we are not involving the public in this.” she says it is a good proposal, but the public need to be involved.
Apparently the proposal does not specifically require a public hearing as it is a permitted use for the area.
O’Keefe does not seem to want to delay this vote, and says Hanlon could go ahead with a public awareness meeting.
Duff says that while she knows that this is a permitted use for the area, she herself does not have enough information. There is no site plan included in what she got.
Duff is concerned about the impact on a nearby school and church.
Hann: “I can’t believe what I’m hearing”, he says in reference to other councillors “there is no reason we should not let this go ahead”
Hickman reiterates that this plan was approved in 2005, and has not changed substantially since.
Duff has made a motion to defer the proposal for one week so that council can get more information.
Motion to defer denied, Breen, Hann, Tilley, Collins, and O’Keefe against.
Proposal approved, with Hanlon voting against.
The city is being asked to help fund the creation of Bannerman Park Foundation Inc. a citizen group to help inform changes to Bannerman park
This non-profit will help to raise money to implement upgrades to the Park. The cost they need now is only $70 for incorporation.
Hann wants to know what the costs to the city will be. Duff says they are looking for $15k for this year, subject to availability.
There is also a long-term ask here which Hann is trying to get at. Duff says the cost will not be known until they decide on what they want. Now I see, the foundation would be created to fund-raise, and cost-share improvements to the park.
Collins wants to know why there will be 3 or 4 members of council on this board, and he is the only member on the Bowring park foundation.
O’Keefe says he wants to look at the funding mechanism here. He says that Bowring Park foundation is not an automatic 50/50 cost sharing.
O’Keefe says it is not clear to him that this 50/50 funding would not be automatic, and wants it explicitly stated.
Breen says that the last time any significant money was put into Bannerman park was the 1970′s for the ball field.
Council voted to help in the creation of this foundation, but with the stipulation that any funding requests must be approved by council, as is the case with the Bowring Park foundation.
Republic of Doyle is asking to film at city hall! O’Keefe says he can make himself available.
O’Leary is bringing up concerns with eastern health workers smoking on public property around long pond.
O’Leary: Dialogue has been going on for some time and there has been no action. “It is on our property, and we have to do something about it”
O’Leary says we need signage, receptacles, and enforcement. O’Keefe is asking for the cost.
O’Keefe: “We’re not going to be the cigarette police.” he says we put $15k [$1,500 -- corrected amount] into the butt it campaign, and it went “up in smoke”
O’Leary was hear to say “that is a terrible reaction” to O’Keefe’s cynicism, and reluctance to take action on this matter.
O’Keefe brings this back to that it is a budget item. “It’s not a terrible reaction, it’s realistic reaction”.
O’Keefe: “Signs are not going to make a difference, I don’t think they are going to make a difference”
O’Keefe and O’Leary are having a spirited argument about this, and the effectiveness of signage.
Hann says he agrees that something needs to be done in those areas, but an “attitudinal change” is needed, and that can’t be legislated.
Hanlon says that at the Northeast Avalon Regional Economic Development Board they are concerned as to where the Province’s Regional Plan stands.
There is no new information from Duff, or city staff on the regional plan, and it is still in the Minister’s hands.
The Economic Development association is also developing a local foods map. If you sell local food, get in touch to be included.
Hickman says that the city should look at putting a west end pool into the same location as the new proposed school for the west end.
Duff says that in the recreation plan they are looking to include some community-based organizations in the design if the school.
Duff says they should setup a meeting with the Dept. Of Education to discuss the design of new schools.
Collins is asking what time people should be putting garbage out. Staff says 6am is the earliest it should be out.
O’Keefe takes note of the bus drivers again, and hopes for a quick resolution to their impasse.
That’s all folks. Tweet you next week for more council craziness.
Mon, Nov 22, 2010
The last couple of months I’ve been looking for an apartment to rent in St. John’s, and I found there’s really very little for rent in the city. So I started to consider the available options which include either renting a condo downtown for upwards of 2000 dollars a month (?!), or living in a basement apartment somewhere far away from work and getting a car. Neither of these seemed very appealing to me, and I bet there are a lot of people in a similar situation. In fact I know there are, just from the amount of ‘apartment wanted’ ads in local media like Kijiji. To the chagrin of would-be downtown renters, it looks like the place to live in St. John’s right now is the suburbs.
The suburbs are no longer housing-only areas, where inhabitants commute to and from the downtown core every day. They are transforming to become small, self-contained satellite cities on the edge of a larger city. There’s a school, a salon, a family-friendly restaurant, a sports bar, and maybe even the office building in which you work. In theory, you never really have to leave your neighbourhood. Many suburbs around St. John’s are starting to look like this, or already do. And it’s attractive for many people who find living downtown just too noisy, congested, crime-ridden, and expensive in comparison.
On the other hand, we all know the negative effects of suburban sprawl. The obliteration of our forests, property tax hikes for everyone, and generic architecture. The American Journal of Public Health and the American Journal of Health Promotion, have both stated that there is a significant connection between sprawl, obesity, and hypertension.
But my biggest beef is that there’s nowhere to go, besides the Costco parking lot, to be around people in a public space. There’s no place to hang out that isn’t centered around buying stuff.
One might say a suburban lifestyle is more individualistic, if you compare it to living in an apartment building where many of the domestic services are shared. Things like laundry, garbage collection and recycling, parking, heat and hot water, a gym. I once lived in a building that had three parking spaces reserved for a car-share service, which was outrageously convenient and economical. The services become part of a ‘public life,’ and you become a part of public life. The sacrifice you make is the abundance of privacy and space.
