
Is the city truly willing to build a multipurpose arts centre in the city? …This year? …Or the year after? …Or the year after? The proof is in the pudding, says Andrew Harvey.
If you are involved in the arts in St. John’s, you already know about the desperate need for more artist work space. While the booming economy is great for many, it has led to a difficult situation for those who produce things other than fossil fuels.
At the May 5 meeting of St. John’s city council, they took a step towards helping out artists who are struggling to find a place to work. Council voted to approve $33,333 to cost-share with the provincial and federal governments a needs assessment, business plan, and concept design for a multipurpose arts centre. The next step would be to find funding from government or the private sector to fund the construction.
The vote to approve the money was a contentious one. Deputy-Mayor Duff and councillors O’Leary, Hickman, Collins and Galgay voted for the motion and councillors Hann, Colbert and Tilley voted against it. While they all professed their support for the arts, those voting against the motion argued that this was unbudgeted money, and it should be deferred to next year’s budget for consideration.
Councillor-At-Large Tom Hann voted against the motion, stating that it would be fairer to deal with it as a part of the budgetary process:
“Let’s see where it will fall in the list of all the other priorities we have,” he said. “Then we can determine, well… maybe we can do it, start something on it next year, or the year after, or the year after.”
Fellow Councillor-At-Large Sheilagh O’Leary would prefer not to wait for next year, or the year after, or the year after. O’Leary said “the time is now.” She highlighted the importance of funding this initiative, recognizing that it is simply a step towards getting anything built. O’Leary said we shouldn’t wait until next year’s budget, and that “there are potential spaces that could be economically retrofitted right here and now that will slip through our fingers. We have to be very, very expedient on this.”
O’Leary also points to a broader philosophical debate which lies under the surface at city hall. This debate centres around what exactly the city should be funding. Some councillors believe the city’s role should be to support core infrastructure only, and leave others to funding social and cultural programs.
2012 is an assessment year for property owners in St. John’s. With property values continuing to skyrocket, we are sure to see this philosophical debate come to a head. If the 2012 budget will be a pudding, that’s where the proof will be. As Tom Hann says, we will need to see where funding for the arts stacks up against the other priorities of the city. Let’s hope that the arts are indeed a priority, and we see more progress towards a long overdue multipurpose arts centre.
Tue, May 17, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here with a massive agenda beside me in the gallery of council chambers in the bunker on New Gower.
Lots to be covered today, including new details about the proposed Fortis proposal for Springdale street.
We also have more information about a proposal from Turndown BMX Inc. to establish a bike and skateboard park on Blackmarsh rd.
This is a contentious proposal. It was deferred several weeks ago, and has come back with 23 letters of support, and 10 letters opposing.
Here comes council and staff, with Tom Hann winning the race out today.
O’Keefe is still on the mend, so Duff will again be in the chair. Hopefully O’Keefe is feeling better, and gets back soon. I miss the guy.
The meeting has begun. Hanlon, Colbert, and O’Keefe are missing.
There is a proclamation here from St. John’s clean and beautiful encouraging people not to litter.
You know what they say about litter bugs… people don’t like them.
May 16th is the week of Take Pride, Take action campaign, an initative encouraging people to take a few minutes to pick up litter.
Tom Hann says he had 5 calls about litter today, and it is important to people.
Hann: “There’s an attitudinal problem out there [regarding litter].”
There is a delegation here from Emergency Medical Services (EMS) for Emergency Medical Services week.
The theme for EMS week is “everyday heros.”
The third proclamation is for Municipal Awareness Day. Come down this Wed for a tour of city hall.
There is an open house on Wed from noon – 4:30pm, including a colouring contest! You can colour Dennis O’Keefe and win an iPod!
They are discussing the proposal for Turndown BMX, at 77 Blackmarsh Road, now. The proponents are in the gallery (and on Twitter) waking anxiously.
Galgay is tabling a petition from 7 households an 4 businesses opposed to the development. There are 23 letters of support.
Galgay: “[the proponent] has never had any trouble with the neighbours in that area” [the current location on Waterford Bridge rd].
God forbid kids have a place to be active and pursue a sport. I can think of a lot worse things for kids to be doing.
Galgay moves to approve the application, on recommendation of the planning dept.
RT @JacquiKJanes @thescopeNL Take Pride Take Action May 16 – June 16 Clean & Beautiful will provide garbage bags & arrange pick up of garbage for cleanups
Tilley is convinced that this is a good location for this business. “I have no trouble to support this application”.
Hann likens this proposal to the establishment of Wallnuts. “Youth have it hard enough”.
Hann: “Sometimes the image which is created is not reality” [of the users of the potential skate/bike park].
O’Leary: “Youth are often labeled in inappropriate ways… This is a very smart faculty for recreation”.
O’Leary says we need to be encouraging youth to become active, citing raising diabetes rates and childhood obesity.
Duff: “Skateboarding… is a legitimate sport that requires a great deal of skill” she cites the importance of having indoor facilities.
Proposal approved unanimously. I wonder if we’ll see Duff ripping it up on a BMX?
Hann: “Ziplines are coming to town.”
There is an application looking for a crown land grant for the Zipline on Petty Harbour Rd.
The planning committee is recommending a Land Use assessment be completed for the Fortis proposal on Springdale st.
The land will also need to be rezoned, which means there will be a public meeting. The view-plane study has been completed already.
The Planning committee has recommended to rescind the previous motion of council to wait to review the Municipal Plan.
The previous motion was to wait for the provinces Regional Plan. We don’t know when that will be completed.
Hann: “My understanding is that the plan is going nowhere” on why he is now supporting the review of the municipal plan.
Hann urges the province to finish their plan, and for the municipal plan review to be a fully inclusive process.
This was a debate which occurred a year or so ago, when some of council wanted to review the municipal plan, but in a split vote didn’t.
Tilley: “I think we’ve waited long enough on the province” [to complete the regional plan].
Duff: “This is a landmark development… It will be the first thing you see when you come into the city.”
Duff: “I think the process is as important as the product” in relation to the municipal plan.
The Parks and Rec Committee are recommending an increase of $15k to the Goulds Rec association operating grant, bringing it to $153k/yr.
Galgay wants to commend Wally Collins on his wok for the Goulds and Kilbride which he does quietly behind the scenes.
There is a huge list of tenders. $44k for Sodium Bisulfite going to the sole bidder, Brenntag Canada Inc.
$2.676 million going to Modern Paving to do work on the Robin Hood Bay landfill gas collection system.
This tender is to help with the odour problems down at the dump. This money comes out of capital funds from the province.
Breen wants to know if they can vote right away to proceed with beginning the review of the municipal plan.
Carried unanimously. The review can now begin… only a couple years after it was supposed to have happened.
