As was the sonnet for Shakespeare and the ode for Shelley, the internet comment is the great literary form of our time. In an effort to elevate this art form, The Scope launched its own bastion of anonymous pornographic ravings and confessions of mild-stalking: I Saw You..
To celebrate this literary triumph, we have commissioned a famed literary critic to take a closer look at a few of the more popular I Saw Yous.
![]()
I saw you, table,
and I still managed to walk into you…
like I do every day.
I’m starting to think you’re sentient.
Please stop
tenderizing
my legs.
The question this work ultimately poses isn’t the overt query about the sentience of the table; rather, it is the question of what attracts two bodies, especially one mammalian, one inanimate? Sentience is a trivial matter in this equation, sentience indicates agency and in compulsion, there can be none. In compulsion, the will matters not.
Newton called this attraction gravity, from the Latin gravitas—weight, dignity, seriousness, solemnity of matter. The bending, the bowing of the spacetime continuum, and one of the four fundamental forces in the universe. The straight-faced sincerity of the universe. The drama to the comedic and epic nuclear strong and weak forces of the universe.
The grimace in earnestness, in pain.
This is the irresistible compulsion: the pull, the attractive force between objects, between both heavenly and earthly bodies; between masses, passing in the night. This compulsion, this straight-laced force is as old as time itself. Before Newton’s apple, before Einstein’s black hole, there was space and there was time and as Odin flexed the great Body By Jake® Crusher Flexbar™ of spacetime, pain was born. The following morning, as the diffuse masses of the universe became whole, became solid, came to bear on Odin’s shin, as he, too, bashed into a coffee table on the way to his morning constitutional.
But this force is yet more than that. It is more still than what constitutes the universe, than what furrows the brow and stiffens the upper lip. There is an animalism at its core, a compulsion that is almost fatalistic. The compulsion of wills bereft of freedom. The vector along the continuum that is marked for each of us, colliding, as we do, with other masses.
Some vectors are such that they veer from the solemnity of the drama to the interstellar gravitas of romance. The points where these vectors cross—where the arrow of Cupid pierces the heart, where the Lövbacken of IKEA strikes the tibia—is the transcendent moment of ecstatic synaptic explosion. This compulsion, it seems, is stronger than Newton or Einstein ever surmised. With these vectors crossing, these masses colliding, the Big O trumps the Big G.
The true hero here accepts their path. The mind that grasps this universal attraction is not a physicist, but a lover. Erika Eiffel—famously married to the Eiffel Tower—stands in solidarity alongside this anonymous author, both of them connected fundamentally, eternally, irresistably with their unspeaking, unmoving partners.
![]()
I saw you clicky pens,
driving me f**king nuts.
They should be outlawed.
CLICK…
CLICK…
CLICK…
CLICK…
CLICK…
The Industrial Revolution ended for good when man set foot on the moon. What seemed like humanity’s highest point had been made possible by one of our lowest: German V-2 rockets raining on London from, for the first time, long-range. This was part of industrialization’s parabolic trajectory. What began with Watt’s steam engine thrusting industry across the frontier reached its zenith with the Wehrmacht’s V-2 thrusting destruction over the English Channel during the war, and terminated in the moon landing—when man strapped himself to a big bullet, shot himself into space, stopped the bullet at the moon, got off, went for a walk, got back on the bullet and finally shot himself back to Earth.
Machines, which had begun—to borrow from McLuhan—as an extension of man, morphed into monsters during the war, then continued on to transcend man, and Earth altogether. To become extraterrestrial. Technology was now beyond human control, and it demanded total domination. With this, the true consequence of the Industrial Revolution—machine overthrowing man—everything changed. Including the way we write our grocery lists and pen pal correspondence.