Why should we worry about this now? Our city is growing—and needs to be growing in a more thoughtful manner. Last year our population grew by 0.5 per cent, the largest increase since 1983. And by the end of 2010, another increase of 0.5 per cent is expected, translating into several thousand people migrating to Newfoundland. New housing ‘starts’ are expected to increase 1.5 per cent, to 3102 houses, and almost two thirds of these new houses are located in St. John’s. At the same time, rental vacancy rates in St. John’s are at an historic low of 0.9 per cent, and there is little or no development of new rental spaces.
Limiting subdivision development might not be a bad idea. It would help preserve the natural areas we still have on the Avalon, and I believe it would be in our collective social and economic best interests. While some Canadian municipalities have successfully adopted ‘urban growth boundaries’ to limit the sprawl, there would naturally be debate about how much of a role our governments should have in determining whether we choose to live a communal lifestyle in the core of the city, or in an unattached house in the quiet suburbs.
The bigger question, perhaps, is how can we stop developers from making irresponsible subdivisions? How can we ensure new developments reflect Newfoundland culture through architecture? And, as a city, how much do we prioritize public space, places where you can go to be with people? Flattening a forest to make a clean slate for a subdivision is easy. The alternative—working on already developed areas—requires designers, planners, impact studies, a lot of time and a lot of careful consideration.
But it might just be worth it.
Tue, Nov 16, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal madness, live from the gallery of council.
Striking Metrobus workers have again made their way down to council to try and encourage council to intervene to end their strike.
Metrobus workers are joined by members of MUNSU, who are supporting them.
There is an interesting memo at the end of the agenda from the owners of the Star of the Sea Hall to buy 7 parking spots owned by the city.
The memo says that the city would maintain control of the parking, butneed the land for “calculation purposes” to make the building larger.
Council is starting to file in now, twelve min late already I might add. I will have to scold them for their tardiness.
O’Keefe has arrived. All of council is here except Frank Galgay.
A young girl, Juiliana, who won a contest to be Fire Chief for the day, is here.
She won a fire safety poster making contest. Her poster has some good tips such as call 911 and stop, drop, and roll.
Colbert points out that the girl is from Mount Pearl. O’Keefe says that some day she may be he fire chief of an amalgamated city.
There are two kids here who won a contest for National Child day to “Meet the Mayor”. O’Keefe has given up his seat for them.
They are announcing events for National Child day, for ore info go to www.stjohns.ca
It is World Peace week, an effort of the YMCA.
It is also crohn’s and colitis awarness month.
NL has the highest rate of irritable bowel syndrome in Canada. They hope to find a cure in the next 20 years.
This week is also National Bullying awareness week. This week is many things it turns out.
O’Keefe says St. John’s is striving to be bully-free. Bullying is a problem for not only kids in school, but adults in workplaces too.
I think we should give some anti-bullying info to Bruce Tilley, they ride him some hard sometimes.
O’Keefe recognizes the striking Metrobus workers and hopes that their issues with Metrobus are resolved quickly.
O’Keefe is careful to stay well away from directly being involved in the strike issues.
The Board of SJ sports Entertainment project next year they will only need a subsidy of $1.25 million. They are greatly improving over time.
This projected needed subsidy is down from over $2 mil 4 years ago. The final game of the womens hockey tournament was sold out on Sat!
The board of SJSE says their goal is to continue to bring events to SJ, and ultimately get a hockey team back.
Hann says that over the years he has been highly opinionated about Mile One, but wants to thank the Board for reducing the subsidy so much.
O’Leary has made a notice of motion to rescind a precious motion to make changes to development regulations for Signal Hill.
That was a tweet-full, but it essentially means they will not change the regulations because the Signal Hill development is not happening
Council is moving to reject a proposal for an extension to a garage in Paradise because it is in the watershed.
Tilley says he has asked staff to look at alternatives to allow for quarries within the city. Apparently they get aggregate from Terra Nova.
Hanlon has a petition from the Residents of Winter Ave to turn it into a cul-de-sac to reduce traffic.
A motion has been made on the Star of the Sea Hall, and the cities parking.
Duff is asking for clarification on how the city will maintain the spaces for residents of the area.
The sale of this parking has gone ahead. It seems a bit weird to me, and I wonder whatthe whole thing is about.
Hanlon wants a letter of congratulations to go to Ches Penney who was apointed to the order of Canada.
Hanlon also says that she thinks the recycling program is going ahead fine on a voluntary basis.
Wally Collins is also receiving complaints about truckers bringing heavy equipment into the Teakwood development before 7am.
Staff says that they have a huge wood chipper from the CB mill which will deal with all the Igor deadfall in 7-10 days.
On the topic of construction noise early in the morning, Danny Breen says he has met with homebuilders, will talk to staff and come back.
Staff says construction on Brookfield rd should be done by the first week of Dec.
Hickman has asked about hunting within the city. The lawyer says discharging a firearm is only allowed in some parts of the Goulds.
Duff reminds people of a conference on funding affordable housing the city is hosting next week.
Duff is asking why biodegradable blue bags are not allowed in our recycling program. Staff says it is because they are not recyclable.
My question would be how in the hell would they know the bag was biodegradable when they collected it?
Anyways folks, that’s all she wrote for today. Tweet you next week.
