The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Blogoween - Daily horror movie reviews in October
Blogoween archives | RSS feed | Contact Us

Blogoween: Dr. Caligari (1989)

Sun, Oct 3, 2010

Dr. Caligari (1989)

“That’s the funny thing about desire: if it ain’t crude, it ain’t pure”

Directed by Stephen Sayadian.

What Kind Of Movie Is it? Campy surrealism.

I’ve long-maintained that the truly great cover songs don’t remain faithful to the originals, but destroy them. So, too, should movie remakes and sequels reflect the quirks and vision of the writers and directors behind them. Keep the essence of the film you’re bouncing off of and discard the rest. Otherwise, you just end up with bizarre compromises between ideas new and old, like Martin Scorsese’s horrendous Cape Fear remake or the pointless remakes of Death At A Funeral and Psycho.

Here, the grand-daughter of the infamous Caligari (Madeleine Reynall) is now performing strange experiments at the C.I.A. or Caligari Insane Asylum, where the patients are subject to cruel experiments involving body modification, hallucinations and cannibalism.

Caligari’s main focus is on the sexually ravenous Mrs. Van Houten (Laura Albert, a stuntwoman with credits on Batman Begins, Pirates Of The Carribean and other blockbusters). Van Houten is subject to bizarre experiments after her husband (Gene Zerna) commits her for her overactive sexual appetite. Subject to Caligari’s experiments, she is disfigured, slobbered on by a giant tongue and harrassed by a doppleganger on a TV set.

How much of this is actually happening and how much of it is the result of hallucinogens Caligari uses to control her victims is up for debate. All of her patients speak in extremely stylized, deliberately stilted dialogue accentuated by avant-garde theatrical poses. So do the CIA’s entire medical staff. Caligari’s techniques and the film’s cartoon-like vision raise questions about which sequences are actually occuring and when are we seeing the results of the mad doctor’s special brand of therapy. Mid-way through the film, Mr. Van Houten is locked up and is molested by his wife, who suddenly has an arm that looks like a marital aid designed by H.R. Giger. It gives his constant panic about his wife’s uncontrollable urges a dark and funny ending, and whether this scene was “real” or not doesn’t even matter, as the plot is far less important than the style and humour.

It wouldn’t be Halloween without a brilliant cult movie to watch. The otherwise unclassifiable Dr. Caligari is gorgeous to look at and it’s eclectic sets and costumes are wonderful to look at. The entire film feels like a cross between Pee Wee’s Playhouse, a DEVO video and another cult-classic, The Forbidden Zone. While the clever-clever dialogue and overt sexuality of the Van Houten sequences might turn some viewers off, this is the kind of cult movie I live for. I wish more movies were as unflinchingly strange as this.

Given how much the movie talks about sex, it’s not surprising that co-writer and director Stephen Sayadian has a background in the adult film industry. Under the pseudonym “Rinse Dream”, Sayadian produced one of the few mainstream XXX films to make an impact, with 1982′s CafĂ© Flesh, a sci-fi dystopia about a largely sexless population watching the few people who can still have intercourse. I haven’t seen that film or others he filmed under that name, but this YouTube clip from a film he wrote and directed entitled Night Dreams suggests that his adult films might be worth investigating.

Stephen Sayadian plays the dancing piece of Wonderbread in that clip, by the way.

Regardless of his XXX career, the work of Stephen Sayadian is impressive, unique and strange. There are elements of Guy Maddin in Caligari, but it also has much in common with early John Waters. That Dream/Sayadian disappeared from the world of mainstream film after Caligari‘s release is as mysterious as it is disappointing.

The inspiration for the film, The Cabinet Of Dr. Caligari, has inspired a shot-for-shot remake in 2005 and the 1962 Cabinet of Caligari, a film written by Robert Bloch. Neither recaptured the strangeness of the original German film, but this bizarre semi-sequel does. Stephen Sayadian captures the 80′s surrealism of music videos, counterculture and video games at its best, just as the original film embodied the expressionist movement. It’s horror by the way of John Waters and it works like a brilliant cover version of a fondly remembered song.

Availability: DVDs can be found in unsavoury places. You can view its slightly NSFW trailer below.

This was written by:

: e-mail

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
 

One Response

  1. avatar
    Adam Clarke Says:

    In a perfect world, the Sin Jawnsians in StitchedUp would be dressed like the characters from this film.