In the municipal plan it stated a review should have happened in 2008. Better late then never, I guess.
They have moved to update “Footprint and Height control overlays” for the Battery Development Area.
They are discussing lands in the Southlands area which could be serviced or water and sewer above the 190m contour line (whatever that means)
This comes from a directive 4 years ago, and a public meeting 2 years ago.
It sounds like it would create 2 new development zones to be added to the Municipal Plan.
Hann: “This is a very complicated, and important issue for the future of the city.”
These changes seem to be a long-term step, to allow changes down the road.
Cliff Johnson says that he anticipates that the city will take an active role in the development of this area.
Breen wants to commend 26 students from Mary Queen of Peace school who wrote letters about safety concerns re. traffic at their school.
That’s all folks, tweet ya next week with more municipal madness. Andrew Harvey out.
Tue, May 10, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
The St. John’s city council live blog: Council in easy-to-swallow 140 character bits.
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the going’s on from the bunker on new Gower.
Council is starting to assemble, with Frank Galgay chatting up the media, waiting for the rest of council to show up.
Here they are, Duff still in the chair for the recovering O’Keefe. O’Leary, Hanlon, Colbert and Breen are also absent.
Small crew tonight, and no delegations. This will be a short meeting.
There was a public meeting on the rezoning of a property at 599-601 Topsail. Change from Residential Low Density to Residential Medium Density zone.
Apparently only one individual attended the hearing. Tilley says that his concerns were addressed at this meeting.
The Development Committee recommends approval for a drive-thru to go in at the Irving at Stavanger drive.
The committee is also recommending approval for a mixed development for Harvey Rd.
This proposal was deferred after it required changes to comply with heritage regulations.
The proposal will have commercial space on the main floor, and have 6 residential units above.
It was deferred last year, and apparently has changed since then. The say it was “a glass box” last time.
Duff on the changed proposal for Harvey Rd.: “Let’s see what we get.” Council has not seen the new plans yet.
Hickman is asking questions about access on Long’s Hill for a garage beneath it. The traffic engineer has taken a look at it, apparently.
Duff reiterates that this is only approval-in-principle, and no building permits will be issued tonight.
The Police & Traffic Committee is beginning to look at the implementation of the traffic calming policy, looking at the # of streets involved
The Committee also considered a request from Downtown St. John’s to move the taxi lay-by from George St to New Gower.
The lay-by will not move until the George St. redevelopment plan is implemented.
There is a proposal call for $10k worth of fireworks for Canada Day. It went to the sole bidder WJ Fireworks.
Who says you can’t buy happiness. Fireworks make me pretty happy!
A Doctor from MUN is complimenting the city on it’s employee wellness program, and the good work they are doing.
Galgay is discussing the Municipalities NL meeting held last week in Gander.
Wade Locke gave a presentation entitled “Funding Municipalities”. Addressing how property tax is insufficient to fund cities these days.
They have voted to allow Demolition of 12 Henry st.
Hickman is discussing some potential provincial grant for community recreation projects up to $15k. He thinks some schools may apply.
Wally Collins says that they got $120k to improve the trails in Wedgewood park. Presumably fed or prov $
That’s all folks. Tweet ya next week. Andrew Harvey out.
Fri, May 6, 2011


By Taryn Sheppard with anaglyph cyan-red 3D effects by Elling Lien
Wed, May 4, 2011
Every week, Andrew Harvey tweets live from the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays (or whenever council sits) at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
There is a delegation from the Salvation Army for their Red Shield drive.
There is a delegation here for Occupational Health and Safety week.
The theme for this week is “Health and safety: What’s your plan?” It’s encouraging good planning for emergency situations.
O’Keefe is still out, so Duff is in the chair, and Breen and Hanlon are also not here.
There is a memo from the Dir. of Planning regarding the rezoning of land on King Edward Place.
As for any rezoning, a public meeting was required. Because they did not receive any written objections, it was cancelled.
There was a public meeting which went ahead for the rezoning of the Church of England (CEI) club on Hamilton Ave. They want to rezone for 30 condos.
O’Leary on the rezoning of the CEI club on Hamilton Ave for condos: “There was a very favourable response to it.”
There were some concerns noted around parking, and access for Hamilton Ave for the area. As well, some wanted to ensure they keep the trees.
Galgay thinks that the residents in the area were pleased that this development is coming to the neighbourhood.
Galgay on the Hamilton Ave condos: “All in all, this is a good development.”
Hickman says that his only concern is the trees that border Victoria Park. He thinks if one tree falls, one should go in.
Cliff Johnson says that they can add to the requirements of the approval can be for the developer to have to plant trees in the park.
The Development Committee is recommending an extension for a previously granted approval-in-principle for 123 Water St to be extended.
Approval was granted in 2009, but is only good for 2 years, construction is to start in the fall.
There is also a proposal for a hotel at 411 Stavanger Drive, beside Boston Pizza.
It turns out that a small piece of land included in the Henry Bell development on Duckworth St was not rezoned with the rest.
O’Leary has a question about a rear deck which is being proposed for Church Hill.
Rooftop patio’s are not allowed, but apparently this is not on the roof, is at the rear, and not on the top level of the building.
Galgay says that the whole proposal for the old CBC building will not be approved until they have an access agreement with direct neighbours.
Colbert has to take the chair while Duff gives the Finance Committee report she chairs.
Duff is moving the report from the committee, making one item on a multi-purpose arts centre separate (for purposes of voting).
The city’s corporate social media policy has been amended to include and govern Twitter usage. Nice job city!
Hann is asking whether or not it is necessary to have sent 4 people to a conference on clean drinking water. Why not 2 or 3?
Colbert says that the issue is that some of these conference are highly technical, and often staff have different areas of expertise.
Tilley would like to see a two-page summary of “what we have learned to benefit out city” whenever staff or councillors go to conferences.
Galgay on his attending conferences: “I bring back a rather exhaustive report of what happens.”
Duff is discussing a potential multi-purpose arts centre. She says they have been talking about the new cultural space for 6 years.
She says the number one thing the Arts Community has asked for is more space to produce art.
Right now, the Arts Committee is asking for $33k in funding for Phase 1, which would be for a business plan and needs assessment. Phase 2 is for a concept design for the facility, if it gets there.
The money the committee is asking for the arts centre is contingent on the fed and provincial gov’t matching the city’s funding.
O’Leary says that since MUN Extension Services has closed, there has been a void in the city and that cultural products in NL are a $400 million industry.
Hickman says that we need to find out exactly what the artists need, which is what this report will determine.
Hickman also wants to see if a downtown library can fit in on this report, or if it is a separate thing.
Tilley says he can’t understand why the arts community has taken this long to try and secure funding for this.
