The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
The Scope's Log (Blog)
The Scope's Bloggy Log Blog | Log Archives | RSS feed | Contact Us

Jun 25, 2008

Scope contributor Jonathan Adams in conversation with student filmmaker Justin Oakey about his experience at Ryerson, the films he’s made so far, and how he feels about having a film in the Nickel for a second straight year (VCR).

In the very earliest shorts you did at Ryerson I was as impressed by the writing as by the images. You seemed to do a really good job of portraying teen angst and narcissism in a weird and funny way. It’s not always easy to tell though how sincere you’re being. Did you intend the films to come across that way?

For shorts such as Helios (or Mother Bird, written by Jonathan Balazs) I believe I did intend for humour to shine through, despite the subject matter being quite grim. I mean, the sun blowing up and destroying the world is pretty dismal. But in light of being in film school I decided to see how over-the-top and melodramatic I could write the narration with hopes that my class would like it more than the original, minimal, script. And of course they did, and I went along with it, only a few others noticing the irony – the class appreciates a film when it’s a “real” film, complete with dramatic, captivating dialogue. Same thing goes for Seamstress, which actually played at The Nickel Film Festival in 2007. The class and professors weren’t digging my original plans to have it realistic, unmotivated and brutal. Instead, I compromised, flipped it into something hokey.

While I’m not too fond of the short itself, it was worthwhile in seeing the mixed reactions, especially at a festival like the Nickel in St. John’s. Some people laughed aloud thinking it would offend me, others held back—some thought it was disturbing and asked me why I needed so much blood and gore while others thought I could have used more. The truth is, the film is purposefully confused, I would say. It doesn’t know which direction it should be heading, primarily because it’s a product of film school where many ideas are adjusted based on the general likes and dislikes of your class, or your professors. Nothing’s really sacred, so to speak.

Coming back to your question, I would say that I was quite sincere in these early short films. And by that I mean I was sincere in producing films at the discretion of a film school. That being said, a film like Mother Bird was a great experience for myself and Jon Balazs, as we did something so totally bizarre and incomprehensible that our peers really weren’t ready for it. It was our first year of school, everyone had been producing run-of-the-mill stuff with linear plots that showed technical prowess. Then, at the final screening of the year, out comes our film with a shattered plot, high contrast and a droning, mechanical score. We even had one of our professors, Hugh Innis—son of Harold Innis—read lines for the narration. It was great. And at that point, I think you could say my sincerity was still present, it just shifted to a more personal level. Instead of being at the hands of criticism, I had come to realize I wanted to work for myself. Sorry that this is all about (my first year at) film school, but, I mean, experiencing a fine arts school like that really helps you define what you’re doing and how you’re going to do it.

Which came to you first when you were conceiving those films, the visuals or the narration?

When producing the earliest of my short films, the visuals came first. Working on film, with no money, means you think of how good you can make something look first and deal with the sound later—if you’re even going to use sound, for that matter. For Helios I wanted to see overexposure, tops of roofs. For Seamstress, I wanted to see gore. The visuals come to mind first, and I plotted a small story around it.

With each short film you’ve done has there been some new technical problem or challenge that you’ve had to overcome? Do you set out to do something different each time or do you simply deal with problems as they arise in the course of making the film?

Generally speaking I set out to do something different, and I will deal with problems as they hit me. There’s no use worrying about how you’re going to get things done until it comes time to do it. Well, that’s not entirely true for every production, but it’s the way I work. You can prepare, you can have everything set up, but if it comes down to something technical or being unsure, just risk it. You never learn anything outside of just trying. If you fuck up, who cares?

When your film Seamstress showed at last year’s Nickel Horror Screening, to me it stood out from all the other films that night as the only one that didn’t have a misogynistic element. All three of the other films were largely based around killings of women. In the case of Long Pigs, which I actually enjoyed, I managed to get past it because there were other things going on in that film, but one of the others that screened that night I thought was just irredeemable in the way it seemed to take delight in the capturing and torture of a female character—presenting the whole thing in almost a titillating way. I guess Seamstress just does a sexual role reversal in depicting a woman who carves up her unsuspecting boyfriend, but still—I wonder if you think there is a misogynistic element in a lot of horror film and, if so, whether it’s problematic or something you consciously try to work against.