The development of the pen—another phallic instrument of industry which began as an homage to the virility of man and morphed into an instrument of his domination—mirrors the parabolic trajectory of rocketry. But, in ways far more anatomically analogous, the development of the pen mirrors the demise of the Will of man. Far from the early rudiment that was the quill, the Revolution was set in motion with early strokes of the industrious fountain. Man then went ballistic during wartime with the ballpoint—commissioned early on by the RAF for its airmen.
But where then are we left following this trajectory of machine, of rocket, of pen? Where will the future lead us?
As this author laments, there is no more frontier, no more conquest, there remains only the impotent “CLICK…/CLICK…/CLICK…” of a gun that has been emptied of its bullets.
![]()
I saw you acquiring
an attractive
parasitic host.
In the pantheon of gastrointestinal dinner guests, the parasite is analogous to the uninvited party crasher. It shows up unannounced, hangs around, eats your chips, drinks your booze, and generally mooches off your life in an unpleasant manner for as long as it is able. This is the usual circumstance of the parasite-host relationship—the epitome of unidirectional beneficence. An overzealous parasite overstays its welcome, gorging itself on the hospitality of its host to a point where the host, parasite, and party are all three rendered null.
The protagonist of this work notes a distinct paradox. This anonymous author is apparently some sort of internet savant with a troglodytic grasp of basic grammar and/or parasitic science.
In the author’s apathetic accident, the parasite is seen attracting its host; a glorious vice-versa that gives the more keenly astute or fundamentally literate parasitologists pause for thought. It is a subversion of the norm—a norm not so much in a normative sense, but in a biological necessity sense. The host, a sadomasochist, has become its own parasite, clinging to its parasite.
And so, what this internet savant may have originally thought clever, but was actually an egregious display of ignorance, is clever once again—up and out the other side—leading the mind of the reader, ultimately, where all roads on the internet ultimately lead: to hardcore S&M pornography.
![]()
Dr. Abergavenny is a professor is a professor emeritus of English Literature and Criticism at Apocryphal College, Oxford. He tweets sporadically @DrAbergavenny
Thu, Jul 5, 2012
In the 18th it was the poet, the 19th the novelist, the 20th the rapper; in ours, the 21st century, the great writer is the anonymous internet writer. Famed literary critic Dr. Reginald D. Abergavenny III turns his critical eye to two recent I Saw Yous.
![]()
I saw you
sour cream
and onion chips:
bring it.
Walter Benjamin’s Angel of History beholds all of history as a “catastrophe that keeps piling ruin upon ruin.”[1] Which is to say that all is an accident. While heroes, according to Joseph Campbell, are found in their station most often by accident.[2] Likewise, both potato chips and sour cream find their geneses in mishap: the former a failed act of vengeance, the later a refrigerator left ajar.
The narrator of this I Saw You, then, is an Angel of History himself, witness to an ever mounting pile of accidents. Unlike Benjamin’s Angel, however, who is powerless in the face of a storm blowing from Paradise, the narrator is an Angel-Hero standing at the threshold of a journey into the abyss. This moment of crisis is the moment of truth for our Angel-Hero. The moment that the tides of progress, in Benjamin’s Marxian sense, or the Fates, in Campbell’s mythological sense, are confronted courageously. Caution, and potato chips, are thrown to the wind. The General, leading his troops, plunges, like a dagger, into the enemy line with the brave cry: “bring it!”
1. Walter Benjamin, “Theses On the Philosophy of History,” 1942.
2. Joesph Campbell, The Hero with a Thousand Faces, 1949.
3. Benjamin, “Theses,” and Campbell, The Hero.
![]()
I saw you violently vomiting
on the side of the road
near Victoria park
after the Tom Petty concert on Saturday.
You clearly enjoyed the show!
Rock and Roll, man.
Rock and roll music, as James Osterberg, Jr. sings, is the “runaway son of the nuclear A-bomb.”[1] It is the hypersexualized illegitimate child of uncontrolled inter-breeding between pre-war American music—rhythm and blues, bluegrass, gospel, and jazz—and Cold War techno-corporatism. Driven by the impotent rage of youth violently torn from its nurse’s breast, rock and roll is the fury of reckless violence.