Tilley: “I cannot, and will not, support this [money for the report on a multi-purpose Arts centre]… Why does the city have to do this?”
Hann says that the chair of the Finance Committee is the gatekeeper of ensuring the budget is kept on track. This is a shot at Duff.
Hann says that requests for money like this which have not been budgeted for happen all the time but there are many other important project
Hann says that we are starting $6 million in deficit for next year and is not sure where the money for the Arts Centre would come from.
Hann, as well as Tilley have asked why we can’t use the Arts and Culture Centre for some of this?
Hann wants to have this deferred to next year’s budget.
Collins clears up that this is not $100k, as Hann said, it is 1/3 of that, split with the fed and provicial gov’t.
Colbert says that this funding should be stacked up against other budgetary needs and would not happen mid-year.
Duff points out that money was found outside of the budget for the Telus Cup. This is an event which comes and goes.
Duff says that she agrees that they should look for private sector funding, but this cannot happen without a business plan.
Duff: “This is step one, and you cannot get to step 2 without it.”
Duff says that this will help honour the commitments the city has made. She says artists space is disappearing under development pressure.
Motion passed! Colbert, Tilley, and Hann voting against.
There is a report on the Cycling Master Plan. The city met with residents of Old Topsail Rd, who are concerned about losing parking.
They talked to the residents, and the consultant, and the only sage way to do it apparently is by taking all parking of the street.
Tilley is asking about Canada Drive, as he says residents don’t know what side of their street will be used for a bike lane.
O’Leary is asking about a duct which is going up for Magnum & Steins where it is moving (in the laneway by The Ship.)
Galgay is discussing the need for parking DT. A recent report showed an immediate need for 500 spaces.
Galgay is moving for an amendment to allow for a rezoning of land on Cliff Baird’s Close.
Colbert says that why they are doing this now is because the property is for sale, and they want to ensure that it stays as parking.
O’Leary and Galgay attended a meeting in the Georgestown Neighbourhood Association regarding establishing a community plan.
O’Leary is responding to the idea that the arts should be self-funded and says there are tangible and intangible benefits gained by the arts.
O’Leary also points out that all industries are subsidized in the province and country.
Paul Mackey says that the city’s four street sweepers are out doing 16-hour days now.
Cliff Johnson says that the last meeting on the Regional Plan happened in Fall of 2010. He says a report will come to the next planning meeting.
Hann: “Everywhere I go these days, potholes are an issue.”
Paul Mackey says that commercial hot asphalt is not available until the end of the month, which limits what they can do.
Tilley wants to know when the streets rehabilitation program will begin. Walt Mills says they expect work to begin in another week.
Tilley on potholes: “There are some real ‘beauts in Ward 3.” He encourages people to call 3-1-1 to report potholes.
That’s all folks. Make sure to get out and vote, and I will tweet ya next week. Andrew Harvey out.
Tue, Apr 19, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey tweets live from the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays (or whenever council sits) at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call from his perch in the gallery.
Wally Collins overheard speaking to the new city manager, Bob Smart: “Grab your earmuffs, you’re going to listen to a pile of shit tonight.”
That’s why I love Wally Collins, he’s hilarious and frank.
Duff has called the meeting to order. There is a delegation from the Mayors Advisory committee on Youth.
It is youth week, promoting youth, and the importance of recreation programs on youth.
There is a series of events throughout the week, including an art exhibit and a beach party.
Breen says that the mayors advisory committee is there to listen to youth, and see what they want.
Duff is welcoming Bob Smart on his first day as city manager.
Smart has a 30 year career in the public service, and has been deputy minister in several provincial gov’t departments.
Hann is “pleased and impressed” that Bob Smart came forward, and ultimately got chosen for the job.
They are discussing a proposed text amendment to allow multiple dwellings for a proposed Easter Seals housing development in Pleasantville.
Colbert has moved to amend four city by-laws to bring then in line with national building codes.
Galgay is discussing the denied appeal regarding the Burger King drive thru on Torbay rd.
The city was provided additional information by the appeal board, but Galgay says it was “nothing substantive”.
Breen says that he was not for the proposal in the first place because it was in a residential neighbourhood.
Breen cites that in Toronto they have a 30m setback for drive thrus from residential homes.
This is all discussing a proposal which has already been approved, and will go ahead.
O’Leary is discussing the new, revised policy and guidelines for arts grants.
Breen had asked for information on this. He says that it is not as in-depth of a review as he was looking for.
Breen wants to make sure that the $130k the city is spending on this is serving both the city, and the artists well.
Breen wants to make sure the program is “doing what it is intended to.” Either by staff, or an outside professional.
Hann wants to know if, in the review, the city went out and talked to artists in the community.
Hann: “As councillor Breen mentioned, art is changing… with technology… with the webs”.
Duff: “The implication is that it was not done properly” on Hann’s comments. “There’s no implication,” he responds.
Duff: “This [the review on the city art granting process] was not a cursory look.” She says that the guidelines are established with the public.
Duff has invited Breen an Hann to come to the next Arts Advisory Committee to talk to the members of the committee.
Apparently the most recent review was based on best practices and examples from other as well as the NL Arts Council.
As a note, O’Keefe is still out, as well as Bruce Tilley.
Hickman says that the granting program is really important for artists who are looking for further funding from other organizations.
Hanlon: “The mere pittance we give them [artists] is not nearly enough.”
Arts have been targeted as an area for growth in the cities upcoming Strategic Economic Roadmap.
Duff says that for three years the Arts Advisory Committee has asked for an increase in the amount of funding, and never got it.
They are again discussing an extension to Healy’s Auto Body on Empire Ave.
They are discussing the public meeting held for the Henry-Bell proposal on Duckworth (which includes the CBC building.)
Breen says that people at the meeting were concerned about the look of the parking garage on the streetscape.
Breen references comments that “this is a done deal.” He says it is not a done deal until after the public meeting.
Breen says there was also a question of how many parking spaces which would actually be created. They will lose some on Duckworth.
Breen says that the proponent has stated that without the additional height (2-3m), the proposal would not be economically viable.
The issue here is that the proposal could be within all regulations and within height, without one of the floors of parking.
The city will be paying this developer something around $19k/space to use part of the parking garage for public use.
O’Leary thinks that this is a great proposal, but there is still work to be done.
Staff is recommending that no final decisions be made at this time. They want to see any changes that come out of any concerns.
Duff: “It was the city that asked [the developer] to put in that extra public parking.”
Duff says the developer originally came in with a proposal within height regulations, and the city asked they to go above height for parking
The Development Committee is recommending approval to rebuild a shed in the Outer Battery.
There is a proposal for a business on Howlet Ave ext. Very few details, and they are deferring it.
The city got a letter requesting their involvement in the St. John’s Community Roundtable Initiative.
