The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Blogoween - Daily horror movie reviews in October
Blogoween archives | RSS feed | Contact Us

Blogoween: The Isle Of The Dead (1945)

Thu, Oct 14, 2010

The Isle Of The Dead (1945)

“Go on with your nonsense Old Woman. These are new days for Greece. We don’t believe the old foolish tales anymore. ”

Directed by Mark Robson

What kind of horror movie is it? Psychological Horror.

After a string of popular horror films for Universal, Boris Karloff signed a deal in 1945 to make three pictures for RKO with Producer Val Lewton. Lewton had made a name for himself making low budget but artistically ambitious horror films. Financial successes like I Walked With A Zombie, and Cat People meant that Lewton could indulge in the kind of atmospheric and psychological complexity that Karloff yearned for after years of playing the Frankenstein Monster.

In The Isle Of The Dead Karloff plays a ruthless Greek general during the the Balkan War of 1912. The first time we meet him, he’s sentencing another officer to death for his failures in battle. An American journalist played by Marc Cramer, takes him to task for his inhuman behaviour, but Karloff is unmoved. The two travel to a nearby Island where the General’s wife had been buried, only to find her tomb broken open, and the body missing. Searching for answers they come to the house of an archaeologist who explains the the graves were desecrated 15 years ago when the local peasants went looking for artifacts to sell. There are a number of guests at the house, including a British diplomat, his sickly wife, his wife’s servant, and a tin salesman who falls ill with what turns out to be the plague. A doctor is called and orders everyone quarantined till the danger has passed.

The elderly housekeeper believes the real danger comes from the servant girl, whom she believes to be a vorvolakas — a vampire-like creature from Greek folklore. Karloff’s character is a rationalist, and dismisses the idea, but as the deaths multiply, he becomes less and less sure. This brings him into further conflict with the now-smitten American journalist.

The Isle Of The Dead was Inspired by the Arnold Böcklin painting of the same name. The movie is very open-ended, as Val Lewton films often are, leaving it up to the audience to decide if the plague, or something even more sinister is behind the events. Either way, madness and violence erupt leading to a very intense climax. The cast is solid. Ellen Drew is good as Thea, the possible vorvolakas, and Helen Thimig is even better as Madame Kyra, the superstitious housekeeper, but Boris Karloff steals every scene he’s in. He brings a sense of melancholy, and moral confusion to a character who in lesser hands could have been a simple brutish thug.

Canadian director Mark Robson had worked with Val Lewton extensively leading up to The Isle Of The Dead. Assisting on I Walked With A Zombie, and Cat People, and directing The Seventh Victim. He later went on to direct the late 60′s camp classic The Valley Of The Dolls, and the 70′s disaster epic, Earthquake. Here he’s in full command of his subject matter, letting the atmosphere build slowly toward the inevitable breaking point.

Availability: The Isle Of The Dead is available on DVD as a double feature with Bedlam (another collaboration between Karloff, Lewton, and Robson), and also as a part of The Val Lewton Horror Collection

This was written by:

: e-mail

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.