The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Blogoween - Daily horror movie reviews in October
Blogoween archives | RSS feed | Contact Us

Blogoween: The Island (1980)

Tue, Oct 6, 2009

“You and I are the only living men ever to see what you see now.”

“A bunch of arseholes playing Long John fucking Silver.”

Directed by Michael Ritchie

What kind of horror movie is it?: Pirate Thriller/Adventure

The movie opens with some old geezers fishing for marlin. They get their fish, but some sea-going brute has taken a huge bite out of it, making it unsuitable for stuffing.

Life is hard.

That night they anchor just off an “uninhabited” island, and enjoy a few post-fishing martinis. One of the old guys notices what looks like a canoe floating towards their yacht. They decide to investigate and are rewarded with a brutal axe attack.

Next thing you know and we’re in New York City, and Michael Caine is badgering his editor to fly him down to Florida to do a story on all the boaters that went missing. He’s sure there’s some reasonable explanation to all this Devil’s Triangle stuff.

His editor agrees, and Caine is on his way, only he’s got to take his son along, because his ex-wife has no consideration.

Now, Caine is a working gent, and that means he doesn’t get much quality time with his surly pre-teen. I mean, he tries his best, like buying little Justin a hand gun and stuff, but their relationship is strained.

This becomes important later when they’re captured by murderous pirates.

I hemmed and hawed a bit about whether I should include this little flick in the list. See, the problem is it’s not really a horror movie. In the end I decided that it had enough of a horror pedigree to get in.

For instance, it was written by Peter Benchley, the man who wrote Jaws, one of the most popular and influential horror franchises ever. And it was definitely marketed as a horror movie. The use of the word “terrifying” on the movie posters makes that clear.

And then there’s that moment in first five minutes when a character gets an axe to the forehead.

And what’s more “Halloween” anyway than Pirates?

Also, it is awesome.

So here it is.

This movie is fucking bonkers.

Like I said, it starts off with extreme violence and gore, so you think you know what you’re in for and then it goes off in this pirate adventure direction. And then it’s back to the brutal violence.

I don’t know where to start. Should I talk about how Michael Caine is made into a sex slave? Or should I talk about the barely-there “brain washing” of Justin? They don’t threaten him or anything. They’re like, “hey, want to be a pirate and murder people?” And Justin is like, “sure, I guess… I’m not doing anything else.”

The morality is murky, but amazing.

If you like pirates, this is a fun movie, because these are real-deal 17th century-style pirates. Sure, they’re aware of the modern world, but they’ve chosen not to take part. Instead, they’re busy killing yachters, stealing children, and inbreeding. They’re like the drunk cousins of “The Others” from Lost.

You can tell the actors are having a good time being so blood thirsty, and David Warner is great as the leader.

I probably don’t have to tell you this was a total flop. It was nominated for two Golden Raspberry Awards (saluting the worst that Hollywood has to offer each year.) One award was for Worst Actor (Michael Caine) and one for Worst Director (Michael Ritchie). I don’t think that was really justified though. The movie, while unhinged, looks great and never gets boring. And the acting — across the board — is in keeping with the overall tone.

Break out the rum, and hardtack, and invite your friends over. Trust me, a good time will be had.

Availability:The Island is available on DVD in Australia, and Germany, and from Amazon Video On Demand in the United States, but is not available in Canada. What is a pirate to do?

This was written by:

: e-mail

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
 

One Response

  1. avatar