Collins is questioning giving arts grants to “some of these old artists,” and why they need grants.
Hanlon has referred some issues with where they moved some post boxes to on Viscount St. in Airport Hts. He has forwarded this to staff.
Breen is discussing how they have dumped a big pile of fill on an old heli-pad in Pleasantville. I guess the kids used it as a skate park.
RT @Turndownbmx @thescopeNL friends of mine built that place as a quiet place to skate. Too bad their hard work is gone
Sorry kids, you’ll have to find somewhere else to skate, unless you have $500k to buy one of the houses there.
Hann says that he has a letter from the provincial gov’t extending funding for the para-transit system.
Hann says that the Harris Centre of MUN says that to move forward, municipalities need to cooperate more. No shit.
Hann: “We need to improve our relationship with our neighbours.”
RT @CarlaCHaynes @thescopeNL If Tweeting for a widely read local publication, you must be able to spell, or at least proofread.
@CarlaCHaynes I am a terrible speller, and write too quickly. Thanks for noticing though.
Hickman: “Mount Pearl is doing research that we have already done, god love ‘em.”
Hickman encourages people to call 311 and complain if election signs are a safety concern.
RT @hydroqueen @thescopeNL election signs always a safety concern – democracy is always being hit.
There was also issues with municipal election signs, but I have not heard anything about them changing their own bylaws.
That’s all folks, tweet you next week, on Tue, because of the holiday. Andrew Harvey out.
Wed, Apr 13, 2011
We probably don’t have to tell you, but house prices in St. John’s are up. Still.
A survey put out yesterday by Royal LePage shows the biggest price boost in local houses is condominiums, which rose 5.9 per cent to an average of $256,023.
Following the rising trend in St. John’s are detached bungalows with a 4.7 per cent increase to $238,793. Standard two-storey houses also climbed 4.4 per cent to a $327,627 average.
“We expect house prices will continue to creep up,” says Phil Soper, president and chief executive of Royal LePage Real Estate Services. Most of the housing demands caused by early dropping interest rates have been sorted out, says Soper, adding in that houses are slowly becoming less affordable.
The steady pace of Canada’s real estate market in the end of 2010 shows what he calls “post recession recovery.”
In the first bit of 2011, the national average price of a detached bungalow is $341,355, an increased 4.3 per cent compared to last year. Standard two-storey homes also went up 3.5 per cent to $379,388.
The Royal LePage Price Survey is considered the largest most in-depth study of its kind in Canada. The survey gives information on seven types of housing in over 250 neighbourhoods, focusing on price trends for the three most popular types of Canadian houses.
Wed, Apr 13, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey tweets live from the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the comings and goings from the bunker at New Gower St.
O’Keefe is still out, recovering from open-heart surgery. Duff will be in the chair.
Duff has arrived. She is sending condolences to Wally Collins, whose mother died recently. Collins, O’Keefe and Tilley are not here.
Steve Watson (of One Chef One Critic) is here discussing a trip he took to Ottawa with the Dept. of Tourism.
Hickman is talking about how Chef Watson does a wonderful job of promoting the province at trade shows.
Hickman on Steve Watson: “He’s a great ambassador for the province”.
Hanlon was at a ceremony over the weekend where the city received the Silver Treefoil award for supporting the girl guides.
There is an application to re-zone property on Kings Bridge Rd for the garage. There will be a public meeting on this.
The decision on the BK on Torbay Rd was appealed by a condo board behind the proposed site. The appeal was denied.
Breen is moving to defer a decision on this until some new information they have received has been reviewed by staff.
Breen is questioning why the appeal board said that it was not in their jurisdiction to approve the appeal.
Neil Martin says that the appellants were informed the appeal would not be approved, but they appealed anyways, which is their right.
Galgay wants to know if there is precedent for the appeal board to ask council to reconsider this, as they did.
Hann says that what we need to do is ask staff to take a look at drive-thru’s and restaurants in residential neighbourhoods.
Hann on when these restaurants and drive-thrus should be allowed: “I don’t think we have a set of standards now.”
They are approving a recommendation to advertise the proposed zoning amendment approved last week for Maddox Cove Rd.
They are discussing a proposed quarry for Foxtrap Rd. There will be some restrictions on the operation of this quarry, size, site plan, etc.
Other requirements will be restrictions on when it can operate, and a bond for the completion of a detailed remediation plan.
The Town of CBS and CBS residents have expressed concerns over this development.
Proposal for the quarry is approved. This will be sent to the Dept. of the Environment for final approval.
The Heritage Advisory committee is approving a mural for the side of the new Newfoundland Chocolate Company building on Duckworth.
O’Leary says she fully supports this, but wants to see some professional standards established in the future for murals.
Colbert made a notice of motion that there will be changes made to by-laws to come in line with 2010 National Building Codes.
They have approved the demolition of 59 Merrymeeting Rd, apparently it is more than 50% “depreciated.”
The Mayor’s Advisory Committee on Housing is asking for the city to write to federal candidates for two federal funding programs.
Hann is tabling letters which will be sent to federal candidates asking how they will support public transportation in the city.
Hann on the lack of stable funding for public transportation: “We’re at a critical stage here… We need to know what the long-term plan is.”
Hann: “We could end up with no money here,” he says, noting that all federal funding for municipalities will run out in 36 months.
O’Leary says that there was an issue with phone registration for swimming lessons. She says they are moving to online registration.
O’Leary says that she received a compliment from a citizen on the good work done by public works when he had a sewer line break.
O’Leary encourages everyone to “not just look at the garbage, but get a bag and pick it up.”
Two weeks from tomorrow street cleaning starts, and the schedules will be mailed out. Make sure you know when it is for your area.
Colbert wants to thank Neil Martin for the good work he did as acting City Manager over the last 4-5 months.
Galgay says that the new proposal from Fortis will bring in $1.5 million in taxes a year once completed.
Duff is tabling a letter from a citizen asking questions about the Arts Jury procedure.
That’s all folks, Andrew Harvey out. Tweet ya next week.
Tue, Apr 5, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal shenanigans from the bunker on New Gower.
I was handed a copy of a press release by Shelley Pardy from the city’s Waste Management Dept.
The press release is to announce a video for the new recycling facility. Check it out here:
Duff will be filling in for O’Keefe or a bit. Apparently Dennis will be having cardiac surgery.
RT @Dill709 @thescopeNL Any development on a council podcast?
@Dill709 I’m working on it. I forgot my audio recorder today, it did cost an “astronomical” $70.
All in attendance except O’Keefe, who supposedly is at the Health Sciences, doing well.
There is a delegation from the Parkinson’s Society.
April is Parkinson’s Awareness Month, over 6000 people have Parkinson’s in the province.