Tue, Nov 9, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
The St. John’s city council liveblog: keeping the public informed on municipal matters, 140 characters at a time.
Andrew Harvey here in the gallery of council chambers to bring you the call.
It is a packed house here tonight folks, a huge contingent from the Amalgamated Transit Union local 1462. Metrobus workers.
The Metrobus workers are on strike, and have showed up in numbers to encourage council to settle their labour dispute.
After council there will also be the one and only public consultation on the 2011 budget. Immediately following the meeting in Foran room.
Come on down to have your voice heard on how you want the city to spend your money! Should be around 6-6:30pm.
There is a delegation here for Restorative Justice week.
The next delegation are the two winners of a $1000 scholarship from the city.
One girl is in nursing, and is the daughter of an employee in the Public works dept.
The guy is hoping to do Pharmacy, and is the son of an employee in the finance dept.
There is a delegation for Archives Week. This is to encourage people to become aware of, and use archives.
It is world town planning day! How exciting. A fitting day to be planning for the 2011 budget. Come down to the Foran room for 6pm!
All of council is here today. There will also be a vote to rescind the approval of the signal hill proposal. Looks like it is crown land.
O’Keefe welcome the bus drivers, and says he hopes that their issues are resolved as soon as possible.
Apparently the rules of council do not allow for signs to be displayed, and O’Keefe has asked them to take them down. They have complied.
Danny Breen is commenting on a question from a previous meeting about service charges on tickets at Mile One.
Breen says that the service costs come because they use a 3rd party company, and says they review this service and cost.
O’Keefe also noticed a group here from the Save our Signal Hill group, and said that they will vote on that right away so they can go home to their suppers. The Signal Hill vote normally would have been at the end of the meeting.
O’Leary has made her motion to rescind.
The Crown owns at least some of the land which is included in the proposal, and would have to sign off on it.
Apparently there is mention of a lease (from the crown), on the deeds dating back to 1949. They do not know where this lease is, but apparently this is enough to determine the crown’s stake.
O’Leary wants to thank the public, the Save Our Signal Hill committee, and the individual who brought forward the question over ownership.
O’Leary is suggesting that they look at more in depth title searches for areas with historic significance, and complicated ownership issues
Colbert also thanks the people who brought this forward, and applauds them, and assures people they will be heard in council in such cases.
Breen also says he will support the rescinding, and says the new information changed it as it is no longer private property.
Duff says that they could require proponents of proposals in such historic areas to prove ownership. This could have saved a lot of time.
Duff also says she would like to see what the original PHP report recommended, to rezone the area to Open Space.
O’Keefe says he is sure the Telegram will criticize them tomorrow but there is nothing wrong with changing your mind because of new information.
O’Keefe reminds people that often developers do not own the land when they submit the proposal, this is normal.
There was a public hearing for a proposal off Ruby Line to rezone land from Rural Zone to Residential Low Density.
Tilley says that there are 13 main issues that the public had with this proposal, and the main unaddressed one was the buffer.
This re-zoning is for 18 hectares! Lotta land, especially when they are 450 square Meter lots.
Tilley says the Developer removed 9 lots from one area which was contentious.
Tilley says this would be about $550k/year in taxes for the city.
Wally Collins says he will not support this. He says they are turning old Bay Bulls rd into a floodplain with all the houses in there.
They all want to commend Councillor Tilley for all the work he has put in on this in allaying citizens concerns. Apparently this has been months in the making.
Tilley made up a chart with the 13 major concerns, and what the city and developer are doing to address them.
Hann says that the Southlands is a long-term development, and many of these issues such as traffic and servicing will need to be addressed.
Hann says that his major concern is the buffer which is in place, and that current residents bought with the promise of a buffer there.
The proposal was approved, with Hann, and Collins voting against.
The Municipal Plan will need to be changed to rezone this land to allow the proposal to go ahead.
Galgay is discussing the proposed redevelopment of some land on Shaw St, off Topsail rd. It would require rezoning of land also.
Apparently they are going to be doing a good job of keeping most of the old trees on the property.
Duff: “Of all the proposals we have seen for this land, it is the most respectful of the properties historic nature” This is the third proposal they have seen for this property, the first two were rejected.
The re-zoning was approved. This will allow 11 new homes on the property.
A development in Port. Cove-St. Philip’s, in the watershed, was rejected to make an extension of their home. Because it was an increase of more then 50% in size.
Apparently they are not allowed to approve extensions for over 50% of area under regulations.
Council has approved to pay for a Santa Shuttle for the Christmas Parade. This will only go ahead if the Metrobus strike is over.
O’Keefe says that Ron Penney (city manager) has submitted his intent to retire on Jan 1st. They will start an open process to replace him.
City Clerk, Neil Martin will be acting City Manager until a replacement is found.
That’s all folks. Tweet you next week. Hurry down if you are coming for budgetary consultations.
Mon, Nov 8, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
The St. John’s city council liveblog: council you can enjoy without putting pants on.
Andrew Harvey here (regrettably, with pants) to bring you the call of all the municipal goings-on from the bunker on New Gower St.
Council chambers is jammed with kids and parents for Walk to school day! Much more lively then the normal, nearly-vacant quiet.
The kids are excited for the arrival of the mayor, and seem impressed by the gold scepter which the commissionaire is holding.
O’Keefe has arrived, and the meeting begins. O’Keefe is shaking kids’ hands.
Everyone appears to be here except Debbie Hanlon.
