Crime & violence
Wait now, has it really gone up?
Runner Up: Hurricane Leslie
Other Answers: “New condo construction”, “Closing of Zellers”, “Lack of colours this Fall.”, “Southside smell”, “Construction Galore”, “Losing Big Tom”, “The roads are still shitty”, “Nothing bad ever happens here”, “I got a parking ticket”, “stabbing in the park”, “Sidewalks. They just pile up with snow and no one cleans them off and people get hit and it’s just a friggin mess.”, “No good Thai food”, “Road construction everywhere you looked from spring to fall”, “The change of Tim Hortons cup sizes”, “Hurricane Destroys Bannerman….again”, “ended up in the ghetto”, “VOCM question on date rape”, “Bill 29”, “Toxic Chemicals to Kill Alder Brush Along Highways”, “Donny Dumphy”, “Death of Peter Narvaez”, “all dem trees crushin the sheds”, “Ron Hynes’ throat cancer diagnosis”, “Oil Money”, “People keep blatantly littering – more than ever it seems. Disgusting.”, “the end of summer”, “bike lane. is anyone really using it?”, “cutting all the forests to build super centres and subdivisions”, “Local “artist” raps apology in court”, “The vote on the Bannerman bandstand”, “Bear Spray Attacks”, “remembering last year”, “The Lyubov Orlova. Scuttle that scow.”, “gosh darn thievery! too much of it”, “Bird left to suffer on roof of building. Says a lot about the city… not good.”, “The loss of that large pheasant mural.”, “Me quitting drinking”, “Des getting shot on Doyle”, “CBC Live Recording Cutbacks”,“Dunderdale …”
Seriously. You can’t flick on the radio for five minutes without hearing a story about a cocaine bust or an armed robbery with a sword or something.
Last year Statistics Canada even released numbers showing that violent crime in St. John’s had gone up by 29 per cent in 2010. It was the biggest increase in any Canadian city. It was big news.
Hell in a handbasket, right?
Well, maybe not. At the time, StatsCan had just introduced something called the Crime Severity Index. The standard crime rate counted the number of crimes reported, and each crime reported was just a tick on a piece of paper, but the new Crime Severity Index aimed to give a bigger picture: it assigned more weight — more ticks on that piece of paper — to instances of crime deemed “serious.” For example, a city’s violent crime index would go way up if there were more murders that year.
And that’s what happened with our numbers in 2010, according to Bob Johnston, Chief of the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary, who spoke to the CBC last July about it. There were two murders in St. John’s in 2010, while in 2009, there weren’t any. There were also a large number of armed robberies, and a few stabbings. By all accounts, 2010 seems to have been an uncharacteristically horrible year for violent crime here.
Sure enough, the city’s crime severity index and violent crime index dropped with the 2011 numbers. They were still up from 2009—the 2011 Crime Severity Index increased by three per cent from 2009, and the 2011 Violent Crime Severity Index increased by 7.5 per cent—but that’s a far cry from the 29 per cent in last summer’s headlines. In fact, the city’s total crime rate went down in 2011 by eight per cent.
That’s not to say there isn’t anything to be concerned about. For example, the overall crime severity for the province has gone up by about seven per cent since 2001, while every other province and territory, except Nunavut and the Northwest Territories, has seen a decline.
Cocaine-related arrests, like trafficking and possession, were up by 20 per cent in the province, and robberies were up by three percent.
But things might not be as bad as they seem. Or not as bad as they seemed last summer.
Criminal lawyer Bob Simmonds agrees. Though he says he perceives an increase in armed robberies and young offenders, he doesn’t think that crime in the city is out of hand. He also thinks that the RNC are doing a good job keeping up with the changes in crime patterns.
As for the cause of these changes, Simmonds says, yes, the drug trade is booming and prosperity is bringing hardship along with it, but according to him the true underlying cause is simple.
“It’s desperation,” he says.
You’ll find that no matter where you live, he says.
Sarah Smellie




2013
Best of St. John's