When the mayor is not in the chair, they do not announce “his worship, the mayor,” and the gold sceptre is already in front of the seat.
There is currently no cure for Parkinson’s. They are researching for a cure, and to improve treatments available.
Today is National Oncology Nursing Day. We have a delegation to proclaim this.
This has got to be a tough type of nursing to do, and they all deserve a lot of respect for doing this difficult job.
They are launching the video about recycling, you guys got a sneak preview a la Twitter: http://www.curbitstjohns.ca
This new video shows the journey your recycling takes.
Sandy Hickman reiterates the importance of using clear blue bags. Apparently there is good process-related reasons for this.
Ohh, Duff says there is an addition to the agenda related to “the Fortis announcement” whatever that is.
Galgay is moving to defer a proposal for Hamilton Ave. City staff has asked for this after some new information.
Holy quick meeting, already on Tenders, for paint and rental equipment for robin hood bay.
The economic update shows things are going well here! $14 mil is being invested in St. John’s for 6 research projects.
They are currently accepting nominations for the Tourism Awards, you have until April 6th.
Hann wants to know why we are down 40% on building permits on the YTD from last year.
Hanlon says this was due to several major projects thy had occurred early last year.
Galgay is discussing the Fortis proposal announcement.
They have submitted a proposal for a 12-story $50 million “Class-A” office building. Bordering Springdale, New Gower and Hamilton Ave.
Galgay: “This is a good news story.”
The proposal is in the west-end of DT, and is in an area already designated for bonus height.
Galgay: “This council is very pro-development.”
Cliff Johnson from planning confirms that the area is designated for bonus height, but the zoning limits it to 15m.
Tilley: “I knew Fortis was going to be back, because they are good corporate citizens,” in reference to the proposal from last year.
O’Leary would also like to share commendation, and says that this “works within the rules of the regulations and municipal plan.”
Galgay is showing an artist’s rendition of the proposed building. It’s okay Frank, I’ll check online.
Duff: “The difference between this and the last proposal is not east and west, but that it complies with the rules.”
Colbert wants to let them start building now so that they can have tenants in there by the time they finish the committee stuff.
Collins is discussing a proposed rezoning for Old Bay Bulls Rd.
Tilley says he also supports this, as there are houses right across the road, so why not let them where they are being proposed.
Breen says he was not initially for it, but when he went to take a look at it, he now agrees, as it would not be fair to reject it.
Galgay has asked Cliff Johnson to explain why staff has recommended to reject the proposal.
Johnson says that the land is currently zoned open-space, the most restrictive type of zoning. He says across the street is different zoning
Johnson has also said that the city is very restrictive with rezoning in Rural Zones. This is on Maddox Cove Rd, not Bay Bulls, sorry.
The proposed lots are 1/2 acre lots, and are currently unserviced, so would have to be on septic and well.
City Staff are concerned that if they approve this, they will receive many more proposals such as this.
Collins: “As far a farming, a worm would have to dig it’s own topsoil out there”
Motion passed, 8-2, Duff and Galgay against.
Galgay is discussing Municipal Awareness day. They will have an open-house and various informational booths from the city.
Galgay hopes this encourages people of all ages to run for council in 2013. I hope it does too!
Duff wants to congratulate CBS on becoming CBC’s Hockeyville 2011.
Duff says O’Keefe collapsed under a stress test. He will either have a stint, or open-heart surgery. Wow, I hope he’s all right.
Duff on how fit O’Keefe is, and how optimistic they are for him: “He’s a lean, mean, walking machine.”
O’Leary wants to commend the quality of the instruction offered through the city’s swimming lessons.
O’Leary feels that there really needs to be an emergency access laneway on Margret’s Place, which is seeing several big developments.
Hann is going to send a letter as the chair of the SJ Public Transit committee to ask for the parties stance of providing for public transit
An excellent move by Hann to make an issue of federal funding for public transit. He encourages people to ask candidates when they see them.
Colbert says that the city is paying a 1/4 million a year in provincial road tax to run our own buses on our own streets “it’s scandalous”.
Colbert says that people are offended that the Village Mall says they are going to kick Metrobus out.
Apparently a spokesperson from The Village Mall said that during the Metrobus strike, theft and vandalism was down.
Hann says that in a letter to Metrobus, the Village Mall wouldn’t agree to a meeting to discuss the issue, and the decision is final.
@Jamie_Brace They actually did make this argument apparently, citing increased profits during the strike. Good point.
Colbert says that these comments put “a dark cloud over Metrobus… I’ve discussed this with our lawyer, and I wish there was another way”
Hanlon says that last year, St. John’s was not involved in Municipal Awareness day. This year Lionel West brought it to the city’s attention
Lionel West is another council-watcher, and former candidate.
Hanlon says that on April 11th, she will be podcasting herself on her website, http://www.ward4report.com
Collins: “Some of the stuff was good, but some of it was a load of crap” on the pesticide conference he went to at the city.
O’Leary says that what Collins is not addressing is the large amount of scientific research out there.
That’s all folks tweet ya next week.
Tue, Apr 5, 2011

A rendering of the proposal, facing Springdale Street.
From the press release:
Fortis Properties Corporation announced today its submission of a development application to the City of St. John’s for the construction of a 12-storey, Class A office building at the corner bounded by Springdale Street, New Gower Street and Hamilton Avenue Extension, also known as the former Horwood Lumber site. This site is designated by the city’s Municipal Plan as an area allowing for additional building height to 12-storeys. [...]
The $50 million project will feature 145,000 square feet of Class A office space and include 183 parking spaces in line with municipal requirements. The building will be constructed to environmental and energy efficient standards and will exceed the Model National Energy Code for Buildings.
A view of the site (as far as we can tell) on Google Street View:
View Larger Map
Fortis withdrew their proposal for a 15-storey office tower on Water Street last year.
Thu, Mar 31, 2011
Your corner trim is too wide. Please play again.
For many homeowners, spring time is renovation time. But if you live in the downtown area—in a ‘heritage’ designated area—working on your property isn’t always enjoyable. Building regulations for the heritage area, which determine what you can and can’t do to your house, can be difficult, convoluted, and creatively stifling.
Recently, a friend recounted to me her experience of building in a ‘Heritage 3’ area. Her vision for her property was for a modern saltbox. She found that the contemporary detailing she wanted wasn’t allowed, and instead the city requires certain window types, trim widths, and eave placement, all specified with particular dimensions and colours. No casement windows, no cove style siding, no architectural panelling, no face-nailed members, no awning windows, and on and on. The guidelines for house constructions are incredibly specific in dimensions also. Listening to her, I couldn’t help but wonder: Why does it have to look like this? And where do all these details come from, anyways?