The first delegation is here for Downs Syndrome Awareness Week.
The week is important to promote the strengths and contributions of those with Downs Syndrome are. Like anyone, we need to focus on strengths.
Come out to the Mt Pearl Reid Ctr on Sat at 1:30pm for a family-friendly event.
Now is a massive delegation for Wall to School week. Kids from 12 schools are here!
The main themes of the week are promoting safe walking, physical activity, environmental impact, and decreasing traffic congestion.
O’Keefe says that if the kids study hard and work hard they can be mayor too.
RT @towniebastard @thescopeNL Is that a threat?
Larkhall Academy won $500 for participating in Walk to School day. Congratulations to them!
There is a father and daughter here for Diabetes Awareness Week. The girl participates in the city’s diabetes summer camp.
O’Keefe says that Banting discovered insulin today, way back when. This discovery has had a huge impact on those with diabetes.
Gary Brown is here with his book Fallen Boy Soldiers.
The book is about the Royal Newfoundland Regiment, and the many people who lied about their age to fight in WWI.
The Uncle of Frank Galgay was one of the men who lied about their age and died in the war.
Frank Galgay says that this book is a important contribution to the history of the Royal Newfoundland Regiment.
Apparently people in Ireland were impressed that O’Keefe too the time to visit schools when he was over there. Way to represent us Dennis.
There was a public hearing for the traffic calming policy. Colbert says there was a good crowd, and some good comments and suggestions.
Colbert assures people that the implementation of the traffic calming policy on individual streets will be an inclusive process with public.
The streets will be prioritized, and looked at in order, each of which will have to be approved in the budgetary process.
O’Leary says that information on the classification of streets would be interesting to post on the website. She has asked for this.
There was also a meeting about a proposal for a seniors’ home in Kilbride. It would require a rezoning to go ahead.
The city received a petition of 187 residents opposed to the rezoning of the land. Main concerns are about traffic, view-planes, and flooding
These traffic concerns have been referred to city staff to look at it. The applicant has asked it be deferred for a traffic study.
Hickman says that a proper traffic study is not on the way, and moves for rejection.
Wally Collins says “to put anything else there is crazy… He can put 5 or 6 houses there, and that is what he should do.”
Apparently the location is already bad for traffic, and 69 rooms for seniors would make this much worse.
Galgay says that soon 1/3 of the province will be seniors, this type of development is not intrusive, and will not affect traffic.
Tilley: “The traffic issues were there 20 years ago when I was on council… I want to speak on behalf of seniors.”
Breen: “This is not about seniors, this is about a major traffic problem that already exists. We cannot go in and make the situation worse”
O’Leary says that she also visited the site, and although we have a need for this type of development, it is not an appropriate site.
Colbert says that when someone moves into a certain area, they have an expectation about the zoning.
Colbert says that we need inclusive planning that takes into account all types of needs, such as the Pleasantville redevelopment.
Colbert is making reference to Pleasantville because a huge bunch of land is being rezoned, with a mix of types, residential and apartment.
Duff says that she initially was in favour of this because she approached it through a seniors’ lens but changed her mind when she went there.
Duff says the site is on a slope and a bend in the road, and could potentially be dangerous.
Duff says that she is aware that we have a need for this type of development.
Motion to reject the application passed, Galgay and Tilley voted against.
The Credit Union on Water St has an application to reconstruct Pasta Plus that burned down last year as an extension to the Credit Union.
The new part will be 3 storeys high, and because it uses the existing layout of the former building, it will not require adding parking.
This sounds like a cop-out to me, the city recently removed a exemption for parking requirements DT, why not make them add parking?
Hann presented the Para-Transit advisory committee report. They recommend that there be a yearly public meeting on para-transit.
The first yearly para-transit public meeting will be mid- to late-November.
In the tenders there is one for Ammonia, which was awarded for $70k. The only other bid was $241k, that’s whack! Makes you wonder.
The city will be paying $25k in costs Mile One incurred for The Igor relief concert.
The Mayor has recognized a bunch of members of the Board of Trade, and says they are here because of money. There will be a budget update.
In the Economic Update, building permits are up 107% over last year!
O’Keefe says that we are very close to an agreement between the airport authority and the province for a new Cat 3 landing system.
Duff says that the Public consultation on the Budget will be on Nov. 8th, not the 9th. Right after council. Come on out, this is important.
Duff and O’Leary both want to thank Dave Lane for his work on the Your City, Your Ideas forum held over the weekend. yourideas.happycity.ca
O’Keefe says that he is happy so many people are interested in the future of the city, and he will listen to those who came sat and the Board of Trade
Breen wants to remind people that his year in the East End the leaf drop-off will be by Quidi Vidi, not St. Pat’s like usual.
Galgay says of HappyCity.ca, that they will have the same opportunity to present issues to council as any organization.
Duff is clarifying that happycity.ca is not a lobby organization, but provides an opportunity for discussion.
O’Keefe says that 104,000 lbs of waste was diverted from the landfill in the first week of recycling.
That’s all for the regular meeting. There is going to be a brief presentation on the budget process.
Make sure you all come to the public meeting on Nov 8th to give your input on the budget for 2011. It will be a tight one people.
That’s it for this week people, Andrew Harvey out. Tweet you next week.
Thu, Oct 28, 2010

Photo by Darrell Edwards
Our city is going through some big changes. It’s time to be thinking big.