The author of this I Saw You—observing, with great alliterative ingenuity, a rock and roll victim-hero in the orgasmic state of rock and roll excess—gets to the heart of this dying beast: Ears ringing with the distorted electricity of “Free Fallin’” and after hours of sensual convulsions, the body has turned on itself.
The futility of attempting to escape the violence of our world via the violence of rock and roll is writ large in the biography of Petty himself. Compelled, like so many, by the gyrating sexuality of Elvis Presley—the post-War West made Übermensch[2]—Petty saw his fate in rock and roll. To the chagrin of his overbearing father, Petty traded his slingshot for Presley 45s,[3] seeking refuge from violence in violence, a futile protest that left him, all these years later, with little more than a handful of gold records and international stardom.
1. The Stooges, “Search and Destroy,” Raw Power, Columbia Records, 1973.
2.Friedrich Nietzsche, Thus Spoke Zarathustra, 1883.
3. Melinda Newman, “Tom Petty: Portrait of an Artist,” Billboard Magazine, November 28, 2005.
![]()
Dr. Abergavenny is a professor emeritus of English Literature and Criticism at Apocryphal College, Oxford. He Tweets sporadically at @DrAbergavenny
Thu, Nov 3, 2011
As was the sonnet for Shakespeare and the ode for Shelley, the internet comment is the great literary form of our time. One year ago, in an effort to elevate this art form, The Scope launched its own bastion of anonymous pornographic ravings and confessions of mild-stalking: I Saw You.
To celebrate the anniversary of what has become the most popular section of our website, we have commissioned a famed literary critic to take a closer look at a few of the more popular I Saw Yous.
![]()
I saw you
drive up on the curb
and hit me
with your car.Even though you
sped off quickly,
I found your car
in the parking lot
and kicked off
your muffler.
“Revenge is a kind of wild justice,” wrote Francis Bacon.[1] And this Lex talionis—an eye for an eye, a muffler for a bruise—I Saw You is a classic example of revenge literature. A hero, wronged by a villain—be it a bad driver, the government, or the fates—-journeys—literally, or figuratively—to the ends of the earth, or a nearby parking lot, to find justice through retribution.
The Newtonian Laws of Revenge dictate that to every act of violation, there is an equal corresponding act of vengeance—an eye for an eye. The first act unbalances the violatee’s sense of fairness—“that so-and-so just hit me with their car and drove away”—which cannot be restored until vengeance is meted out—kicking off their muffler—and the violatee is vindicated.
The persistence of revenge, or what scholars call altruistic punishment—punishment meted out by me upon you for your own good—gives justice its substance and sense of balance.[2] As Old Testament God said unto Moses: “anyone who maims another shall suffer the same injury in return: fracture for fracture, eye for eye, tooth for tooth; the injury inflicted is the injury to be suffered.”[3] The pairing of violation and revenge is often treated as though it were a metaphysical law of the universe that constitutes justice, and thus civilization, in the first place.
However, unspoken in this insistence is what comes next. The violatee achieves vindication but the original violator is newly violated. This person who drove their car up on the curb, upon seeing their muffler detached from their vehicle and laying on the ground, will thirst for vengeance. Rather than constitutive of justice, this endless cycle creates a condition of escalating violence and mutually assured destruction.
As Ghandi said, “an eye for an eye can make the whole world blind.”[4] Or, a muffler for a bruise can make the whole world uncomfortably loud. To escape the cycle of violence that revenge perpetuates one must, at some point, forgive, let go, pass over, or turn the other cheek, as Jesus amended his Father’s eye-for-an-eye law. As Bacon put it, “certainly, in taking revenge, a man is but even with his enemy; but in passing it over, he is superior; for it is a prince’s part to pardon.”[5]
1. Not to be confused with the painter, or the popular breakfast meat. Sir Francis Bacon, “Of Revenge,” Essayes: Religious Meditations. Places of Perswasion and Disswasion. Seene and Allowed, (1597).