Enforcing certain architectural features to keep things looking historic is a questionable practice. How do you choose what era of the past defines future architecture? How do you pinpoint a window of time and decide that we will collectively remake our city in this fashion? There’s no doubt that our historians have identified many important historical buildings and houses and, for residential buildings in heritage areas, the St. John’s Victorian townhouse seems to be the city’s vision. But what if we looked at other times in the city’s history to use as an homage to the past?
If the city chose the 1700’s as their hallmark heritage era, we’d all be maintaining rough, unpainted spruce sheds. It would be pretty silly if, in the name of historical continuity, we weren’t allowed to paint our houses. It seems equally silly to me that a city inspector is paid to make sure your corner trim is exactly six inches wide and not a fraction more.
The fact is, heritage regulations can’t possibly outline a perfect historical house. The idea of reproducing a Victorian past is there, but this architecture we enforce is affected by the construction industry, the National Building Code and, of course, availability of supplies. It’s as much a product of our time as it is a revival. It’s a compromise, made up of 1890s window and trim styles, bright 20th century paint colors, synthetic building materials and contemporary building proportions. New heritage style buildings would probably look pretty alien if placed back in the time they are supposed to be from.
With the start of this new construction season, I expect to see more of the gaps in the downtown streetscapes seamlessly filled in with clapboard and trim. This can be a good thing, as it further establishes the present look of our city, but these heritage regulations can be really limiting for creative home owners, and it’s hard to understand the rationale behind some of the very strict and seemingly arbitrary rules. Is it a hidden truth that the Heritage Advisory Board is more like an arbiter of taste than a guardian of heritage? It might be more honest to refer to it as the ‘present architectural zeitgeist’ of St. John’s, rather than its ‘architectural heritage.’ After all, it’s not entirely historically accurate. It’s hard for people not to ask why things are the way they are, especially when they own their property and they are paying their bills.
Thu, Mar 31, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal shenanigans from the bunker on New Gower st.
His worship, the mayor. O’Keefe has arrived, and the meeting has begun. All here except Duff.
There is a delegation here from the Canadian Cancer society for Cancer Awareness month.
April is Daffodil month, to raise awareness, and show support for those experiencing cancer.
They say every year in Canada 73,000 people are diagnosed with cancer.
The mission is to eradicate caner, and improve the life of those living with cancer.
Neil Martin (city clerk) is a class act. He gave O’Keefe his daffodil pin when he saw he didn’t have one.
April is volunteering appreciation month. Newfoundlander and Labradorians volunteer for 35 million hours a year! Nice one us.
Bernard Davis is here from the CLB armoury, and says there will be an event to honour volunteers up there on April 10th.
O’Keefe: “Volunteers are the backbone of out community”
Hickman is making a motion to change the Snow Removal regulations.
He wants to allow for the city to recover costs which are incurred by the city in removing snow put in the road by citizens.
Colbert says that some people are concerned that the sidewalks are the only place to put the snow.
Colbert says that it is only a concern for people who put snow on a street, or sidewalk which have already been cleared off by the city.
Hickman says this is only affecting enforcement, not what peoples responsibilities are when it comes to snow clearing.
Galgay is moving to rezone property on King Edward place. There will be a public hearing held on this change.
Breen says there has been some confusion over the decision of last week to increase the borrowing limit of Metrobus.
Hann wants to clear up some misunderstanding he sees with this.
Hann: “The borrowing will be spread out over seven years, maybe more… We’re never going to reach the $15 million”
Hann: “The jury is still out [on hybrid buses]” he cites troubles in Halifax and Toronto.
Hann mentions that there is a test the city has undertaken for some sort of hybid unit they have tried as a test.
Hann: “The savings on the smaller buses are minimal” he says the small busses are not the same quality as the larger ones.
Colbert says he has several questions on this. He thought they should look at having a capital reserve fund for Metrobus.
This capital reserve fund is something the city had for capital costs, and saves on what they would spend in interest.
Paul Mackey (public works), says the city has 5 hybrid SUV’s on a trial basis, and they are evaluating what the saving will be.
Colbert cites that Quebec city also uses several electric buses for specific routes.
O’Keefe: “By’s, there’s no need to debate the whole public transportation system” he says on several councillors comments on this.
There is an application for a non-conforming use to put a furniture and appliance store for 74 Springdale street.
The application has been rejected as there has been no business there for 11 years. After 3 you lose the ability to use non-conforming uses.
O’Leary and Colbert say they will not vote to reject this. The proposal is to be in conjunction with the HUB.
Cliff Johnson (planning) says that they legally cannot approve this because the 3-year window has closed to apply in this manner.
A big planning and housing report has been tabled. Ten items included.
Another application has been submitted for a 4-story, 22 unit condo on New Cove Rd. They want more specific traffic information on this.
There is also a proposal to rezone the land for the CEI club to allow redevelopment as a condo.
A proposal is in there for a quarry on incinerator road. Apparently this is not the one people in CBS were upset about. Different spot.
There will be a public meeting for the rezoning of 599-601 Topsail rd.
Colbert asks if the city gets in touch with CBS when proposals come in near them. Cliff Johnson says yes, they do.
Another great example of how St. John’s already plays nice and works with neighbouring municipalities. It’s not all bad.
There is a poposal for affordable housing on Bonaventure Ave. They want to put an apartment building there, and this is too dense for there
There is a sort of convoluted rezoning application for Cuckold’s Cove Rd in Quidi Vidi.
There was a boat house which was approved way back, and now it turns out it had been used as a residential home. Application rejected.
The Heritage Advisory committee report. 7 Plank road is getting new windows. They stipulates they be the same width as the floor above.
Breen says that the audit committee met on St. Patrick’s day “wonderful day for an audit committee meeting”
The committee presented a report on how to tighten up processes in Parks & Rec to ensure quality and completion of work on open spaces.
Breen says that the committee is also looking at implementing whistleblower policy.
Breen: “This is not in relation to any specific incident” on a proposed city whistleblower bylaw.
O’Keefe: “We’re probably one of the most open and transparent municipalities, certainly in Canada”
Colbert questioned whether an event O’Leary attended in Halifax was related to the city.
O’Leary says this was because the Atlantic Book Awards will be held here next year.
Collins has again brought up that he is concerned that they are not doing enough to cut travel for council.
O’Keefe: “We’re going at the streets with a vengeance this summer.”
The streets rehabilitation program is $8mil, from $6mil last year.
Tilley says that there will be an even better communication piece around road closures this year.
Breen thinks that compliance on the on-street parking ban was better this year due to changes they made.
O’Leary says that in BC, the new premier, Kristy Clarke, is trying to ban cosmetic pesticide use in BC.
Hickman wants to thank the provincial gov’t for their assistance in funding $20k in equipment.
Hickman also wants to look at the limit on the # of garbage bags now that we have recycling.