Compiled and edited by Sarah Smellie, Andrew Harvey, Kerri Breen, Bryhanna Greenough and Elling Lien. Thought balloon photo by Darrell Edwards. Collages by Elling Lien.
Kerri Breen
Metrobus has its problems – but would you ride more if it were free?
A recent Toronto Star online feature makes the argument that free public transit “Might be worth consideration for smaller communities that are struggling to grow transit ridership.” Cough.
Though the number of Metrobus riders has pretty much stabilized in the last 10 years, it has declined considerably from its former glory. Metrobus’ ridership peaked in 1985. Back then, there were almost a million more riders per year than there are now. A million.
And when you consider how much municipal governments are already funding Metrobus rides, offering free service is not really too much of a stretch.
Your $2.25 (or $1.75) covers a little more than half the costs. For every hour Metrobus was on the road in 2008, it cost about $84. Revenues, however, were about $50.
What it would actually take for this to happen: A lot. Those holding the purse strings aren’t going to spring for it unless they have evidence that offering free rides will increase ridership. And the results of the summer of 2009’s downtown Buddy Bus experiment were not exactly encouraging. Plus, they would need the money to do it, and the St. John’s Transportation Commission recently shelled out millions for a new bus depot.

Kerri Breen, Bryhanna Greenough and Elling Lien
New Brunswick has Crystal Palace, Nova Scotia has Upper Clements Parks and Newfoundland has… a travelling fair that serves its purpose well enough.
But! What about a theme park with a roller coaster? A historical reenactment village, with salty Newfoundland pirates? Yar, tourists would be all over that like bright red paint on a row house. And it would have other benefits too. Upper Clements Parks, in Nova Scotia, for example, employs about 200 people and generates about $6 million in economic activity locally. It is run by a volunteer non-profit called group called the Hanse Society. But, of course, ours would be for profit.
But where would we build it? We can’t think of a better location than Bell Island. First of all, it’s enchanted. Second of all, they already have some of the infrastructure you would need: spooky mine shafts, mine carts, ice cream and fish and chips.
Sure, there are people living there now, but they could be relocated, and with minimal effort, a splash of paint and a little bit of imagination, we could convert the island, in its entirety, into a passable Disney World knock-off.
The ferry ride would only add to the experience. Can’t you already imagine the pirate costumes and sea shanties blaring through the sound system? I know we can imagine The Flanders with tattered sails and a gang plank, and the Beaumont Hamel with a crow’s nest and chests overflowing with plastic doubloons.
Sure, most people would see this as a slap in the face of history and good taste, but think of the local economy! Think of the children!
Now, to think of a mascot…
What it would actually take for this to happen: Canada’s Wonderland took nine years and $121 million to establish, and that was in the late ‘70s and early ‘80s. This year, Six Flags emerged from Chapter 11 bankruptcy after ditching a billion dollars of debt. But there have been ACOA grants for crazier things. We say give ‘er.
Andrew Harvey
We already have some great community groups here in St. John’s like the Georgestown Neighbourhood Association, and the brand-spanking-new Outer Battery Neighbourhood Association, but imagine how many we could have if they had a little support to get themselves off the ground, and running effectively. The more you talk to your neighbours, the more you can work with them to identify and address mutual concerns. It might be something like deciding on a day to get the whole street out to sweep up the garbage you all complain about, or it may be putting together a letter to send to your ward councillor to make them aware of a parking issue which has been bugging everyone for a while.
The city of Toronto has five Community Development Officers, each responsible for a section of the city. Their role is to provide in-kind support for individuals and groups looking to build strong communities. They can assist with community planning. They can help organizations start, plan, and get their finances in order, and can point them in the right direction for programs.
What it would actually take for this to happen: About $50k and a desk in city hall. With a budget of over $200 million, anyone who is looking hard enough can find the money to fund a position like that. More important is having a council who is serious about community development, and willing to recognize that citizen engagement is worth it.
The City of Toronto’s Community Development web page: www.bit.ly/aULnuO
Sarah Smellie
For some, these can be lonely shores to land on. It’s a bit alienating to have your hometown culture yanked out from under you and replaced with that of some homogeneous, sometimes hostile, place called “Away.” And then there’s all that boiled meat to get accustomed to.
So why not make the transition smoother for everyone? Let’s set up CFAs of all origin with welcoming Newfoundland families who’ll have them over for dinner and feed them through isolating times, like Sundays, Thanksgiving and Christmas, when they miss their families and friends back home in Away.
What it would actually take for this to happen: Maybe not much.
Yvonne Collett is the former coordinator of the Christmas Holiday Hosting Event, organized through MUN’s International Student Advising Office.
“We recruit families who are interested in hosting an international student, usually for a Christmas or holiday dinner,” she explains. “We get lots of students participating. For many, this is their first opportunity to go into a Canadian home.”
She doesn’t have much trouble recruiting families, either, saying that they’ve never had too few families, and many of them now approach her, instead of the other way around.
Coordinating the program, she says, isn’t all that much work. “The more people involved, the longer it’d take to organize,” she says. “But on a city-wide level, I think it’s do-able. Definitely.”
Find yourself some funding and call yourself Coordinator, and you could soon have one of the best jobs in town.