2. de Quervain, et al., “The Neural Basis of Altruistic Punishment,” Science 27 August 2004.
3. Leviticus 24:19-20
4. Eisikovits, Nir, “Transitional Justice”, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2009 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.).
5. Bacon, “Of Revenge.”
![]()
I saw me lure you
to my bed
with a grilled cheese sandwich.I don’t know
what the f***
is going on between us,
but it’s pretty good.
This, in fact, it is not an I Saw You at all. The author turns the conventions of the medium on its ear, making it an “I Saw Me,” thrusting the reader into a metaphysical state of uncertainty and anxiety. The disembodied author, the “me,” is addressing the reader, the unknown “you,” directly. No longer the bystander, the voyeur, or the seen, the reader is thrust into the action, becoming the lured in this greasy scene.
The author’s subsequent admission, and glorification of luring the unknown “you” into their bed further unsettles the reader. This “me” did not seduce a lover, they lured a victim, like a mouse to a trap. But instead of cheese placed on a trap on its own, it is a grilled cheese sandwich, made on white bread, with processed cheese, and nutritionally-invalid, cheap margarine, no doubt. Empty calories, filling an empty bed, for an empty affair (“it’s pretty good” the narrator states).
The titillation—physical arousal devoid of emotional attachment—is increased by the harshness and vividness aroused by the use of the F-word. It is obvious to the reader that love is not being made in this bed, but greasy, perverted, cheese-stained pornography is. The sound overheard by roommates would not be moans of ecstasy, but clumsy Neanderthal slaps and grunts.
The author’s seemingly straightforward double entendre—“I don’t know/what the f***/is going on between us,/but it’s pretty good”—admits to some sort of relationship uncertainty, while pointing to some sort of sordid affair. However, the straightforwardness of this double entendre is upended—what could be called an “entendre double” perhaps—when juxtaposed with the talk of grilled cheese in the previous sentence. Leaving the reader not with a vivid image of two people making love, but rather an image of two people squishing a lump of melted cheese between them.
![]()
I saw you Jiffy Cab driver,
stop to let a pigeon
cross the road.
The set-up for a joke that isn’t funny (“Why did the pigeon cross the road?”), a social commentary on class and power dynamics in urban space shared between the human and non-human, a meditation on the city as a narrative phenomenon, this I Saw You plumbs complex depths.
Ubiquitous fixtures in the urban landscape, the cab driver and the pigeon are as indispensable as the office tower and the tree-lined boulevard in the concept of city-ness. Both are semiotic shorthands for urbanity. Yet this is not all they share.
Despite their mutual iconicisim, both taxi cab and pigeon have a tormented relationship with the cities they define and create.The taxi cab, while functional—couriering people from place to place through the labyrinth of city streets, is often taken for granted and viewed with suspicion and disdain by other city dwellers. There is never a cab nearby when you need one, when there is they don’t stop, when you finally get one they might take you the long way. As a pedestrian, or motorist, cabs can present a grave threat. Cab drivers, who live and breathe city streets, navigate according to a tacit connection to the arterial roadways, and not always the rule of the road. While the pigeons—one-time war heroes couriering secret plans to and fro the front lines—are today sneered at, dismissed as pests, as carriers of disease, as rats with wings.
Taxi cabs and pigeons are kindred urban spirits, indispensable vertebrae of a city’s backbone, but both sharing a low wrung in the social ladder. Both sit on the margins, waiting, on statues and stoops, on taxi stands, and airport parking lots, waiting for their scraps of whatever is left over, on whoever doesn’t have a ride, to scrabble together a hard won living.
![]()
Dr. Abergavenny is a professor emeritus of English Literature and Criticism at Apocryphal College, Oxford.
Wed, Dec 4, 2013
The Scope