Hann says MacDonald drive is in the running for a contest through Pepsi, and they are looking for your support to get $100k in funding.
There is a public meeting tomorrow night for the Henry Bell proposal, including the old CBC building on Duckworth st.
Galgay says that the old NL Tel Building across the way on Duckworth will also happen, with commercial space on Duckworth, and condo’s above
O’Keefe: “This will be the most redeveloped council in the history of the city. You wait and see.” On the proposals for Duckworth st.
Hanlon wants to know if podcasting, or live streaming of council meetings is something the city is looking at.
Hanlon: “Can we look at the possibility of podcasting out meetings?” She also gave me a shout out for what I do with Twitter.
Hann: “Astronomical” is how he describes what the cost of podcasting meetings would be. O’Keefe also agrees it would be.
This shows how little some members of council know about technology. I’ll do a podcast for them for almost nothing.
Anyways folks. That’s it for this week. Tweet ya next week.
Wed, Mar 23, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
St. John’s city council live blog: council in easy-to-swallow 140 character bits.
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call, “live” with the Rogers broadcast.
There is a proclamation for Multiculturalism Week in St. John’s.
“Diversity is our strength,” the proclamation says. There will be 40 events across the province.
Apparently 36 countries of origin are represented in the students at Holy Heart.
Gerry Colbert says he never went to Holy Heart, but he used to hang around the parking lot. Whatever that means… Hm.
O’Keefe says that we bring together all of our strength and diversity to make our society what it is.
Hanlon says that encouraging diversity and attracting new immigrants is a part of the city’s Strategic Economic Road Map (pdf)
O’Leary notes that Diversity Week also includes aboriginal people, not just newcomers.
There is a proclamation for Purple Day, to raise awareness for epilepsy. 10,000 people in NL have epilepsy.
One of the biggest problems with epilepsy is a lack of understanding about the condition.
There is a delegation for Earth Hour, March 26th.
8:30-9:30pm on March 26th you are encouraged to turn off your lights. This is to encourage people to think about how we use energy.
In 2010, 10 Million Canadians participated! 51% of adults. Wow, nice job Canada.
O’Keefe points out that Bob Smart, the new City Manager is in the gallery. He starts April 18th.
Galgay on Smart: “We are fortunate to have a gentleman with his experience and his background.”
Tilley: “I know he’ll be a smart man for us.” Like his last name, “Smart.” Bruce is a regular joker.
Breen is reporting on a public meeting held for the rezoning of 69 King’s Bridge Rd. Apparently there was no objection.
Colbert says that it is simply to reflect the ongoing use of King’s Bridge Service Station as it had been for 3-4 generations.
Collins is reporting on the Parks & Rec committee. Several requests were made by SJ minor baseball, some approved, some rejected.
The committee report also includes an item regarding MacPherson school.
The city has requested that they have first dibs on the property if it goes up for sale. They want to ensure it stays in public use.
Nothing is for sure on the MacPherson land, and this is a very preliminary discussion. Colbert says they are only asking for an opportunity.
Tilley us making a resolution on behalf of the SJ Transportation Commission to increase its borrowing limit by $15 million.
This borrowing limit is to purchase 30 new buses over a number of years.
O’Keefe: “Some of the buses are that old that they were around when Councillor Tilley was a young fella.”
Collins is delighted to get the $11k approved for Southland Days. He is also happy to see some of the work being done in Bowring Park.
O’Keefe says that Bowring Park is the jewel in the crown of our parks system.
Hanlon encourages people to vote for the tourism awards, information is on the city’s website here: http://www.stjohns.ca/csj/NewsDetails?id=472
Tilley is discussing that the airport authority is looking at putting an industrial park in.
O’Keefe on competing industrial parks: “We’re [communities on the NE Avalon] all cutting each others throats down in places like Huston.” This comment is in reference to an oil and gas show (or some such activity) that St. John’s was represented at down in Huston. At the same show, Mount Pearl had it’s own booth, competing with St. John’s for bringing business to the NE Avalon.
Tilley encourages people to nominate someone for Senior of the Year Award. Pickup the nomination papers from the city clerk’s office.
Breen says that St. John’s has been shortlisted for the 2013 World Women’s Hockey Tournament.
Breen is tabling a report on an ongoing research project and how community design impacts health.
Breen says that some work in the dump at Robin Hood Bay which was not completed last year will continue this year.
The work will be done by the fall on the gas collection system, which Breen says was the major recommendation out of the consultants report
Hickman pleads for the provincial and federal government that we need their support for our many outstanding capital works projects.
O’Leary is discussing a report which has been commissioned by the Outer Battery Neighbourhood Association.
The neighbourhood association has contracted an engineering firm specializing in traditional structures.
The city has agreed to put a hiatus on any demolition orders for damaged stages, etc, which have been damaged, pending the report.
Good on the Outer Battery Neighbourhood Association! They’re working to preserve our amazing traditional structures out there.
That’s all folks. Tweet ya next week.
Follow along at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Tue, Mar 15, 2011
Is there a disconnect between St. John’s city hall and the public? And is that disconnect to blame for the kerfuffle at city hall last week? Ward Four councillor Debbie Hanlon thinks so.
To recap: Hanlon has had quite the time over the past week. Ever since on March 1, when she asked for a review of council pay, responsibilities, and time commitments, a veritable shit-storm has happened. Hanlon’s personal life was dragged into the spotlight, followed by public fervour at the idea of paying council more money.
At the regular city council meeting on March 8th, that veritable shit-storm hit the fan. After a rapid-fire series of events — the original motion failed, a second notice-of-motion from Hanlon was presented, and there was a vote to force that motion to happen at that meeting — things got ugly.
Hanlon says part of the intense reaction comes from a disconnect between the public and city hall.
Councillor-at-Large Tom Hann took the most exception with Hanlon’s notice of motion and her discussion with the media. He said that she had “besmirched” the reputation of council, and that he had been personally affected by it.
“Everywhere I’ve gone this week it’s [the notice-of-motion of March 1st] been brought up in a negative way,” he said.
After taking flak from every other member of council, the motion was defeated 9-1. Duff seconded the motion “only to allow the debate.” In her defense of the motion, Hanlon reiterated that the review she was asking for did not have to be a $50,000 consultants report, but needs to involve public debate.
“My issue got convoluted,” Hanlon tells me after the smoke had settled after the meeting. The emotionally-charged comments from her fellow councillors were more about the response they had received from the public than the content of the motion, she says. “They turned it into a personal issue, but it’s about a governing body and how it represents the city,” she says. “If that’s the response they got, maybe they should wonder why that is.”
“People are not aware of what we do,” she says. She feels the city needs to do a better job of engaging with the public, particularly youth.
Ward Two councillor Frank Galgay addressed the issue of accountability at the meeting.