As sad as it may be, I think that there’s definitely a misogynistic element to everything in this world. Everything we’ve ever learned as kids has women as the underdog – damsels in distress are a good example. Even if women aren’t necessarily even portrayed, men will be saving the day. I think the inherent misogyny of the horror genre in film and literature is from the overall exaggerated nature of the genre itself. I mean, if you’re working in a milieu where you can be as over-the-top as you want, the values you grew up with will still exist within the world of your films or books, they’ll just be exaggerated. I think that’s why women get it bad in horror films, they’re always running, screaming, being tortured and rarely getting away in the end.

The screening last year at the Nickel was pretty brutal for that—I mean, the first film had two women killing each other because of the influence of a man (take that however you will, I guess), and the other two had women being overpowered and murdered with little struggle. Seamstress definitely stood out, as I made it consciously against the traditional set of rules for horror films. It seems to get more people involved that way, where the males might react to the role-reversal and get frustrated, and woman might be all for it.

Either way, they should remember the film in the end. Even though it was two minutes, I still think it was a great provoker of ideas. It might be seen as a feminist film, which isn’t necessarily correct. I’m not supporting any feminism in particular, I just think that each gender should have the same opportunity to be murdered. Interestingly, the film didn’t get accepted to the Women’s Film Festival, hah.

… In the recent video art piece Otto, a male figure is being humiliated, covered in paints, slapped and spit on by a woman figure. It’s great to see the reaction to that, most people try to draw lines when they see a woman doing that in a film, they start to draw relationship ties or something of that nature—when in reality Otto had no story, no plot, it’s only meant to disturb, so maybe it’s doing its job.

Otto and other recent films you’ve done are more in the line of avant-garde, experimental work. I’m especially fond of your weirdly beautiful blood/piss/snot/semen showcase, Fluid Study. What drew you to this kind of filmmaking?

The more recent work I’ve been pursuing is definitely in the line of avant-garde and experimental, I would also go as far as to say transgressive. Film- and video-making has become more personal for me, like I said before. My line of creativity at this time mostly reflects my curiosity for the human body and how estranged and repulsive it has become to most people. I mean, people aren’t exploring their bodies like they used to. It’s like science, really, where just because something is discovered, doesn’t mean it ends there, you know? Your body is infinitely incredible, and the artists of the 1960s and 70s began pushing its limits. And that’s what inspires me lately, Chris Burden and the Viennese Aktionists in particular.

Fluid Study was the first piece I did in what ended up being a video art series I’ve taken on. It arose from my particular interest in Andres Serrano’s work, although I took it to a different level with video. He sought after the boundaries between vulgarity and aesthetics, and as I put this idea in motion (literally) it became more of a study of natural, arbitrary compositions. Blending, swirling colours that just so happen to be body fluids. The second piece in the series is Otto, a video recreation of Otto Muehl’s “Kardinal” performance film—coming out of the Aktionist period. Again, it’s about the body and it’s about re-provoking people’s conception of the body. The body is a canvas, and in this case I mean this literally. The video art series at this point is primarily re-creative and self-reflective. In recreating these pieces, I feel as if I’m ushering them into a new form of technology.

A couple of the films you’ve also scored, haven’t you? How do you approach that task? . . . . And what’s that creaky rhythmic noise in the soundtrack of Fluid Study?

With video there’s also the impact of a soundtrack, which I took on similarly to the images – the use of traditionally vulgar, tasteless sound to produce something rhythmic and cohesive. Fluid Study in particular was composed by various noise sound waves, a background track from a slaughterhouse and a hand-cranked meat grinder. The scores for these pieces is just as important as the images, of course, and it needs to be handled appropriately to each video.

Do you see this as a continuum between the two genres you’ve worked in? What I mean is—do you think of conventional horror films as being motivated by the same transgressive approach to the human body as the Aktionists’ experiments?