Andrew Harvey
The City of St. John’s has supported the creation of several small community gardens, but with the rising interest and action on food-security here on this island of ours, many people would like to see the City get their hands dirty to help support community gardens, literally. In 2006, Vancouver City Council unanimously supported a motion by Councillor Peter Ladner to challenge the residents of Vancouver to create 2010 new community garden plots by January 1st, 2010. Residents responded in force, not only meeting the goal, but exceeding it, creating 2029 new community garden plots. This amazing feat was completed through a series of brilliantly simple programs such as the Sharing Backyard program, which is essentially a complex google map identifying individuals who have space in their backyard they are willing to share, and those who need space to garden in. Another fantastic initiative used was the Grow a Row, Share a Row, based off an initiative by the Canadian Association of Food Banks.
What it would actually take for this to happen: Council needs to identify food security as a priority, and issue a challenge similar to that of Vancouver. The real beauty of a challenge like this, and the means Vancouver used to achieve it, is that it requires little or no money to do. Fire up a Google Map and figure out how to put the right dots on it, and we are off to the races. This could even be rolled into the $80k city website redesign… Hmmm…
You can find details about the Vancouver project at bit.ly/atrRSU.
Kerri Breen
St. John’s and free public Wi-Fi — think it’s just a pipe, or tube, dream? Well, it’s happened before.
In 2004, the City of Fredericton launched Fred-eZone, a free city-wide Wi-Fi for visitors, residents and businesses. There are over 120 access points around the city, and according to Tony von Richter, who went to university in Fredericton, it’s decent.
“I can’t say how fast download speeds are or anything like that, but for basic web functionality it seemed to work fine,” von Richter said. He added that there are some dead areas.
Montreal, Toronto, Moncton, Regina, Saskatoon and several other cities have some form of municipal wireless service.
What it would actually take for this to happen: The bad news first: If Fredericton is any example, it will take a long time. According to a white paper on the topic, it took four years to “form a non-dominate carrier company, construct the fiber optic network, deploy the point to multi-point wireless network, and finally, to deploy over 120 Cisco Wi-Fi access points in the field.” (Glaven).
The good news is that it had been done using existing budgeted dollars by re-investing the city’s telecom savings back into the network and by accepting commercial subscribers on the network. The private sector also kicked in over $250,000.
St. John’s would have to think of a better name than “Fred-eZone” though.
Thu, Oct 28, 2010

Collage by Elling Lien
Leslie Vryenhoek
Writer and communications consultant
The St. John’s Solarium—Imagine: it’s mid-May, the 26th straight day of drizzle and fog after a long, dismal winter. You can’t bear to turn on the television or answer the phone and find out how the rest of the country is soaking up the warm spring sun, so you toss some summer duds in a bag, grab the sunscreen and head out. No, you’re not going to the airport—you’re just spending yet another day (after all, you have an annual pass) in the world’s only indoor tropical island, an underground mecca (change rooms on the second floor let you leave your boots behind!) with high-above sunlamps to offer a Vitamin D dose and take the edge off your pasty. Real tropical plants, constantly refreshed air (heated, of course, geothermally), a wave pool for the kids, street vendors, outdoor cafes… At night, the sun goes down, the moon and stars come out and local musicians take the stage at the patio bars.
God I wish somebody would build it. Sure, it would take massive private/public investment, but imagine the tourism potential—and the mental health rewards.
Liam Herringshaw
Professor, MUN Dept. of Earth Sciences
It took me a while to notice, but Newfoundland faces the wrong way.
St. John’s harbour looks east, to Europe, to Britain, to the colonial powers, the fishermen and the settlers. No one returns its gaze. Influx comes from the airport or the Trans-Canada Highway.
Out west, behind Newfoundland’s back, Canada carries on regardless. With a new capital city on the Gulf of St Lawrence, St. John’s could return to its life as a harbour town – the jelly bean houses and Signal Hill bringing in the tourists, and the choppers and trawlers shipping out the petroleum workers. Its tedious western sprawl would be wiped happily off the face of the Earth.
A capital in western Newfoundland would connect the province to its country. Rather than a 600 kilometer drive from Port-aux-Basques to the Avalon, people could be off the ferry and into the city in no time. The other Atlantic provinces would suddenly be an island-hop away.
There would be no need for the preposterous food miles required to shift groceries all the way across the island, no need for the trans-Canada highway to be potholed into oblivion by a steady stream of juggernauts.
Memorial University could switch its campuses around, making Wilfred Grenfell College the main focus of attention and leaving St John’s as the satellite centre. For marine biology, geology, geography and other earth and life sciences, the west coast is far more suited to study than the barren, boggy terrain of the Avalon.
Then there’s the weather. The west coast gets warmer, drier summers and reliably snowy winters. The skiing around Marble Mountain could be a genuine centre of snow sports.
Walter Parsons,
Engineer
To make public transit attractive to St. John’s residents, we should build a BRT (bus rapid transit) system that would form the core of a redesigned Metrobus. Specific arterial transit routes should be identified and their roadways upgraded to enable the features of a rapid transit network. Like similar systems in Halifax and Saskatoon, these routes would include transit-priority traffic signals, bus stations with improved shelters at major destinations, access to park-and-ride facilities, less stops than traditional bus routes, and frequent continuous service that would allow users to use the rapid bus system without the need to consult a schedule (service intervals of ten minutes or less). Less frequent neighbourhood routes could connect to the BRT system at major stations – perhaps using smaller vehicles. The BRT busway could feature extended service hours and could even be designed to allow for the possibility to upgrade to light rail as the city grows.