“In 2013 [the next municipal election] we’ll get our message… and people will boot us out, or affirm us as councillors,” he said.
This was a sentiment echoed by other members of council, and it’s one that troubles me. If council only thinks they are accountable to the public once every four years, who in the hell do they think they accountable to the rest of the time?
What do you think? Leave your thoughts below.
Thu, Mar 10, 2011

Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets the St. John’s city council meeting. Follow him on Mondays at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here (arriving a bit late, sorry people) to bring you the call for the council meeting from the bunker on New Gower.
All of council is present except Gerry Colbert.
They are discussing the proposal for the harbour-front proposal beside The Keg.
Hanlon: “I feel there is a disconnect between us and the public” on her previous wish to have a public meeting on this.
It seems like this proposal is generally popular, and it satisfies the parking requirements. It would require a rezoning for the land.
O’Keefe: “Right from the start, I felt there was tremendous benefits from this project.”
O’Keefe thinks it will draw people down to “the heart of the city”.
Galgay is citing the 1950′s Diefenbaker-era harbour renewal. Frank goes way back to this one, drawing on his many years.
There is a proposal to rezone land on King Edward Place from apartment high density to residential high density.
There will be a public meeting before any zoning change occurs. I don’t think we should be giving up any land that should be apartments.
Duff is reporting on the Municipal Arts Grant program. They gave out $103k this year to artists and organizations. Out of something like 106 applicants, only 16 were rejected.
Breen on the applicants: “There is a tremendous amount of talent there, and it is difficult to choose from.”
Breen says that he asked last year, but would like to see the arts jury terms of reference reviewed.
Tilley is discussing the Police & Traffic Committee report. People have had many comments on the recent traffic calming study.
This committee sees a lot of requests from residents for signs, speed-bumps, etc. most of which are rejected it seems.
Tilley also mentions some confusion regarding what counts as holidays for parking meter enforcement.
The city holidays are different then the province. This led to people getting tickets when they shouldn’t have over the holidays.
The new traffic calming policy seems to be quite the piece of work, covering a lot of ground on how to deal with traffic issues.
O’Leary is discussing the possible use of round-about’s in the city. She also has received complaints about cross walks on Military Rd.
The city will be eliminating the school crossing guard program, apparently. I guess the schools do not provide this.
Councillor Breen has been approached by a potential sponsor for the school crosswalk program.
Hanlon says the most important thing for her is that in 12 years the city has operated the school crosswalk program, not one kid has been hurt going to school.
They are discussing Hanlon’s notice of motion to “have a full review of council… including roles, remuneration…” (this is a new notice of motion, her one from last week failed to get a seconder at the start of the meeting.)
St. John’s has been named one of “This Old House’s” 12 best neighbourhoods for 2011.
The Heritage Advisory Committee has approved a chain-link fence for the Murray Premises temporarily, for up to 3 years.
Collins wants to start planning for a community centre in Southlands. There are 35,000 people there now, and more coming all the time.
Hanlon wants to put a request in for the city to look at snow clearing in Churchill Square.
Tilley has started talking about Hanlon’s motion to look at making councillors full-time.
Neil Martin, the city clerk says that Tilley’s comments are getting close to debating the motion. This cannot be done until next week.
Tilley: “I could go on and on about this, but obviously I am out of line.”
Neil Martin, the city clerk, continues to shake his head at some comments of Galgay’s. It is a fine line of what they are able to talk about and when.
Neil Martin says that the notice of motion is broad, and they cannot debate it without a specific allowance.
Hann, and a few others want to have a go at this one. “My reputation has been affected by this.” -Hann
They are moving to debate Hanlon’s issue of council right now. Moved by Hann, seconded by Collins.
Oh my. They have voted 9-1 to have the motion heard right now. Watch out.
Hanlon: “I wish I had more time to prepare, I only got the information today at 3pm.”
In 2004 there was a report on something related to elections. “This was hardly a review of council.” – Hanlon
Hanlon cites a report from 1994 which recommends a system of six Ward, and two At-Large councillors.
Hanlon: “Everything everyone tells me is that there a disconnect between people and council.”
Hanlon: “I believe we can be a leaner, more efficient council.”
Breen: “I work 9-5, and more then that… I knew what I was signing up for.”
Breen says that a part-time system works better because you get a better cross-section of society.
Hann has some harsh words for Hanlon on the effect of her motion: “Everywhere I’ve gone this week it’s been brought up in a negative way.”
Hann: “It is an abomination! It is an abomination!”
Hann says that all of council knew what they signed up for when they were elected.
Hann has directly challenged the media, pointing at them (he missed me), telling them to go look at council attendance records.
Hann: “[This is] a contrived media event gone wrong.” Tom says it has affected his reputation, and he wants an apology from Hanlon. (He never got it.)
O’Leary says that money, and whether or not council is accountable, are two separate issues.
O’Leary mentions that she told me before this all started, she talked to me, and said she would not vote for an increase to pay.
Collins: “Any one who wants to come down here and follow me around is welcome, but I won’t vote for no money for any studies.”
Tilley points to the fact that this pay issue is making waves in the media, but last week a fantastic report on affordable housing got zero coverage.
Galgay: “It’s unfortunate that the issue has gone off and taken a life of it’s own.”
Galgay is giving a retrospective of 13 years on council which comes back to the point that things are moving smoothly now as it is.
Galgay: “In 2013 we’ll get our message… and people will boot us out, or affirm us as councillors.” [The next election is Sept. 24th, 2013]
Hickman says that it is different for councillors in big cities. He thinks that the best thing to go for here is a good cross-section of the city.
Duff says that there are people on council who work full-time outside of council, and do a good job at both.
Duff says there are things that could be changed right now, internally.
She suggests making it possible to kick out a councillor who misses three consecutive meetings.
O’Keefe says that the current system allows for new people to come in from all walks of life.
O’Keefe says that in 2004, the structure of council was reviewed, and it affirmed the current structure.
Hanlon says that everyone is missing the point. “It is about the public, and their perception of us.”
Hanlon: “I believe the public has lost faith, and we need to get it back.”
Hanlon: “Things they say in the back room are different then what they say out here.”
Hann: “Fine, dig yourself in deeper.”
Hanlon: “The biggest room for improvement I see is in public engagement.”
Hanlons motion has been denied, 1-9.
O’Leary says that Pet Adoption Day is this Sat, stop by the Shriners building on Topsail Rd.
Duff is addressing John Dinn’s comments on “over-regulation” of the development of housing. She says that the rules are there for safety.
Duff also says that there is a full review underway of city policies to see if they impede housing development.
That’s all folks. More municipal matters next week. Andrew Harvey out.
Thu, May 19, 2011
Andrew Harvey