I don’t necessarily think most horror films are consciously motivated by the Aktionists, but there the movement (although, never recognized as a true, defined movement) definitely transcends to today’s filmmaking. Especially conventional works of horror and science fiction, I would say. Shock-art eventually translated to shock-filmmaking. It’s hard to really decide whether one is motivated by the other, actually, because it seems like most people trade off the artistic and intellectual merit that was behind work like Aktions for the shock itself. I don’t know, it’s a good question. But if it’s any kind of answer, I do believe transgressive tendencies flow through both, and I think that it’s great to challenge and blend what most people find appealing and grotesque.

You’ve also made a couple documentaries at Ryerson. Do you enjoy documentary filmmaking as much? Do you feel more restricted than when you’re doing fictional or experimental work—and if so, do you enjoy that aspect or not?

We’re forced to make documentaries at Ryerson, as part of the curriculum, which is pretty great in the end because most of the students would never explore the genre otherwise. I personally think documentary filmmaking is great, regardless of how sincere it may or may not be. I believe it’s a great tool for bringing radical thinking to a bigger audience. The documentaries I’ve done at Ryerson such as Funeral Director and Chipped Tooth Hotties aren’t as “radical” as I would like, but they seemed to go against the grain of the school, which was awesome. Funeral Director was shot with no lights, no tripod, no shot list and none of the crew had heard the interview with the subject. I wanted the piece to be purely observational, drawing on my fascination with mondo cinema. In any case, it didn’t go over well at all at first, but some saw the merit. And with Chipped Tooth Hotties, it was a shit storm too, because people that didn’t support the claim that “chipped teeth are alluring” really couldn’t get on board with the film at all.

Some people openly stated how they thought it was wrong, or just gross or whatever. Which was kind of what Mark and I were aiming for too. Right now I’m working on a body horror documentary, that explores the completely radical idea that the body is physically conscious outside of the power of the mind, and that it can destroy itself at any time with disease. It’s out there, but it’s going to be great. Peers and professors were completely against it in every way, because it’s not tangible. And I think that this film will be my first real documentary that will have my “style” (if one would say I have a style yet) imprinted on it. I do feel more restricted with documentary filmmaking though, as it seems there is more attention you need to pay to the audience – what they want to see is what makes it a good documentary. You can’t confuse anybody without resolving it, you can’t bring in information and let it go without explaining it, it’s not as liberal as narrative or experimental filmmaking, despite having an infinite amount of subjects to choose from here on this planet (or beyond the planet for that matter).

When you finish film school, do you see yourself continuing further in the direction of the experimental films you’ve done or would you prefer to do more commercial, narrative work?

I’m almost done film school, and it’s kind of scary because it’s obviously really hard to tell where you’re going to end up afterwards. I’d like to see myself as one of the few trying to raise work of an experimental nature into the commercial zone. It’d be great to work with higher budgets, and make films that are accessible to more audiences, but still maintaining your own personal art. Elias Merhige comes to mind—he made one of the most controversial films of the 90s, then moved on to making commercial films that received Oscar nominations, but he still falls back on a short video art piece afterwards. It’s great. But who knows where I’ll end up. As long as I’m making something I’ll be content.

How do you expect audiences to respond to your film in this year’s Nickel? Do you feel that you’ve grown significantly as an artist between Seamstress and VCR?

The horror screening this year at the Nickel might be similar to last year, I think. I mean, VCR is totally ridiculous and it’s over-the-top and gory and funny, but I still think the audience isn’t really going to know how to take it. Some of them may have seen it before on YouTube or whatever, but for those that haven’t it’s going to be interesting. The whole thing was produced with multiple video formats and the story features VHS and video culture, perhaps with a style that throws back to direct-to-video horror releases. So, I mean, it will be great to see how people take that. Maybe they won’t realize it looks like video on purpose, because every great filmmaker knows everything has to look like film, right?

On that note, I think I have grown since Seamstress. I’ve come to find a personal niche, so to speak, so everything I work on now is something I’m extremely devoted to. I’ve found my own style, at least for the time being, and I would hope that with time the work I do has my own stamp, you know? Ask me the same question this time next year.

Justin Oakey’s short film VCR will be screened as part of the Nickel Film Festival on Thursday June 26th, at 10:30 PM (The Horror Show) at the LSPU Hall.

To watch Oakey’s videos, visit his YouTube page.

 
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.