Part of the BRT network could be built along the Columbus Drive-Prince Philip parkway to link St. John’s east to west, serving the Village and Avalon Malls, the Health Sciences complex, Memorial University, Confederation Building, and the College of the North Atlantic along the way. Bus stations (at intersections with transit-priority traffic lights) would need to be added to the parkway to allow buses to quickly merge in and out of traffic. Major thoroughfares into the downtown would also need to be upgraded with bus-only lanes where required. The new system, if implemented properly, could make a major difference to traffic and parking problems in the city core.
Mon, Oct 25, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal shenanigans from the bunker on New Gower.
Council is assembling in anticipation of the arrival of O’Keefe.
O’Keefe has arrived, preceded by a gold scepter, announcing his arrival.
There is a delegation here from Ford Mustangs in the Park. The first Mustang in the world was sold here in Newfoundland!
We got the first Mustang made because we were the furthest place they were sent.
It is in the Henry Ford museum, still with Newfoundland plates from 1964.
Now there is a delegation about getting your flu shot. O’Keefe is going to get a flu shot right now! Live! He’s no wimp.
The nurse administering the shot says that it especially important for seniors, children under two, and those who have compromised health.
They are discussing the amendments to the Municipal Plan which would allow extra height on Water St West.
They had a public hearing scheduled for Sept. 15th, but it was canceled because they did not receive any written complaints.
Galgay is saying that a proposal for the old Woolworths building is an “excellent proposal, and will serve the city well.”
Tilley says that it will be a $40 million dollar development, and will create many excellent construction jobs.
Tilley also says that it will add parking, “Class A office space”, and retail space, as well as $1.2 million in taxes to the city.
Duff says that she has supported this from the beginning and “has received some flak for it.”
Duff is mentioning a letter from fellow former Ward 2 candidate Bill Maddigan, who is concerned about keeping the history and retail space.
O’Keefe: “It gets rid of what was a terrible eyesore in our city”
There was a public meeting about the rezoning of some land on Golf Ave from Apartment Medium Density to Residential Medium Density.
Hann says that there were only three people who attended, and the concerns were minor, and have been addressed.
They are recommending rejection of a home business to distribute hockey sticks sold online. It is against regulations for home business.
Colbert has questions about this, and says there seems to be some confusion in the regulations.
The development committee has approved limited home-based businesses such as making crafts, and incidental sales.
The committee is mainly concerned with the warehousing aspect of the business.
Wally Collins says that we should look at a few rejected permits for quarries up by Foxtrap Access Rd. “You can’t get that anywhere.”
Here’s a report of the joint committee of council and the Downtown Development Commission.
The committee is going to have staff draft regulations to allow temporary gravel parking lots downtown.
O’Leary is mentioning the naming of a street, Angel Street, which is to make an issue of domestic violence. This is a national initiative.
O’Leary wants to see a storyboard outlining the significance of the name, and a mural by an aboriginal artist.
Breen is making a notice of motion to amend the sound bylaw to change the start time on construction sites on weekends and holidays to 9am. WAS THIS APPROVED?
Wally Collins is presenting a petition from citizens of a street in Ward 5 who want their ditch cleaned out, as it is flooding.
Tilley is also reading a petition requesting speed bumps on a street in his ward.
Duf is discussing an upcoming conference called “Leveraging Resources for Affordable Housing.”
Hanlon is mentioning a National Geographic article which ranked St. John’s #1 out of 99 costal tourist destinations!
Hanlon is mentioning that she has received concerns from residents that people are digging through their recyclables for ones worth money.
Paul Mackey from public works says they are aware of this, and are trying to figure out what they can do about it.
Tilley is asking for everyone to respect the safety of our children on Halloween, and that people try to give out healthy food.
Breen wants to clarify something about the Irving gas bar on Torbay rd. There are two parts: a redevelopment for the gas bar, and a BK drivethru.
Breen wants people to know that the Burger King drivethru has not been approved yet, the work that is being done is the reno.
Colbert says that although the Boulevard has been torn up, they are going to try and get a coat of asphalt on there for the winter.
Hickman says that in relation to the National Geographic article, we need to make sure we keep this in mind and keep our city as a walkable place.
O’Leary is mentioning a public forum called Your City, Your Ideas. For more details check out www.happycity.ca
O’Leary wants to see more pressure on the businesses to put a fee on plastic bags, or even an outright ban.
Duff is mentioning a conference on sustainable farming held over the weekend. In particular the importance of protecting agricultural land.
Duff says the availability of farm land, and access to markets to sell goods, in is a problem for new farmers.
Duff says that in the new year we should look at a similar project as the new farmers’ market in Halifax. Ours is “bursting at the seams.”
That’s all folks, tweet you all next week with more municipal madness! Andrew Harvey out.
Mon, Oct 18, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey is running late for council for the liveblog. Should be there shortly. Sorry die-hard liveblog lovers.
I made it here in the middle of a delegation for Ocean’s week.
Everyone is here except Sandy Hickman.
There is a proposal for 2 commercial building lots on Robin Hood Bay rd out by the dump. They are recommended for approval. Tilley asked what they will be for, and Hann says that this was not discussed at the committee level.
There is also a proposal for a Coffee shop on Quidi Vidi rd. Also recommended for approval.
Now you will be able to get a drink besides a Blackhorse at the Inn of Olde when down for a walk in Quidi Vidi. Not that there is anything wrong with the Blackhorse.
They approved a tender for $1.4 million for implementation of Phase 1 of the cycling plan. Ye-ah, let’s get it done!
They also have awarded a tender for $88k for the re-design of the City’s website. About time, this is long overdue.
If you have ever used the City’s website, you will know how much it could use some 21st century-ing. A good move by council.
On Oct. 22nd they will stop taking new appointments for pickup for debris from Igor. This will have given people a month to book a pick-up. Anyone who has called in already is good. They have a huge backlog, but will eventually get around to everyone.
The City has put out it’s first Arts and the City report, updating the public on how the implementation of the Municipal Arts Plan is going
This report is a great way to keep people informed about the progress of he plan. The actual implementation is wanting I would say.
The City has done nothing new since the Municipal Arts plan came out, and the report simply states what they have already been doing.
The NL housing and homeless network wants to thank the city for their support with the Pleasantville development.
Hann says the current city website has not been updated in 8 years, and says it is “high time for a re-vamp”.
On Oct 21st there will be a public meeting on the Traffic Calming study. Come out for information on the study, and what the city is doing.
As far as the Pleasantville thing goes, there will be space for various non-profits included in some of the city’s affordable housing units which will be built there.
Wally Collins ran the Cape to Cabot race in 2 hrs 15 min!
Holy snikies Wally, I could never have done that, and Wally has a few years and a few pounds on me.
Early stats show that the city had over 40% participation on the first day of Recycling. Yeah St. John’s!
That’s it folks, short meeting today. Tweet you next week.
Thu, Oct 14, 2010

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal shenanigans from the bunker on New Gower.
They are discussing the proposal for Condos and office space on Harvey rd. This is a deferred decision from the heritage advisory committee.
This proposal is recommended to be rejected by the committee because many of the features do not fifths character for a heritage area.
Shannie Duff says that this same architect has recently designed two proposals which fit these regulations including the Henry-Bell proposal
Hann is raising the question as to why this proposal was previously recommended for approval then removed from the report.
Hann says that if you sit in the parking lot of Tim Hortons the buildings around you do not look like heritage buildings.
O’Leary says “There is a way to marry the heritage and modern designs”, and cites examples of buildings which did this well, like Bluedrop.
Colbert wants to know why they are here debating this when they have a letter from the Director of Planning saying not to grant approval.
The Dir. of Planning says city staff has not had time to give formal approval-in-principle. Colbert says “good thing I came in”. He was late
Colbert is asking to have this deferred again until staff have reviewed it.
They voted 5-4 to defer. Collins, Galgay, O’Leary and Duff wanted to vote now. Presumably to reject the design now.
Frank Galgay wants to clarify something about the Signal Hill proposal. He has asked if the city determines ownership of properties.
The city solicitor says “short answer, no.” It is not possible for the city to do so for every proposal.
The Dir. Of Planning says that the city asked the dept of municipal affairs that they have asked to have the text amendment deferred.
The text amendment is what would allow the proposal to go ahead.
Wally Collins has made a motion to give the applicant 3 weeks to prove ownership, then they will rescind the approval.
This is a convoluted legal issue it seems. Apparently this land was crown land and the applicant may apply to get the land from the crown.
The applicant will have 4 weeks it seems before this application could be rescinded. The applicant will have to prove ownership before then.
O’Keefe: “We will have to see what information comes out in the coming weeks.”
For note, Bruce Tilley is the only one missing.
A proposal for a Gas Bar/Burger King drive thru for Topsail rd. They will have a public meeting when staff have technical specifications
They are recommending rejection of an application for a Juice Bar/store on Signal Hill rd.
The main issue is parking and this is the 2nd application from this individual. Colbert wants to see if they can discuss what could go there
O’Keefe says a Juice Bar halfway up Signal Hill would not increase it’s ambiance or “flavour”
The Audit committee is reporting that management has agreed to implement the recommendations of a 2005 report on grants and subsidies.
Breen says that will be reviewing how and who they give grants to for the upcoming year, including criteria for funding.
The Parks & Rec committee has deferred a decision to give $25k to the EC trail association to the budget. They had much damage from Igor.
Hanlon says that Colbert received a 20 year award from Municipalities NL on the weekend. Congrats to you Gerry!
Hanlon says that Mt. Pearl has moved to iPads to reduce paper and save money. Yes b’y, they don’t even have Internet in council chambers yet
The iPads are a good idea though. We don’t want Mount Pearl to make us look bad either.
Galgay wants to thank Hanlon for a job well done in acting as chair for the committee and the city’s representative on Municipalities NL.
Breen assures people that city staff are still getting around to picking up bulk garbage from Igor damage, and asks for patience.
Colbert says that it is impossible to have 20 yrs of service to a city without the support of city staff, fellow councillors, and his family
Hann said he talked to the chief of the RNC and is happy to see that they are moving forward with putting cameras on George St.
Hann says that this bodes well for George st, and hopes this will make it safer and more profitable.
O’Leary wants to congratulate the LSPU hall on it’s official grand opening, and for city staff who have been working with them.
O’Leary encourages people to call 311 to report graffiti so the city can get a handle on where it all is. I don’t know how realistic this is.
O’Leary wants to thank Mr. Murphy for bringing forward the question over the title of deed over the Signal Hill Development.
Fri, Oct 8, 2010

Just to post this somewhere while I have it, this is a map of the proposal submitted to City Hall to build a nine-lot subdivision on the hill on Murphy’s-Right-of-Way, off Signal Hill Road.
Tue, Dec 14, 2010
Andrew Harvey